Pink Floyd - Is There Anybody Out There? (Live)

[WestonMattandJimmy]

i was obviously born at the worng time, i hate music now all i listen to is floyd and the beatles and maybe some ac/dc here and there

[BudStrong]

Saw this show in L.A. in Feb '80. A furled curtain caught fire in the rafters, which some long-haired doofus decided he could deal with best by OPENING IT. Whoosh! I watched him crazy-dance his way out of the flames, lol. A newspaper-sized sheet of glowing ash then floated down directly onto an unsuspecting Roger as he played, exploding in a finale of orange sparks as he frantically shook his head to save his hair. Some blame pyro, but my belief is that it was caused by contact with a hot light.

[badboybob1074]

This is a very beautiful yet very sad song.

[rodney49342]

I am 69 and not hardly does a day go by I don't listen to Pink Floyd and Frequently Requested by my Children, Grandchildren, and Great Grandchildren. 

No Generation Gap when it comes to Pink Floyd. There music is timeless and ageless

[scage12]

@rodney49342 im 21 and i totally agree with you.no one can do that today or claim to be able to do that!pink floyd are masters!and acid were their master thought!

[TheRobMars]

AaaaHHhaaaaaHahhaaaaaaaa......­.......

[Redmilitiageneral]

trully underrated. better than comfortably numb in my opinion. (lets see how many people hate that XD )

[ZefreyLove]

Young people, sorry you missed out ,Love the 70's / 80's,,,,

[tencr4z]

You know its a good song when you start to play it on your guitar in your dorm room and your roommate looks up and asks WHat song was that!

[mathenault]

I absolutely love this song... the acoustic part is just beautiful, a peaceful contrast with all the rest

[1dirtysouth956]

ok never mind i love this song so much lol love ya

[1dirtysouth956]

i hate this song so bad i mean like what does it mean by the song about died people or just a stupided song uh tell me now so what is this can anybody tell me nd if its a good reson then the song well be ok and i will tell my school to it uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh and dddddddduuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhh lol lmfao

[OldMusicftw]

@1dirtysouth956 I lost like half my brain cells reading that.

[dkssx64banjo]

jesus christ i wish i was born 10 years earlier, i would give anything to see these amazing guys live in their prime

[JaneandJanineDancing]

this song make my heart ache...Gilmour is simply beautiful on the acoustic

[JaneandJanineDancing]

this melody is haunting

[AmphibiousReconMSOB]

I like how everything turns scary like you just been dumped in a pitch black jungle with lucifers pets talking to you...

[john63van]

Classically melodic and beautifully spacey. Right up there with High Hopes as two of their hidden gems.

[natvar64]

@john63van a hidden gem, indeed! one of my all-time favorites.

[ilikeblondie]

this is amazing though ..... i always wonder what they do when they go home from a god like show such as this . . . .

[killerxela]

is it an oxymoron that on almost every video on youtube, the highest ranked comments are about the lowest ranked comments?

[x10secsx]

creepy

[jpeter69]

Does anyone there know whether David Gilmour is finger picking in this instrument or just playing the lead melody while someone else is providing the plucking at the back?

[GunJockey1]

20 people can kiss the wall of my ass!

[ZEDZOR2]

Why wont you except video response's from genuine Pink Floyd fans,you have no rights to this song or video.Give someone a uniform and they think they're Hitler all right.Your A JOKE.

[RoberMatts]

I don't know if it's only me, but I've heard a lot of music in my short life, and I think The Wall is one of the best albums of rock music ever made, at least top five if not the best.

[beardedspock]

@RoberMatts I'll have you know that I am a very (very) young person, and I would have to agree with you. The others are Close to the Edge by Yes, Snow by Spock's Beard, Permanent Waves by Rush, and Abbey Road by the Beatles.

[ChersTry]

I LOVE THIS SONG- And I need to ask it again when the predictions of the world ending come again! like today May 21st 2011. I will post it at 11.

[dezm101]

incredible, sound quality or otherwise...

[curedcreature]

Slightly bittersweet, memories of my paranoid period drips inside my head and I recall not many laughs, just a sad sad sad life as it became harder. I love this song and I love P.F. They`v brought me comfort, true samaritez. Shine on, all of you out there, like the stars you are and will become. As we ride into the shining sun with our backs to the moon .

[kaisqais]

Who's playing the guitar? Gilmour?

[Plutten1994]

The damn most powerful intro ever made! It's a masterpiece I Say!

[urssglory]

yyyeeeesss. i'm out there...and i waiting for u :-) thanks roger

[lanajai]

beatles??? não o melhor do mundo é pink floyd

[superstormj]

Wish this was longer. Way too short for such a great song.

