I do enjoy both, but to hold a new book in my hand, to turn the pages by actually turning the pages wins by a mile. Im a nut for the library and bookstores.
I keep imagining a future where kids won't read books, not because they can't read, but because they can't figure out where the batteries go into them
I blame ecomentalists. With the whole desire to go electronic nowadays and 'save paper' for the sake of trees, its kinda six of one and half a dozen of the other.
@Ceinmcgill Do grow up kid.. They're not what so ever. Sure there's alternatives, but they're not obsolete. infact book sales are going up again if you look at the stats :)
@tangocolt02 It depends on the stats really, as the latest say that more people own iPads than books now. Ironically, I know a lot of people who just use books as bookends to prop up their multimedia devices on the shelves. Don't get me wrong, I don't have anything against books, they're just a bit boring.
@shoehorn11 You crack me up. Books have been around way longer than you or I and they will be around long after we are gone. Maybe you should open a book. :)
So I was just watching on the news that there is a word in this book that a school thought was bad so they banned it....... so, what am I missing? lol
Reminds me of "Animorphs." In that series, the Andalite race thought that humans were backwards because we came up with books first (considered a superior device) and then the Internet.
Great book! Great teachable moment! Too bad the last page renders it unusable in any elementary school library/classroom. And Lane had to know this. Who will risk having it's students referring to peers as jackasses? What was up with that!
@claudettelibra its a male donkey... i hate how people dont know that and it renders things unusable!! the kids at my school were freaking out "OMG it said jackass" "yeah you freaking idiots, jackass means male donkey, honestly"
aw they didn't say the right line at the end where the donkey says "don't worry I'll charge it up later!" and the monkey says "You don't have too..." and the little mouse says "It's a book, jackass!" lolerz we read it in school
So glad a friend sent me the link to this! I love it!! I posted on FB that I was taking a break from FB ... I wanted to do some reading (books). This is priceless. LOL
Science fiction author M. David Blake (yep, that's me...) enjoyed this video enough to give it a write-up on his Facebook page.
Lane, nice idea, and it makes for a very enjoyable short film! I look forward to tracking down the hardcover and reading it to my daughter, because she already loves "Squids Will Be Squids."
So the donkey is portrayed as a dense tech-head who can't understand or accept anything that's not digital, while the ape is a smug, deadpan reader who looks down on those who prefer digital media, speaking to the donkey as if it should be grateful to have a moment of the ape's precious time. Awesome use of stereotypes!
It's too bad the content of the book (OR pdf file) isn't the central focus. The content and the message are what should matter, not how they're served up.
@SquidRooster LOL so you're complaining about "donkey" and "ape" stereotypes? I didn't even know there WERE stereotypes for them that needed eradication.
I read the actually "It's a book" by lane smith, and I must say I am very disappointed that at the end the monkey did not say "*sigh* You don't have to, it's a book jackass."
The idea that books (paper copies) may be lost to children makes me sad, but I just can't see how you can cuddle up in bed with a computer... you need something physical and tactile... like a book!
Huge fan of Lane Smith - can't wait for the digital-natives (children of this millennium) to READ this book (and no it doesn't have wifi, nor does it tweet).
Great book. Just read it in our high school library. I'm buying one. Precious.
lillian68 1 week ago
Why is the monkey bigger than the ass???
UglyFilms64 4 weeks ago
This vid is popular on Canada
ebastianlar718s 1 month ago
both are media for information!!! be the media
the medium is not the information
noxpox 1 month ago
This video is a favorite on Cape Verde
beverlybradley210 1 month ago
Brilliance!
BarryBlueoom 2 months ago
I love this! I am a career ink-and-paper printer who just got his first e-reader, I admit to some guilt associated with that. I love books!!!!
peterpun1 2 months ago
My friend has this book kmll
Asan12ful 2 months ago
Remember when books weren't obsolete?
I do. It was pretty bad.
i can only wonder what's going to make the internet seem 'pretty bad' in 50 years.
panameadeplm 2 months ago
Cool! It is an interesting VDO for all book lovers!
pussadee11 3 months ago
I love how he's said "It's a book". Sounds better than hearing Herminie saying "Leviosaaa!"
xilent234 5 months ago in playlist Liked
its a book... Jackass! ROFLMFAO
YLCC23 5 months ago
@YLCC23 you mean, ROFLMJO.
nancywvo 4 months ago
its a book... Jackass! ROFLMFAO
YLCC23 5 months ago
love it
Americagirl109 5 months ago
@Americagirl109
Americagirl109 5 months ago
Awesome, I'll show that in my Library!!!
nancypo1 6 months ago
@nancypo1 lol my teacher did that!
