周杰倫 - 一路上有你／分手總要在雨天（自彈自唱，國／粵雙語Live視聽版）

[aina1228]

我肯定現在的他能唱到.

[w94w031122]

周董是亞洲有名歌手 不喜歡他的批評他的人當然也多,不過我是最喜歡周杰倫的^^ 永遠支持

[tljameswade]

张学友在哭泣。。。

[kenvintqd]

^^

[whiteblong]

歌神的歌不是这个垃圾能学得来得

[DynastyIRI]

@whiteblong 人不是妳這種畜生學得來的 叫聲來聽聽 不要學人講人話 妳媽勾引鸚鵡?

[Allergie66]

是不是快斷氣了?

[2SueAng]

很努力了. 你们去唱未必能唱得那么好!

CHEER UP JAY

[terences82]

廣東話講得差就唔好講廣東話哥個版本啦= =a

[KivaEmperor]

As Jay's fan, I'm disappointed with this. He was a rookie back then anyway so I believe he will do much better now. :)

[evaleung88]

@ redbutterflylily

I feel sorry for u that mandarin is the only language u know. Stop judging people if u don't know shit about it.

[tom8me]

Holy shit! Jay shoud go to a karaoke room and practice this song a lot more. So bad to listen to...

[RedButterflyLily]

廣東話是垃圾方言, 不論九聲調亦是...

國語才是最有用,



[RedButterflyLily]

廣東話是垃圾方言, 不論九聲調亦是...

國語才是最有用, 

[kstar123345]

U stupid cunt u wrecked the song for me

[jaylau7]

114个人，那个按钮不是下载！

[EdioW]

想問這個片段是出自哪個演唱會?

[hinwchan2]

羅力威黎?



[joycechung2002]

張學友唱歌有幾好聽唔需要多講, 但大家唔好忘記, 其實廣東話係好難學架~ 國語只有四個音, 但廣東話有成九個音, 只係我哋講開唔覺得難學啫, 如果吓吓執住Jay唱既廣東話唔得, 咁我敢講香港九成歌手都唔得, 依家香港有幾多個香港歌手真係會咬字好清? 自己係講廣東話既歌手 聽完幾次首歌我都係唔知佢唱乜, 就算係衛蘭呢啲唱得好啲既, 咪一樣咬唔正啲廣東話, 咁唔通又話佢唱得唔好咩? 我由佢出既第一首歌「龍捲風」開始就聽佢既歌、買佢既碟, 好老實, 呢十年裡面, 中段佢既歌係有啲停滯不前, 但好快佢又進步噃, 嚟到上年2010年既大碟, 加埋演唱會, 我絕對相信佢既粉絲又多咗一、兩成, 又相信大部份粉絲都唔係鍾意佢夠靚仔 (我睇咗十年都唔覺佢靚仔), 而係鍾意佢既歌同才華, 試問有幾多歌手可以好似佢咁, 十年十隻大碟所有歌都係佢一手包辦作曲? 我諗呢個神話嚟緊廿年都唔會再出到第二個周杰倫, 而且近年睇住佢不斷發掘新既音樂元素, 真係好多謝佢帶咁多好歌畀我哋! 最後補充, 我細佬係廿歲青年, 近年都開始聽噃周董第一、二隻碟既歌喇!

[moprettymo]

@joycechung2002

david tao!!! mr jay's mandarin is not understandable at all too!!!

[voidezlove]

哪裡沒走音了......而且咬字不清不楚......廣東話一­聽就知道不熟......

他很多地方低不下去......幾年前, 還會買Jay的專輯, 現在回來想都覺得自己好傻

[c911911911]

@voidezlove 好傻...好天真...

[002000200002]

好像鸭子在唱歌

[wingcheng88]

i love you

[tqllxex588]

10年前我聽周杰倫的歌 未來10年我還是會繼續聽

[Seymourbuts]

oh shit i shouldnt have clicked this.... ruined my memory of this song

[iamthegodlol]

不要再和張學友比了,,,各自有不同的演繹方式,,,我認為他們­兩個的版本都給了我不同的感覺吧

[jojobigoldtwo]

我覺得比張學友的好聽....

我一直覺得張學友唱歌好匠氣太油我很難融入

我反而覺得周杰倫現場演唱有時候感覺聲音很自然很真情流露很感人­

[jjmaxqq]

周杰倫至少沒走音,ok了啦! 

[foreveryoursbabe95]

please jay you suck so much......the movies you make it so stupid...it sound like all thye fans are under 10years old retared..

[foreveryoursbabe95]

suck so much

[colintjy]

You people should stop having the mentality that singers of a new/current generation will never surpass the benchmark performance of the original singer. In fact, both are good in their own way.

