If only Les mis was released years before, Dench would have made an amazing Fantine! .. and your right @lanpbx - She wouldnt make it past the first round of the x-factor... shes not bad enough to be on a stupid TV get famous quick scheme... because shes a professional.
What a lot of people forget about Sally Bowles (or they never knew in the first place) is that she is supposed to be a second rate singer. The problem is, it's difficult to make a musical with a singer who really is second rate! I think Judi Dench is superb in the role. Wish I'd been old enough to actually see her live!
Judi is an amazing actress and singer, she brings SO much life to Sally Bowles and the character isn't suposed to be perfect! If you think Judi isn't great listen to her singing Send In The Clowns, its incredible!! And watch the film Nine!
Do none of you saying that Judi Dench can't sing realise that the character of Sally Bowles is meant to be an amateur. She's not meant to be good. Liza Minnelli sung properly.. She was "too good" to be Sally Bowles. Judi Dench makes herself bad to suit the character.
@joniJEALOUSY I don't know. Think Minneli is a little flat now and then. This song is about personality, and most of the ladies who sang it gave it their all, whatever that all was. Richardson was particularly bad and good. Minneli defined it. But why not? Completely deserved. And of course we all love Judi Dench.
The proplem with ,say ,Liza Minnelli's Sally Bowles is that she is too good a singer.Sally HAS to sleep around to keep her job because she's not.This ,for me ,is a truer performance.
Personally, I've always much preferred JILL HAYWORTH'S Sally from the Original 1966 Broadway Production. I think Hayworth's Sally is a lot more SYMPATHETIC than Judi Dench's Sally, and is replete with an effortless *YOUTHFUL* CHARM that I don't find in Dench, who acts and sounds a little *TOO* JADED for my liking, although awesome in her own right.
I basically think Jill is better at balancing Sally's endearing qualities with her *DARKER* attributes, but of course that's my own affinity..
Very interesting observations. I for one felt like Judi Dench's Sally was the most "sophisticated" out of the lot - the one who oozed "refinement", and considered Jill Hayworth's Sally to be the "smokin'", more "erotic" one who "oozed sexiness". Of course, both Jill and Judi have distinctively HUSKY voices, and are BOTH effortlessly *CLASSY* albeit in VERY DIFFERENT WAYS. :)
Compared to Jill and Judi, however, Liza's Sally ends up looking like a TOMBOYISH *LITTLE GIRL*, as much as I LOVE Liza.
Dench is still fabulous and sexy no matter how old she is she can sing and dance with the best of them. She is known for her throaty voice that is what makes her stand out. she has one play after another lined up for 2009 and 2010. We love her we all go to London to see her.
She sings and packs the audience to sold out tickets. She still has a sexy throaty voice and is still sexy in person. I would watch her if she sand and read a phone book she has class compared to a lot of the younger actess;s today.
I call it art. She delivers the emotion the writer/director wanted. I like Cher too and she is always flat. Some people like Celine Dion and she is always sharp. We have different aural pleasures.
Her voice is undeniably unique and an excellent tool used to describe the character of Sally Bowels.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
If you managed to think about it for a moment you would realise the situation is the opposite, ie. X-Factor is a very low standard. Dench's singing here is so bad that she would even fail the first stage of that. If this was a 'nobody', everyone would be cringeing, but as it's arch luvvy Judi Dench, it's bloody marvellous, dahling, positively divine. What a load of rubbish.
You don't know what you're talking about - this is from a recording of a musical where she is playing a CHARACTER. That character is an untalented singer. What people are praising here isn't Dench's "singing" in the sense of X Factor singing, but her acting through song - she portrays the character incredibly, but you need to know about the musical and the character to appreciate what she's doing in this song. Nothing to do with being a luvvy.
@Ianpbx She's singing badly because that's the character of Sally Bowles. She's not meant to be a good singer. She's MEANT to be an amateur singing in a sleazy club.
Jane what do you think of this ?
Love Sallie.xxxx
MegaTiggers 2 weeks ago
SALLY bOLES WAS TO BE FLAT AND JUDI IS A ORIGNAL SINGER FROM THE DAY WHEN THIS WAS POPULAR.THE SONG WAS MADE FOR SOMEONE WHO SANG THIS WAY.
Bluedolphingirl01 2 months ago
Holy crap, it's 'M'
ohsnapiam59 2 months ago 2
Incomparable!
gladys12373 3 months ago
If only Les mis was released years before, Dench would have made an amazing Fantine! .. and your right @lanpbx - She wouldnt make it past the first round of the x-factor... shes not bad enough to be on a stupid TV get famous quick scheme... because shes a professional.
Classicalytrained 3 months ago 4
I love Judi Dench.She is a true star.What a trooper doing this even with a cold,like the article said.Wonderful job!
1jillshaw64 4 months ago
trop bien
patypatcheco08 4 months ago
Thousands with better voice, prettier figure, more beautiful face. No one better. And it's not even close.
1blacklab 4 months ago
Comment removed
Gigigamble 5 months ago
What a lot of people forget about Sally Bowles (or they never knew in the first place) is that she is supposed to be a second rate singer. The problem is, it's difficult to make a musical with a singer who really is second rate! I think Judi Dench is superb in the role. Wish I'd been old enough to actually see her live!
lindacooper61 6 months ago 5
Is there anything she can't do? This is magnificent. Real art. I love her voice -- I'll take it over any of those pop belters any day.
AtLastOnTheGround 8 months ago
Nobody like Judi. ♥.
