Thats pretty sad if all you got from the first part of the novel is Sunny. I mean thats exactly what Holden hates about adults. Sex, which is inevitably the gateway to adulthood and loss of innocence. You guys have obviously loss your innocence.
The warning label in the beginning was correct. it's not even worth bashing because the actors are fully aware of how this sucked. At least you're honest.
I actually understood the book(because i'm a nerd like that)And im only 12 years old, I think that book was great,I read it 2 months ago the slang was a little problem but later I knew what it meant later on.
Some people believe that the book is Evil,because john Lennon's murderer Mark David Chapman was obsessed with the book,they believe it gave him insight on how to kill,so i cant see how this book can be great,because of the involvement it has in killing a great Artist.
i'm not even twelve yet and i've read "the catcher in the rye" it is now my favorite book. this scene with sunny the prostitute is the only "bad"(explicit) scene in the book and i think that this book isn't that contiversial at all besides all the swearing and stuff but who cares. i think that people shold stop being pussies and that this book should be required reading in every school.(but not every grade; 7th sounds good.)
The Catcher in the Rye was not meant to be read by kids in 7th grade, no offense. In order to understand the true meanings behind the book and really understand Holden, you have to have a level of maturity that middle-schoolers just don't have yet. Its cool that you can understand the words, but read it again in a few years and you'll have a much better understanding of the book.
well i can see why you would say that, but not ALL younger people are unable to comprehend the deeper meaning behind what is said in this book. people underestimate the mental capacity and maturity level of some young people.
i agree catcher in the rye is meant for teens and older, you can't get the idea of grieve over loss innocence before you actually lose your innocence, sure kids are smart they are underestimated but intellectual cleverness shouldn't be confused with emotional maturity
he is not emo, he isjust very hungy with the hipocreasy of his life, he's a kind of philosopher punk xD, but not emo, the emos aren't so real like holden, holden always says the true, but the emos tinhk that they are like holden
lol im in the 7th grade in just reading it for the fun of it i like it so far anyway i loved the part when you played sexy back lolz omfg that was golden
I've read The Catcher in the Rye but I've heard Salinger's other books aren't very good. Could anyone help me out and tell me their favorite J.D. Salinger books beside's The Catcher in the Rye? Thanks alot!
personally, catcher in the rye is as good as it gets. its my favorite book, and im very prejudice. but many people think it's his best book, and it is definately good and its a short read so i'd read it forsure if i were you.
Nine Stories, Franny and Zoey, Raise High the Roof Beam. They are equally good, depending upon on how you take the stories. Catcher of course is incomparable.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
well you little faggots who have no life actually sat there for 8 minutes and watched a video of some kids you dont even know you fuckin pedophiles get a life
Couldn't have a picked a worse actor to play Holden in the whole goddam universe. Feel so depressed watching those phony actors it just about killed me.
LMAO! im reading this book again right now for the third time, I just got past the part where the elevator man beats holden for his 5$. pretty depressing book.
erm ... that was ... oh weird my brothers name is Maurice .. OH and my last name is Holden .. OH .. my first name is in here !! ... o.o hahaha weird ... aha niiiice video btw w00t w00t
its overrrrrrr...lol pretty funny, and good acting actually, i was surprised. funny, today i used this book in the regents shit, and here i am looking at a video of it, ....
*ding* "hey man, what's your floor" *ding* ...lol
internziko 6 days ago
rly nice, looks like u had nice time shooting it
gj
xicsix 1 year ago
featured on gawker after Salinger's death..
(catcher-in-the-rye-as-performed-by-youtube)
theace0398 1 year ago
featured on gawker after Salinger's death
theace0398 1 year ago
love that hooker.
platoonbugger 1 year ago
this fucking video ROCKS HARD BALLS. Awesome job, thanks for not taking it too seriously.