[donnieyenhk]

班門弄斧

[hyacidol]

love 杰倫~~~~~~~

[mykingabcfung]

真係吾好聽

[king0228]

你们干嘛把歌神跟歌手比啊？就像你也不会拿车神舒马克和你老爸的­驾驶技术比吧？ ==

[equitatus]

lol his fans just scream at anything.....he could very well be singing abc's they dont care.

[GamblingSaint]

The sad truth is Jay's unwarranted popularity makes his fans scream deliriously regardless of his actual merits. Any dissenting view of his over-hyped "talent" is suffocated from the angry voices of his fans. In theory, Jay could sing completely off key, forget half the lyrics, and his fans would be screaming just as loud. Anyone who believes he even comes close to the god of song Jacky Cheung is terribly mistaken and in denial.

[kellya88822]

聽自己喜歡的音樂不就好了

幹馬在那邊吵 意義何在= =?

[gamerdt]

in comparison jacky feels like heaven, jay below earth....

[turkmex]

I love this song!!!!

[ekyikai]

勇氣可嘉！

[h3366991512]

就是有你們這些小朋友花錢買當初所以他才會紅會賺錢 等大家都老了年長了就知道甚麼歌可以品味久聽了 我是覺得周杰倫作曲還不錯 但是唱歌就不語置評

歌唱藝術沒有這麼簡單的 如果是要出歌唱專輯讓人花錢買 就該有相當的實力

畢竟都是血汗錢 不是階段性的撈錢 

[lam0715]

算吧...

大家知道杰倫是最屌的就可以了...

他們一定是沒看過"超人不會飛"的歌詞~_~

[j0913505858]

再怎麼不好也比你好吧 除非你夠格 不然你有什麼資格批評他

你算什麼 別在那顯示自己的無能

[368Dirk]

每個人的歌路不同 所以音樂也分很多種類 周董在自己的演唱會唱學友的歌 代表她真的很景仰他 就這樣而已 用不著去評好不好聽吧

[evoranger]

LOLZ..... horrible!!!!

[zea0307]

在我看來，杰倫唱學友哥的歌是向學友致敬，因為杰倫也是聽這些前­輩的歌長大的，就是這樣而已吧，有什麼好吵的呢？不用質欵杰倫唱­學友歌不夠味，難道學友又能駕御杰倫的歌嗎？

[ZShen1122]

@zea0307 我可以講,以宜家既學友,可以駕御任何歌

歌神呢個名唔係流嫁

[niwakaoru]

不喜歡可以別進來聽 周董的風格就是這樣的 而且聲音里充滿了感情

他就是天王

全亞洲沒有哪個歌手有他的震撼力大

選錯歌？嘗試別的語言和別的歌曲是他的勇氣

錯了又怎樣呢 還有連中文都不打的就別拿英文在那狗嘴吐不出象牙了吧

不覺得用英文在那罵幾句有多“厲害”

支持周董 支持他的音樂 才華。

[ispd123]

i can't believe he is considered a 天王，go listen to Jacky's version....

If he is 天王 with this kinda of performance then i am god.

[368Dirk]

@ispd123 really ?! give u 10 second compose a song? can u

[hohoyun]

@ispd123

comparing a rookie jay from 10 years ago to jacky was unfair to begin with. I'm a jay fan and i agreed that he did very bad in here, but you gotta give him time to grow.

check out his other concerts, he did very good in those, and the latest one was just amazing

[pedrokongo]

jay chou reminds me of jacky cheung when he sings this song just as much as he reminds me of bruce lee as kato...not at all. although i heard some jayonese: slurred mumbled canto

[eclipsegsx268]

you guys cant really compare him to Jacky. Can Jacky play the piano like him? To be fair, Jay is a better "Musician" and Jacky is a better singer.

[ispd123]

@eclipsegsx268 then tell Jay to just be a musician.....please don't be a singer...stay instrumental maybe he will be better.

[mcmcmc333333]

回水!!!

[ericsu0306]

such a shit.....

[DireDirge]

this is the difference between a boy and a man

[smashshuttle]

sucks man dunno why people were screaming away

[minibundy007]

Eh its Jay Chow manz, cant expect too much :D

tts y some r Legends, while others will stay as Fanbois :D

I kinda feel sad for Jacky tho

[minibundy007]

Eh b4 i comes in, i kinda Expected e flaming .. LOL

Hey its JAY man, wot u expect? heheheee

Lifes fair, some will be LEGEND, while some will only b Fanboi :D

I kinda feel sad for Jacky tho .. :/

[yundi79]

佢練歌個陣冇人同佢講佢揀錯歌 ? 

