@AboutPixieDust That is cleverly said! I think that you are right. The lyrics have some ambiguity and i am glad that my thoughts about the lyrics showed in this video. That is a lovely compliment to get! Thank you! :D
@AgaJoanna Goodness, sorry for not replying sooner :( You must have forgotten about this video! Thank you! I a very glad that you liked it so much! And I just love to hear the words pure beauty! Have a good day :).
Very nice to hear that you like watching this video! Even several times, I feel honored :D. This song is very good, but I am not very fond of the mix. It has lost some of it's charm for me. Of course that makes it even better to read such a nice comment as yours :). So, thanks! I know, in some scenes you just feel like attacking Briony and kicking her ass :p. But in the end I felt really sorry for her too. She never wanted all that too happen of course. She is just human I guess...
Haha! Yes, I guess you can be biased because you heard this song for the first time in a YT video XD. LOL! I know, that version is lovely :) I prefer it over my version to be honest. I am so glad you mentioned that part! I liked it too! It is slightly weird but I had fun editing it XD
Yeah, I have to admit that you are right (A). I regret the combination now *blushes*. But do Teardrop/Massive Attack and Atonement go well in your opinion? Thanks for your honesty! :) I'll give you a thumbs up! ;-). Lotte
Great job! I laughed when the scene where Robbie's typing the letter is cut so it looks like it says "In my dreams, I kiss you" instead of you-know-what. Nice touch!
Gosh! Thank you!!! I don't see what is so good about it, but I feel honored! I like my other Atonement video much more XD but I must admit that it's lovely to get such a comment ^-^. Have a good day.
I don't mind making you a vid (in fact, I'd be honored XD) but that song is really hard! Do you prob have another R&B song in mind that isn't used for Atonement yet? It will take me lots of time before it is finished though, cause I am incredibly busy, but if you want me to give it a try, let me know! :)
I dont know I guess its cuz its one of those slightly sappy love songs on the radio but it suited the video so well I just had to like it. *damn catchy songs*
Yes, you are right, itis a sappy love song ;-) I didn't want to use this song at first, because I already heard it too often. But then I searched for the lyrics and I found out that this match hasn't been made yet and I felt it as my duty to make it XD, hehe! Anyway! Glad to hear that it won you over! Damn catchy songs indeed, I just keep singing this song after I heard it somewhere -_- Have a good day :)
Nah.. I am not so keen on the way I've edited the end in this video :S Or did you think that I spoke about the end of the film? Thanks for your comment!
What is bawlen? I can't find a proper translation ;-) Anyway, thanks a lot for your comment, I loved the movie too, it is so sad but so beautiful *sigh*. Bye!
This is a very good video! I don't know why I haven't seen this one before. Keep up the great work and thanks for viewing my version also! Your video is definitely wonderful and unique! :-D Can't wait to see more Atonement vids from you!
Thanks a lot for your nice comment. I am really glad that you like it (I think that we both edited the video very different, which is a plus ;-)) I have uploaded another Atonement video I like that one more then I like this one, if you are curious you can check it out :) Take care!
OMG ! Did I comment on this one before !? If I havent`t then I`m really late ! I wasn`t so sure about this song before but it has totally grown on me and its my current favourite ! Lotte ,you`ve done an amazing job putting together this beauty ! Love how you did the scene of Cecilia going under water ! Brilliant ! I`m adding this one to my faves ! 5 stars !!!!! :D
Really?? I really don't think that this is worth favouriting (I like my new Atonement video much more :S) but okay, that is up to yourself! Thanks a lot for the sweet words. I am really glad that you like it this much :) Btw, got to check now if you posted a comment before! LOL x
Love love love love love love love...this! After seeing Val's video to Pirates of the Caribbean w/ this song I had to come back to yours and watch it again! 5stars
Yes, I loved the movie too, it is beautiful indeed, but so sad as well *snif* I like my other Atonement video much more actually, but I am glad that you like this one! ;-) Thanks for your comment.
the movie is one of my favourites (i think that is one of the best movies ever),is brilliant,emotional,passionate and so sad (i cried a lot)...great performances and beautifully directed!
i loved your video, i think that you did a great job (it is allways a treat for me to watch scenes of atonement..i just can't wait for the dvd)!
Yeah, I loved this movie too! You expressed the beautyness really well :p It is good to hear that you like the vid, because the last comment I got on this video made me feel a bit down. At least someone likes it XD LOL take care too!
Hm.. Thanks for your honesty. It isn't a great comment to get, but it is good to hear that you are being honest! I understand that you dislike the song, but is their anything from the editing you like? Or don't you like that all too? I am just curious ;) I tried to match both things as good as possible, but in your opinion I failed, I got that already.
Can you tell me why on earth you bother to watch and comment this video then?!? Just asking.. why dont you go and watch some vids YOU like and stop bothering people with negative comments, please!! it is you who are cruel to the art of others! Shame on you!!! And if you can't say anything positive than please just keep it to yourself... I think that would make everyone satisfied!
I love those opinions like yours:-) 1) I stopped watching after several second, becouse matching this music to this film is really unsensitive. 2) Im really not responsible for that you dont hear it. 3) To be critical is not notihng i have to be shamed, it my opinion and to say it is my right, right? Moreover, this music (unproblematic like opinions you would like to read here) shows how simply is this movie understanded.