Lootsparkie 5 months ago
@nancypo1 well my librarian
Lootsparkie 5 months ago
I read this book last week. Hilarious. Love the mouse!
Great book trailer as well. I've tried to create my own....with some success. Thanks for the inspiration!
Chris
chrisifrancis 6 months ago
I read that book to my niece all the time! she loves it! She's going to love this <3
XcrosbyxXxfearlessX 7 months ago
4 people are books
Murdo861 8 months ago
@Murdo861 801 people are books.
zappingzeppelin 7 months ago
4 people are books
Murdo861 8 months ago
omg i love this book :B
SuperBananaChannel 8 months ago
Comment removed
mondayasusual 8 months ago
It's a youtube video!
mondayasusual 8 months ago
it's a hook
coldfeel 8 months ago
It's a bad animation!
ribogok 8 months ago
i walk with books all the time!
omgitsskyandces 9 months ago
Get a "narrated by Christoper Walken" version and any book is epic. Lol
SnAyJonTaylor 9 months ago 2
Awesome. I also loved the irony of watching this in video form.
FaithDAmato 9 months ago 21
It's a book.
ShadowBladeSceptile 9 months ago
Books are the greatest form of entertainment there is.
Retact 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
my teacher is jane smith!
haneenk123 9 months ago
my teacher is jane smith!
haneenk123 9 months ago
ja die gute alte zeit
talla81 10 months ago
Cool video. Does it come in book format?
hads010 10 months ago
Talk about funny! LOL!! luv the gorillas face
123zyxabc987 10 months ago
I do enjoy both, but to hold a new book in my hand, to turn the pages by actually turning the pages wins by a mile. Im a nut for the library and bookstores.
immomsy 10 months ago
You left out the best part in the actual book.
"It's a book, Jackass."
LinKeuiSwampert 10 months ago 2
Great video, this is much more effecttive than writing the story down....IN A BOOK!
theKitchenFiddle 10 months ago
I saw a book once :P scary shit.
Mize5 10 months ago
I keep imagining a future where kids won't read books, not because they can't read, but because they can't figure out where the batteries go into them
Xonk61 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Did you use a book to create and distribute that video?
Pnevma67 10 months ago
Comment removed
Pnevma67 10 months ago
I blame ecomentalists. With the whole desire to go electronic nowadays and 'save paper' for the sake of trees, its kinda six of one and half a dozen of the other.
MediaMachinima 10 months ago
It's a book Jackass!!
MC13597908 10 months ago 29
@MC13597908 that was a good line in the book ahhhh :D
marshallwa2 2 months ago
Books are awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
jennram01 11 months ago 2
Comment removed
Ceinmcgill 11 months ago
So true, books are totally obsolete now. You tell 'em Lane Smith!
Ceinmcgill 11 months ago
@Ceinmcgill mmm no they're not.
tangocolt02 11 months ago
@tangocolt02 Ha ha, yeah but they are.
Ceinmcgill 11 months ago
@Ceinmcgill Do grow up kid.. They're not what so ever. Sure there's alternatives, but they're not obsolete. infact book sales are going up again if you look at the stats :)
tangocolt02 11 months ago
@tangocolt02 It depends on the stats really, as the latest say that more people own iPads than books now. Ironically, I know a lot of people who just use books as bookends to prop up their multimedia devices on the shelves. Don't get me wrong, I don't have anything against books, they're just a bit boring.
Ceinmcgill 11 months ago
@Ceinmcgill omgosh.. that is so not true, more people DO NOT own iPads than books.
ShelliKittens 3 weeks ago
<3 tgis like sooooooooooo much :D
MsAsya6 11 months ago
In the last page of the book it says. Its a book Jackass O_e :D
Clonetrooper1019 11 months ago
omg its a book!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ArchieMacGillivray 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Get a peace to your life with an Latino girl rockmycity.info
senurireka 1 year ago
I <3 to READ! :D
tsconflictfree 1 year ago
You gotta read this CHILDRENS BOOK and see wat the first and last page say xD
xXxTalkingxTurtlexXx 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Low cost marriage service for you rockmycity.info
ghfjtyufghdfj 1 year ago
Love the voices!