[kasierthegreat]

點解我聽到佢唱：「轉身殺呀，看見食屎的老婆……」

[keungkeungyeung]

@kasierthegreat 真系好似wor~.~

[boredjl]

dont try to sing something that's beyond your vocal capability. lesson learned.

[jessefanlin]

so awesome O_O

diao~

[emptinessform]

what a loser.... and i really don't understand what's all the stupid idiot fans scream about??? what a shame!!!! poor listener..... that's why asian is poor in quality....... I'm sure Jacky Cheung is very angry to see this idiot Jay Chou broke his wonderful song to a piece of shit!!!!! Shit Jay Chou....

[emptinessform]

yeah... it's true! Jay Chou broke this song as a piece of shit without the singing skill and respect to the origin of song! is he drunk while singing this song???? shit..... poor singer!!!!!! go to hell Jay Chou!!!! What a shame live performance!!!

[wangwade123]

有聽出感情

雖然不清楚(尖叫聲也很多

不過這就是他的特色 他的風格

[h3366991512]

他到底會不會唱歌么阿 歌神的歌 唱不出感情給我哼來哼去 台灣歌唱出片真隨便

[j0913505858]

@h3366991512 那麼厲害你來發展呀 有辦法出名我買你專輯 不然就閉嘴

[devil01942]

like somebody before dying~~ no strength at all... Jacky OWNS~~~

[ccfirst]

you have got to agree with fly110.. no way he can do anything even near jacky cheung..

[MrKukujiao]

Wait...I think I hear the fans screaming in horror...

[MrKukujiao]

What language is this?? Mantonese? OMFG stop singing hahaha!!

[dolphinloveremogirl]

完全不知道他什麼時候唱粵語什麼時候唱國語

在這些不同的版本裡面周杰倫是唱的最爛的

[shadowj3di]

jay chou is only showing how bad his singing is

[cc0986151939]

他只是周杰倫唱張學友的歌.....他沒要變成張學友阿

你唱著張學友的歌時就會覺得 自己是張學友 就會想讓人把你認為是張學友嗎

我想不會吧^.<

[Junrichan]

sucks

[greenmileofcurry]

well...last few lines not bad.

[Wonghowpin99]

My god, I admired Jay Chou till listen to this song. Is he singing Turkish?

[wangcong314]

what a shitty cover

[leanwinleng]

i dont care what u all think... but jay sing this well == ... i dont know how you guys rate a song ==

[sj51204]

Was he really singing in Cantonese?

聽起來怎麼像台語?

[teelein]

jacky cheung sang the songs of my childhood, he is a living legend to me!

jay does not sound that great in this video, but why do so many people have to flame. it was not bad and besides jay has composed SO many good songs. one album per year and on each album (ok except his new ones) more good then bad songs!

c'mon except it, both are great :D

[thebigaznguy]

jay chou is no jacky cheung. this one was decent. jacky version is just too godly. there is no comparisons at all

[bobeloveful]

好奇怪好搞笑，哈哈，周傑倫真系唔系好識唱學友嘅的歌，但系好好­玩~~~

[pammywammyxd]

Two words: THIS SUCKS.

No offense to his fans, but seriously don't even compare him with Jacky Cheung

Jacky Cheung is an immediate win win in singing.

At 1:18 Jay Chou or whoever it is sounds so weak.

If you listen to Jacky Cheung's version, you'll know it is 1 million (or even more) times better than Jay's singing

Also if he wants to sing, sing it well. I don't get why he has a lot of fans.

[pammywammyxd]

Two words: THIS SUCKS.

No offense to his fans, but seriously don't even compare him with Jacky Cheung

Jacky Cheung is an immediate win win in singing.

At 1:18 Jay Chou or whoever it is sounds so weak.

If you listen to Jacky Cheung's version, you'll know it is 1 million (or even more) times better than Jay's singing

[MsSlk350]

張學友可以唱周杰倫的歌.但周杰綸唱唔起張學友的歌

[ppshchik]

Jay Chou is a stinking pile of shit, his early songs were good but now his songs sound the fucking same with some hybrid American shit, not to mention that he has that pussy of a voice.

[fabiotaotao]

好啦好啦，音准，声音都不重要，只要天王巨星的神似就ok了。

[Bobby0917]

周傑倫寫音樂的才華張學友還是很欣賞的，張學友亦是周傑倫的偶像­，兩個人互相欣賞，但系講真周傑倫真系唔識得唱歌，尤其唱張學友­概

[harubong]

wtf!!! ear sore!! even a child can sing better than him!!

