I've so far seen 3 versions of this scene and I must say, this is the most convincing one I've ever seen. Leave it to the legends to portray such a scene so perfectly!
I respect Laura Benanti's deeper resonance and performance, but I do perosnally like Cynthia Gibb's performance better. Of course, I sat through that whole movie to watch her develop in that role, a moment of this play doesn't do justice to the character.
I'm sorry but Laura is laughably over the top and campy. She sounds like she is possessed by a demon! First of all...both of them talk too fast during this scene...they rush it and then try to make up for it by having an overly long dramatic pause after the fight. It just feels so over done and cheesy. They are both as subtle as a heart attack! Tammy Blanchard did this scene beautifully! And she did not have to sound like the Exorcist to get the point across either!
@Brathford I have to agree and I LOVE both these women...especially Patti. They both earned well-deserved Tony's for this performance. However......this scene (the most important int he show outside of Rose's Turn) was blown by allowing Laura to overact so melodramatically. It's jarring. An actor's intention does reach the last row. You don't have to scream like a banshee.
Well, it was supposed to be seen on a live stage, not on a video screen. The difference in medium makes a big difference. What seems over the top is magnified on a screen whereas you need something larger than life for it to register in a live theater. What's important is that the actors are conveying genuine emotions. Compare this to the Bette Midler version of the same scene, the TV movie version seems bland and sitcom-y in comparison.
@futuresuperstar4life Ok in response to you and all the others below, I work in casting for Broadway. So my opinions are hardly from some theater lover who does not have an objective eye. I do this for a living...so I am pretty well qualified to say that Patti and Laura both overacted the shot out of this, EVEN FOR THE THEATER! And the whole, "It's on film so it looks sillier than it was live." argument, does not hold water. I saw it live too...and it sucked then too. Period.
@Brathford Well of course we know that someone working in casting must be the utlimate arbiters of taste in matters of theater (certainly above the paying audience and theater critics). And while I admit that the scene could have been toned down in terms of impact, I still hold that the genuine raw emotions displayed here beats the synthetic repressed performances we see in most commercial pursuits. And the late Arthur Laurents seemed to think so as well.
If anyone wants a copy of this show on dvd with a autographed playbill of Gypsy, signed by Patti LuPone, Laura Benanti and Boyd Gained. Hit me up on my aim xoalxscrzox , im looking to trade both those items for the Judi Dench cast recording of A Little Night Music
Help me out here. What is Patti's line at 2:49? It sounds like she says "Beautiful lesbian speaks lousy french and reads book reviews." For some reason I don't think that's right. I don't trust Patti's diction. Maybe it's "Beauty burlesque queen"? Someone throw me a bone on this one.
@milesfile77 She says ... "You, the burlesque queen, that speaks lousy French and reads book reviews.." Ms. LuPone's diction is amazing. Illegally recorded videos from the mezzanine are not to blame for any misunderstanding of her performance. Who do you think you are?
I sort of wish Patti wouldn't play every character like she's Evita. I'm sorry, I don't want to come off trollish, but...I'm kind of tired of that same schtick...
@Mattbrain I totally agree. The performances from LuPone, Benanti, and Gaines were all well-deserving of Tonys. The supporting cast was incredible as well. Such a glorious memory!
ALL acting is so lame! I can get every emotion on a dime... watch out!!
marcomariaz26 2 months ago
I've so far seen 3 versions of this scene and I must say, this is the most convincing one I've ever seen. Leave it to the legends to portray such a scene so perfectly!
jessicatheginger 2 months ago
"I LOVE IT!" LMAO
LittleMissBlondie130 2 months ago
Utterly amazing.
broadwayfan66 4 months ago
I respect Laura Benanti's deeper resonance and performance, but I do perosnally like Cynthia Gibb's performance better. Of course, I sat through that whole movie to watch her develop in that role, a moment of this play doesn't do justice to the character.
Demidota2009 5 months ago
My favorite scene! Thanks for posting!
emopinata12345 6 months ago
THAT was INTENSE!
futuresuperstar4life 7 months ago
wow.....wow.....woooooooaaahhhhh
shes good
harajukukevin6657 7 months ago
Laura really comands this seen, though she's a lot bitcher than other louises ive seen.
sweeney60 8 months ago
I'm sorry but Laura is laughably over the top and campy. She sounds like she is possessed by a demon! First of all...both of them talk too fast during this scene...they rush it and then try to make up for it by having an overly long dramatic pause after the fight. It just feels so over done and cheesy. They are both as subtle as a heart attack! Tammy Blanchard did this scene beautifully! And she did not have to sound like the Exorcist to get the point across either!
Brathford 8 months ago
@Brathford I have to agree and I LOVE both these women...especially Patti. They both earned well-deserved Tony's for this performance. However......this scene (the most important int he show outside of Rose's Turn) was blown by allowing Laura to overact so melodramatically. It's jarring. An actor's intention does reach the last row. You don't have to scream like a banshee.
lcowles 7 months ago
@Brathford
Well, it was supposed to be seen on a live stage, not on a video screen. The difference in medium makes a big difference. What seems over the top is magnified on a screen whereas you need something larger than life for it to register in a live theater. What's important is that the actors are conveying genuine emotions. Compare this to the Bette Midler version of the same scene, the TV movie version seems bland and sitcom-y in comparison.
kornpone 7 months ago
@kornpone See my response above.
Brathford 7 months ago
@Brathford study some of the tchniques of theatre!
futuresuperstar4life 7 months ago
@futuresuperstar4life Ok in response to you and all the others below, I work in casting for Broadway. So my opinions are hardly from some theater lover who does not have an objective eye. I do this for a living...so I am pretty well qualified to say that Patti and Laura both overacted the shot out of this, EVEN FOR THE THEATER! And the whole, "It's on film so it looks sillier than it was live." argument, does not hold water. I saw it live too...and it sucked then too. Period.