It's not like you are not allowed to write your opinion, but try to understand that it might hurt people! You saw the title, you knew what song it was.. why did you bother to see it?
I dont get it, sorry :P We all have different taste, accept it!! Personally I'm not a big fan of this music myself, but come on!the lyrics fits the editing & film! Look, I dont want to start a fight or anything;) but you should think about what you are writing.. People put their heart and soul into their videos..
I am not a fan of this song either to be quite honest, but I did think that the lyrics suited at least MY storytelling. I really like the fact that you are defending me, but you don't have too of course, everyone may give her/his own honest opinion! I am really curious after the comment that will follow actually XD.
Im really think about what I write. Author of this video is not alone, I mean there are tons(?) of these amatuers expreminets on youtube, thats it, but if I were her/him (sorry to talk about you in 3rd case) I wouldnt presented it here. I had no expectations when I opened this video, I was just looking around, if there wasnt the real beginning of the Atonement (try to search it in youtube, you will get this vid).
Im critical, because this vid is out (and the author wants some comment, I geuss), I was really disgusted in the moment of surprise and moreover to be noncritical to these creations is not useful for the author him/herself either. (And Im critical, because I work as a critic/review writer... however its more joke than some acceptable reason.)
Just curious.. have you already watched the whole video? Or can't you just force yourself because you disgust the song (and probably my "amateur editing") too much? LOL, you must get sick of me and frklinee, don't you?
yes, but... i havent solved it anymore... its just one vid... i just have tried to explain my statement - i think that it is normal to say no without shame:-) it has nothing to do with sometihng that i want hurt somebody or make somebodys bad day. this was my very first reaction on that video. i just wonder sometimes, thats all.-)
just try to understand that other people might feel offended and hurt!
As you say, we are not professionals.. So maybe you should take it easy before you use your "professional reviewing" words?? it's ok that you say what you think! But there are better ways to put it! That's why we react, the way you wrote it! It's mean.. I guess we just have to agree to disagree in this matter ;) Have a great week :P
I like the way you deffend your amigo or love you have sympathy for. Try to imagine my shock - reaction really fits to it, it was really immediate, moreover i could use stronger words to be really rough... Its nice you take care of, but this is an open space. I have no sentimant for pink flowers, I think its really cheap... Thats it. But itsnot the reason to say, im not a sensitive type. Contrary is the case. I my point of view some people should be unsensitive if they match things I spoke about
Pink flowers? What makes you think of that?? It is allright! I think we both understand what you mean, and of course you can say/think what you want, I get the point about the unsensical matching now ;-) I am not an unsensitive person either. Perhaps in your opinion in this case, but IRL sometimes the contrary (although I can be hard and mean too, probably like you! LOL) And yeah, your statement is clear, and no it hasn't ruined my day, though I felt insulted.. Anyway, have a great life! ;-)
I dont think we will get an end to this, you obviously dont get what we try to tell you!
And of course I defend my friend!!
even if maybe you wouldn't have felt offended if you got this comment, others may! And it has nothing to do with pink flowers or how she is as a person!! And I know for a fact she's not like you think :P As she said, have a great life ;)
That is okay (talking about me in the 3rd person I mean). I don't need comments, I just like editing videos and if other people like it (at least 40 people do, else it wouldn't have been favourited so often) it is only a stimulation to go on with making videos. I appreciate your honesty, if however you are a professional critic writer, you got to keep in mind that I am only an amateur, like you've said already! Nevertheless, I actually think this whole discussion is starting to become funny :)
I somehow felt forced to respond again (A) Yeah, I am a tuff one :p I agree, probably this song may not suit the film, but well, I am a simple person! (Perhaps even a young silly girl in your opinion, yeah, only 18..) Nevertheless this movie impressed me and I wanted to edit something. But, if however you stopped watching after several seconds, you don't have a good image how the video is, right? Perhaps you could have gone in too it more open-minded? Just my opinion (that I may say too :p)
You really think so?? I have seen better Atonement videos :S I am too scared to enter my video I suppose, but thanks for the compliment! I shall think of it :)
Wow Lotte! I can't believe I hadn't seen your vid before (maar da's volledig mijn schuld, ben de laatste tijd niet zoveel op YT geweest) and it's absolutely great! I must admit that Leona Lewis doesn't make my kind of favourite music, but I could stand it in this video as it accompanied the clips of a wonderful movie ;D Great job, 5* and in my faves! xx Yasmien
That is no problem at all Yasmien :) Thanks for your great comment, it is a wonderful compliment if you like the video when you dislike (or just not like :p) the music, thanks a lot for the highest rating and the fave. I think her song suited the film and I suppose some people agree with me! ^-^ The movie was wonderful IMO too. Have a great day and take care! xxx
wow this is the only atonement vid that has actually moved me to tears well done brilliant video god i hate briony so much coniving little cow i dont forgive her she can atone all she wants but i still want her to die a terrible death lol
That is a great compliment, I feel honored. Thanks a lot for your nice comment :) You are a cruel person I see! I am glad that she didn't die a terrible death, I couldn't have 3 dead leading characters in one movie LOL. Take care!