peace2baby 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Online Latino women here who can trust rockmycity.info
tenikanilmini 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Your total marriage solution partner **rockmycity.info**
senurireka 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Last chance for you **rockmycity.info**
ghfjtyufghdfj 1 year ago
The book is so much better. Seriously.
atsouthdam 1 year ago
Just like any skill, you have to practice reading to be good at it.
sporter323 1 year ago
Love it...what a great idea for my technology class to emulate!!!!!!!!!!
sporter323 1 year ago
wonderful, thanks, lane!
georgeshrub 1 year ago
@shoehorn11 Take that stick out of your ass and lighten up you frumpy ole tard . :D
schnulli79 1 year ago
Wow! Try anger management -- you need it.
sporter323 1 year ago
@shoehorn11 You crack me up. Books have been around way longer than you or I and they will be around long after we are gone. Maybe you should open a book. :)
bungchiwow 1 year ago
:)))
schnulli79 1 year ago
This should go out around the world as a public service announcement in ad-breaks. Brilliant.
310sucks 1 year ago
I agree with the ape... I like reading a book from a BOOK. Not an IPad!
katniss11 1 year ago
I do both and they both have merit.
sporter323 1 year ago
can i do this? "toot"
xD
NINtastisch 1 year ago
Comment removed
dolphinofdespair 1 year ago
So I was just watching on the news that there is a word in this book that a school thought was bad so they banned it....... so, what am I missing? lol
EvilMonKiki 1 year ago
the actual book is better!!
TheDemolitiongirl 1 year ago
Reminds me of "Animorphs." In that series, the Andalite race thought that humans were backwards because we came up with books first (considered a superior device) and then the Internet.
Agent0042 1 year ago
My english teacher read this to us....were in grade 10 (Y)
PrezTyler 1 year ago
its a friken book you retarted donkey
TheAirsofting 1 year ago
Great book! Great teachable moment! Too bad the last page renders it unusable in any elementary school library/classroom. And Lane had to know this. Who will risk having it's students referring to peers as jackasses? What was up with that!
claudettelibra 1 year ago
@claudettelibra its a male donkey... i hate how people dont know that and it renders things unusable!! the kids at my school were freaking out "OMG it said jackass" "yeah you freaking idiots, jackass means male donkey, honestly"
TheDemolitiongirl 1 year ago
@TheDemolitiongirl You should hear what happened when we gave my students "pirate's booty." Guess that shouldn't be eaten in schools then :P
aohitomi19 1 year ago
@aohitomi19 im not surprised kids jst cant stay serious... thts y we nvr got to read anythng good... theyd over react
TheDemolitiongirl 1 year ago
Or, learn to spell.
sporter323 1 year ago
aw they didn't say the right line at the end where the donkey says "don't worry I'll charge it up later!" and the monkey says "You don't have too..." and the little mouse says "It's a book, jackass!" lolerz we read it in school
mechanoid2k 1 year ago
@mechanoid2k Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhh ok so that must be the word that schools decided to bann this book over.
EvilMonKiki 1 year ago
@EvilMonKiki that was my sis on my account
mechanoid2k 1 year ago
love this book... definately a xmas pres for the a few (too many) nephews. :)
shitfukpiss 1 year ago
Stumble <3
Xavius14 1 year ago
So glad a friend sent me the link to this! I love it!! I posted on FB that I was taking a break from FB ... I wanted to do some reading (books). This is priceless. LOL
lostdesmondDOTcom 1 year ago
2 nerds watched this!!!
Gizmo994 1 year ago
@Gizmo994 Actually I'm a nerd and I enjoyed this...two technologically impaired buffoons watched this.
tangocolt02 11 months ago
Wonderful!!!!!!
faciorosa 1 year ago
uuuuh, can i get that on kindle?
kleshco 1 year ago 35
@kleshco No...It's a book.
tangocolt02 11 months ago
Muy bueno el vídeo. Nos muestra las bondades del libro a pesar de todas las tecnologías. :D
faciorosa 1 year ago
I think I'll just wait for the movie to come out.
schvantz 1 year ago 3
I <3 this!
rizugeass 1 year ago
Science fiction author M. David Blake (yep, that's me...) enjoyed this video enough to give it a write-up on his Facebook page.
Lane, nice idea, and it makes for a very enjoyable short film! I look forward to tracking down the hardcover and reading it to my daughter, because she already loves "Squids Will Be Squids."
VintageSeason 1 year ago
Comment removed
VintageSeason 1 year ago
It needs a firmware upgrade.