RightWingCon81 1 year ago
funny. it is better than doing something dum. at least this is creativity.
felixmoga 1 year ago
LOL ROB YOUR SUCH A TOOL
darnathein 2 years ago
Thats pretty sad if all you got from the first part of the novel is Sunny. I mean thats exactly what Holden hates about adults. Sex, which is inevitably the gateway to adulthood and loss of innocence. You guys have obviously loss your innocence.
ng3333 2 years ago
was that acting..if it was...then it was the most painful bit of.... that i have ever seen..
jammyjo610 2 years ago
haha brilliant, I hope you got an A for this. The guy who plays Holden looks and sounds like i would imagine Holden
Wrz2e 2 years ago 2
lol.. not bad. not bad.
Haseena07 2 years ago
ding
apparentlyamyclare 2 years ago 2
awesome
deathnoterave 2 years ago
is better than the one with the black guys
Andreitacuca 2 years ago
Oh god, it is embarrasing me just watching it..
EdgeCrusherXx 2 years ago 3
I just finished making a video for my English project. :] yours is much better though..
DayyummHesHawt 3 years ago
The warning label in the beginning was correct. it's not even worth bashing because the actors are fully aware of how this sucked. At least you're honest.
jenaosa1224 3 years ago
Comment removed
jenaosa1224 3 years ago
that was really good.
all the other catcher in the rye stuff ive seen
has been people trying to hard.
but this was natural and terrific.
withadozenways 3 years ago
five dollars for the throat?
dryboogers 3 years ago 2
5 dollars for a throw.
sarip93 3 years ago
should have done the seen with the teacher and the petting =)
piike1992 3 years ago 10
I actually understood the book(because i'm a nerd like that)And im only 12 years old, I think that book was great,I read it 2 months ago the slang was a little problem but later I knew what it meant later on.
guzzabub 3 years ago
I don't usually like reading but catcher in the rye was the best book I have ever read
ImmortalArtist09 3 years ago 13
That book was amazing^^ a lot more enjoyable then i thought it would be
IKillYouVids 3 years ago 2
this is a fucking diss servise 2 the greatist book ever writtern
thewho0806 3 years ago
Some people believe that the book is Evil,because john Lennon's murderer Mark David Chapman was obsessed with the book,they believe it gave him insight on how to kill,so i cant see how this book can be great,because of the involvement it has in killing a great Artist.
Elevationary 3 years ago
So you don't eat toast because a toaster has fell on someone's head and killed them?
Stop being such a fucking moron.
EdgeCrusherXx 2 years ago
Im almost done with the book.
Its really goooddd i love it.
the guy that played as holden caulfield sucked at acting. he made holden seem plain o.O
but who cares , right? :D
JapaneseWolf17 3 years ago
You're spot on with that last remark.
MadcapVagrant 3 years ago
i'm half way through this book. it's really good, but it gets into your head if you catch my drift.
xoloverlyxo 3 years ago
i totally get what you are saying
i finished a few months ago
bu3asalli 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this book sucks
mattmac0912 3 years ago
i'm not even twelve yet and i've read "the catcher in the rye" it is now my favorite book. this scene with sunny the prostitute is the only "bad"(explicit) scene in the book and i think that this book isn't that contiversial at all besides all the swearing and stuff but who cares. i think that people shold stop being pussies and that this book should be required reading in every school.(but not every grade; 7th sounds good.)
gilch666 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
HAHAHA the fucking heel you are twelve!
Trying to fool us with this misspelling shit!
Lillogambino 3 years ago
Nobody gives a shit that you're 12 years old and reading The Catcher in The Rye.
Jolt459 3 years ago
nobody cares that your mom is a fucking alcoholic either
gilch666 3 years ago
I never said my mom was an alcoholic. I don't know where you get your facts from... or do you just make them up?