[joe1121tw]

@atamaitai0102 妳說台灣人可悲 我想你也好不到哪裡去吧

大陸人一整天在那吠 說什麼一堆狗屁倒灶

學嘴砲有沒那麼難啊 打開電腦動動手指 妳說多麼健康

[jimmy8349]

如果周杰伦比跟张学友，当然还有一段距离，张学友的称呼歌神不是­白称哦，不过，各歌手都有自己的长处，只是这首歌并不适合周杰伦­唱，一样的，杰伦的歌，学友未必适合唱。。。

[saphira512]

ppl are commenting out of their jealousy.

Chill down guys.

if you can't do it then do bitch about it.

[Aznproz]

勇气爆灯，吾悉广东话都居然敢唱广东歌！！哈哈。但是唱功就不掂­，handle吾到呢首歌！没feel!！始终都是张学友的好百­倍！！

[inFamOUzcarlOS]

周杰倫当然无得比上张学友. 没有人比得上张学友. 但是周杰倫也是一个好歌手阿.

[sobusted1245]

It's not exactly the best, he doesn't exude the presence or the feel that Jacky gives. Jay is an excellent singer in his own right. Guys shut up or put up

[ZomgL33tZors]

Leehom would've done better

[inFamOUzcarlOS]

if you checked one of leehom's concert a few years back, he messed up VERY badly. Going off tune and shit so go search that up and restate your self

[mervynteng1]

Like I said before.. This guy can't sing..!

Really spoilt the song..

[atamaitai0102]

說的好 這個閩南白痴小孩

確實不會唱歌

[pang0806]

傻西

[atamaitai0102]

唔識講廣東話,就唔好唱廣東歌

嘴巴含滷蛋的白癡閩南小孩

[ex0duzz]

hahaha, i came to see what the fuss was about, and yep, this is pretty bad lol

[hnlzero]

angry fobs commenting, lol

[atamaitai0102]

不會唱廣東歌 也不需要這樣強迫自己唱吧

死閩南仔小孩 想裝廣東仔

等下輩子吧

[larien2527]

Ahhhhh!! 3 years ago

Wanna hear he sing this song once again now, maybe he will sing better than 3 years ago ??? LOL

[xyz2211xyz]

古人曰:人必自辱而後人辱之!!!

古人誠不欺我矣!!!

[kennyboi86]

ok what at least he tried =)

support jay chou always

[iluvbogs]

i don't know who this guy is but got here while browsing Jacky's song. I think he forgot some words while singing. He is not consistent, some times good and sometimes sound like shit.

[mamanki]

SBSBSB

[Cantonakan]

佢流眼淚wo.. 可能首歌對佢黎講好有回憶呢~

咁感動得制係唱到咁架ma...

[hacinchi]

开演唱会累的 所以没唱好。不过他真的很不适合唱这首经典 他表达不出那种伤感。唱砸了。。。

[vienna2046]

确实不会唱歌 。。。

[lvoodoo2you]

sti ca chante comme une tapette comparativement a Jacky

[funnybunny9396]

都唔期望他會唱得好過学友,但也不至於唱成這樣....所謂歌手­~ 唉!!!

[jessefanlin]

@fly110 fuck you

he sings it with more feelings and romance

[dabosical]

geez since you all hate him for singing this song then go watch jacky cheung's version instead. let those who think it's okay listen to it in peace. what good do you get out of being so rude about him anyway?

[plantnoyo]

活像嘴巴含了顆滷蛋

[JasonCarter2009]

fuck you jay chou,you sing not better than jacky,go to hell

[jeff46]

wads this? i can sing better than him! lol

[yinpeng100]

me 2

[samho0123]

他创作可以,讲到唱歌他真的不行,把这么好的歌唱像念书.拜托请­用心点唱吧

[firehouse2328]

好什麼好比的= =

張學友本來就是他那個時代的歌神，唱得本來就比Jay好。

不過Jay跟他是不同時代的人，很明顯地Jay的音樂一出來之後­，之前的音樂突然變成上一世紀的歌曲。雖不想承認但他在華人流行­樂的確是一個偉大的革命家。

[stranger4135]

聽到一半就不想聽下去了

他還是去唱自己的歌

"你怎麼連話都說不清楚"

歌名一聽就知道適合他

[yklee1024]

jay chow is not good enough to sing this song...

[fufriedrich]

奇怪大家在这首歌上意见这么统一?...

如果只想听纯正的普通话或广东话就看新闻联播和听罗文吧

[mydadacapt]

gosh...im lost for words...

even aaron yan does it so much better than him...