BatmansFavoriteGirl 8 months ago in playlist MY FAVORITES
Judi is an amazing actress and singer, she brings SO much life to Sally Bowles and the character isn't suposed to be perfect! If you think Judi isn't great listen to her singing Send In The Clowns, its incredible!! And watch the film Nine!
sandunderfeet 8 months ago
I think she's a better Sally Bowles than she was a Fraulien Schneider (though she was a pretty good Fraulien)
Jazzzkidd 9 months ago
I just got the original london cast LP with Judi as Sally. I ADORE her soo much!
Poontasty 11 months ago
She has the excellent voice for Sally Bowels. A wonderful person, to her fans also.
Bluedolphingirl01 11 months ago
judi dench is undeniably a very talented actress
felilov 1 year ago
Gosh, never knew she was a singer!
BlackLelie 1 year ago 2
Her voice is... different.
Atheneastro 1 year ago
this is incredible. judi is 100% on pitch. thats more than I can say for most 'singers'
flicfan416 1 year ago
Do none of you saying that Judi Dench can't sing realise that the character of Sally Bowles is meant to be an amateur. She's not meant to be good. Liza Minnelli sung properly.. She was "too good" to be Sally Bowles. Judi Dench makes herself bad to suit the character.
joniJEALOUSY 1 year ago 10
@joniJEALOUSY I don't know. Think Minneli is a little flat now and then. This song is about personality, and most of the ladies who sang it gave it their all, whatever that all was. Richardson was particularly bad and good. Minneli defined it. But why not? Completely deserved. And of course we all love Judi Dench.
brelfan 1 year ago
do you have 'Maby This Time'??
ChannelTin 2 years ago
@ChannelTin Maybe This Time wasn't in the original score.
jemb2000 2 years ago 7
The proplem with ,say ,Liza Minnelli's Sally Bowles is that she is too good a singer.Sally HAS to sleep around to keep her job because she's not.This ,for me ,is a truer performance.
patlaws 2 years ago 6
Dench is defiantely the best no doubt in our mind , she is known for her throaty singing and this was how it was suppose to be.
Bluedolphingirl01 2 years ago
Personally, I've always much preferred JILL HAYWORTH'S Sally from the Original 1966 Broadway Production. I think Hayworth's Sally is a lot more SYMPATHETIC than Judi Dench's Sally, and is replete with an effortless *YOUTHFUL* CHARM that I don't find in Dench, who acts and sounds a little *TOO* JADED for my liking, although awesome in her own right.
I basically think Jill is better at balancing Sally's endearing qualities with her *DARKER* attributes, but of course that's my own affinity..
Rapture1987 2 years ago
I prefer Judi Dench's Sally Bowles to Liza's version.
Judi oozed sexiness and was just so smokin' going across the stage.
Plus, the husky voice.......very erotic.
Now I love Liza Minelli but her Sally just didn't have the same appeal as Judi Dench's.
ElectricShark 2 years ago 6
Very interesting observations. I for one felt like Judi Dench's Sally was the most "sophisticated" out of the lot - the one who oozed "refinement", and considered Jill Hayworth's Sally to be the "smokin'", more "erotic" one who "oozed sexiness". Of course, both Jill and Judi have distinctively HUSKY voices, and are BOTH effortlessly *CLASSY* albeit in VERY DIFFERENT WAYS. :)
Compared to Jill and Judi, however, Liza's Sally ends up looking like a TOMBOYISH *LITTLE GIRL*, as much as I LOVE Liza.
Rapture1987 2 years ago 2
Thank you for sharing this! Excellent photo montage to go with the recording. What a fascinating performance!
sallydurant 2 years ago
Dench is still fabulous and sexy no matter how old she is she can sing and dance with the best of them. She is known for her throaty voice that is what makes her stand out. she has one play after another lined up for 2009 and 2010. We love her we all go to London to see her.
Bluedolphingirl01 2 years ago 2
She sings and packs the audience to sold out tickets. She still has a sexy throaty voice and is still sexy in person. I would watch her if she sand and read a phone book she has class compared to a lot of the younger actess;s today.
Bluedolphingirl01 2 years ago 2
Judi, Judi, Judi!!!
JohnnyNW 2 years ago 3
Omg this is fucking fabulous. I never knew she could sing. It all makes sense now.
jophus82 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You call that 'singing'? People of this standard even get kicked off x-factor! She's flat and constantly changing sub-key.
Ianpbx 2 years ago
I call it art. She delivers the emotion the writer/director wanted. I like Cher too and she is always flat. Some people like Celine Dion and she is always sharp. We have different aural pleasures.
Her voice is undeniably unique and an excellent tool used to describe the character of Sally Bowels.
jophus82 2 years ago 17
I'm sorry to say this, but if xfactor is your measure of excellence, you shouldn't be questioning someone else's individual taste.
jophus82 2 years ago 20
This comment has received too many negative votes show
If you managed to think about it for a moment you would realise the situation is the opposite, ie. X-Factor is a very low standard. Dench's singing here is so bad that she would even fail the first stage of that. If this was a 'nobody', everyone would be cringeing, but as it's arch luvvy Judi Dench, it's bloody marvellous, dahling, positively divine. What a load of rubbish.
Ianpbx 2 years ago
You don't know what you're talking about - this is from a recording of a musical where she is playing a CHARACTER. That character is an untalented singer. What people are praising here isn't Dench's "singing" in the sense of X Factor singing, but her acting through song - she portrays the character incredibly, but you need to know about the musical and the character to appreciate what she's doing in this song. Nothing to do with being a luvvy.
darkjosh 2 years ago 7
@Ianpbx She's singing badly because that's the character of Sally Bowles. She's not meant to be a good singer. She's MEANT to be an amateur singing in a sleazy club.
joniJEALOUSY 1 year ago 8
genius piece of casting
genius performance
grai 2 years ago 3
she was so gorgeous back in the day
shpidoinkleboy 2 years ago 3