[TheSolid119]

20 people are not out there

[cinbrian28]

19 people just tried to say...Dis-I-like!!

[wylie9000]

2010 Roger Waters was visually stunning, and the music was good. If David Gilmour was involved it would have been musically stunning as well.

[cditmer]

I love Floyd, but I don't think I would have liked sitting at a concert watching a wall the whole show

[amevilee]

@cditmer It wasn't the whole show,they progressively built over the course of the show :D

[mictoproductions]

@cditmer lol yah they were very pscychedelic and slow, i think a led zepplin concert would be more fun, but a pink floyd album has a lot lyrical and musical genuis.

[rock4life133]

@cditmer

I went to the Wall in concert. They built up the wall throughout the concert, then epicly tore it down at the end.

So it was staring at visual effects on the wall for 3 or 4 songs.

[lpavletinet]

@cditmer then you don't know what you're missing man

[Marooned2010]

This is superb in every way.

[RaymondSequenza]

@paradisecity599 Because that's what music is about, right?

[paradisecity599]

@RaymondSequenza no im just sayin. i love pink floyd so dont think that.

[davidano2]

the beginning reminds me of apocalypse now

[kevmilla]

i love pink floyd but this song scares the shit out of me

[hussie34]

youtube should automatically disable comments by stupid cunts

[CrazyBear65]

18 people work for the government

[TheLegend313]

I SEE WE HAVE 18 DISLIKES....

I SEE WE HAVE 18 FUCKING IDIOTS....

[jamesedwardtheobald]

@TheLegend313 don't you see, the people who dislike stuff that is obviously good, just do it to get that reaction of ire, or condemnation from you, they live for it. it's kind of a form of invisible trolling! don't give them the satisfaction!

[TheLegend313]

@jamesedwardtheobald Lol! Hey dude, Sorry my reaction was maybe a..... little over the top. But I totally hear what you're saying. :)

[titobondito]

this song is amazing! it was also in the movie "the wall". love this song!

[sticklift]

18 people are fucking idiots who try to suck their own dick.

[wytchenavixens]

so classic floyd, one of my all time faves. thank you for sharing this live concert

[Sleepyhead6350]

where the hell are the words??

[manifestgtr]

this song used to scare the hell out of me when I was a kid...I always pictured someone wandering around in the pitch black after the end of the world

[TheAspieKid]

@manifestgtr Me too.

[russianXgamepro]

@manifestgtr i always thought about someone kind of roaming around in like black

[Qartveliiii]

no1 there, for 16 people

[sexytracy1000]

Fuck the eight people who aren't out there is there anybody in there!!!! Joke love Floyd my mum used to listen to them!!!!

[firefreak2007]

16 people aren't out there.

[ukraininoak]

@firefreak2007

19 now !

[atbestvague]

@firefreak2007 16 people prefer "Us and Them"

[walabalabingbong]

@atbestvague what the hell is that supposed to mean?

[chadd990]

@firefreak2007

41 people want me to reply to your comment and call you a douchebag 4 months after you posted your comment. ... douche bag.

[firefreak2007]

@chadd990 (gasp) I love you too! :D

[peppepinzu]

@firefreak2007 20!

[gtstp1]

@firefreak2007 22

[mislimdaklepostojim6]

One short sentence which explains a lot + acoustic guitar. This song is pure art!

[OrgasmicOliver]

Great band(:

[darkblue69fuck]

fags ..queers..lezbo..sikos ...werdios...homo...doesnt like this!!!!!

[legolite45]

Roger:"Is there anybody out there?"

Fan#1:"Yeah, Im over here!"

Fan#2:"Hey Tom, I see you, Im over here!"

Fan#1:"Hey I see you too!"

Then Roger comes up and spits in both their faces.

[kingfarouk2]

@legolite45 Yes. Yes you're very right.

[Greatscott0420]

gives me the chills

[juankashi]

Beautiful, just fuckin love this song. Perfect chords, pure beauty.

[dreamer013aL]

θεϊκο..

[deuceloosley]

I totally agree with soccerlovesit.

[soccerlovesit]

no joke when 1:31 starts my stomach caves in and my hear drops i think

[yamaharider1997]

i need 15

 bulletz

[yamaharider1997]

i need 13 bulletz

[nonesta13]

my favorite song to play on my acoustic...no vocals..let the guitar do the talkin :)

[fbbinho]

muito maneiro. demais ....

[Claudiobenyossef]

MORAISITO - the best...

[KPeastboundNdown]

@MongoLloydd - ur name suits u , u truly sound like a MONGO , Gilmour brought Floyd to a whole new level , Floyd wouldn't be half the band they are after all these years if Gilmour hadnt joined , the great sound of Pink Floyd comes from Gilmour's influence since joining .