Brathford 7 months ago
@Brathford Well of course we know that someone working in casting must be the utlimate arbiters of taste in matters of theater (certainly above the paying audience and theater critics). And while I admit that the scene could have been toned down in terms of impact, I still hold that the genuine raw emotions displayed here beats the synthetic repressed performances we see in most commercial pursuits. And the late Arthur Laurents seemed to think so as well.
kornpone 7 months ago
RIP Arthur Laurents. The genius behind this production and Gypsy!!!
diego9774 9 months ago
Crying here.
RLviddy 11 months ago
A) Good thing you weren't seen recording this
B) I wish I had the Judi Densch recording - I'd trade a limb for a recording of this show.
alicia92960 1 year ago
@alicia92960 ditto
ERDorsch 7 months ago
11,071 views and no thumbs down. Smart crowd.
TheHallBobby 1 year ago 2
Omigosh both of these women just gave me goosebumps! I love that this live theatre can to you:)
WickedTheMusical7 1 year ago
holy shit laura is ferocious! amazing performance chills up my spine!
lesmizfanatic90 1 year ago
Wow...
Straw2daberry 1 year ago
These two women are sensational and I can't wait to see them together again in Women on the Verge! ^^
Dalthis555 1 year ago
STOP RECORDING THIS VIDEO! WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE?!
Haha : )
russia687 1 year ago 2
I hate the way there is no backdrop and the stage is very bare
fountainchain126 1 year ago
If anyone wants a copy of this show on dvd with a autographed playbill of Gypsy, signed by Patti LuPone, Laura Benanti and Boyd Gained. Hit me up on my aim xoalxscrzox , im looking to trade both those items for the Judi Dench cast recording of A Little Night Music
alxscrz 1 year ago
Damn Laura Benati is amazing, who wouldn't love to do a scene where they get tell of a major diva (not in the good way)?!?! This is incredible!
1995BroadwayBaby 1 year ago
The most electrifying two performances I have ever witnessed in the theatre.
americanboy99 1 year ago
Help me out here. What is Patti's line at 2:49? It sounds like she says "Beautiful lesbian speaks lousy french and reads book reviews." For some reason I don't think that's right. I don't trust Patti's diction. Maybe it's "Beauty burlesque queen"? Someone throw me a bone on this one.
milesfile77 1 year ago
@milesfile77 She says ... "You, the burlesque queen, that speaks lousy French and reads book reviews.." Ms. LuPone's diction is amazing. Illegally recorded videos from the mezzanine are not to blame for any misunderstanding of her performance. Who do you think you are?
212dude 1 year ago
AHAHAHAHA LAURA IS THE SHIT SHE TOTALLY SHOWS UP LUPONE
BellatrixNellieLovet 1 year ago
I sort of wish Patti wouldn't play every character like she's Evita. I'm sorry, I don't want to come off trollish, but...I'm kind of tired of that same schtick...
That being said, Laura Benanti is fabulous here.
yougottagetagimmick 1 year ago
i would give anything to play Louise just to do this scene, if nothing else :D
BwayDreamer1128 1 year ago 2
amazing performances
RentandWicked 1 year ago
this is the way this scene should always be performed! Perfection.
MidtownBlake 1 year ago 3
that was intense.
MrMusicstone 1 year ago 5
Thank god Patti didn't catch you recording this!
Capricaquarius89 1 year ago 54
@Capricaquarius89 WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE. HOW DAAAAAAAAAAAARE YOU.
krispykritterlover 1 year ago
Laura Benanti, omg, amazing acting!
Yesss8 1 year ago 4
This was, for me, one of the best acted shows I've seen on Broadway!
Mattbrain 2 years ago 3
@Mattbrain I totally agree. The performances from LuPone, Benanti, and Gaines were all well-deserving of Tonys. The supporting cast was incredible as well. Such a glorious memory!
Judill 1 year ago 2
yeah, it seemed like this was from the beginning. as good as this is, they brought this scene to a whole new level by the end of the run
ojalaquetubailes 2 years ago
Laura's actually shaking. What a performer.
JmB8207 2 years ago 11
god was is patti so talented is amazing
operastar1994 2 years ago
What does Laura yell at 2:57?
bodes08 2 years ago
@bodes08 "I said 'Turn it off!'"
AngelAdorable3 2 years ago
"I said turn it off!"
ILive4IdinaMenzel 2 years ago 6
Ohhhh...Patti's a diva biatch...I luv luv luv her!!
intomybrain12345 2 years ago 2
Well no wonder she was the first to win the Tony...every other Rose Lee was too nice during the scene
babyboi1002 2 years ago 3
Actually Angela Lansbury won an tony for the Role of Rose in 1974 and Tyne Daly won in 1989.
CromTO 2 years ago
I was talking about Gypsy
babyboi1002 2 years ago
does anyone have this full show??
ciaranhaggerty 2 years ago
I do...send me a message.
fiddleriddler 2 years ago
very intense...
it gave me chills too...
you could even hear people in the audience gasping...
imagine it when you're in the audience...
supertazzyboy 2 years ago 4
Sorry I don't know if this was early in the run. Laura Benanti is such a great actress, she gave me chills when I saw this
alxscrz 2 years ago 7
@alxscrz
MuzzyVanH 1 year ago
when was this from? Was it earlier? It's amazing how far they came by the end of the run.
ojalaquetubailes 2 years ago
If I'm correct, this is from March 25, 2008.
fiddleriddler 2 years ago
Wow.
elphabelle07 2 years ago