I'm sick of all the spastics that comment on Irish videos and I include huns, fenians and yanks in that. Most of you are as bad as each other. You act like it's still 1916. On another note, this is a ropey version.
My favorite version of this song by far. When I listen to Irish music I expect a drinking feel and sound about it and this man clearly sounds drunk :).
Me and my twin brother used to jam all the time. Fucking many damn years ago now. We did all types of songs, but this was always a crowd favorite. Spancil Hill, a well written song.
Shane is Irish by blood, though he often speaks with a North London accent. He's spent a great deal of time in both regions, really. For the record, he was born in Kent, IIRC.
I only hope that what Victoria says about his drinking has merit; it'd be a sad day to lose Shane McGowan.
at first i didn't notice what version i clicked on and was really enjoying Shane singing until i heard the drums and guitars. Shame, it was beautiful up until. At least 85 - 90% of the song or so was great
I didn't like this version at first(preferring the duo with christy moore)but now I love it. The lyrics are different and definitely convey a more haunting feel.
Haunting...unexpected, but brilliant metal with Cruachan...perfection from Shane...kendalandy captures it...God knew what he was doing when He gave us a great gift with Shane MacGowan.
I think God "stepped on board a vision and followed with the wind" when he created Shane McGowan. A genius who has never been bettered, and never will. Born on Christmas day, God knew what he was doing.
Vous êtes un grand, un très grand Artiste. En vous écoutant, je ferme les yeux et je me trouve au temps des Bardes, au cœur de l'âme Celte. Quelle force, quelle profondeur! Au delà du temps et de l'éternité, l'essence de la Musique...
ok there is IRA in your name so i assume your irish(like myself) so how the fuck can you not like this?!?!? are ya fuckin deaf and stupid? Shane is one of the greatest things to come out of ireland. For fucks sake.
shane ma's came from ireland , shane lived in oxford , this a good song , and dont make asumptions that all irish are ira , most irish are embaressed to be associated with the pira , rira , and all on here are joker followers......
Actually shane was born in oxford, but grew up in tipperary, where both his parents where from and where he now lives most of the time. He has lived in england about half his life but is a lifelong irish citizen.
Just because IRA is in someone's name doesn't mean they're Irish. Ever been to Boston, Massachusetts, USA? The northeast USA is/was a hotbed of IRA sympathizers.
@PaddyFlavell96 Born in England yes, but if you have his autobiography like me you would know how much he despised England. He was so happy in Ireland until he moved to "London"? and he endlessly mentioned in the book how much he hated it and longed to go back to Ireland.
@BoxingMadLad Shane is brilliant, and he is 100% Irish (unlike my 12 1/2 %, LOL!) but he is from Bromley, Kent, a suburb of London, although both his parents came from Ireland.
@closecombat3 Noo! I mean... In my opinion you seemed to be talking about him as if he's dead, because you said he is legend. You know, like you would have said: "He was awesome, but he WAS, now he is legend". But maybe I took it too literally.
@aleksandra14 In Ireland when you say someone is a legend it doesn't necessarily mean they are dead... But you were talking about him as if he was dead with you're "for me he's still alive".
@closecombat3 Ok, maybe you're right, I don't know how it looks in Ireland. But when I said: "For me he's still alive", I mean... His the best years passed, he isn't as good known as years ago, there are so many new people who sing and some people just forgot about Shane. But for me he's still alive, for me he didn't gone from music and still is one of the bests musicans.
you find this song on album of irish folk metal band CRUACHAN called FOLK-LORE as another song he sings in called RIDE ON he produced that album.slainte
I couldn't give two shits if it was Brendan Behan, JFK, or the Pope himself the audio is still messed from his addition. That aside it may be the best live duet ever
maybe if he is happy to be the way he is ,i can t argue with that......but it will be a waste if he dies....his mind is so creative an poetic....live on shano for many a year more
i´m trying to do irish music for 10 years ago....and in this time whre i had to left my girlfriend you doing me very good! like so often before!! the irish music is some spezial! thank you and please never ask me bollix!;-) olaf from that germany
Shane's unique !