[chengweechian]

去死吧

[kevin19841021]

把这歌毁了

[hoyun]

低音低不下去

[torresjay889]

Wtf,please la,jacky is 19 king,jay is 2000 king...they 2 is in different music world...how can compare???jay is a rapper n pop...jacky is a super vocal voice...i love both of they...they 2 is jus genius in music..so dun compare they 2,both r the best in chinese world!!!!!

[runnovember]

唱的什么啊/。像狗屎一样。

跟张学友根本没法比。

[368Dirk]

@runnovember 跟狗屎一'樣....妳唱給一首來聽聽阿 PO上來嘛 看看是不是連蒼蠅大便都不如

[funnybunny9396]

nocomparison they are not in the same league jacky is the god.

[leewookie1]

4evajaychou i understand you must be a fan of jay chou but please speak fairly...yes he can play piano but doesn't mean he can sing...are you fucking deaf!

[jacinthtw]

真的不太好聽...

[queenofass]

he has got his own style.

AND I ADORE IT

[TheMonkeysong]

螳螂挡臂。。 非常明显今天和以往的歌界之差。。

[ninjasks89]

Omg what the fuck is this.....this sounds amateurish....if you're gonna sing Jacky's song, at least put some effort into it. Pathetic. HK's singers are getting worse and worse...

[Thtchinkygurl]

Jay is frm Taiwan

[ninjasks89]

point being? I was born in china and didnt go to school and move to the US and still have better pronunciation that him. I would destroy a song if I sing a Spanish classic with horrible pronunciation. If he can't have good pronunciation, don't sing it.

[ItzMe9659]

OMG

why why why did he mess with PERFECTION.

If ur gonna do it...please....do it better.

this is my all time favorite from Jacky!!!!

[YAMET2008]

張學友唱得有感情得多,超正！

[ndey1986]

jay is not suitable to sing this song...... no feel at all

[mariekwok]

omg, I really like Jay Chou and all, but this is absolutely horrible! Hurt my ears so much. Poor song =(

[HeiLong112]

Indeed Jay is a good singer of this day and age, but nothing compared to Jacky whos been around for longer than jays been born haha and still going strong with his songs

[Dengero]

His canto is bad, but he sings it good to make up for it!

[cloudwmok]

...............我反而覺得幾好聽wo~冇錯~佢­d粵語的確唔正~但係佢係台灣人~粵語唔正好正常姐~好似我地香­港人講普通話都唔正啦~雖然佢d粵語唱得唔正~但係我覺得幾有f­eel~當然~杰倫緊係比唔上張學友啦~但我相信世上都冇乜人比­得上張學友唱依隻歌~

[iouning]

The whole thing about 反唱 is not about comparing the two artists... obviously Jacky will own Jay in what he focuses on, which is singing. However I disagree that Jay is a poor singer, he added his own taste to the song, which is a the whole idea to 反唱. Quit dissing, where is the love?

[god11426]

張學友的歌果然不是一般人唱的了的

[CenaBomb]

This is extremely terrible.. he is only good at composing, that's about it. Jacky is the god of song in ASIA, how can he be denied. This is an extremely aggravating impersonating, my god. Jay- Don't do that again.

[worlder2009]

I agree.. totally killed the song~

[chan808yuen]

我敢講歡呼既人 大部分只係追星族

根本粵語部分唱得清 兩成都冇 啲人兩個字聽得到就鬼殺咁嘈 不知所為

一係就練到唱得清楚為止 一係完全國語版 國言版一樣好聽 唔好搞到唔湯唔水

[kelhws]

insulting

[kaitamasaki]

this was one of his earlier performances.. stop comparing.

jay is an all rounded musician... his composing is what got him to the place he is at today. YOU CANNOT DENY IT....

while my impression of jacky is that all he can do is sing, though he is one of the best at that, but jay has a unique image. thats the reason why hes so famous. I think singing also depends on how each singer interprets the song, and isnt just comparisons over and over. I mean, songs are meant to stimulate your emotions..

[M4ns]

好難聽/.

[siphu]

wow, that was horrible. he shouldn't sing jacky cheung songs.

[samuello128]

I like Jay Chou, but I can't deny I LIKE JACKY'S VERSION MUCH MUCH MORE!!!

[bnssapp]

不会说话就不要学人唱歌阿~~~

收山吧..周杰伦~~~~~

[HeiLong112]

哈哈

说得好

[syn3rgetic]

this guy disgrace jacky cheung,..but i like jay shou!

[myacnt8999]

so sad that we have a famous singer in chinese entertainment industry, but he can't sing!! what a disgrace.