20070701 校園歌喉戰 年度總冠軍 張晉樵--春天

[tibia1224]

在聽過古巨基 跟 周治平 的兩個版本後

老實說

我不覺得張晉樵唱的特別好聽

反而是原唱古巨基 唱的比較有味道

但是張晉樵絕對沒有評審說的那麼糟

這首歌旋律也不會讓人記不起來

不知道評審的標準在哪?

尤其最後一個評審更是...(隨波逐流)

[wendy9311]

佢唱得唔錯呀~

有咩問題啵?!

d人kai大左?!個個係度踩人~_~

1個踩完之後個個隨波逐流~我呸

[roomd21]

好濫的主持人

[tonelyes]

If you have a heart, soul and spirit, you will love this beautiful song. But if you are a chasing rainbow guy, the shinning neon is not here at all.

His suppresive voice still the best on interpreting this song.

Watching those judges destroy this younger plant, I am glad finally the audiences dump this show to the hell. It is not a incident.

[iloveAzumi]

i feel upset after watching this vid~this candidate should change the way he sings ~it's too outdated and not good enough,not only the problem of choosing the right song~

[jsrwang07]

真的是不知所謂, 這明明是好歌一首, 比起一些家傳戶曉人人能唱的歌曲更加有深度, 卻被他們講成這樣, 難道時尚感比音樂品質來的重要嗎?

[eddie04291]

的確

這首歌真的很難讓人記得

但是 他的歌聲仍然是難忘的

他變成熟了@@

[k731006]

我覺得這次評審角度好怪..選錯歌?明明就很舒服很ok啊技巧也­不錯啊~這是歌唱比賽不是選明星吧~這首歌到底什麼地方叫選錯!­?就因為旋律比較讓人記不得?~簡直胡說八道~

[whenapigfly]

i love this song and him...good singer!

[alias91919]

you're my favorite just because i think you have more potential to grow. and you're the hottest out of them all. and your voice is sexy.

[oatmeal0609]

such a beautiful song, great lyrics as well!

add oil!!!!!!!!!!!

[bemyselflin]

old BUT GOLD! I Love 樵,AMAZING VOICE HE HAS.

[changsuchen]

樵樵:

我聽了又聽你的演唱,真的厲害ㄛ,尤其在好幾處高音的轉折處理很­專業,但在低音處就沒那麼漂亮ㄌ!加油!

[ncuselena]

張晉樵的高明之處 就是不論唱啥歌都讓人很舒坦  且唱來總是讓人感覺像是他自己的歌！

[tonelyes]

The judges just repeated tell one thing, he needs change in singing style in this new world. So he can have all level fans and a great future...

But he needs a couch.

[tonelyes]

At beginning, I wonder why the song writer use those odd pronounciation and rhymes in this lyric which are not suited for opening you throat, jaw and mouth to sing fluently. After this competitions, I just figure out, 張晉樵 exactly translate the beauty of supressive voice to show a lover's struggling mind in a early SPRING. The song writer and 張晉樵 are true artists.

[tonelyes]

This song is beautiful both in melody and lyric.

[JoyceEast]

I think he did pretty well on this...(though it's true he has done much better when he was in better shape), ( though it's true that this melody isn't so outstanding, but it's not like it's his fault), (thought it's true he actually should hav raised the key, BUT NOT true that this is totally out of his 音域共鳴 SO exactly the opposite!) ..... er... anyway.. this is complicated to explain, lots of different facets

[angie8816]

ohhhh noooo!!!!! He is the one I'm rooting for!!!

[xLiLtWiNsTaR]

doesnt sound like leo ku but good.

[JoyceEast]

......... er..... that's wot's good about it...

[bemyselflin]

樓上同學說的好.聽了幾次，他唱的比當天很多分數在他前面的同學­好多了．說這首歌没技巧．太平．．．不也間接批評到了作者．評審­那天的水準好像也太．．．

[JoyceEast]

分數的確給得太低了... that's the problem with giving points and the order they sing in... (er.. if u know wot i mean... ) BUT... it is actually quite true that this song is not so great... the melody doesn't leave an impression 真的很平... that's why i think he did such a good job of it...

[ncuselena]

他唱得很好 三位評審只想聽旋律很通俗的歌嗎？ 分數給太低了吧

[JoyceEast]

exactly... but how to say this... it's true this melody is pretty... er.. not so good... but then they should focus on his voice and how brilliantly he outdone this song! 是這首歌的旋律害了他, 舒駿老師說得較好 較客觀...

PS... 小松is wrong... this is only a tiny bit low for him... but it only sounded so muffled and dull becoz his nose was totally stuffed that day!!! @_#

[s8502057]

he can sing better@@

[lumi1958]

對啊~~很好聽啊

[lumi1958]

對啊~~很好聽啊

[ddds22]

This is a difficult song.

[bemyselflin]

唱的很好啊~~歌詞挺古典的...評審給分太低了啦

[bluepal]

first