I love the film, but not everyone is so fond of it. I am very curious after your opinion, please let me know what you think after you've watched it :) Thanks for your compliment on the vid ^-^
Thanks! Just great to read such a lovely comment, Atonement is great IMO too, I am glad you think that the video is beautiful. I am going to dislike this song, because I probably heard it too often LOL. Thanks for your nice comment ^-^
Wow Lotte! yes, I saw it, finally. Just now actually XD I had to see this vid right away cause I have been dying to see it for so long! I love it!! Its much better than the film itself IMO XD The song is perfect ^^ I'm so going to see this video every once in a while! Actually made me teary. Thanks for making this! :) 10 stars and faves!! 2:55 is amazing btw!
This video??? Well, it is not so special that you should be deing to see it! LOL I really don't see why you like it more then the film :O, we'll discuss about that later :p Thanks a lot for being so sweet! 10* and faves AND teary eyes, wow that is incredible, thanks sweetheart ^-^
Aww thanks! *hug* unfortunately you are not on msn now, but you are not to blame because it is late already LOL Have a great Valentine's day! If you don't get enough attention tomorrow, just remember that I love you :p hehe
Great video Lotte ^^ I love this song although now I think I have just heard it too many times XDDD Your editing was GREAT and I love how you put the ending here... btw I saw Atonement and I liked it but not as much as you I think ;)
Not? Ow :p LOL that surpises me indeed! I shall hear rom you soon why you didn't like it that much as I think (A) This song is definetely to much on these dayd indeed ;)
Well, after two weeks here I am : PP Yesterday I finally saw this movie. So - I like this vid very much, some fades are really great and they capture the emotions. I like also your end with the machine. But Lottie, sorry to say that - I hate this song. It's so popular in Poland now that each morning I turn on the radio I can hear it about 100 times... It's so annoying. Hope you get my point. Please, make another Atonement vid with another song and I'll be in Heaven :-) 5/5 anyway LOL
Whaha you are adorable! I absolutely get your point about the song. When I started this video the song wasn't very popular yand I really enjoyed it very much, but lately they are sending it way too often :)So, that means I agree! LOL it is good to hear that you like it apart from the song though :p
It is a wonderful film, I am sure that you'll love it! But perhaps you shouldn't have watched the video before you watched the film :p Thanks for your great compliment Nina! ^-^ xxx
Haha, oké, ik snapte je ook wel hoor! A Beautiful Mind is idd erg mooi en daar is mijn hoogst gewaardeerde video van (tja, dat heeft toch iets speciaals (A)) Ik zie je morgen wel weer! ^-^
Oh huns, this is my favorite song paired up with my favorite movie!! How can I not love this!! I loved the sound of the typewriter overlapped w/ the song, as well as the truth being revealed in the end. I want to see the movie again (and I saw this twice in the theater already LOL)! I almost kissed the computer screen when beautiful James popped up HAHAHAHA! To my favorites : D
*phew* I am very glad that you like it! :) You should probably get the film on dvd asap. I have seen it once now, I loved it, but I'll just wait till it is released on dvd(and not so expensive anymore :p) And yes, James isn't bad looking at all! LOL WOW, great!! You even favourited it *wink* I feel honored! Take care
This is one of my fav films, I've just watched it last week but it feels like an eternity. Well, I remember the whole story but I would like to watch it again.
Anyway, I love this vid! You have chosen great clips and a lovely song! :D
Hi Sarah! Did you got suspended?? :O that would be cruel!! You should watch it again I suppose :p Thanks for your great compliment, I am glad you think I choose the right song and clips, take care Sarah :*
Glad to hear you did not got suspended on your formal account :) I shall try to remember that it is you with the caribbeanblack account, not sure if I will remember it though (A). Thanks, I shall try to be proud of it ;-)
Hehe LOL that is a great compliment, but I think it has to do with finishing reading the book too :p Thanks for your comment, I am glad to hear you think it is great ^-^!
Amazing matchup! Loved the song and the movie you used. It was nice to watch a vid to Atonement with a nicer upbeat song than the usual sad ones. A nice change also. Sorry you won't be around on youtube that much! I'll miss you! :) Loved the vid gurl! 5 stars and saved to favs
oh kheb het toch uitgekeken(khad toch al stukjes gezien op yt en kon mezelf niet houden) *pinkt traantjes weg* Kzit hier dus half te wenen, dus groot compliment voor u video!!! Echt zo mooi, maar zo triestig. Ik ga zakdoeken meenenmen naar de cinema xD 5sterren, en als het kon zou ik er meer geven!!!!
