ALL CAN PLAY INDONESIA CULTURE BUT DON'T CLAIM AS YOURS
HERE ARE SOME OF INDONESIAN CULTURE CLAIMED AS MALAYSIAN CULTURE BY MALAYSIA:
SILAT - MArtial Arts from Indonesia
BATIK - Visual Arts from Indonesia
RENDANG - Indonesian food
RASA SAYANGE - Ambonese traditional song
ANGKLUNG - Sundanese Music Instrument
PENDET DANCE - DAnce from BALI (THE RIDICULOUS THING IN THIS CASE THAT MALAYSIA GOVERMENT RECORDED THIS DANCE IN BALI - INDONESIA FOR MALAYSIA TOURISM ADVERTISEMENT)
@sherinamunafik 1 aja buat kamu, perkataan "INDO" jgn diklaim ya itu hak india, tak malu dibilang org maling sendiri jugak maling.. Maling terik maling ya..
Gamelan asal dari suku jawa.. Wong Jawa di mana mana pun berhak mpratikkan budaya nya.. Budaya bkn hak sesebuah Negara.. Bkn hak Indonesia maupun Singapur
@FaridElhanMalaysia betul tu...ingatan untuk org2 indo..orang keturunan jawa ramai kat malaysia...terutama di negeri Johor,selangor,perak ,negeri sembilan......jadi mereka mengamalkan dan meneruskan budaya warisan nenek moyang mereka...tak kan itu dikatakan merompak atau mencuri budaya...begitu juga disingapura ramai juga yg berkurunan jawa....saya sendiri pun ayah asal singapuradan emak asal jawa tengah....kita kena terima hakikat asal-usul kita........
dont mindlah if the gamelan is came frm java or thailnd,cambodia whatsover.The point is that this type of knock type of music has been prscticed all over SEAa hundred years ago with thier own mold of ethicity.and style.maybe java are well known fr thier manufactrg of gamelan in batch & exports thrgout nusantara but nobody know the exactly where this gamelan originates and who is the creator.this gamelan are belong to the people of nusantara.
The feelg of beig a citizen in Indosia is vry much diffrent if compard wth Mlysia & Sg. we hve to compete wth ths 2 biggst races that have an excellnt civilazatn throuhout th world in past time.We knw hw is th levl of our mindst & also thiers.Evthough we compete each others but we still can live peacefully & harmony bcoz we undrstnd ech others ad respect.indonesia is tryng to break th ethc grop to small peices bt mlysia is tryg to unite th ethic grp fr largst peics.tht is the diffent.
in indonesia they define malay as an ethnic group but not a race.While in Malaysia and Singap[ore the races is define to the group of people that have a similar look,similar language and si milar custumes.If compared between Malays, indian and Chinese they have a big different in terms of language,customn etrc. They all not same.While jawa,bugis,minang etc is look similar and can be categories in same group of people. They preferd to be called Melayu.Indonesia is a nation nt races.dont be confsd
meski gamelan dari jawa tapi silakan aja diminati dan dimainkan siapapun. sbg org indonesia sy bangga jika musik nusantara banyak yg mempelajarinya diluar negri, toh org2 indo sendiri suka melecehkan juga sih. makanya pelajari dan cintai budaya sendiri donk....peace :)
Hi there Maqapiz, I am Tam from Singapore. I am writing an opera in Mandarin Language, with western orchestra and some gamelan instruments, but would like to delve deeper into the gamelan instruments. Would you be able to help me out - perhaps suggest to me how I can get closer / hands-on to these wonderful instruments. Could I get a personal tour to the instruments at NUS or somewhere? Thanks so much.
You do not have the right to say that the Malays in Singapore steals Javanese culture. Let it be known to you that the Javanese in Singapore is classified as Malays. Do correct yourself in the future and let not others correct you instead!
ya betul aku setuju, memang aslinya jawa. Cuma titlenya ditulis Gamelan yang dimainkan okestra melayu singapura. Bukan diclaim gamelan punya melayu atau singapura. Harusnya bangga bang. budaya dilestarikan seluruh Nusantara.
and by the way, the music is obviously javanese, not malay. the reason why it's called "malay" is because javanese are considered "malay" in ethnicity-ignorant countries like malaysia or singapore. there is a significant difference from a javanese person to a malay person evnthough they belong to the same race that spans the entire southeast asian archipelago (yes that includes the philippines).