Jolt459 3 years ago
The Catcher in the Rye was not meant to be read by kids in 7th grade, no offense. In order to understand the true meanings behind the book and really understand Holden, you have to have a level of maturity that middle-schoolers just don't have yet. Its cool that you can understand the words, but read it again in a few years and you'll have a much better understanding of the book.
theace0398 3 years ago
well i can see why you would say that, but not ALL younger people are unable to comprehend the deeper meaning behind what is said in this book. people underestimate the mental capacity and maturity level of some young people.
gilch666 3 years ago
i agree catcher in the rye is meant for teens and older, you can't get the idea of grieve over loss innocence before you actually lose your innocence, sure kids are smart they are underestimated but intellectual cleverness shouldn't be confused with emotional maturity
bu3asalli 3 years ago 2
Just because someone is young doesnt mean they cant understand the book.
JapaneseWolf17 3 years ago
i think holden is emo =D
XXxdrummersrokxXX 3 years ago
He's a total emo.
mrdressup101 3 years ago
yeah...never thought about that
whamfan87 3 years ago
no..
he hates cliques
...hes right..fuckin stupid little groups
whiteandgreen 3 years ago
man theres no need 4 cussin it was a joke calm down
XXxdrummersrokxXX 3 years ago
he is not emo, he isjust very hungy with the hipocreasy of his life, he's a kind of philosopher punk xD, but not emo, the emos aren't so real like holden, holden always says the true, but the emos tinhk that they are like holden
ManuRibeiro 3 years ago
lol im in the 7th grade in just reading it for the fun of it i like it so far anyway i loved the part when you played sexy back lolz omfg that was golden
XXxdrummersrokxXX 3 years ago
hehe i have to write about this for my literature exam this june and you totally messed up my mental image of sunny! lol but it was funny
DontHugZetsu 3 years ago
haha love the guy playing the prostitute.. you guys did a great job :)
luvvdabeatles 3 years ago
and the oscar goes to......lol
hahaha cool... now im ready for a test i have about it tomorrow...
SHALOM from israel :)
etaihan 3 years ago
and the oscar goes to......lol
hahaha cool... now im ready for a test i have about it tomorrow...
SHALOM from israel :)
etaihan 3 years ago
i did a search to see how my project would measure up this year, and I stumble upon dan and granooch...who did you have?
poopoobooboo 3 years ago
If it wasn't for the title and the disclaimer at the beginning, I seriously would've thought this was a gay porno. lol but good work.
moua64 3 years ago
this is so funny
the paper signs, the pimp outfit and the close up on the 5 dollar bill are hilarious!
looks like you had fun doing this
faaestaaburrida 3 years ago
lol, i think this is the authors autobiography. And i think he shows his gayness through Holden. I truely think Holden is gay. Or Bi.
vimjas 3 years ago
hahaha and its proven in the book, casue he never fucks that prostitute... so he must have queer thoughts in his mind
lol
sheep41 3 years ago
shut up, in the book says that holden like very much women, but he has respect for them, that because he doesn't fuck the whore
ManuRibeiro 3 years ago
*Ding* lol, i hate this book
vimjas 3 years ago
omg this is soo funny and the best part are the signs on the paper towels ahha
mhuang16 3 years ago
I've read The Catcher in the Rye but I've heard Salinger's other books aren't very good. Could anyone help me out and tell me their favorite J.D. Salinger books beside's The Catcher in the Rye? Thanks alot!
hendrixman1515 4 years ago
Franny and Zooey (:
YOkelseyyy 4 years ago
is it as good as the catcher in the rye?
hendrixman1515 4 years ago
personally, catcher in the rye is as good as it gets. its my favorite book, and im very prejudice. but many people think it's his best book, and it is definately good and its a short read so i'd read it forsure if i were you.
YOkelseyyy 4 years ago
Oh believe me I've read the Catcher in the Rye.
hendrixman1515 4 years ago
im talking about franny and zooey sillyy.
YOkelseyyy 4 years ago
Right when i posted my comment i noticed that haha sorry.
hendrixman1515 3 years ago
oh haha yeahh. so anyways, you should definetely try franny and zooey.