afgekeken?? JIJ!! GRRRR ik ben furieus! :p Had je niet moeten doen, maar ik vind het wel super dat je t triestig vindt, wat hebben jullie toch een grappig taaltje *gnif* Neem idd maar zakdoeken mee ;) wow meer dan 5(!!!) THANKS! xxx
Ahahahah xD ja sorry Antwerps dialect hoor :D Ja ik heb de video toch "bekeken" *zo beter?* En na de krokusvakantie ga ik hem zeker zien in de cinema :D Kzal het wel laten weten xD
I haven't finished watching the entire vid, cause I haven't seen the film yet and scared or spoilers*am reading the book as we speak* but the vid seems so lovely (watched the first half :D and have to contain myself)
Maar euh, het liedje heet 'Bleeding Love' zonder de 'in'. ik dacht ik zeg het maar even, dan kunnen ze je video sneller vinden ;D
Hehehe Thanks Gitta, good to see that you are still alive :p Thanks a lot for your lovely comment, I think that I should read the book myself once ;-) Ow yes, you are right about the song!! Thanks! Glad to see you did not watched it all :)
@AboutPixieDust That is cleverly said! I think that you are right. The lyrics have some ambiguity and i am glad that my thoughts about the lyrics showed in this video. That is a lovely compliment to get! Thank you! :D
Lotjeknorrepotje 11 months ago
so cute **
MaRiaPereiRaAPPLE 1 year ago
@MaRiaPereiRaAPPLE Sorry for the delay but: THANKS! :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 11 months ago
What do I think? Pure beauty :) Excellent vid.
AgaJoanna 1 year ago
@AgaJoanna Goodness, sorry for not replying sooner :( You must have forgotten about this video! Thank you! I a very glad that you liked it so much! And I just love to hear the words pure beauty! Have a good day :).
Lotjeknorrepotje 11 months ago
Keep coming back to watch....great job. Love this song to this vid!
grrrr briony!
rleigh87 2 years ago
Very nice to hear that you like watching this video! Even several times, I feel honored :D. This song is very good, but I am not very fond of the mix. It has lost some of it's charm for me. Of course that makes it even better to read such a nice comment as yours :). So, thanks! I know, in some scenes you just feel like attacking Briony and kicking her ass :p. But in the end I felt really sorry for her too. She never wanted all that too happen of course. She is just human I guess...
Lotjeknorrepotje 2 years ago
i happen to think this movie and song go great together...
maybe that's just me... maybe that's because the first time i ever heard this song it was in an atonement fanvid on youtube lol
txaggie321's version is AMAZING btw...
"but they talk so loud... BRIONY!!!!!" <-that cracked me up ;)
softcelltainted22 2 years ago
Haha! Yes, I guess you can be biased because you heard this song for the first time in a YT video XD. LOL! I know, that version is lovely :) I prefer it over my version to be honest. I am so glad you mentioned that part! I liked it too! It is slightly weird but I had fun editing it XD
Lotjeknorrepotje 2 years ago
Great clips.
But seriously, "Bleeding Love", seriously?
That music and this movie just don't go well.
chanandler20 2 years ago 3
Yeah, I have to admit that you are right (A). I regret the combination now *blushes*. But do Teardrop/Massive Attack and Atonement go well in your opinion? Thanks for your honesty! :) I'll give you a thumbs up! ;-). Lotte
Lotjeknorrepotje 2 years ago
Great job! I laughed when the scene where Robbie's typing the letter is cut so it looks like it says "In my dreams, I kiss you" instead of you-know-what. Nice touch!
DazedConfused23 3 years ago 3
one of the best videos i have ever seen!!
ChristianaDets 3 years ago 5
Gosh! Thank you!!! I don't see what is so good about it, but I feel honored! I like my other Atonement video much more XD but I must admit that it's lovely to get such a comment ^-^. Have a good day.
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i CANT FIND 2 MANY W/R&B MUCiS THAT i LiKE
. . . D0 YOU THiNK U CAN MAKE ONE WiT MUSiC 4rm WEBBiE- i MiSS YOU???????? PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!
Carmel0529 3 years ago
I don't mind making you a vid (in fact, I'd be honored XD) but that song is really hard! Do you prob have another R&B song in mind that isn't used for Atonement yet? It will take me lots of time before it is finished though, cause I am incredibly busy, but if you want me to give it a try, let me know! :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
I dont know I guess its cuz its one of those slightly sappy love songs on the radio but it suited the video so well I just had to like it. *damn catchy songs*
joelmaddenzwife 3 years ago
Yes, you are right, itis a sappy love song ;-) I didn't want to use this song at first, because I already heard it too often. But then I searched for the lyrics and I found out that this match hasn't been made yet and I felt it as my duty to make it XD, hehe! Anyway! Glad to hear that it won you over! Damn catchy songs indeed, I just keep singing this song after I heard it somewhere -_- Have a good day :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
I loved it, awesome movie, loved the editing and the long...as much as I try to hate it has won me over. Nice job :)
joelmaddenzwife 3 years ago
Thanks! That is great to hear :) But why did you try to hate it? Don't you like the song :p? Glad to hear that you like it after all though!
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
Love the song and I thought the occassional audio was interesting even if it was accidental. Thanks for making it.
neznezneznez 3 years ago
Only the letterposting scene was accidental. I am glad that you love the song. No prob for making it, thanks for your comment!
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
Actually i kinda like that you can sometimes fainlty hear the dialogue. gives it a nice touch.
Frodoholic9 3 years ago 3
Well, only the sound when Cecilia is walking to post her letter is accidentally, the rest is on purpose actually ;-) Thanks for your comment!
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
LOVE IT!! 10*** all the way!!
