This is, without a doubt, the best Doctor/Rose video I've ever seen. The editing is flawless... and there's just so much emotion! I keep coming back to this video. Amazing job :)
Oh wow. I love this video. Very well composed - I love how it really speaks, not only about how he loved rose, but how it was all he could think about when martha was around. VERY nice. The transition at 0:55 really got me. It's so sad! Great song, great clips. Kudos, and thanks for sharing.
the part "stuck with you, that's not so bad" and he says "yeah?" and Rose says "yes" immediately; it might just be me, but it is like he can't believe he is loved. Pretty touching. Thanks for the video! Also, the juxtaposition of him smiling and the part where he loses her, wow.
WOW. I want Rose and The 10th Doctor together forever!! They were the perfect couple. Aww I miss them. Your video is spectacular. It's emotional and beautiful. I really love how you made 1;58-2;04 look like they were reaching for eachother. Again, spectacular. amazing
@luvjwtyt11 -- the "a longer life..." etc line is from "The Lazarus Experiment" from Series 3. And then the "Rose..." bit at the beginning, of course, is the Finale of Series 2. Hope that helps! :D Thanks for watching! <3
Very, very good timing, I was impressed ;) These couple still have so much more to say. And even if only in video now. I miss them. Than you for your video, I will rewatched it surely :)
The part where he is begging the Master to regenerate was so powerful in the way you've set it up with the other clips and with the music. Very very moving. Oh, I'm enjoying this season but watching vids like this...god I miss Ten, and I feel so so sorry that once he lost Rose, even with moments of happiness his life seemed to get sadder and sadder. Beautiful vid.
I have listened to alot of Dr. Who Mixes..and I have to say this is by far the best.You picked the right song, the right clips. I would love to see you do another one! Is there anyway you can make a MP3 of this with the audio clips on it? I would love to have this in my collection.
This video broke my heart. As if it didn't break the first time I saw the Doctor and Rose ripped apart. But believe me, the broken heart? It's a good sign. Top job.
Wow. The bit where he was screaming at the master to regenerate just made me gasp!! The way you blended it with the memories of Rose was amazing. I can barely explain my reaction - but it was a strong one. Excellent job, Chlarkent!!!
This video really is the definition of sucsess. Videos aren't about all the great effects and edits, its purpose is to convey a perfect video through mood and images. And your video, more than does that.
I really enjoyed this video! It would be interesting what you would do with Rose's return. I love this song. It's nice the way you told a story with this arrangement of edited clips. I especially like the way the lyrics match up with the clips and how you paired what the Doctor and Rose does. If the Doctor dreams I would think he would dream of Rose. I love the way you captured David Tennant's character of Ten. Five stars!
You know, I was just listening to this song and was wondering if someone did a vid for it with the Doc and Rose. Woohoo! It was beautiful. Too bad it doesn't have any of the series 4 footage in it. But it was made awhile ago....but still very moving! *tear*
Had to comment and say how much i love. this. vid. It makes me cry EVERY time I see it. Thanks so much for making it. PERFECT editing and the song choice is just. guh.
dude thats the best bloody vid ever and im ussally a pick 1 so congrats man u should get a fukin medal but i think the doctor ight not agree with u reminding him shes gone XD
so beautiful. You compare to all his bad times without Rose and you see that series two is the time you see him really see him smiling. I mean seriously in series 3 he tries to kill himself a dozen times. You could see how much he misses Rose! Great vid!
wow-- this is a great vid! It is now in my favorites. I love how you compared his happy times and sad/hard times, they blend well with the song. Also, my absolute fav part was his walking in the tux, from VOTD, and how you mixed it in with the other clips. Phew! Okay, I'm done. :)
I just wanted to say this isn't only one of my favorite Doctor Who vids, but one of my favorite on YouTube as well! I revisit it often. It is made of win! Do you have it available for download anywhere?
WOW!!! :-) really, truely beautiful :-) please check out my doctor/rose vid and tell me what you think :-) (btw the 'wow' wasn't to butter you up lol tis a genuinely good video :-D) xxx
Oh, this is amazing. OneRepublic actually has a few songs that I think could make great Doctor Who videos, and this is definitely one of them. Brilliant editing, m'dear. I love this video!
