Adam Lambert vs Siobhan Magnus C5 - Bb5 note by note

[popiscrap]

to me adam, james, siobhan are not rock at all they are theatrical

[SuperFreakshow18]

@bcopp oh no! pls have some doubt!!! this is unbearable Bwahaaaaaaaaaa OMg Delusion at its best!!!!

[SuperFreakshow18]

@bcopp LMFAOOOOO! OMG where is she now? Nuff said!

[FreakingWillow]

nice way to end the video. :)

[daccord1]

where did you get the video at 2:23??

[daccord1]

i love Adam <33

[SuperFreakshow18]

I had to laugh at this comparison.... Please don't put this girls name in the same sentence as Adam...please don't!

[CauseItsVoodoo]

Adam is ADAMAZINGGGG!!!! :D:D:D

[TheDemiLFreak1]

Adam, no duh ;D

[SorenDaOwl]

i feel like you didnt show off the right parts of siobhans videos

[littlecat0908]

Adam

[TheDemiLFreak1]

Adam is incredible, wehns the last time you heard a boy sing that high!??? :D <3

[Wagnerlover777]

@TheDemiLFreak1 Yesterday.

[TheDemiLFreak1]

@Wagnerlover777 Oh, don't be jelous! >:D

[Wagnerlover777]

@TheDemiLFreak1 I know. I'm not saying they're both not amazing, but I HAVE seen a full-grown man sing higher. It was kinda creepy.

[imarunner89]

Siobhan should have won!

[cdfijjst]

amazing

[etyclorenzo91]

SIOBHAN! 

[limak24]

Siobhan! is the best. Adam is amazing too!

[kittykatt12321]

Siobhan sounds like a dying cat, so.

[danielteoh95]

i like both of them

[sentfromupabove]

No contest- Adam, Siobhan gets shouty at times and her first Eb5 was terrible.

[osahju914]

where was the non idol adam footage from?

[gamerchico]

there both amazing at hitting them hightnotes i wish i can figure out how to hit them but it's kinda hard lol they make it look so easy i would love to know how though but i think siobhan hits it alittle higher alittle higher then adam and she has a advantage she's a female adams a dude so thats fine but they better do a song together it would be amazing

[yupperoonie]

gahd, i love both their A5s so much. :|

[LiveToRide137]

Siobhan ftw!!!!!

[mommasguy]

i like bouht of they but i more like siobhan magnus they bought greatest

[shukigkato]

Very cool!

The website Idolranges has the LFTS note marked as an F#5 too, but I for the life of me can't tell.

[moesalim88]

@shukigkato she reached F#5 after the note while Ryan was talking and she went like for the city ayer ayer ayer . idol ranges by the way not always right .. they say Adam went Bb5 in PTFM while he went only as high as A5

[shukigkato]

@moesalim88 OK, I trust you. Again, love the vid!

[moesalim88]

@shukigkato thanx ... I might be wrong by the way , I was in some notes untill westvoice corrected me ,,,

[sentfromupabove]

@moesalim88 What song was Adam's F#5?

[angelofdarkness4real]

@sentfromupabove its from his performance i think it s called i make you crazy

[sentfromupabove]

@angelofdarkness4real Cheers :)

[angelofdarkness4real]

@sentfromupabove haha

[sentfromupabove]

@angelofdarkness4real What? lol

[angelofdarkness4real]

@sentfromupabove sorry wrong person i meant no problem

[TheSuperlover101]

nice

[akdyer03]

they both sound great to me.

[AdamFlowerful]

That girl Siobhan hurts my ears everytime she screams. Her voice is annoying just like simon said.

[moesalim88]

@AdamFlowerful weird coming from an Adam fan ... she mix her notes in the same teacneaq as Adam , the diffrent is he have more control than her

[AdamFlowerful]

@moesalim88 As an Adam fan my point is you cannot compare her to Adam. Adam is way better, please. Everytime Adam hit the high notes he makes it sounds good.

[moesalim88]

@AdamFlowerful I agree .. I'm a glambert but the reason for that is Adam have more control and training ,, when siobhan reaches his age maybe she will be as good

[vkenv]

@AdamFlowerful The only thing Adam does better is controlling the last two high notes at the end of the video. Siobhan just held the high notes, while Adam could sing a few words.

[Sepia1989]

nice video . ty :x

Siobhan has much more beautiful falsetto. Just compare their last notes "World" in Mad World and Across the Universe.

[blueugene]

@Sepia1989 Exactly =)

[moesalim88]

@Sepia1989 sure she do ... but then again she is a girl ,, it's natural for her to have a better head voice , the impressive thing when a male can belt as high and even higher than some girls

[mellynumerounoo]

AGAIN, the note in "Living In The City" by Siobhan is F#, NOT F.

[moesalim88]

@mellynumerounoo bretty sure it is F5

[mellynumerounoo]

@moesalim88 I'm POSITIVE that it's an F#5. Seriously lol.

[moesalim88]

@mellynumerounoo well make a video and put it as an F#5 if that will make u happy

lol back at ya

[vanemh84]

Adam has 8 more years of practise that Siobhan plus professional theater :) both are great though :D :D

BTW if you wanna reply lol do it @anherji cause this is not my account hehehe

[restlesspride666]

Adam has a louder voice. Siobhan sounds lighter and much easier but Adam has more volume and dramatic flair to his voice.

[DOMINIW5]

adam belting power is alot more captivating then siobhan but i mean siobhan im sure can go higher than that as well as adam

[blueugene]

Both have their own unique voice !

Siobhan hit it beautiful

Adam hit it rock.

[restlesspride666]

@blueugene that's a pretty good way of putting it.

[reyzzz100]

adam is much mush better