KnightsOfArmour 3 years ago 4
:O Thank you!! :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
Thanks,.. it is very good.
K4Norge 3 years ago
Thanks for your comment, I am glad that you think so.
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
you did a fantastic job on the video!
daisy45 3 years ago
Thanks! I am really glad that you think so :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
Good Job. It Makes me teary eyed everytime!
LoveKeira94 3 years ago
Thanks! That is a great compliment to get, it means very much to me :). Have a good day.
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
I meant the end you have edited.
laTMT 3 years ago
I see. Thanks then!
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
You are not satisfied about the end? The end is so touching. I always cry when I see it. Perfect.
laTMT 3 years ago
Nah.. I am not so keen on the way I've edited the end in this video :S Or did you think that I spoke about the end of the film? Thanks for your comment!
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
wonderful
laTMT 3 years ago
Great to hear! I prefer my other Atonement video, I am really glad that you like this one :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
great video and nice editing! keep up the good work!
WeezyBaby117 3 years ago
Thanks! I am glad that you think so :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
I loved it and i bawled through the whole thing.... i love james mcavoy!
PadfootUnited 3 years ago
What is bawlen? I can't find a proper translation ;-) Anyway, thanks a lot for your comment, I loved the movie too, it is so sad but so beautiful *sigh*. Bye!
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
Great vdieo but where do you gt your atonment clips from???!!! =D
ginny2020 3 years ago
This is a very good video! I don't know why I haven't seen this one before. Keep up the great work and thanks for viewing my version also! Your video is definitely wonderful and unique! :-D Can't wait to see more Atonement vids from you!
txaggie321 3 years ago
Thanks a lot for your nice comment. I am really glad that you like it (I think that we both edited the video very different, which is a plus ;-)) I have uploaded another Atonement video I like that one more then I like this one, if you are curious you can check it out :) Take care!
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
OMG ! Did I comment on this one before !? If I havent`t then I`m really late ! I wasn`t so sure about this song before but it has totally grown on me and its my current favourite ! Lotte ,you`ve done an amazing job putting together this beauty ! Love how you did the scene of Cecilia going under water ! Brilliant ! I`m adding this one to my faves ! 5 stars !!!!! :D
veryval 3 years ago 2
Really?? I really don't think that this is worth favouriting (I like my new Atonement video much more :S) but okay, that is up to yourself! Thanks a lot for the sweet words. I am really glad that you like it this much :) Btw, got to check now if you posted a comment before! LOL x
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
LOL yeah, you did, but you didn't favourite it! ;-)
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
Love love love love love love love...this! After seeing Val's video to Pirates of the Caribbean w/ this song I had to come back to yours and watch it again! 5stars
bluesalad 3 years ago
Hmm... I like my new Atonement video better, but I am glad that you like it that much! Thanks for the 5* too :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
excellent vid....
I love atonement!!!! It was so beautiful!
BloomingSparrow 3 years ago 2
Yes, I loved the movie too, it is beautiful indeed, but so sad as well *snif* I like my other Atonement video much more actually, but I am glad that you like this one! ;-) Thanks for your comment.
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
good video! great clips, this movie is so beautiful! and i love this song!
mmgadh 3 years ago
Thanks a lot Marta. The movie is beautiful indeed.
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
I love this Lottie! I can see why this video managed to get honors... faves*
wantingyounear 3 years ago
Thanks :) YAY! Even faves, very cool
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
You're welcome! :D
wantingyounear 3 years ago
the movie is one of my favourites (i think that is one of the best movies ever),is brilliant,emotional,passionate and so sad (i cried a lot)...great performances and beautifully directed!
i loved your video, i think that you did a great job (it is allways a treat for me to watch scenes of atonement..i just can't wait for the dvd)!
take care*
joanamafalda87 4 years ago
Yeah, I loved this movie too! You expressed the beautyness really well :p It is good to hear that you like the vid, because the last comment I got on this video made me feel a bit down. At least someone likes it XD LOL take care too!
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i wonder how some people can be so... cruel to the art of others - this video with such a stupid music is really horrible. :-/
auerbach821 4 years ago
Hm.. Thanks for your honesty. It isn't a great comment to get, but it is good to hear that you are being honest! I understand that you dislike the song, but is their anything from the editing you like? Or don't you like that all too? I am just curious ;) I tried to match both things as good as possible, but in your opinion I failed, I got that already.
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Can you tell me why on earth you bother to watch and comment this video then?!? Just asking.. why dont you go and watch some vids YOU like and stop bothering people with negative comments, please!! it is you who are cruel to the art of others! Shame on you!!! And if you can't say anything positive than please just keep it to yourself... I think that would make everyone satisfied!
frklinee 4 years ago 4
I love those opinions like yours:-) 1) I stopped watching after several second, becouse matching this music to this film is really unsensitive. 2) Im really not responsible for that you dont hear it. 3) To be critical is not notihng i have to be shamed, it my opinion and to say it is my right, right? Moreover, this music (unproblematic like opinions you would like to read here) shows how simply is this movie understanded.
auerbach821 4 years ago
It's not like you are not allowed to write your opinion, but try to understand that it might hurt people! You saw the title, you knew what song it was.. why did you bother to see it?