Okay, so I just recently discovered OneRepublic and fell in love with them, especially this song. As I was listening to it I thought, "This would be BRILLIANT for a Dr. Who vid." But I have absolutely no skills for that kind of thing, so I just settle for watching them on youtube. I searched it and this one popped up, and I must say, you're a genius. I was afraid it would be campy, but you did such a lovely job and I actually cried. Kudos to you. 5*!!
Thank you so much for the lovely comment! This is by-far my favorite song of OneRepublic's as well; I was a bit nervous starting into this vid, if only because I didn't want to ruin the song. ;)
I'm so glad it stood up to your expectations! You cried? *feels loved* LOL ;) Thank you for the rating as well! *xo*
Oh, I wish I had Sony Vegas. *lol!* Just ShowBiz DVD by Arcsoft. As for the audio, you can download Audacity free and do the same; just Google it. It has a good echo feature. :)
Great editing again. I love how fast paced it is and yet it still flows seemlessly! Poor Doctor, things never really do seem to go his way. Great vid however! ;)
This vid so perfectly captures the dark side of the doctor and everything he's gone through. Great use of quotes "...if you live long enough the only certainty left is that you'll end up alone"... chilling I loved it.
Awesome job on this one. :) You see... people who like Smallville and Dr Who are extremely talented...He he. :D Great use of underlying audio, some forget how important quality audio is to the enjoyment of a video. The montage from 2:30 onwards is fantastic. and great use of VOTD footage. WOW.
LOL! I didn't think there were any other people who like Smallville and Dr. Who! ;) And I must say, I'm quite flattered you appreciated the sound editing since that has always been one of your greatest strengths when making your own videos.
and now i cry
mollimolls 4 months ago
So emotional....*sniff*...look!...uh...i mean...er....anyway, my eyes are watering my face like a little garden! great job *does thumbs up*
ShattteredChaos 4 months ago
This is, without a doubt, the best Doctor/Rose video I've ever seen. The editing is flawless... and there's just so much emotion! I keep coming back to this video. Amazing job :)
jammy8758 6 months ago
what program did you use?
VinylKiss 7 months ago
What's the part where Rose looks like she's being pulled into a bright light?
celesitie 7 months ago
<3 This song totally fits. This video actually made me LOVE this song.
thatgirlbackstage 7 months ago
I always keep coming back to watch this. So well done.
Kamane 7 months ago
all of onerpublics songs remind me of DW
VinylKiss 8 months ago
i cried
VinylKiss 8 months ago
Magnifique chanson et le montage vidéo est impressionnant et emplie d'émotions ! J'ai la larme à l'oeil^^!!!
bruno08200 8 months ago
what episode is the clip of Rose at 2:00 from?
kelenloth 9 months ago
Oh wow. I love this video. Very well composed - I love how it really speaks, not only about how he loved rose, but how it was all he could think about when martha was around. VERY nice. The transition at 0:55 really got me. It's so sad! Great song, great clips. Kudos, and thanks for sharing.
kelenloth 9 months ago
Comment removed
kelenloth 9 months ago
Hi, just a suggestion, but using Mercy by OneRepublic would also be a really good song i think - this song just reminded me of that!
Great video and it would be amazing if you could do another one with 'Mercy'. :)
MissARoss95 10 months ago
That was heartbreaking and completely BRILLIANT!
~
sanityisrelative 11 months ago
the part "stuck with you, that's not so bad" and he says "yeah?" and Rose says "yes" immediately; it might just be me, but it is like he can't believe he is loved. Pretty touching. Thanks for the video! Also, the juxtaposition of him smiling and the part where he loses her, wow.
iwant2believe1 1 year ago
WOW. I want Rose and The 10th Doctor together forever!! They were the perfect couple. Aww I miss them. Your video is spectacular. It's emotional and beautiful. I really love how you made 1;58-2;04 look like they were reaching for eachother. Again, spectacular. amazing
immortaletternity 1 year ago 2
This has been, and remains, one of my absolute favourite Ten/Rose vids of all time. :)
februarysongawake 1 year ago 4
/tears! Wonderful video!
