Who Created God- Dr. Zakir Naik answers this question..

[mrtuffyboy]

man created god.

[Gameshunter3012]

Such pathetic excuses of an explanation are what make me proud NOT to believe in God.I used to be ashamed of turning my back on my childhood beliefs(which are bruttaly FORCED in every child's mind btw),but now that I see how man-made religion is,I see it was the right thing to do.Btw,everything can be explained with physics aparently.And the only reason the Bible has correct prophecies over the satanic pope and all is because it was written by those who do it...

[marekmaxpabianice]

Answer is simple. Religions are man made! It is really sad that people all over the world believe in one book, one book written hundreds years ago... really sad...

[rairm2009]

Allah is neither a man or a woman. We can only believe that He's our creator. If god is a man, which means he's similar to human. That characteristic is already seen as a weakness.

[NoBoysCouple07]

الله واحد which means Allah is ONE.

[MrJunnayA]

The creator of god is the mind :D simple answer...

[smashnoor1]

@MrJunnayA ...who created the mind? A big bang? A crash?

[MrJunnayA]

@smashnoor1 the brain created the mind, the nature created the brain, the cosmic dust created this nature along with the planets. When ever we ask you "Who created god?" you answer: god was forever there, thus we may also say the universe was forever there... so people don't reply i don't want to waste my time.

[NoKamWithRam]

Stupid DOCTOR Naik!??



[briggs2012]

I'm yet to find someone who wears one of those silly little white hats who doesn't dish out logical fallacies or mischievously confuse audiences with nonsensical arguments.

[alfianat]

... the good Doctor has merely made a bare assertion that the creator is "uncreated" without offering any objective evidence forming the basis of this assertion. If we adopt the logic of the good Doctor, then by definition we can define anything to exhibit any characteristics we want. I could well then say the good Doctor is a uncreated by definition. And by his own logic, it would be meaningless to ask then who created the good Doctor, as by my definition, he is simply defined so.

[baaroodii]

@alfianat but be careful not to mix the divine attributes of god with the attributes of man ,that what you can assert in context to nature to a certain creation cannot be asserted to the creator of this frame of reference which is nature so god created nature but we cannot use nature to find similarities between it and god and if you do so you would have asserted that god has a unholy attribute which is need, for god needs nothing we do not affect god but we the creations need god.

[alfianat]

... In other words, we know that a "man" does not give birth to a child only because of the evidence that supports this fact. It is by no measure just a matter of simple definition as claimed by Dr Zakir. Now turning to the good Doctor's bare assertion that the creator is "uncreated". He says this is a simple matter of definition. Is it really? In order to define a thing, one needs first to understand the nature of the thing....

[alfianat]

The good Doctor is clearly being mischievous. A "man" is not by definition "one who does not give birth". I invite Dr Zakir to show us a definition of "man" in any dictionary that defines "man" as such. Now, the fact that a man does not give birth is an observable and testable trait that the male of the human species exhibits...

[afterglow2323]

What an answer! So short yet so meaningful and precise!

[briggs2012]

@afterglow2323 I'm missing the meaning. Enlighten me.

[moistfaucet]

Muhammad was sent by Alien. and you human stupidly believe it, die for it, spend time dealing with it. and Alien Watch you people on their TV like Jerry Springer show, laughing at it.

[KarstenOkk]

Seriously? So he's saying that God isnt created because he's a man?? This guy seems to mix things up...

[ArunTheCoolestGuy]

@KarstenOkk what the fuck did he just say??? seriously i didn't get it!

[KarstenOkk]

@ArunTheCoolestGuy same.

[faro0485]

@KarstenOkk Actually you're mixed up. Let me explain it to you in a non-medical form. Giving to the argument of their is a creator of God, we say God. You ask who again created God, we say God. And we go on adinfanitum. God, created God, created God, etc You know what the other definition of God is? God is infinite. اَللّٰہُ الصَّمَدُ allahu assamad, assamad meaning eternal. Even the question confirms who God is.

[furyfuryfuryboy]

@KarstenOkk

Nop, you are wrong, Zakir said that his question is illogical. Do you know what God means? He created ewerything, and he is not born. Who made you? Who made earth? Who made universe? You can NOT go forever with those questions, there have to be someone who was not born, and who is there all the time. Some people are stupid and they can not understand that, but i hope Allah will help them.