@july071992 Hi. Go read up more about our country. We are in the Malay peninsula. We are a Malay country except for the fact that the Chinese are the majority here. Even the Southern Thais play this music. Southern Thais are Malays as well...
So funny...., this is about tourism and big industry.
Tourism makes country sell anything even the one that is not original from their country.
This is one of the impact of globalization. So... don't worry the world know that Gamelan from Java, Indonesia even Malaysian or Singaporean knows. History have been recognizing Java and its culture in many literature .
The important thing is "how to respect each others".... arts is belong to everybody... but history never rest... :-)
This sounds more like Javanese gamelan..minus all the complexities of the actual Javanese gamelan ( I meant the base is Javanese) . Malay gamelan is more Thai-like (mostly played in the northern states of Malaya-bordering Siamese Kingdom hence heavily carrying the Khmer / Ayodhya influence as opposed to Java )
kakak, sememangnya kami orang malay tahu yang Gamelan berasal dari tanah jawa... jangan risau.. kami tak akan claim.... cuma pak pak menteri kami yang brengsek saja yang mahu claim... jangan salahkan rakyatnya ya kakak
lol u guys realy needs to go back and look into history coz this instrument is played widespread even in the siam. though it have change little bit among others but this musicexist everywhere in malay's territory. southern thai are malays, indonesia are malays, brunei are malays and malaysia are malays, and also some in singapore.. those 'penjajah' really had made u guys separated and forgot about ur own ancestor
amitabacanda : orang bodoh je yang suka kata orang lain bodoh..kalau kamu berakal,kamu tidak akan bilang orang lain Bodoh atau goblok.. manusia semua sama diciptakan..dari tanah dan kembali dalam tanah..x kira lah kamu Jawa,Palembang,Batak,Iban,melayu, Kadazan atau bangsa ape sekalipun..jgnlah kamu terpengaruh dgn agenda2 barat yg menguasai media2 kamu yg cuba merosakkan hubungan antara kedua negara..Mak aku asalnya pun Jawa..ayah ku Banjar..xperlulah bergaduh krn hal ni..kita sume sama..
hahah... did u know where ur ancestors were from???
-do u know prameswara?? who's him? he's Majapahit exile... ancestor of all malays..
-do u know najib razak, ur PM? he's a Bugis man.
-do u know mahatir? ex PM? he's India..
so all malays 're not Asli Civil, ur cultur & laguange was derived and originated from another region of Nusantara Cultures and another foreign Asia...
yes i know all of it, but let us think for a while what is 'malay'?its simply 'melayu' that inhibits the malay archipelago (that includes borneo n indonesia) thousands years ago, until the portugeese, british and dutch came and started to separate us and call us indonesia, borneo, malaysia, javaneese, etc. or shall i say u r the left overs of 'tali barut penjajah' yang mahu kita semua masih berpecah belah? 'divide n conquer', thats how they do it, and look now what u r feeling about u r own race
Aaaaaah, this is why I love the sound of the gamelan. The sound is transcendent, and the posture of the musicians, so tranquil and rooted and in unison, is absolutely beautiful.
ALL CAN PLAY INDONESIA CULTURE BUT DON'T CLAIM AS YOURS
HERE ARE SOME OF INDONESIAN CULTURE CLAIMED AS MALAYSIAN CULTURE BY MALAYSIA:
SILAT - MArtial Arts from Indonesia
BATIK - Visual Arts from Indonesia
RENDANG - Indonesian food
RASA SAYANGE - Ambonese traditional song
ANGKLUNG - Sundanese Music Instrument
PENDET DANCE - DAnce from BALI (THE RIDICULOUS THING IN THIS CASE THAT MALAYSIA GOVERMENT RECORDED THIS DANCE IN BALI - INDONESIA FOR MALAYSIA TOURISM ADVERTISEMENT)
FUCK MALAYSIA !!!
sherinamunafik 8 months ago
@sherinamunafik 1 aja buat kamu, perkataan "INDO" jgn diklaim ya itu hak india, tak malu dibilang org maling sendiri jugak maling.. Maling terik maling ya..