Kamane 1 year ago
Lovely video montage. I'm usually not really touched by them, but this one is great selection of scenes and music :) Thanks for posting!
emdash1000 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
put it in with my favorites. )
ninino86 1 year ago
wheres the first part where david's speaking from?
luvjwtyt11 1 year ago
@luvjwtyt11 -- the "a longer life..." etc line is from "The Lazarus Experiment" from Series 3. And then the "Rose..." bit at the beginning, of course, is the Finale of Series 2. Hope that helps! :D Thanks for watching! <3
Chlarkent 1 year ago
Very, very good timing, I was impressed ;) These couple still have so much more to say. And even if only in video now. I miss them. Than you for your video, I will rewatched it surely :)
Bookvegalo 1 year ago
I love the voices mixed in with the song! Perfectly timed and so appropriate! Great job, Chlarkent! :)
crunchypg 1 year ago
such a great video amazing job almost made me cry ahah loved it :)
MrGoldilocks33 1 year ago
He didnt love Rose, and now Moffat is retconning the whole RTD era...ROFL
HeyArnoldsspleen 1 year ago
@HeyArnoldsspleen well actually he did..... there were a number of allusions to it thruout the series
starsintheireyes14 1 year ago
I just want the doctor to admit out loud he loves Rose.
MEROXMESOX1 1 year ago
Awesome! :)
tshen6 1 year ago
The part where he is begging the Master to regenerate was so powerful in the way you've set it up with the other clips and with the music. Very very moving. Oh, I'm enjoying this season but watching vids like this...god I miss Ten, and I feel so so sorry that once he lost Rose, even with moments of happiness his life seemed to get sadder and sadder. Beautiful vid.
paigehobo 1 year ago
I have to say this is the most beautiful doctor/rose vid i've seen,good job
Ejlisha 1 year ago
Brilliant.
bg922 2 years ago
I have listened to alot of Dr. Who Mixes..and I have to say this is by far the best.You picked the right song, the right clips. I would love to see you do another one! Is there anyway you can make a MP3 of this with the audio clips on it? I would love to have this in my collection.
Well Done!!
TMulvale 2 years ago
This video broke my heart. As if it didn't break the first time I saw the Doctor and Rose ripped apart. But believe me, the broken heart? It's a good sign. Top job.
rejectedreader 2 years ago
This is just absolutely wonderful!!! Great job!!!! Keep it up!!!
TheLastTimeLord101 2 years ago
Oh my GOD, this is BEAUTIFUL!
Mayushi09 2 years ago 2
what episode is at 2:58, and then returns a bunch of times up to like 3:15? The one with the doctor walking slowly in a tux?
coconutsdomigrate 2 years ago
All those shots are taken from the near-end of "Voyage of the Damned" from series 4.
Hope that helps ya! Thanks for watching! :D
Cheers,
- Chloe
Chlarkent 2 years ago
Thanks : ) I thought that was the case...who can forget DT in a tux after all xDDDD.
coconutsdomigrate 2 years ago
Haha! So true. ;) That's what I love about "Smith and Jones" also. :D
Cheers,
- Chloe
Chlarkent 2 years ago
What's the spisode at 0;11 I have never seen it and I want too
JeremyKyleLuva 2 years ago
That scene (and the opening dialogue) are from "The Lazarus Experiment" in Series 3. :)
Hope that helps you! Thanks for watching. :D
Ta-ra!
-- Chloe
Chlarkent 2 years ago
Thanks, I thought it was I wasn't so sure. I couldn't remember it
I might hire it out even who much I do not like Martha, just to here him say that. like he was looking at the camera. Nice work!
JeremyKyleLuva 2 years ago
No probs! And thanks for the feedback. :D
Ta-ra!
- Chloe
Chlarkent 2 years ago
No Probs one of the Best. I'll fav it I didn't think I did, I
I'll fav again
JeremyKyleLuva 2 years ago
Aw!! I want Rose and the Doctor to be together! :'(
Lovely Video!
bookworm135 2 years ago 8
wow was für ein hammer geiles video
Jugendbetreuer 2 years ago 2
What is the name of the ep. where the Dr. kisses Martha?
whiteraven101 2 years ago
Smith and Jones, the first episode of series 3, when they are in the the moon running from the platoon of Judoon. ;-)
ooutroaccountfilmes 2 years ago
Wow that was an amazing video! 5 stars!
starliteluv5 2 years ago 6
Wow. The bit where he was screaming at the master to regenerate just made me gasp!! The way you blended it with the memories of Rose was amazing. I can barely explain my reaction - but it was a strong one. Excellent job, Chlarkent!!!
mebee4 2 years ago
This video really is the definition of sucsess. Videos aren't about all the great effects and edits, its purpose is to convey a perfect video through mood and images. And your video, more than does that.