[Instrumentals4Sale]

It took me 2mins to realise that this was not a joke, that this was not a stand up comedian... i thought this was some tongue -in-cheek parody of an ignorant man trying to answer a complex answer. ...the response is rediculious.

Surely a religion as large as islam has better answers than that, its not even an answer to the question.

Im sure this man has spend alot of his life examining the nature of god..and this is his response? such a pity.

[RobotShark55]

wait what

[airworker8]

This guys mental capacity must be very low.

[oODarkEnergyOo]

"A fool in a funny white hat" ... that's what this video should have been called.

[Draeber]

Doesnt make any sense. Is God a human? A male human?

[MsDaxMan]

if god is uncreated how did his words were writen....

[LibnanGR]

@MsDaxMan

The idea behind god is he is the uncaused cause.

Elsewise you have the problem of infinite regress.

[notalkingnow]

@LibnanGR and infinite regress is bad because....?

[LibnanGR]

@notalkingnow

The problem with an infinite regress is as follows.

1) You don't solve the problem.

2) You don't get to where you are now.

Lets use our comments on youtube as an example.

Before your next reply wait an infinite amount of time before making it. What you will find is you will never make your post. You can not be in the here and now with infinite regress, and as such infinite time. Also, the problem of infinite regress also exists in causality. Nothing can happen then.

[ariesabey]

all is fine with the explanation, naik, but who has given this definition to god? And where is this "uncreated" god? Where does he live? His location, domain and perception? Where is he and what is he doing when the power hungry schemers use verses from supposed holy books of great religions to brainwash gullible youths to act in hatred and destroy his own (supposed) creation? No naik, there is no god that fits the usual definitions. Stop doing this rhetoric and be fair with your reasoning.

[6thMessenger]

So...God can't be created because John can't have children because he is a man. DUH of course. Dr. Naik is an idiot. A smooth talking, dodgy, idiot.

The actual answer to this riddle is, "Man".

Man is the creator of God.

Without man, God wouldn't exist.

[whitesquirrel7]

a pioneer of in-vitro fertilization, said in 1999 “male pregnancy would certainly be possible.” In rare cases, women have given birth to babies that developed outside the uterus Winston argued that men should also be able to bear fetuses in their abdominal cavities. But male pregnancy would be complicated and, potentially fatal.

Zakir is wrong about this - so can anything he says be trusted/truthful?

[whitesquirrel7]

1:12 mins

this creationist moron claims he knows no woman called John

how about

Radclyffe Hall: A Woman Called John

I found a fascinating story about a woman named John Brown that will pique everyone's interest. The article is entitled, "John Brown: A Black Female Soldier in the Royal African Company."

so theres two for a start ofund after just 1 min search

[whitesquirrel7]

that one is easy to answer

muhammed created god/allah from his imagination

[kingpinmanoz]

@whitesquirrel7 PERFECT..HAHAHAHAHAHA!

[Enzo012]

@whitesquirrel7 He didn't just copy the idea from the Bible then?

[whitesquirrel7]

@Enzo012

quite definitely not

he appears to have used the bible as the basis

but in a very garbled manner, and including many statements about the bible which contradict other statements about the bible in the qu'ran

almost as if he once heard the bible recited to him, and later in life wrote it all down from imperfect memory

in a very disjointed / disorganized

the gaps in the narrative being filled in with his own misogynist and anti-semetic fantasy rantings 

[frankthemaratha]

if any1 would know who created god then he  himself will became god

[EYEthatwatchestheEYE]

YHWH created lucifer. lucifer is the god of islam. there is your answer.

[ExposingArmyOfSatan]

@EYEthatwatchestheEYE

well paul is the god of christianity aka paulinism.

how can lucifer be the god of islam? when islam teaches to worship The One God?.

while christianity(paulinism) teaches to worship man?

The God of Islam is The God of Adam,Noah,Abraham,Isaac,Ishmae­l,Jacob,Moses,Joshua,David,Sol­omon &Jesus

[ariesabey]

@ExposingArmyOfSatan God of adam, Noah,Abraham, Isaac Ismail and the whole lot of abrahamic religions is the god of muslims. Formerly El and Yahweh the Gods who often fought for supremacy when they traveled with the lot from sumeria, signed an MOU to be friends and be one! millennium and centuries later another prophet by name Mohammed comes witha new name: Allah. If you call god by any other name god will punish you. When assumed power, he said, "Call God Allah, or else I will killyou!"

[aloyblue]

pls read and explain the book of Revelation Dr Zakir Nair ! u sure cannot answer this question !