I dont get it, sorry :P We all have different taste, accept it!! Personally I'm not a big fan of this music myself, but come on!the lyrics fits the editing & film! Look, I dont want to start a fight or anything;) but you should think about what you are writing.. People put their heart and soul into their videos..
frklinee 4 years ago
I am not a fan of this song either to be quite honest, but I did think that the lyrics suited at least MY storytelling. I really like the fact that you are defending me, but you don't have too of course, everyone may give her/his own honest opinion! I am really curious after the comment that will follow actually XD.
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Well of course I'm defending you love!
that comment was a silly thing to write!
The song DOES fit.. everyone else think so, and this person didn't even see your vid!;P
frklinee 4 years ago
*hug*
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Im really think about what I write. Author of this video is not alone, I mean there are tons(?) of these amatuers expreminets on youtube, thats it, but if I were her/him (sorry to talk about you in 3rd case) I wouldnt presented it here. I had no expectations when I opened this video, I was just looking around, if there wasnt the real beginning of the Atonement (try to search it in youtube, you will get this vid).
auerbach821 4 years ago
Im critical, because this vid is out (and the author wants some comment, I geuss), I was really disgusted in the moment of surprise and moreover to be noncritical to these creations is not useful for the author him/herself either. (And Im critical, because I work as a critic/review writer... however its more joke than some acceptable reason.)
auerbach821 4 years ago
Just curious.. have you already watched the whole video? Or can't you just force yourself because you disgust the song (and probably my "amateur editing") too much? LOL, you must get sick of me and frklinee, don't you?
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
yes, but... i havent solved it anymore... its just one vid... i just have tried to explain my statement - i think that it is normal to say no without shame:-) it has nothing to do with sometihng that i want hurt somebody or make somebodys bad day. this was my very first reaction on that video. i just wonder sometimes, thats all.-)
auerbach821 3 years ago
Ok ok we get what you mean! :P
just try to understand that other people might feel offended and hurt!
As you say, we are not professionals.. So maybe you should take it easy before you use your "professional reviewing" words?? it's ok that you say what you think! But there are better ways to put it! That's why we react, the way you wrote it! It's mean.. I guess we just have to agree to disagree in this matter ;) Have a great week :P
frklinee 3 years ago
I like the way you deffend your amigo or love you have sympathy for. Try to imagine my shock - reaction really fits to it, it was really immediate, moreover i could use stronger words to be really rough... Its nice you take care of, but this is an open space. I have no sentimant for pink flowers, I think its really cheap... Thats it. But itsnot the reason to say, im not a sensitive type. Contrary is the case. I my point of view some people should be unsensitive if they match things I spoke about
auerbach821 3 years ago
Pink flowers? What makes you think of that?? It is allright! I think we both understand what you mean, and of course you can say/think what you want, I get the point about the unsensical matching now ;-) I am not an unsensitive person either. Perhaps in your opinion in this case, but IRL sometimes the contrary (although I can be hard and mean too, probably like you! LOL) And yeah, your statement is clear, and no it hasn't ruined my day, though I felt insulted.. Anyway, have a great life! ;-)
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
I dont think we will get an end to this, you obviously dont get what we try to tell you!
And of course I defend my friend!!
even if maybe you wouldn't have felt offended if you got this comment, others may! And it has nothing to do with pink flowers or how she is as a person!! And I know for a fact she's not like you think :P As she said, have a great life ;)
frklinee 3 years ago
I got it, but im not sure, if you get it... Sorry, im used to discuss... have a nice time.
auerbach821 3 years ago
No I get it, really :P I just dont agree ;)
And I'm used to discuss myself, so dont worry!
frklinee 3 years ago
That is okay (talking about me in the 3rd person I mean). I don't need comments, I just like editing videos and if other people like it (at least 40 people do, else it wouldn't have been favourited so often) it is only a stimulation to go on with making videos. I appreciate your honesty, if however you are a professional critic writer, you got to keep in mind that I am only an amateur, like you've said already! Nevertheless, I actually think this whole discussion is starting to become funny :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 3 years ago
I somehow felt forced to respond again (A) Yeah, I am a tuff one :p I agree, probably this song may not suit the film, but well, I am a simple person! (Perhaps even a young silly girl in your opinion, yeah, only 18..) Nevertheless this movie impressed me and I wanted to edit something. But, if however you stopped watching after several seconds, you don't have a good image how the video is, right? Perhaps you could have gone in too it more open-minded? Just my opinion (that I may say too :p)
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Wow, that was really good! I love the song choice!
gracemlinde 4 years ago
Hi! :) Thanks a lot for the compliment. I start to dislike the song, but I am very glad that you think it worked. I am glad you like it!
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
alweer een mooie video van je x3
JustXlikeXme 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Gelukkig! Dank je wel (wink) xxx
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Well done! I loved the movie alltough it was sad at the end. The song is beautiful. Leona Lewis has such a wonderful voice. Your video was amazing.
12scarlett 4 years ago
Yes, I loved the movie too (and yes, the end was way too sad for me LOL). It is great to hear that you rated my video as amazing! Thanks a lot :)!