Perfect.
x
Dtisfit 2 years ago
This is absolutly Beautiful...It made me cry!
Hidethetruth 3 years ago
i love this video it so sad
kt27rule 3 years ago
I really enjoyed this video! It would be interesting what you would do with Rose's return. I love this song. It's nice the way you told a story with this arrangement of edited clips. I especially like the way the lyrics match up with the clips and how you paired what the Doctor and Rose does. If the Doctor dreams I would think he would dream of Rose. I love the way you captured David Tennant's character of Ten. Five stars!
KLady3 3 years ago
You know, I was just listening to this song and was wondering if someone did a vid for it with the Doc and Rose. Woohoo! It was beautiful. Too bad it doesn't have any of the series 4 footage in it. But it was made awhile ago....but still very moving! *tear*
ckslats 3 years ago
This made me cry..it's soo good, well done! :)
GSMFA 3 years ago
This vid is amazing!!!I love ONe republic, this song, and Doctor Who, yet never thoguht of it all together. Great Job! :)
Thumbelina1228 3 years ago 2
Had to comment and say how much i love. this. vid. It makes me cry EVERY time I see it. Thanks so much for making it. PERFECT editing and the song choice is just. guh.
inthepouringrain 3 years ago
dude thats the best bloody vid ever and im ussally a pick 1 so congrats man u should get a fukin medal but i think the doctor ight not agree with u reminding him shes gone XD
sighin out the furbster *aka lewis*
lewi5676 3 years ago
so beautiful. You compare to all his bad times without Rose and you see that series two is the time you see him really see him smiling. I mean seriously in series 3 he tries to kill himself a dozen times. You could see how much he misses Rose! Great vid!
Jude
bohemianhysteria 3 years ago 3
That was great, I enjoyed watching it!
SarahLev3 3 years ago
i really love this video i've watched it about 20 times now and it gets me every time lol well done xxx
cutirae 3 years ago
This was both fantastic and brilliant :D and these sortsa vids get on my nerves, so well done! where do you get your clips from?
doctorwhomadgal 3 years ago
can i also ask what you used to edit this?? and also how did you get the footage?? thanks
ForeverTwilight595 3 years ago 2
It's a lovely vidieo, but only the talking at the beggining really worked
undinae 3 years ago
Beautiful! I love how you used color.
xAnimatedEntropyx 3 years ago
aw thats so sad they cant be togther aw bless. Anyway great vid the song choice was gurd cuz I love this song
xsweetsmilerx 3 years ago
Im Not A Massive Ten/Rose Fan Cause I Really Love Martha! I Do Think Rose Belongs With The Doctor, & I REALLY REALLY Love This Video!
Well Done!! :)
iloveyooall 3 years ago
wow-- this is a great vid! It is now in my favorites. I love how you compared his happy times and sad/hard times, they blend well with the song. Also, my absolute fav part was his walking in the tux, from VOTD, and how you mixed it in with the other clips. Phew! Okay, I'm done. :)
sorcha425 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
thanks for ruining the song
HawkeyeWho 3 years ago
My pleasure!
Thanks for watching/commenting.
Cheers,
- Chloe
Chlarkent 3 years ago
this is sooo good...
i love it at 1.59 when it looks like he's reaching for her.
nice work :D
callhercath 3 years ago
I just wanted to say this isn't only one of my favorite Doctor Who vids, but one of my favorite on YouTube as well! I revisit it often. It is made of win! Do you have it available for download anywhere?
GoBoldly 3 years ago 3
My goodness- thank you so much for the high praise! *blush* Fantastic to hear, thanks mate.
And yes, I just added a link to the video info with which you can download a copy of it in .WMV :)
Ta!
- Chloe
Chlarkent 3 years ago
WOW!!! :-) really, truely beautiful :-) please check out my doctor/rose vid and tell me what you think :-) (btw the 'wow' wasn't to butter you up lol tis a genuinely good video :-D) xxx
SexieEstie 3 years ago
love it xx
justbeen01 3 years ago
Oh, this is amazing. OneRepublic actually has a few songs that I think could make great Doctor Who videos, and this is definitely one of them. Brilliant editing, m'dear. I love this video!
nolaespoir 3 years ago 2
Oh. My. God.