[SHINYEOK8580]

@KPeastboundNdown you right absolutely.

[happyenjoytime]

Yep, we are all out here but we are too shy to vent our angst!!!! So .... happy ... So accepting of the powers-that-be. Oh well. I didn't vote for them ... puke!

[martin073]

14 people should get the sand out of their vaginas

[rahooligan]

Gilmour is my favourite guitarist and musician of all-time.. but yes it is true that he did not play this song on the album because he couldn't play it well enough fingerstyle. I think Ezrin may have played it...

[ashfordspyk]

excellent sound

[jcalli66]

one of my favorite pieces off one of my all-time favorite albums. Love the background vocals kicking in at 2:20. I remembered reading years ago that the version that made it to the album was played (maybe-?) by the co-producer Bob Erzin ; that Gilmour got very frustrated trying to get it 'just right' in the studio and finally gave up. Don't know how true that is...

[dustin99352]

Long live Pink Floyd.

[EMARQUEZ23]

First song I ever learned how to play on guitar

[01txtech]

Just Awesome!

[unkwonstudios]

for this i leave all the lights off and have only one spotlight then start playing this

[Brandon18valensi]

@lalocallejero i think they like justin bieber

[nosoypez]

@lalocallejero cuz they're gay.

[Master0Shake]

@lalocallejero The priest from the "Another brick in the wall" video clicked it thirteen times.

[ACDChemi]

@lalocallejero mf

[BillGtrMan]

@lalocallejero Justin Bieber keeps clicking on the dislike button LMAO - losers will do this occasionally!!!

[ricayovillanueva]

@lalocallejero 13 dumbs , XD just that....

[iStaybIazed420]

@lalocallejero that is a very good question my friend ........ probably homos

[bengalballa]

@lalocallejero terrapin

[keepinthatvibealive]

@lalocallejero I swear the same 10-15 bieber fans are running around clicking dislike on all of these amazing songs.

[LMMEjsmith]

@lalocallejero putrid pop paraphernalia produced people placidly poised in their own puke, that's who. Or justin beiber fans for short. just had to throw that rib in there  ;)

[Jakov77]

@lalocallejero

There is not a single piece of content on this site with more than 500 likes that doesn't have a dislike.

There are always, and I mean always people that dislike the content that majority likes.

De gustibus non disputandum est.

[lalocallejero]

@Jakov77 Well said bro, totally agreed...it's just this song is so awesome...

[kingwilliamorange]

@lalocallejero  Exactly....I mean what the fuck goes thru someone's mind when they click dislike? What is there to dislike? The deep emotion, perfectly designed chord progression, or the beautiful guitar work? I dont get it

[Linkrnr]

@kingwilliamorange its becauese its not a justin beiber auto tuned peice of shit

[tornadomad]

@Linkrnr please dont feed the trolls. they just want more and more... ;)

[timeliss]

@kingwilliamorange

I think it's the deep emotion. Some people don't like where Pink Floyd brings them...

[tomiko183]

@timeliss

then they shouldn watch fucking pink floyd videos...

i mean, if you "disslike" the emotions or the song or whatever go watch another damn video...

the "disslike" button shouldnt exsist al all.

[lilRadRidinHood]

@kingwilliamorange - the dislikes are little girls who want to grow up and marry Bieber

[VehementiNacon]

@kingwilliamorange Sound quality of the upload? Just a thought there kiddo.. Just a thought.

[atbestvague]

@kingwilliamorange I always click dislike, because I think its funny that folks like you care.

[gbadri1]

@kingwilliamorange

it is sad that everyone does not get it. Which is ok. It distinguishes us from them. This is natural. Being of different taste of sound, mind and body is perfectly normal. Live and let live. They say the samething about other forms of music.

[centwise]

@kingwilliamorange I'll tell you what goes through someone's mind when they click dislike,,,, Air on breezy days!!

[chadd990]

@kingwilliamorange

70 people wanted me to reply to your comment and call you a douchebag half a year after you posted your comment. douchebag.

go live in a box if you cant handle people who dont agree with you

[hrbnbrd]

@kingwilliamorange My thoughts EXACTLY!

[craigscarpet83]

@kingwilliamorange ...they are probally Justin Bieber fans !!...why would someone come 2 this song if they dint like it !!..its stupid i know !!!

[juankashi]

@lalocallejero Now are 16!

[xratiugx]

pink floyd is one of the greatest bands i've ever listened to! Long Live Rock

[lalogamer]

this song have the most beutiful solo

[timshill]

i would love to be able to play the guitar like that, gilmour is the greatest, no contest

[abnormlman]

I'm going! Well go! Alright, I will!

