People can say watever of comunism... thats it bad or watever. In fact i accept marxist ideas but i know it wouldnt benefit me by my social status. Still the art of footage and cinematography of Eisenstein its the best i ever seen in my whole life.Even if this can be considered communist propaganda its epic. Eisenstein shows us a revolution during the mute era with use of epic russian choir music and structured use of extras and shots. Communist or not Eisenstein its a pure genious.
@rudy4pl Well, in that time movies needed to be more prestigious and overwhelming. so, instead of doing the scene with a few hundred people, like in the actual event, they used few thousand people. Also they asked the people to bring their own weapons. needles to say it resulted in total chaos. Most of the amateur weapons were loaded etc...
long live the soviet union? your joking me right? does 7 million people killed through industrialisation and collectivisation mean nothing to you? hierarchy is needed otherwise no one has incentive to work. The Soviet Union was unproductive and morally backward, who wants that? socialism is a waste of time.
inspiring film. the weird thing is that more people died making the film then they did in the actual revolt because they accidently loaded the rifles with real bullets.
It's true, because of the great number of actors, there's wasn't really a role for everyone so they just kept shooting in all directions. And it's also true that they used real guns and bullets so more people got killed in this movie then at the real revolution. btw: can someone tell me wether it really was Lenin who led the people in St-Petersburg? Because at that time I think he was hiding in Finland.
I can't believe I used to hate communism. But now, i see the light. All oppressed people of the world must unite to strike down capitalism and fascism! Rise up as one!
6 people died in the October revolution and mainly from friendly fire. The only interesting event is ommitted by Eisenstein, Kerensky leader of the PG fleeing Petrograd disguised as a female nurse and no thats not a pathetic attempt at humour it really did happen.
@Mikrodasende long live the soviet union? your joking me right? does 7 million people killed through industrialisation and collectivisation mean nothing to you? hierarchy is needed otherwise no one has incentive to work. The Soviet Union was unproductive and morally backward, who wants that? socialism is a waste of time.
o my gosh, the famous fragment where more people got killed in the movie then in the real oktoberrevolution, in the time when people took over the palace, shame on eisenstein but still the most excentric artist in sovjet and user of russish editing!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
PG- Pure Garbage. An "autocracy" replaced with one of the most vile regimes ever. The Okhrana and Siberia were paradise compared with the NKVD and the gulag. Russia deserved better but didn't get it.
Things are starting to happen little by little. Check out Latin America, right now they are experiencing something similar to this with indigenous and working class peoples uniting to elect revolutionary governments.
look at southern Europe. Greece and Spain are suffering very badly under their right wing regimes and t he economic crisis, and masses of the people are rioting against it. I even read that they burned down a neo-nazi headquarters in Athens. Very admirable of them.
This clip is 2 minutes and 20 seconds and during that time it seems as if there were 200 shots. Soviet montage films can leave you dizzy with the barage of images. The Germans, on the other hand, with camera movement is more to my liking.
Comment removed
AG111999 8 months ago
Révolution trahie mais espoir identique a celui des révoltes d'aujourd'hui en Afrique du nord
fiadoneable 11 months ago
It's amazing!
Camy158 11 months ago
People can say watever of comunism... thats it bad or watever. In fact i accept marxist ideas but i know it wouldnt benefit me by my social status. Still the art of footage and cinematography of Eisenstein its the best i ever seen in my whole life.Even if this can be considered communist propaganda its epic. Eisenstein shows us a revolution during the mute era with use of epic russian choir music and structured use of extras and shots. Communist or not Eisenstein its a pure genious.
gol67 1 year ago 4
Anyone know the song title?
coolpersonz 1 year ago
sorry to sound dumb, but can someone tell me how this is a metric montage example, what repeated value is he using for the cut?
MrRivaz 1 year ago
amazing
sira44 1 year ago
Que viva LENIN
titopereirajacome 1 year ago 2
@titopereirajacome Viva!
AndrewMann552 1 year ago
Did you know more people died in the making of this movie then in the attack on the palace in the revolution itself? That's fucked up
FREAKSmoviereviews 1 year ago
@FREAKSmoviereviews
How did more people die in the making of this movie?
rudy4pl 1 year ago
@rudy4pl Well, in that time movies needed to be more prestigious and overwhelming. so, instead of doing the scene with a few hundred people, like in the actual event, they used few thousand people. Also they asked the people to bring their own weapons. needles to say it resulted in total chaos. Most of the amateur weapons were loaded etc...
FREAKSmoviereviews 1 year ago
long live the soviet union? your joking me right? does 7 million people killed through industrialisation and collectivisation mean nothing to you? hierarchy is needed otherwise no one has incentive to work. The Soviet Union was unproductive and morally backward, who wants that? socialism is a waste of time.
JamieMillwall 1 year ago
@JamieMillwall You would make a great slave owner...if the practice was still around.
EyFmS 1 year ago
@JamieMillwall reading you is a real waste of time
cplasgaunas1 1 year ago
I mention Eisenstein and Potemkin in The Celebrity Song.
superdavid002 1 year ago
Let's Go bt the Red Army Choir
grannyszip 1 year ago
does somebody knows the name of the song ???
darkhorse2506 1 year ago
Aqui esta ;)...
Russian Red Army Choir - "Let's Go" (В путь!)
watch?v=_jqOGpzNrg4&feature=related
EyFmS 1 year ago
I mean I really like it alot..alot..I wish I knew what they are saying..It's a waltz..I think is the most russian song I ever heard
ingerrash1 2 years ago
Radnaea..I don't know what they are saying, but I like the song alot..It's ..heroic..proud..heavy ..and ..sweet..all in the same time ..
ingerrash1 2 years ago
I like the chorus singing. What is the name of this song?
vaallkk3 2 years ago
Comment removed
vaallkk3 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Lenin was a cocksucker
BlueTruckGuy 2 years ago
no more stale meat!
psynema 2 years ago
History will repeat itself...One day instead of the Winter Palace....the people will be rushing the stairs of Capitol Hill in Washington D.C.