Suppressedify 3 months ago
Every fucking vidoe its a debate where he's irish or not.. he's london irish. End of story. Great version, Shanes voice is so beautiful
STFCstoneroses 3 months ago
This is just another thing that makes me wish I was irish! Long live the IRA!
stirnerit 5 months ago
as a prod a like this so any shit to do with religon suck it its history if not the truth get on and over it twats
gunnerz1985 8 months ago 2
@seaneyg1992 Probably? Certainly!
hrabnya 10 months ago
I'm sick of all the spastics that comment on Irish videos and I include huns, fenians and yanks in that. Most of you are as bad as each other. You act like it's still 1916. On another note, this is a ropey version.
kez1979 10 months ago
people need to stop saying RIP shane cause he aint dead. a
however he has been quasi alive for 30 years
GillyNotKingofPhilly 11 months ago
This is gorgeous. The birdsong in the background makes it more beautiful, but Shane, even toothless and plastered, is brilliant. He just is.
suzannji 11 months ago 2
Ah Shay my man. It's good to hear your voice again.
piker1977 11 months ago
RIP Shane
cultstatus7 1 year ago
@cultstatus7 why??
Bohumill2 11 months ago
@cultstatus7 hes not dead.
GillyNotKingofPhilly 11 months ago
@GillyNotKingofPhilly Apparently sarcasm is
cultstatus7 10 months ago
@cultstatus7 sure
GillyNotKingofPhilly 10 months ago
I stept on board a double vision and then I came to wank her off?
furakkueroru 1 year ago
Just because he was born in England doesnt mean hes English!
Illidanee 1 year ago
Great song, shame he sounds pissed.
PaddyF96 1 year ago
@PaddyF96 he probably is pissed !
seaneyg1992 1 year ago 3
i hate rangers
themacgregor15 1 year ago
Comment removed
realnetprofits 1 year ago
Who's with Shane here?
hanshotfirst1138 1 year ago
@hanshotfirst1138 Cruchan
realnetprofits 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@hanshotfirst1138 Cruchan
realnetprofits 1 year ago
My favorite version of this song by far. When I listen to Irish music I expect a drinking feel and sound about it and this man clearly sounds drunk :).
Hogo69 1 year ago
this guy is finished with the world
FranziskaLiebtBill 1 year ago
Me and my twin brother used to jam all the time. Fucking many damn years ago now. We did all types of songs, but this was always a crowd favorite. Spancil Hill, a well written song.
Countzir0interrupt 1 year ago
Shane is Irish by blood, though he often speaks with a North London accent. He's spent a great deal of time in both regions, really. For the record, he was born in Kent, IIRC.
I only hope that what Victoria says about his drinking has merit; it'd be a sad day to lose Shane McGowan.
Seamus451 1 year ago
Er, double-check on the accent bit. I think I may have misremembered a source.
:shrug:
Seamus451 1 year ago
Outstanding. A living legend.
jblackstar 1 year ago
sorry Boxing but shane wasn't born in Ireland
robbie8563 1 year ago
@robbie8563 Yeah, both his parents were Irish though, and he was raised Irish.
Cainus44 1 year ago
first time i've heard this song and i really like it tbh, shane's a legand..
is there a woman singing with him in the background in some parts of this song?
welshperson123 1 year ago
she isn't the farmers daughter,she is Mac, the rangers daughter,it does a disservice to the song to change the words to appease republicans.
prodeoetpatria1691 1 year ago
@BoxingMadLad: I'm feeling quite alright,pal!
westfalianalien 1 year ago
listen
this guy is a genius
dastipe 1 year ago
@dastipe
beethoven was a genius this guy got god lytics and funny voice
supermutantify 1 year ago
This is like the christy Brown version
Dundon100 1 year ago
the best irish singer i ever heard
greetings from austria
painhouses 1 year ago 6
Shane is a genius and those not realising this lack of the ability of appreciating true music and talent!
mssynne 2 years ago 2
There's no humor in this world! Please give me, who I adore Shane, more thumbs down!
westfalianalien 2 years ago 5
at first i didn't notice what version i clicked on and was really enjoying Shane singing until i heard the drums and guitars. Shame, it was beautiful up until. At least 85 - 90% of the song or so was great
fuckweed 2 years ago 2
Laft night af I lay dreaming of pleafant dayf gone by...
What a graet version of Fpanfil Hill.
westfalianalien 2 years ago
@westfalianalien What the fuck is wrong with you?