KHLV 1 year ago 2
Like it? Love it!
Mattheo123 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
THIS IS SO FUCKING GAY
TheMrpwnman 1 year ago
Like it so much I just "Tweeted" the link!! (",)
jamesmggardner 1 year ago
I hear that plucky little song everywhere. What is it?
stjxp 1 year ago
Just read the book at an actual book store and I am obsessed - love the idea - can't wait to share with everyone
Lizardqueen11 1 year ago
wat the fuck!!!
2121montana 1 year ago
wat the fuck
2121montana 1 year ago
I Saw This At My Library. Kinda Weird, But I Like It!
SuperRokoman 1 year ago
So when will this be available in the Kindle Store?
PREY4WAR 1 year ago
Wonder if they will come out with an ibook version :)
luluntony 1 year ago
I hope all you guys have actually READ THE BOOK - it's even better than this clip. Go on . . .do it!
ruthleonie 1 year ago
LOL, awe man that's great. What's really scary is that it's a possibility 100 years from now. >.<
12rscott 1 year ago
This is so cute. I love ebooks, the Net, word processing, and BOOKS. You don't have to hate technology to find this endearing.
Lizbetslave 1 year ago 2
So the donkey is portrayed as a dense tech-head who can't understand or accept anything that's not digital, while the ape is a smug, deadpan reader who looks down on those who prefer digital media, speaking to the donkey as if it should be grateful to have a moment of the ape's precious time. Awesome use of stereotypes!
It's too bad the content of the book (OR pdf file) isn't the central focus. The content and the message are what should matter, not how they're served up.
SquidRooster 1 year ago
@SquidRooster LOL so you're complaining about "donkey" and "ape" stereotypes? I didn't even know there WERE stereotypes for them that needed eradication.
CalperniaAddams 1 year ago
I read the actually "It's a book" by lane smith, and I must say I am very disappointed that at the end the monkey did not say "*sigh* You don't have to, it's a book jackass."
deadxXxjinx 1 year ago
That just made my day. Thank you very much.
UTRIGFRIT 1 year ago
Awww!
LOL this is SOO cute
hoolahoopchad 1 year ago
BWAHAHA xD this is amazing~
ourkittyshack 1 year ago
haha! <3
FredrikSinkkonen 1 year ago
haha nice one its a book XD
luddomatic 1 year ago
OMG I love it :) makes me feel nostalgic! And the gorilla is awesome.
pillarofdust07 1 year ago
@pillarofdust07 no it's a book
scardorn145 1 year ago
Absolutely adorable!! : D And a great message....nothing wrong with putting the laptop down for a while.
greenteaandbeans 1 year ago
This just put a big smile on my face!! Love Lane Smith :)
gwen4me4ever 1 year ago
I have had this exact same conversation with my 10 year old (well almost).
gigiblews 1 year ago
"Can it Tweet"?? Ha, So cute! There is *nothing* that beats cuddling up with a good book : )
littlepicklepod 1 year ago
They make a good point in a very cute way.
KellyBundy55 1 year ago
That's the funniest donkey I've ever seen.
stylusgreyjay 1 year ago
The idea that books (paper copies) may be lost to children makes me sad, but I just can't see how you can cuddle up in bed with a computer... you need something physical and tactile... like a book!
Janetsurname 1 year ago 11
: ^p I'm just like the donkey!! Really should get back into books
daddyhas11 1 year ago
Huge fan of Lane Smith - can't wait for the digital-natives (children of this millennium) to READ this book (and no it doesn't have wifi, nor does it tweet).
gatheringBooks2009 1 year ago 2
lol This is the cutest thing ever!!! I can't wait to get it for my little nephew who spends his life online...: D
christiechrist 1 year ago
This is so sweet!
Karencarpenterdoll 1 year ago
Lane Smith is a genius! Thanks Stumbleupon!
kaydeerunning 1 year ago
me three
SSSmEeRs 1 year ago
Yes, Stumbled too!
abbamamamia 1 year ago
Stumbled! Love it!
divinedavida 1 year ago 27
Too funny, od that I'm watching it on my computer ;)
leeleelee3333 1 year ago 39
@leeleelee3333 Would you rather watch it on a book?
ProfesserMoriarty 1 year ago
@leeleelee3333
As opposed to watching it on a book say.
BrokenBjartur 1 year ago
Thus, I came to a sad, but eventful realization... a book can do even less than an iPad. :)
gigsworld101 1 year ago