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
well i just made a atonment contest i really think u should enter this vid its awsome!
knightley00 4 years ago
You really think so?? I have seen better Atonement videos :S I am too scared to enter my video I suppose, but thanks for the compliment! I shall think of it :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
ok!
knightley00 4 years ago
Really good video! love the song...
Atonement is the greatest movie for me...
JOKC79 4 years ago
Yes, it is great movie indeed! Thanks for your nice comment :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
gr8 video!
knightley00 4 years ago
Thanks! I saw that you favourited too, that is great :) Have a good day!
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Your welcome,and i hope u have gr8 day too!
knightley00 4 years ago
Wow Lotte! I can't believe I hadn't seen your vid before (maar da's volledig mijn schuld, ben de laatste tijd niet zoveel op YT geweest) and it's absolutely great! I must admit that Leona Lewis doesn't make my kind of favourite music, but I could stand it in this video as it accompanied the clips of a wonderful movie ;D Great job, 5* and in my faves! xx Yasmien
Absynthie 4 years ago
That is no problem at all Yasmien :) Thanks for your great comment, it is a wonderful compliment if you like the video when you dislike (or just not like :p) the music, thanks a lot for the highest rating and the fave. I think her song suited the film and I suppose some people agree with me! ^-^ The movie was wonderful IMO too. Have a great day and take care! xxx
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
wow this is the only atonement vid that has actually moved me to tears well done brilliant video god i hate briony so much coniving little cow i dont forgive her she can atone all she wants but i still want her to die a terrible death lol
sheffieldminx 4 years ago 4
That is a great compliment, I feel honored. Thanks a lot for your nice comment :) You are a cruel person I see! I am glad that she didn't die a terrible death, I couldn't have 3 dead leading characters in one movie LOL. Take care!
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Great work, Lotte. I can't wait to see the film.
JaneJunkie 4 years ago
I love the film, but not everyone is so fond of it. I am very curious after your opinion, please let me know what you think after you've watched it :) Thanks for your compliment on the vid ^-^
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
I really really really love this video! :D
Atonement is a great movie. Loved it<3
And you made a very beautiful video of it :D I like the song. :)
FallenAngel136 4 years ago
Thanks! Just great to read such a lovely comment, Atonement is great IMO too, I am glad you think that the video is beautiful. I am going to dislike this song, because I probably heard it too often LOL. Thanks for your nice comment ^-^
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Wow Lotte! yes, I saw it, finally. Just now actually XD I had to see this vid right away cause I have been dying to see it for so long! I love it!! Its much better than the film itself IMO XD The song is perfect ^^ I'm so going to see this video every once in a while! Actually made me teary. Thanks for making this! :) 10 stars and faves!! 2:55 is amazing btw!
frklinee 4 years ago
This video??? Well, it is not so special that you should be deing to see it! LOL I really don't see why you like it more then the film :O, we'll discuss about that later :p Thanks a lot for being so sweet! 10* and faves AND teary eyes, wow that is incredible, thanks sweetheart ^-^
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Well it was so special! ^^ For me at least :)
But as you said, we'll discuss that later ;)
frklinee 4 years ago
Aww thanks! *hug* unfortunately you are not on msn now, but you are not to blame because it is late already LOL Have a great Valentine's day! If you don't get enough attention tomorrow, just remember that I love you :p hehe
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Great video Lotte ^^ I love this song although now I think I have just heard it too many times XDDD Your editing was GREAT and I love how you put the ending here... btw I saw Atonement and I liked it but not as much as you I think ;)
Melodia222 4 years ago 3
Not? Ow :p LOL that surpises me indeed! I shall hear rom you soon why you didn't like it that much as I think (A) This song is definetely to much on these dayd indeed ;)
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Well, after two weeks here I am : PP Yesterday I finally saw this movie. So - I like this vid very much, some fades are really great and they capture the emotions. I like also your end with the machine. But Lottie, sorry to say that - I hate this song. It's so popular in Poland now that each morning I turn on the radio I can hear it about 100 times... It's so annoying. Hope you get my point. Please, make another Atonement vid with another song and I'll be in Heaven :-) 5/5 anyway LOL
koniczynkaL 4 years ago 3
Whaha you are adorable! I absolutely get your point about the song. When I started this video the song wasn't very popular yand I really enjoyed it very much, but lately they are sending it way too often :)So, that means I agree! LOL it is good to hear that you like it apart from the song though :p
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
What a relief!!! ROFL btw, it's about 7 a.m in Poland now and in radio I hear Bleeding Love again... *sobbing with despair* LOL
koniczynkaL 4 years ago
Hehe I am listening about 1.5 hours radio now and it hasn't been on yet! :O I am very suprised :p LOL
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Thanks a lot BaByPoWer2030. Danielle it is I see :p Great that you even favourited it ^-^ Have a good day!
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
That's ok don't mind watching it because then I have a good idea if I will like it or not.
ninamc81 4 years ago
Yes, you are right about that! Let me know what you thought of it when you saw it, okay?
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
I will, going to wait until it goes down in price before I buy it like to get a bargain.
ninamc81 4 years ago
I have to be patient I see :p
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Can't wait to see this looks fantastic love the song and video it's just wonderful.
5 stars & saved to faves.