FaridElhanMalaysia 8 months ago
Gamelan asal dari suku jawa.. Wong Jawa di mana mana pun berhak mpratikkan budaya nya.. Budaya bkn hak sesebuah Negara.. Bkn hak Indonesia maupun Singapur
FaridElhanMalaysia 11 months ago
@FaridElhanMalaysia betul tu...ingatan untuk org2 indo..orang keturunan jawa ramai kat malaysia...terutama di negeri Johor,selangor,perak ,negeri sembilan......jadi mereka mengamalkan dan meneruskan budaya warisan nenek moyang mereka...tak kan itu dikatakan merompak atau mencuri budaya...begitu juga disingapura ramai juga yg berkurunan jawa....saya sendiri pun ayah asal singapuradan emak asal jawa tengah....kita kena terima hakikat asal-usul kita........
putrawarisanbanting 8 months ago
Ini irama gamelan jawa, gamelan melayu bunyinya lebih sedap
ummfaizal 11 months ago
dont mindlah if the gamelan is came frm java or thailnd,cambodia whatsover.The point is that this type of knock type of music has been prscticed all over SEAa hundred years ago with thier own mold of ethicity.and style.maybe java are well known fr thier manufactrg of gamelan in batch & exports thrgout nusantara but nobody know the exactly where this gamelan originates and who is the creator.this gamelan are belong to the people of nusantara.
matkilau70 1 year ago
The feelg of beig a citizen in Indosia is vry much diffrent if compard wth Mlysia & Sg. we hve to compete wth ths 2 biggst races that have an excellnt civilazatn throuhout th world in past time.We knw hw is th levl of our mindst & also thiers.Evthough we compete each others but we still can live peacefully & harmony bcoz we undrstnd ech others ad respect.indonesia is tryng to break th ethc grop to small peices bt mlysia is tryg to unite th ethic grp fr largst peics.tht is the diffent.
matkilau70 1 year ago
in indonesia they define malay as an ethnic group but not a race.While in Malaysia and Singap[ore the races is define to the group of people that have a similar look,similar language and si milar custumes.If compared between Malays, indian and Chinese they have a big different in terms of language,customn etrc. They all not same.While jawa,bugis,minang etc is look similar and can be categories in same group of people. They preferd to be called Melayu.Indonesia is a nation nt races.dont be confsd
matkilau70 1 year ago
indonesial suka cari gaduh...dah la mengemis dekat negara orang masih nak tunjuk hebat..
basikalhijau 1 year ago
meski gamelan dari jawa tapi silakan aja diminati dan dimainkan siapapun. sbg org indonesia sy bangga jika musik nusantara banyak yg mempelajarinya diluar negri, toh org2 indo sendiri suka melecehkan juga sih. makanya pelajari dan cintai budaya sendiri donk....peace :)
kambova2000 1 year ago
Hi there Maqapiz, I am Tam from Singapore. I am writing an opera in Mandarin Language, with western orchestra and some gamelan instruments, but would like to delve deeper into the gamelan instruments. Would you be able to help me out - perhaps suggest to me how I can get closer / hands-on to these wonderful instruments. Could I get a personal tour to the instruments at NUS or somewhere? Thanks so much.
HOE68YEN 1 year ago
brengsek kamu orang semua..suka ngobrol pasal race. jawa melayu sama je lol..kita ini dari nabi Adam juga. yg membezakan cuma iman dan takwa.