YOkelseyyy 3 years ago
Nine Stories, Franny and Zoey, Raise High the Roof Beam. They are equally good, depending upon on how you take the stories. Catcher of course is incomparable.
tetziecou 4 years ago
Thats what I figured.
hendrixman1515 4 years ago
like the matrix trilogy
midence 3 years ago
tartan?
backlash01 4 years ago
You guys are great!
nickichick 4 years ago
i like the 'ding!' guy. it was the best part
Staina 4 years ago
read directly from the book much??
wist0301 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
well you little faggots who have no life actually sat there for 8 minutes and watched a video of some kids you dont even know you fuckin pedophiles get a life
chilicheezfriez 4 years ago
what are you talking about....?
lullabysounds 4 years ago
oops, that was a reply to chilicheezfriesz.
hah
lullabysounds 4 years ago
was not that fun
mariocantero 4 years ago
...monotone much? atleast memorize your lines instead of reading the book hidden behind a pillow.
Ranimal006 4 years ago
The boring wombat who plays Holden is crap.
Love the pimp in the elavator..
bizzlehuggy1 4 years ago
nice " alright alright get on with it"
maryzilla1337 4 years ago
Im reading this book rite now 4 english 2
VOLCOM14incali 4 years ago
SMACK!!! XD
taekun77 4 years ago
YOU GUYS ARE SEXY.
hit me up, seriously.
xxx savanna.
SAViTOMx3 4 years ago
haha, genius. :]
melcantdancexo 4 years ago
This was pretty much the best thing ever!
You guys are hilarious! =]
dorkariffic 4 years ago
I loved the warning in the begining! hahah, youre not that bad of actors.
shueln 4 years ago
Couldn't have a picked a worse actor to play Holden in the whole goddam universe. Feel so depressed watching those phony actors it just about killed me.
extremepoker75 4 years ago
LMAO! im reading this book again right now for the third time, I just got past the part where the elevator man beats holden for his 5$. pretty depressing book.
irascib1e 4 years ago
ahahahah DAN !
i really like your elevator
semicharm3d 4 years ago
hilarious pimp!
renatabrasil 4 years ago
the prostitute was funny. i just read the book and i have to get 5 quotes and make connections. i just decided to watch the video. nice video
david0616 4 years ago
Such a great book! but yet again such mischieve has come from it! poor Holden never grow up!
Kainspear 4 years ago
...best book ever...adore it...
wowceci 4 years ago
`hahah...
`funny!
`when old maurice smack holden...
`hahahah!
`i lyk ur elevator....lol
aiziek013 4 years ago
XDXDXDXD That was HILARiOUS!! XDXDXD
DuchessAliana 4 years ago
Hahahaha that was frickin awesome.
scottyfry05 4 years ago
you talk wayyy to fast.
haha
oh and nice elevator
BeretABC 4 years ago
Dunno why i watched it, i just love catcher in the rye
skaterconz 4 years ago
i like your elevator!!!
faunce1177 4 years ago
funny...was that pimp cane a flute with tin foil on it?
imnotokay1289 4 years ago
nah the pimp cane was a leg we took off a table.
DaNooch 4 years ago
erm ... that was ... oh weird my brothers name is Maurice .. OH and my last name is Holden .. OH .. my first name is in here !! ... o.o hahaha weird ... aha niiiice video btw w00t w00t
Llama54DcL0wN 4 years ago
its overrrrrrr...lol pretty funny, and good acting actually, i was surprised. funny, today i used this book in the regents shit, and here i am looking at a video of it, ....
guitarshredder389 5 years ago
damn right he is
DaNooch 5 years ago
That guy in the red that plays Maurice is dead sexy.
dpops 5 years ago
lol. biiiiitch
behindcoldeyes 5 years ago
best part
thedejavu 5 years ago
this was pretty amazing.
endoftomorrow 5 years ago
btw, this is chris.
endoftomorrow 5 years ago
its overr
thedejavu 5 years ago