EyFmS 2 years ago 19
hope they put it on YouTube lmao
BlueTruckGuy 2 years ago
eisentein used discontinuity editing, that's why its feel weird..
agoregore 2 years ago
punish individual thinking and crush the human spirit. long live solzhenitsyn and heap dung on the bolshevik thugs
dybbuk4640 2 years ago
Long live the revolution!
Long live the theories of Marx,Engels,Lenin and Stalin!
remusretux 2 years ago 3
Long live international revolution!
AndrewMann552 2 years ago
bu filmi ben çektim
NeverLanD0o0 2 years ago
Ein hoch auf Mütterchen Russland xD
PureParanoya 2 years ago
Truly epic.
Svartalfgeist 2 years ago 2
Long live revolution everywhere!
AndrewMann552 2 years ago 10
inspiring film. the weird thing is that more people died making the film then they did in the actual revolt because they accidently loaded the rifles with real bullets.
midgiemarsh 2 years ago
lol i find this very hard to believe
DiVeronica 2 years ago 2
It's true, because of the great number of actors, there's wasn't really a role for everyone so they just kept shooting in all directions. And it's also true that they used real guns and bullets so more people got killed in this movie then at the real revolution. btw: can someone tell me wether it really was Lenin who led the people in St-Petersburg? Because at that time I think he was hiding in Finland.
Buekers 2 years ago
Capitalism isn't doing so well just now. Still, some ethnic or religious minority will take the rap, most probably the Muslims.
SteveKaczynski 2 years ago 2
I can't believe I used to hate communism. But now, i see the light. All oppressed people of the world must unite to strike down capitalism and fascism! Rise up as one!
ramberghini 2 years ago 3
wow, a fast change of point of view hehe
cplasgaunas1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
oh noes watch out for youtube communists!
ihaveaclevername 2 years ago
hahaha exactly my thoughts, but in a hellokitty format
DiVeronica 2 years ago
So Eisenstein pioneered the technique of really quick changes in images like in short attention span MTV music videos and most commercials nowadays?
wilshiregazette 2 years ago
6 people died in the October revolution and mainly from friendly fire. The only interesting event is ommitted by Eisenstein, Kerensky leader of the PG fleeing Petrograd disguised as a female nurse and no thats not a pathetic attempt at humour it really did happen.
ajhrules 3 years ago
Who is the composer of this music?
Good film.
mndaiuto 3 years ago 4
What a good video! Long live the Soviet Union! Long live the socialism! Down with the fucking capitalism!
Mikrodasende 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
@Mikrodasende long live the soviet union? your joking me right? does 7 million people killed through industrialisation and collectivisation mean nothing to you? hierarchy is needed otherwise no one has incentive to work. The Soviet Union was unproductive and morally backward, who wants that? socialism is a waste of time.
JamieMillwall 1 year ago
studying Sergei Eisenstein in A Level
Film Sudies
LittleMissEncore 3 years ago
o my gosh, the famous fragment where more people got killed in the movie then in the real oktoberrevolution, in the time when people took over the palace, shame on eisenstein but still the most excentric artist in sovjet and user of russish editing!!
hihikate 3 years ago
Long Live The Workers Of All Nations!
The working class will conquer the capitalist pigs in the U.S. one day!
Fellini115 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
PG- Pure Garbage. An "autocracy" replaced with one of the most vile regimes ever. The Okhrana and Siberia were paradise compared with the NKVD and the gulag. Russia deserved better but didn't get it.
genrail1 3 years ago
God I wish I lived prior to 1950. I was born in 91 and all I've heard is modern shit with U.S. dominance.
In those days there seemed to be a major, large scale historical event occurring every day.
Trenmanner 4 years ago 2
righto.
and you lived in constant fear that you were going to have the living hell bombed out of you at any moment.
SwaeShampine 3 years ago 4
Yeah, there is a reason for the old Chinese curse- "May you live in interesting times".
BalboaParkJPN 3 years ago
Don't get discouraged. These times may prove interesting yet.
sweetpotos 3 years ago 3
Things are starting to happen little by little. Check out Latin America, right now they are experiencing something similar to this with indigenous and working class peoples uniting to elect revolutionary governments.
Fellini115 3 years ago
look at southern Europe. Greece and Spain are suffering very badly under their right wing regimes and t he economic crisis, and masses of the people are rioting against it. I even read that they burned down a neo-nazi headquarters in Athens. Very admirable of them.
ramberghini 2 years ago
The music is a Second World War Soviet military sog, though I don't know the title.
SteveKaczynski 4 years ago
The song is called "Soldaty V Pohod" usually translated as "Let's go" or "Off we go". you can find it on youtube by searching for "Soldaty V Pohod"
DeHeld8 4 years ago
Red Army Choir - Let's Go (From Maxime Perepelitsa)
InfinityEye 4 years ago
Oh Very nice!
lahabana2006 4 years ago
Hmm Dutch subtitles... interesting...
DeHeld8 4 years ago
This clip is 2 minutes and 20 seconds and during that time it seems as if there were 200 shots. Soviet montage films can leave you dizzy with the barage of images. The Germans, on the other hand, with camera movement is more to my liking.
floyjoy 4 years ago
Wonderful! I saw these images during a reportage on high school in Holland and I thought they were real!!!
datoparis 4 years ago 3
a masterpiece in the movie's history!
nixonvigano 4 years ago
The music is not original, has even nothing to do with this.
berlinSS 4 years ago