[eyezwideopen]

This has always been my favorite piece of acoustic. Out of all the typical songs like "stairway to heaven" that all players have learned at some point, I'm amazed to find that no one has thought to learn this one. It is very moving. Absolutely amazing.

Maybe I can be someone who will be able to play it : )

[idontbelieveok]

@eyezwideopen it is not because this is difficult, it is because the guitar is simply simple and boring.

As a song, it sounds great, it is a delightful song, but the guitar is not as spellbounding as the guitar in stairway to heaven.

[timshill]

@idontbelieveok i love listening to zep as well, but i have to disagree with you on that, sorry

[idontbelieveok]

@timshill a matter of taste i suppose. just as a guitar player pink floyd has never impressed me in any way. although i do like their music.

[chubbychad]

better than grandma's pancakes...just sayin...

[timshill]

@chubbychad superb, couldnt put it better myself lol...

[Rush1013]

@chubbychad

Ive had your grandmas pancakes, they were delicious. But i have to agree that this is better.

[chubbychad]

@Rush1013 Imagine if you will, listening to Floyd while eating my grandma's pancakes!!! Ohh Dude... dude...

[patriksund]

ok i don't wanna throw shit about slash or start a flame war but the other day i wanted to check if slash had anny improv and seriously i got very bored, he played the same shit again and again and again.

[sergiomarques73]

who cares who's better?

[hermanmerman18]

this is ridiculous and i havent even watched it but disable the comments hell they should be disabled on every video

[Av2ene]

wah-wah

[theoffendandrun]

Big shit! Gilmour! and not Guilmour!

[nirvanaguitar]

amazing how people can't just listen to this piece of music, but must post useless comments about whos better and what-not. God damn the human race is fucked.

[stoffeboyei]

this almost makes me cry. soooooooooooooo beautiful

[xxJimster94xx]

i cant believe i actually get 2 see this in october!!!

[lucciorodriguez]

Perfect

[thedeadliest]

what a great touch comes out from his hands.....gosh..!

[VJSco]

peace

[1MrJoness]

Gilmour is by far my favorite guitarist ever.

[Ubersomesam]

Ive know this song for a while but I still dnt get that first part..

[ARDUNNO]

@Ubersomesam ..it's his feeling of being alienated , behind his wall....he's wondering is there anybody out there? (like him? or that can help him maybe? )

[bigt0530]

@Ubersomesam is there anybody out there? pink is trying to call out beyond his wall and to no avail no one is there

[iiinitr0]

i had this wholeee album on my ipod from my aunts BF, (he had the live version of it :):)) then i had to sync my ipod with a new computer and o how i miss that album.. wonderful piece of work that makes you think and think..

[evilemperordude]

@iiinitr0 I hate to tell you this now, but there is a way to extract the songs from your iPod.

[almutamide]

VERY GOOD.

[marenovanta]

quello del "se avrai bisogno ti verrò a prendere"....

[MadSound321]

someone now who to do this slide on guitar 2:25 ??

[Aslongasimhere]

@MadSound321 Press the B string with your pinky on the 5th fret as the same time you press with your index the same string on the 3rd fret. At the same time too, press the G string with your ring finger at the 5th fret, as the same time you press one fret above the same string (4th fret) with your middle finger. As you do this, pluck first the G string followed by the B.

[Aslongasimhere]

@Aslongasimhere Then, repeat the same plucking as before, but at this time, instead, lift your pinky and ring finger from the B and the G strings respectively (remember, they where at the 5th fret each). So, your fingers now are the index and the middle pressing the B and the G strings respectively.

[Aslongasimhere]

@Aslongasimhere Now, the plucking is the same (first the G then the B string, just only once), but at this time, slide the position just before (middle G string 4th fret and index at the B string 3rd fret) two frets above: index at the 1st fret B string and the middle at the G string 2nd fret. To complete the slide, lift these two fingers and play the G string, followed by the B, and then the G again, all without no pressing.

Thats it!

[Aslongasimhere]

@Aslongasimhere Remember: the first three measures, from all the four I've explained, the plucking (G first, B following) doesn't change - once at the time.

Enjoy.

[nabelbutten]

lol

[gagowiccano]

Great!

[thedeadliest]

is the vocal part played in playback?

[danielspital]

pink floyd are in my opinion up there with the all time legends of music like mozart

[perfectionless]

This song is one of the reasons why I want to play acoustic AND why I hold the highest respect to Gilmour

[jjgiasson]

Yeah...that's pretty cool.  Real Floyd.

[mvdbrink29]

master

[shooterwall]

i was taken on a ufo 26/81979,showed me ww111 would you like to know more

[dodepaling]

This isn't gilmour playing... It's Snowy White... If you don't believe me look it up