BoxingMadLad 1 year ago 2
@BoxingMadLad cocaine is a wonderful drug
ThePGeraFuckingSucks 10 months ago
@ThePGeraFuckingSucks lol good name it doz
kingpharaohtsar 1 month ago
I didn't like this version at first(preferring the duo with christy moore)but now I love it. The lyrics are different and definitely convey a more haunting feel.
andypearlfisher 2 years ago 3
Haunting...unexpected, but brilliant metal with Cruachan...perfection from Shane...kendalandy captures it...God knew what he was doing when He gave us a great gift with Shane MacGowan.
Swampier 2 years ago 4
This is awesome and Shane sings all of the written lyrics.
Weatherbyrd 2 years ago
I think God "stepped on board a vision and followed with the wind" when he created Shane McGowan. A genius who has never been bettered, and never will. Born on Christmas day, God knew what he was doing.
kendalandy 2 years ago
First 4 minutes, yes.
After that, no.
t3hvanil4intel 2 years ago
No pints of Guiness or slugs of Lagavulin, this is drunkennes ultimate! Leave the rock end out!!!!
hdmk5 2 years ago
I stept on board a double vision
furakkueroru 2 years ago 2
macgowan is good but whos fuckin idea was it to turn spancill hill into a rock song??? jesus christ
seanog648 2 years ago 2
????
buachailgomaith 2 years ago
john kennys reggae version is class...ha
baguhmeister 2 years ago
Jesus, shane is the best. This is my new favorite version of this song !
Hogo69 2 years ago
just amazing!!
Legende1979 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Loada bollox
SuperDoom5 2 years ago
artifice can be more true than truthh
suburbansuperstar 2 years ago
i love shane more than anyone, but i would rather him and christy singin this or don stiffe or the dubliners
theerealdeal 2 years ago
you are amazing !!!! you are my better singer !! i love your voice !!
materez 2 years ago 2
Magnifique!
Vous êtes un grand, un très grand Artiste. En vous écoutant, je ferme les yeux et je me trouve au temps des Bardes, au cœur de l'âme Celte. Quelle force, quelle profondeur! Au delà du temps et de l'éternité, l'essence de la Musique...
Merci!
Elfgris 2 years ago 3
i loveeeeee youuuuuuuuuuuuuu SHANE
materez 2 years ago 4
On which Cd can I find this Version?
Can someone help me?
Thanks a lot
JanBasler 2 years ago
Cruachan -> Folk-Lore (2002)
qwertzfvf 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Tryin to put me to sleep ?
ShamrockerIRA 2 years ago
ok there is IRA in your name so i assume your irish(like myself) so how the fuck can you not like this?!?!? are ya fuckin deaf and stupid? Shane is one of the greatest things to come out of ireland. For fucks sake.
BoxingMadLad 2 years ago 27
@BoxingMadLad
shane ma's came from ireland , shane lived in oxford , this a good song , and dont make asumptions that all irish are ira , most irish are embaressed to be associated with the pira , rira , and all on here are joker followers......
1st9thaircav 1 year ago
Actually shane was born in oxford, but grew up in tipperary, where both his parents where from and where he now lives most of the time. He has lived in england about half his life but is a lifelong irish citizen.
However this song is hardly him at his best.
tommyanthonymcgee 1 year ago
spot on !!!
1st9thaircav 1 year ago
@BoxingMadLad
Just because IRA is in someone's name doesn't mean they're Irish. Ever been to Boston, Massachusetts, USA? The northeast USA is/was a hotbed of IRA sympathizers.
Michelewicz 1 year ago
@BoxingMadLad Actually Shane was born in England.
PaddyFlavell96 1 year ago
@PaddyFlavell96 Born in England yes, but if you have his autobiography like me you would know how much he despised England. He was so happy in Ireland until he moved to "London"? and he endlessly mentioned in the book how much he hated it and longed to go back to Ireland.
BoxingMadLad 1 year ago
Comment removed
PaddyF96 1 year ago
@BoxingMadLad its cuz hes a provo a real sticky knows his music so yea he is fuckin stupid ...and deaf
demonikfunk 1 year ago
@BoxingMadLad Shane is brilliant, and he is 100% Irish (unlike my 12 1/2 %, LOL!) but he is from Bromley, Kent, a suburb of London, although both his parents came from Ireland.
neotenousape 6 months ago 2
cool music for getting drunk
and cool pic...too
meskalitoLen 3 years ago 3
class song shano
irishforever040708 3 years ago 3
Nice one Stephan, Shane forever
ClashCityRockers0 3 years ago
I got to see him and the Pogues last year in Seattle and feel unbelievably privileged. He is truly one of Irelands finest sons. Slainte Shane!