JALAKBROJOL 1 year ago
terima kasih telah ikut melestarikan budaya jawa.memang dulu singapura/tumasik masih wilayah kerajaan jawa
k155w4ndry 2 years ago
melayu suka maling budaya jawa
arimbozho 2 years ago
You do not have the right to say that the Malays in Singapore steals Javanese culture. Let it be known to you that the Javanese in Singapore is classified as Malays. Do correct yourself in the future and let not others correct you instead!
lawang1sg 2 years ago
DUNIA JUGA TAU. dari nada2nya itu kebudayaan indonesia
rezalovethem 2 years ago
betul bgt tu bro,,, nada2nya jawa bgt!!! Dasar Malay and Singapore tak sepatutnya mengakuinya.
m4l1n9s14 2 years ago
ya betul aku setuju, memang aslinya jawa. Cuma titlenya ditulis Gamelan yang dimainkan okestra melayu singapura. Bukan diclaim gamelan punya melayu atau singapura. Harusnya bangga bang. budaya dilestarikan seluruh Nusantara.
sAhreAl666 2 years ago
ok bang,,, lestarikan,,,
m4l1n9s14 2 years ago
and by the way, the music is obviously javanese, not malay. the reason why it's called "malay" is because javanese are considered "malay" in ethnicity-ignorant countries like malaysia or singapore. there is a significant difference from a javanese person to a malay person evnthough they belong to the same race that spans the entire southeast asian archipelago (yes that includes the philippines).
july071992 2 years ago 4
@july071992 Hi. Go read up more about our country. We are in the Malay peninsula. We are a Malay country except for the fact that the Chinese are the majority here. Even the Southern Thais play this music. Southern Thais are Malays as well...
92959921 1 year ago
So funny...., this is about tourism and big industry.
Tourism makes country sell anything even the one that is not original from their country.
This is one of the impact of globalization. So... don't worry the world know that Gamelan from Java, Indonesia even Malaysian or Singaporean knows. History have been recognizing Java and its culture in many literature .
The important thing is "how to respect each others".... arts is belong to everybody... but history never rest... :-)
rindrasih25 2 years ago
where is malaysia gamelan..i know malaysia gamelan is diffrent as same as batik , wood craft etc eventhough its have a similarity ..
kastatelier 2 years ago
This sounds more like Javanese gamelan..minus all the complexities of the actual Javanese gamelan ( I meant the base is Javanese) . Malay gamelan is more Thai-like (mostly played in the northern states of Malaya-bordering Siamese Kingdom hence heavily carrying the Khmer / Ayodhya influence as opposed to Java )
muzamira 2 years ago 3
silahkan dimainkan, asal jangan diklaim punya org melayu yah......
cz dunia juga tau Gamelan itu dari mana? Yaitu dari tanah Jawa..
amitabacanda 3 years ago
Yes....we, respect that....
maqapiz 3 years ago
kakak, sememangnya kami orang malay tahu yang Gamelan berasal dari tanah jawa... jangan risau.. kami tak akan claim.... cuma pak pak menteri kami yang brengsek saja yang mahu claim... jangan salahkan rakyatnya ya kakak
harristhecavaliers 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I HATE INDON
emeraldgal28 2 years ago
lol u guys realy needs to go back and look into history coz this instrument is played widespread even in the siam. though it have change little bit among others but this musicexist everywhere in malay's territory. southern thai are malays, indonesia are malays, brunei are malays and malaysia are malays, and also some in singapore.. those 'penjajah' really had made u guys separated and forgot about ur own ancestor
hazrulthegreat 2 years ago 5
what????? lol for u... stupid...
u said singapore is malay, thai is malays....
belajar dulu lah kau yang banyak dan rajin...
bodoh sekali kau....
nyatanya bahasa kau saja beda dengan bahsa batak, beda dengan bahasa jawa, beda dengan bahasa makasar...
kenapa masih kau bilang sama...
mana dasarnya bodoh....
aneh yah ada orang seperti anda yang bermimpi kalo semua dunia itu adalah malays... pantas saja semua ingin kau akui...