That was...wow!
AsarathWitch 3 years ago 2
such a great one republic song-nice job with the video, i love doctor/rose.
slapchar77 3 years ago 2
oh, i love it
5 stars for you!
hazzo666 3 years ago 2
wow that was so good 5* and faves
totallyDT 3 years ago 2
Okay, so I just recently discovered OneRepublic and fell in love with them, especially this song. As I was listening to it I thought, "This would be BRILLIANT for a Dr. Who vid." But I have absolutely no skills for that kind of thing, so I just settle for watching them on youtube. I searched it and this one popped up, and I must say, you're a genius. I was afraid it would be campy, but you did such a lovely job and I actually cried. Kudos to you. 5*!!
februarysongawake 3 years ago 2
Thank you so much for the lovely comment! This is by-far my favorite song of OneRepublic's as well; I was a bit nervous starting into this vid, if only because I didn't want to ruin the song. ;)
I'm so glad it stood up to your expectations! You cried? *feels loved* LOL ;) Thank you for the rating as well! *xo*
All the best,
- Chloe
Chlarkent 3 years ago
Brilliant vid BTW! 5*s favourited!
zcatz 3 years ago
Do you use Sony Vegas? If so how do you get the sounds to echo?
zcatz 3 years ago
Oh, I wish I had Sony Vegas. *lol!* Just ShowBiz DVD by Arcsoft. As for the audio, you can download Audacity free and do the same; just Google it. It has a good echo feature. :)
Thanks for watching!
- Chloe
Chlarkent 3 years ago
i really do love dis video,
please never delete this from youtube please lol
justbeen12 4 years ago 3
Aw, thank you so much. *blush* I promise never to delete it. Since you asked so nicely and all. ;)
All the best, justbeen!
- Chloe
Chlarkent 4 years ago
wow...really great!
Yecats17 4 years ago
Oh my gosh I love it!! It's such great editing and the song matches perfectly. Wicked stuff!
Mysteries4ever 4 years ago
WOW this was great
i dont really no da song but it does go well with wot u av made so well done, it made tears come to my eyes lol great job xx
justbeen12 4 years ago
Good work, what did you edit this with? This must have took ages, it's fantastic.
Sefulan 4 years ago
i dont even watch this show and i started crying. PERFECT SONG
smaville1622 4 years ago
Pass the tissues....excellent!
btvsfreak 4 years ago
woow wow and woow im this is such an amazing vid, i love doctor who reallly great and fantastic editing!
darkmarkgirl 4 years ago
Man... I love this vid. :D xx
seduff 4 years ago 2
Man, I love seeing you on this vid. *glow*
Chlarkent 4 years ago
Great editing again. I love how fast paced it is and yet it still flows seemlessly! Poor Doctor, things never really do seem to go his way. Great vid however! ;)
THEpowerOFme 4 years ago 2
yay- I liked that
sallangel 4 years ago
This vid so perfectly captures the dark side of the doctor and everything he's gone through. Great use of quotes "...if you live long enough the only certainty left is that you'll end up alone"... chilling I loved it.
pammcasso 4 years ago
absolutely AMAZING everything fits perfectly!!
great job! keep it up!
triplejjs 4 years ago
Awesome job on this one. :) You see... people who like Smallville and Dr Who are extremely talented...He he. :D Great use of underlying audio, some forget how important quality audio is to the enjoyment of a video. The montage from 2:30 onwards is fantastic. and great use of VOTD footage. WOW.
I really enjoyed this one. Sarah xx :)
seduff 4 years ago 2
My word, Sarah- what a fantastic comment. *glow*
LOL! I didn't think there were any other people who like Smallville and Dr. Who! ;) And I must say, I'm quite flattered you appreciated the sound editing since that has always been one of your greatest strengths when making your own videos.
Thank you so much for the comment, Sarah!
Chlarkent 4 years ago
I love the song too. Already downloaded it and have it playing in my car. :) xx
seduff 4 years ago
This video is pretty amazing! The voice overs fit so well, the song choice and everything just fit together really well.
cjhar512 4 years ago
It was great loved the beginning and the black and white instances are so sweet andsad the whole vid is fun. Touching, miss them together.
DavidsGirl841444 4 years ago
omg that is so awesome!!! 5 stars!!
00runawaysmile00 4 years ago