OscarLimaMike 3 years ago
Brillant Combi Shane ! lovely and sweet .. Cheers my companion.
CowboyAdler1899 3 years ago 2
I stept on board a double vision!
furakkueroru 3 years ago
hahahah good one!!!!!!
joe123folan 3 years ago
Only in heaven will you hear the likes of this. Brilliant!
Swampier 3 years ago
No. Not MUCH better.
7AngryIrishmen 3 years ago 2
does music get any better than this?
agger2 3 years ago
no i don't think that it can
EsamG 3 years ago
shane mcgowan what a legend
closecombat3 3 years ago 35
@closecombat3 For me he's still alive. But it's truth, he is legend, I think he will never be forgotten.
aleksandra14 1 year ago
@aleksandra14 Aaaaahhh you seem to be talking about him as if he's dead.. He isn't!!! For everyone he's still alive because he is literally.
closecombat3 1 year ago
@closecombat3 Noo! I mean... In my opinion you seemed to be talking about him as if he's dead, because you said he is legend. You know, like you would have said: "He was awesome, but he WAS, now he is legend". But maybe I took it too literally.
aleksandra14 1 year ago
@aleksandra14 In Ireland when you say someone is a legend it doesn't necessarily mean they are dead... But you were talking about him as if he was dead with you're "for me he's still alive".
closecombat3 1 year ago
@closecombat3 Ok, maybe you're right, I don't know how it looks in Ireland. But when I said: "For me he's still alive", I mean... His the best years passed, he isn't as good known as years ago, there are so many new people who sing and some people just forgot about Shane. But for me he's still alive, for me he didn't gone from music and still is one of the bests musicans.
aleksandra14 1 year ago
@closecombat3 as an irishman.... i want this played at my funeral...so everyones says " oh what a lovely version of spancil hill "
DUN DUN, DUN DUN, DUN DUNN DUN DUN ahahahah
GillyNotKingofPhilly 11 months ago
what album is this off of i have all the albums pogues and popes was it a popes single
pogues9225 3 years ago
you find this song on album of irish folk metal band CRUACHAN called FOLK-LORE as another song he sings in called RIDE ON he produced that album.slainte
renepayback 3 years ago
its a band called Cruachan
WalksWithDeath 3 years ago
the one with christy on the late late is much better imo
dankirdcu 3 years ago
great job so many great irish singers have done this famous spancill hill i think he does it the best
closecombat3 3 years ago 3
Thanks a lot ...
Sean175 3 years ago
beautiful
cheyennebritbrat 3 years ago
Would you mind sending this to me as well?
This is a fantastic version. Unusually strong vocals.
God bless.
KensaiBlade 3 years ago
The guy yelling yoyoyo at the end of the Shane and Christy set screws it all up
Pogue009 3 years ago 3
That's Gay Byrne. Twit
roboconccr 3 years ago
I couldn't give two shits if it was Brendan Behan, JFK, or the Pope himself the audio is still messed from his addition. That aside it may be the best live duet ever
Pogue009 3 years ago 2
I mean Gay is a twit not you!
roboconccr 3 years ago
beter dan dit is er niet
edwinmees 3 years ago
damn i can only find the download whith ham and Moore, i really want this one:D
InfernoArmpit 3 years ago
I have this On MP3, i will send it over if You Like
roboboyo 3 years ago
oh,for me to please
edwinmees 3 years ago
maybe if he is happy to be the way he is ,i can t argue with that......but it will be a waste if he dies....his mind is so creative an poetic....live on shano for many a year more
pjthecat666 3 years ago
i´m trying to do irish music for 10 years ago....and in this time whre i had to left my girlfriend you doing me very good! like so often before!! the irish music is some spezial! thank you and please never ask me bollix!;-) olaf from that germany
Chrisokraus 4 years ago
My God! How this music moves my soul..
Becomes me as I am IT!
Thank You Shane and all the Irish for giving all
this beautiful music!
I am 1/2 Irish in America
Dugan Clementi
reddugan 4 years ago
ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh, heaven from the heart singing from the bowels of a less than fiery hell, but a sad hell none the less. Lovely.
berryjewell 4 years ago
Good man Shane. thanks for posting it.
machree01 4 years ago 5
Good old shane!
Thanks for this!
rpgplayer101 4 years ago 8