inget bung.. budaya itu kreasi tiap bangsa, jangan asal klaim
bodoh
amitabacanda 2 years ago
amitabacanda : orang bodoh je yang suka kata orang lain bodoh..kalau kamu berakal,kamu tidak akan bilang orang lain Bodoh atau goblok.. manusia semua sama diciptakan..dari tanah dan kembali dalam tanah..x kira lah kamu Jawa,Palembang,Batak,Iban,melayu, Kadazan atau bangsa ape sekalipun..jgnlah kamu terpengaruh dgn agenda2 barat yg menguasai media2 kamu yg cuba merosakkan hubungan antara kedua negara..Mak aku asalnya pun Jawa..ayah ku Banjar..xperlulah bergaduh krn hal ni..kita sume sama..
oktizarvia 2 years ago
betul bro,,,
m4l1n9s14 2 years ago
hahah... did u know where ur ancestors were from???
-do u know prameswara?? who's him? he's Majapahit exile... ancestor of all malays..
-do u know najib razak, ur PM? he's a Bugis man.
-do u know mahatir? ex PM? he's India..
so all malays 're not Asli Civil, ur cultur & laguange was derived and originated from another region of Nusantara Cultures and another foreign Asia...
amitabacanda 2 years ago
yes i know all of it, but let us think for a while what is 'malay'?its simply 'melayu' that inhibits the malay archipelago (that includes borneo n indonesia) thousands years ago, until the portugeese, british and dutch came and started to separate us and call us indonesia, borneo, malaysia, javaneese, etc. or shall i say u r the left overs of 'tali barut penjajah' yang mahu kita semua masih berpecah belah? 'divide n conquer', thats how they do it, and look now what u r feeling about u r own race
hazrulthegreat 2 years ago
Comment removed
leoaltus 2 years ago
how about the philippines. we also have some gamelan instrument. we just call it "kulintangan".
july071992 2 years ago
@amitabacanda Kebanyakan orang Melayu Singapura adalah keturunan Jawa.
montadang 1 year ago
@amitabacanda gamelan tu juga asal dari melayu terengganu!
seluarkotak2 8 months ago
need more improvement...
livius2x 3 years ago
anyway this was their first time... they just get to learn n touch the gamelan 2 weeks b4 they perform this show.
maqapiz 3 years ago
singapore gamelan sucks...java gamelan the best
7717tzm 3 years ago
since when there is such a thing called "Singapore Gamelan"?? duh hahaha....
Of course Indonesian gamelan is the best...
They should be.... They must be,.....
They BETTER be good.!
Its their own traditional instrument for GOD sake.....
maqapiz 3 years ago
hahahaha
Tgurl2008 3 years ago
@7717tzm bodoh
maisteel 1 year ago
@7717tzm please say something with full of respect.
MyDestroyer777 1 year ago
do you do weddings? mine's nx year..how to contact you? pls call Feisal 97620346. tanx
ach130608 4 years ago
gamelan ... great! i love it!
harristhecavaliers 4 years ago
Absolutley beautiful! Well done, OMS!
leelasethuraman 4 years ago
x blh tgk pun!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
naznina 4 years ago
Hey,Friend's if you want to learn javanesse gamelan and dance go to INDONESIA EMBASSY.The address is in Washington dc UNITED STATE OF AMERICA.
kolombeng 4 years ago
skola mana ni?
shadowfoe 5 years ago
Aaaaaah, this is why I love the sound of the gamelan. The sound is transcendent, and the posture of the musicians, so tranquil and rooted and in unison, is absolutely beautiful.
nimblehuman 5 years ago
Lovely song... Well done!!!
Samar88 5 years ago
the music is very haunting...lovely.
scurvyscallywag 5 years ago
By the way , what is the name of this gamelan group? and where can we learn to play this instruments?
RadenZul 5 years ago
This group is from the Orkestra Melayu Singapura (Youth).
maqapiz 5 years ago
beautiful! the sound makes me feel comfortable
kiuioiuytrew 5 years ago
Name of tune: SERAYU
MeAlek 5 years ago
La escucha no presenta la mejor de las condiciones, aunque parece estar bastante bien conjuntado.
Robufnoru 5 years ago