Added: 3 years ago
From: SpaceJax
Views: 21,148
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (82)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • To be honest Madonna sings this song horribly live ! ,Natasha can sing it better than her live

    anyway this is my top favorite pop song E V E R ! the lyrics are just legendary lol

    but the original version shits on madonna's version (kinda)

  • She's hot as hell

  • cool version :-) i like natashas smoky voice

  • Madonna sings it with more passion and grace and movement so Madonna but Natasha did an amazing job!

  • NO ONE CAN BE LIKE MADONNA.......THERE IS NOTHING MORE TO SAY

  • MADONNA

  • Honestly, is there anyone out there who actually thinks this is better than Madonna?

    I'm not hating or anything, THANKS GOD, it was Madonna and not her to sing it otherwise the song wouldn't have been a hit in the first place. She should try to sing it like the original but I guess it's be too difficult

  • @dioioego besides on Oprah, Madonna can't even sing it like the original!

  • she's got such an amazing voice!!

  • as the biggest fan of Madonna, I would say that M's version is just the best...to be honest, Natasha (the first time I heard about her) is doing the song in her own style, and it's working. Thank you N for re-visiting this song

  • I am a Madonna fun, but Natasha sings it without backing vocals and she does it really great !!!!!!

  • Natasha said she really formed a new respect for Madonna voice after singing this saying Madonna has tremendous range and ability to sing this ( and Madonna has given some great live version of this and a few bad ones).

    Ray of Light is a VERY hard song to sing.

  • woooooooooooo really ugly version lol

  • Kicked Maddy's @ss

  • i think madonnas version is better, she has good vocals though

  • wow, she sings that well! Madona is amazing! but this is pretty amazing!

  • Natasha is fuckin awsome. Madonna amazing too

  • Dreadful ... who the hell is this nobody trying to sing this song and turning it into a massacre.

    No wonder i never heard about her in France.

  • Madonna. No one can beat an original (except glee sometimes!)

  • glee sucks

  • @pablorubiolugo you suck.

  • Madonna is better singerin than Natasha

  • @alcastars5 wow!!!you don´t have ears!!!!!!

    madonna wouldn´t never ever in her life sing that high and never ever improvisate like this.

    she can just dance.that´s all

  • @littlerainworm550 BS. You obviously don't know about Maodnna.

  • @littlerainworm550 You don't have mind,baby!

  • A MADONNA ARREBENTA ESSA GAROTA.

  • excelent cover!but madge is the god!

  • I love this version better

  • I like Natasha but Madonna's version is better

  • Madonna's

  • Darren Hayes version is so much better

  • nice voice

  • Madonna's always :)

  • No one can beat Madonna.

    I also like this version but we cannot compare.

  • this is so different and interesting, but the vocal is a little weak.

  • @wuyiting lol. I'm a huge Madonna fan (way bigger than I am a Natasha fan), but it's sort of hilarious for someone to say that about a Madonna cover. Her vocals are weak in the first place, much weaker than these.

  • You were saying Madonna's vocals were weak in the first place? You're right, she doesnt have a big voice. I'm just staying Natasha's vocal here is still weak. :)

    - Fellow Huge M Fan.

  • natasha doesn't have the voice to carry this song. don't get me wrong, she has a good voice, but no-one can beat Madonna at this one so far.

  • shes a good singer but

    madonna is madonna and this song is an original must be...

  • Madonna!

  • Madonna's. She does it much better even with the old female voice she had during the Sticky and Sweet Tour

  • how can you say this is better than madonna's!? i like natasha but there's no way that she can be better than M!

  • Madonna...but i love and this version.

  • YOu mean William Orbits version !?

    Yes William Orbit RUled nr 1# genius producer

  • My song...... :)

    enjoyed hearing it from Natasha Bedingfield, she is an unique talent.

  • this one is better for sure

  • I prefer the Madonna album and also live version... when Madonnas plays the E-Guitar.

    But this version has a great Natasha Bedingfield style and I also like it.

    But Madonnas original is better... specially live :-D

  • personally i like natasha's voice much more, but thats just in general. I think both versions are solid

  • Madonna's is best by a long shot, but she definitely brings something to the table

  • can madonna sing this song live ?

  • Nope. That's why she's NEVER sang it live before!!!!!!! NEEVER!!!

  • The way she sings it is totally different....you can't compare... they are both fantastic and beautifully artistic

  • madonna always!

  • Madonna is better by far.

  • Original always the best! like it too :)

  • I'm sorry, Natasha Bedingfield sounds like a white trash alcoholic in this vid. I can't believe people actually think this is better than Madonna--the girl sounds like Amy Winehouse after one of her crack binges. And I normally like her. Sorry but the original is far better. And Natasha can sing better than this.

  • She's british and I already know she did better last month performing it on NBC! I bet she'll perform it a 2nd time on TV...and where else but ABC?

  • i LOVE natasha's version better. she's the best singer out there<3333333

  • Well, it can't beat the original version, but it's amazing. She sings it so good.

  • Both are good. but NATASHA'S IS AS GOOD AS THE ORIGINAL CUT!

  • This is absolutely better than the original. She put soul into it!

  • Compare THAT to Bullet For My Valentine's cover of Welcome Home(Sanitarium) in 2006!

  • why does it have 2 be a "vs"? both versions r great........NB fkn did a great job! the "and i feel" part is hard- even madonna has trouble doing it live....good shit!:)

  • I dont think she sang the song her way thinking it wouldve been better than Madonna's.

  • I don't love dance pop electro pop and rnb but i love her so much

  • Comment removed

  • OMG I LOOOOOOVE HER NOW!!!!!!!

  • I really do not think she had any idea just what she was doing when she covered this song. The end result ( R1 live lounge was excellent) is absolutely amazing and totally wiped the floor with the original version.

  • Jeez, yu must be frickin' jokin.. th original IS the only reason Ms B can ride the coat tails..its surely meant to be a tribute or she wouldn't have honoured the existence of the song..Madonna comes out on top

  • also, th Big M always improvises on her own orginals in concert, so continuously revises and revitalises her own music..NB is just an irreverent pretender to th throne

  • Well, she performed yet another beautiful replay on NBC August 21st.

  • love her voice!

  • it was OK but itll never come close to madonna, no one can do hers

  • i love natasha!

  • wow wow kapaW

    excellent!

  • kicks madonnas versions ass. she can actually sing.

  • The only problem I have is that dosen't make me feel all giddy inside like Madonna's version

  • It's a nice cover, but it doesn't make you feel as good as Madonna would.

  • sound like shit. never mess with the work of the queen!!

  • omigoodd she's AMAZING!! i love her soo much!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more