Added: 3 years ago
From: spiddia
Views: 34,411
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (66)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i love the unreleased songs because they're better...

  • ARE WE ALL WORKING IN A BETTER VERSION OF US???

  • I like this version...but I think a lot of it has to do with me craving something new from Fiona. Does anyone know if she's working on anothe studio album?

  • @MrXipetotec79 Yeah. According to an article online, Fiona has said herself that the album has been done for a year now. Her record label hasn't released it so far for some reason, though. :\

  • pc 14

  • pc 13

  • Comment removed

  • pc 12

  • pc 11

  • pc 10

  • pc 8

  • pc 9

  • pc 8

  • dehhlp COMBO BREAKER!

  • pc 7

  • pc 6

  • Puta que pariu \/

  • pc 5

  • pc 4

  • pc 3

  • pc 2

  • pc

  • 1:46-2:01 is my favorite part of the song, it should have been the chorus. so amazing, her voice gives me chills!

  • Definitely like this version more so than the released one.

  • I definitely like this one better. It seems most of the unreleased versions have more emotion, maybe because it was one of her first times singing them. idk.

  • My bootleg version of this track is different. How many versions of this track are there?

  • @NIGELNOTRENDS There were actually about 2 or 3 version. One is more drum heavy, then there's this one, and then probably an inverted one *shrugs* Maybe there's just two lol

  • i like the released version better but i like this version's ending better than the other one's

  • fantastic song. I love the beat of the unreleased version

  • pretty sure that when she originally recorded this album she was unsatisfied so she rerecorded the entire thing.

  • @Kurosaki2112 That's not true. The record company didn't like the Brion version.

  • How did there get to be 2 versions? Where did these amazing unreleased versions come from? Are they Fiona's original recordings?

  • i love the Jon Brion-produced version of Extraordinary Machine...

  • i personally don't think fiona has the passion for music anymore. she's a brilliant artist, but i don't think her heart is in it anymore. you have tidal in 96 when the pawn in 99 and 6 years for extraordinary machine. it will probably be another 6 years till we get another amazing album ... which is sad. WE LOVE U FIONA !

  • Personally I don't think that this is real...I think someone altered it on their own computer and then said hey look unrleased Fiona.....

  • @TheRealMollyMaev actually they are the unreleased. she talks about it in interviews. these were out before the finished album was.

  • @TheRealMollyMaev It's totally real. I was listening to this five years ago before the "new" version of the album was even recorded. And having seen Jon Brion live, this unreleased Apple album is about as Brion as it gets. Not only that, but Apple frequently turns up at Brion's LA gigs even now - they're close.

  • @bigbold2 then I guess I stand corrected. This just doesn't sound anything I have ever heard from her. The music and the lyrics sure as hell do but the echo....nah I just don't get it!!! Thanks for letting me know. No matter what Fiona is still in my top 5 <3 that WOman

  • @TheRealMollyMaev - yeah except that these songs were leaked before the final version of the album

  • In the modern world between Fiona and Maynard James Keenan's crew they have taught me everything I know!!!

  • @TheRealMollyMaev agreed.

  • I prefer the other version..

  • Are these unreleased versions on the CD?

  • @crazypianolady no, u can't find these anywhere but maybe somewhere online. she should release the original versions proper ... maybe one day ...

  • They totally killed the feel of this song on the official release, I feel like the craziness of the unreleased versions relates the sentiments of wanting to be a better person a lot more effectively. Like you gotta go through a lot of bullshit and mayhem until you can finally call yourself a person in this world... ah

    "I don't want a home, I'd ruin that

    Home is where my habits have a habitat

    Why give it a turn"

    God damn amazing,

  • Comment removed

  • This one, Window and Please, Please, Please are the only ones I really, really wish they had left alone. The Elizondo versions pale in comparison.

  • It's nice to hear a different version of the songs she decided to put out on the first album. They're definitely more energetic.

  • I don't know why she was disappointed with the album the first time. I like this original much better then the final one.

  • so, it's my firm belief, the only reason why we like these unreleased versions of these songs so much, is because we've been desperatly fiending for more Fiona songs. This is the closest we have to something new yet genuine. I don't know, but personally, I need more Fiona, still! Nothing is better therapy than this! I was fortunate to see her live once, it was amazing!

  • @negativepositive Well, new album should be out shortly. we can rejoice :)

  • Comment removed

  • @negativepositive Well on the bright side, a new album is coming out this spring!! :D :D

  • @negativepositive A year late to respond to this, but it's just as (if not even more) relevant now. You are 100% right about why we love the unreleased versions-- it's "new" Fiona. I need a new album like I need oxygen.

  • i love this song

  • i have all of these. I love them <3

  • Can i ask where you found these?

  • I was privee enough to get a copy of the entire album in its pre-release version and honestly, it is a hell of a lot better. The actual release is overproduced as hell. This is pure song writing goodness.

  • I totally agree with you. I bought the released version, heard it once and decided i liked the unreleased much better.

  • GENIOUS!!!!!

  • I love both versions of this song, but this might just be my favorite. I love you Fiona

  • totally loving this right now ....

  • i really think the unreleased version of extraordinary machine is much much better ...

  • But the other version says it's better. Then I go listen to that and then this one says it's better. It's an endless cycle. Ahhhhhhhhhhhh!!!!!!!!!

  • fiona has that "magic power".. you will love anything she makes

    and it's so true.. i first had all the unrealised version on my computer and when i bought the album i erased all because i liked better the realeased version.

    Now i listen to this and im sorry i erase these songs, i can't find them anymore

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more