Nina x
ninamc81 4 years ago 2
It is a wonderful film, I am sure that you'll love it! But perhaps you shouldn't have watched the video before you watched the film :p Thanks for your great compliment Nina! ^-^ xxx
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Haha, oké, ik snapte je ook wel hoor! A Beautiful Mind is idd erg mooi en daar is mijn hoogst gewaardeerde video van (tja, dat heeft toch iets speciaals (A)) Ik zie je morgen wel weer! ^-^
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
hehe, dank je! Das een mooi compliment ^-^ Al is dit niet echt een kostuumdrama :p LOL Dank je! Ik hoop dat er nog veel videos zullen volgen ;)
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Oh huns, this is my favorite song paired up with my favorite movie!! How can I not love this!! I loved the sound of the typewriter overlapped w/ the song, as well as the truth being revealed in the end. I want to see the movie again (and I saw this twice in the theater already LOL)! I almost kissed the computer screen when beautiful James popped up HAHAHAHA! To my favorites : D
ehrynL85 4 years ago 5
*phew* I am very glad that you like it! :) You should probably get the film on dvd asap. I have seen it once now, I loved it, but I'll just wait till it is released on dvd(and not so expensive anymore :p) And yes, James isn't bad looking at all! LOL WOW, great!! You even favourited it *wink* I feel honored! Take care
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
This is one of my fav films, I've just watched it last week but it feels like an eternity. Well, I remember the whole story but I would like to watch it again.
Anyway, I love this vid! You have chosen great clips and a lovely song! :D
Sarah (from FireFoxisback)
caribbeanblack 4 years ago 4
Hi Sarah! Did you got suspended?? :O that would be cruel!! You should watch it again I suppose :p Thanks for your great compliment, I am glad you think I choose the right song and clips, take care Sarah :*
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
ohh no! I didn't got suspended but I'll be soon closing firefox or just ignore it (I have too many accounts :S).
You really did an awesome work on the vid, be proud! ;)
caribbeanblack 4 years ago
Glad to hear you did not got suspended on your formal account :) I shall try to remember that it is you with the caribbeanblack account, not sure if I will remember it though (A). Thanks, I shall try to be proud of it ;-)
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
whow ~! gave video!! :D
MissEnnya 4 years ago
Hej Ennya! Dank je :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
That made me more emotional than the movie did. (maybe the fact that I just finished the book plays into that too lol) but Great job!
slonroberta 4 years ago 4
Hehe LOL that is a great compliment, but I think it has to do with finishing reading the book too :p Thanks for your comment, I am glad to hear you think it is great ^-^!
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
It's sweet. I like it! :)
ladnyhaft 4 years ago
Great to hear, thanks!
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Great job on your first vid for Atonement Lotte ! The beginning was superb ! Love your pace and choice of scenes !!!! 5 stars !!! :)
veryval 4 years ago
Thanks Val, a lovely comment to get, and thanks for the 5* too :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Amazing matchup! Loved the song and the movie you used. It was nice to watch a vid to Atonement with a nicer upbeat song than the usual sad ones. A nice change also. Sorry you won't be around on youtube that much! I'll miss you! :) Loved the vid gurl! 5 stars and saved to favs
bluesalad 4 years ago
aww thanks! :) I am glad you think the song worked well ^-^ great you even favourited it :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
oh kheb het toch uitgekeken(khad toch al stukjes gezien op yt en kon mezelf niet houden) *pinkt traantjes weg* Kzit hier dus half te wenen, dus groot compliment voor u video!!! Echt zo mooi, maar zo triestig. Ik ga zakdoeken meenenmen naar de cinema xD 5sterren, en als het kon zou ik er meer geven!!!!
Xje
XLovingLOSTX 4 years ago
afgekeken?? JIJ!! GRRRR ik ben furieus! :p Had je niet moeten doen, maar ik vind het wel super dat je t triestig vindt, wat hebben jullie toch een grappig taaltje *gnif* Neem idd maar zakdoeken mee ;) wow meer dan 5(!!!) THANKS! xxx
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
Ahahahah xD ja sorry Antwerps dialect hoor :D Ja ik heb de video toch "bekeken" *zo beter?* En na de krokusvakantie ga ik hem zeker zien in de cinema :D Kzal het wel laten weten xD
XLovingLOSTX 4 years ago
Ach nee... niet beter, ik vind t gewoon grappig, maar ik vind niet dat je m al had moeten kijken! Grrr :p Maar goed, toch bedankt LOL
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago
EERSTE!!! *Yay!* xD
I haven't finished watching the entire vid, cause I haven't seen the film yet and scared or spoilers*am reading the book as we speak* but the vid seems so lovely (watched the first half :D and have to contain myself)
Maar euh, het liedje heet 'Bleeding Love' zonder de 'in'. ik dacht ik zeg het maar even, dan kunnen ze je video sneller vinden ;D
XXXXXX Gitta *ja, ik leef nog xD*
XLovingLOSTX 4 years ago
Hehehe Thanks Gitta, good to see that you are still alive :p Thanks a lot for your lovely comment, I think that I should read the book myself once ;-) Ow yes, you are right about the song!! Thanks! Glad to see you did not watched it all :)
Lotjeknorrepotje 4 years ago