Genesis with Phil Collins was more a "pop/rock" group to me and that's not an insult in my mouth. Queen also evolved into pop territory during the 80s and used the keyboards as well. Did not prevent both bands from making masterpieces like "Invisible Touch" or "A Kind Of Magic"
Can't we all agree they are both good, disturbed's version does do this justice. Can't we be glad that we have bands out there that make music with meaning unlike the rest of the manufactured shit out their?
An amazing song by one of the greatest bands of all time!!! We are really inspired by these guys, and would love your opinion on our material, any feedback would be greatly appreciated, keep on rocking man!!
@DisasterPiece73 I don't know if you have it but the DVD is missing the "Cage" medley (was meant to take place after "The Brazilian" and before "Land Of Confusion") :)
That was a concert in wembley in july 1987. Queen was there exactly one year before in they're best concert. The eigthies was a very nice time!! here in mexico city genesis was in the charts in 1987. i was 11. thanks
genesis version is always better, mainly cuz they wrote it, there the ones who brought the issues up in the 1st. place plus the video makes the song more political because it critizes the president at the time (Ronald Reagan) and it also makes fun of all the pop stars at the time (example a knocked up madonna)
madre mia, oh my God, super expectacle,super show...y yo creia que los mejores eran Pink floyd,espero que toquen en españa...alguna vez, la ultima me los perdi.
what the words mean for the 2 versions ( genesis and disturbed) are totaly different. disturbed's version has something to do with the chaos of the world and stuff. as for genesis i have no freaking idea what the words mean.
You said "I like Disturbed version better, but this band takes all the credit for the song". And I commented as to why. Read what YOU said before telling someone else to read it right. Genesis takes credit for it because THEY wrote it. They had a hit with it. And did so when members of Disturbed were in middle school. I like both versions but your original comment was foolish.
Hey if your giving Genesis props for it, great. But read your phrasing. Your phrasing makes it sound like your bitching about Genesis taking that credit, as opposed to giving them "props".Thus my initial correction. You wanna give props, give props. Choose your words alittle better so that people know thats what your doing.
I mean your seriously dense. Genesis wrote it back when your heros Disturbed were barely hitting puberty. So your damned right they take full credit for this song. It's THEIR song.
Oh and as far as correcting you. Notice the original comment you made has gotten 6 negative responses, 5 of which before I found it. So obviously either your clueless as to what you say, or your a dense moron. You were corrected, because you said something foolish and inaccurate. You wanna be pissed and childish about it little boy, then feel free. But your comment was idiotic and I have no issue telling you so.
I like Disturbed version better, but this band takes all credit for the song.
I interpreted that to mean that Genesis takes credit even though they shouldn't. I obviously misunderstoond but in fairness I'm not the only one and you weren't very clear.
Genesis is without a doubt one of the best rock groups ever, certainly the best progrock group. It's songs like LoC that cemented that reputation! Of course, it's a great song, so unless you totally screw up , most covers are good ;)
it's a great song in any cover i've heard except for a swedish band called Alcazar who've stolen the chorus but nothing else (dont ask me why, they're just stupid if u ask me). The 3 most famous versions of the song would be this (obviously), disturbed and in flames. all 3 versions are great and worth listen to. its no wonder why there's been so many covers of it
I wouldn't say that either is better. Depends on what you like more. Genesis is electronica, and Disturbed is heavy metal. The song itself, in any rendition, is awesome: a song ACTUALLY about Revolution, out of the confusion.
Is the fact that this occurred while most of Disturbed was in Grade School mean nothing to you? Oh wait, you can't differentiate between the words herd and heard, so I am fighting a losing battle.
It is an awesome moment to be able to have front row seats to see Genesis in 2009...what an honour and deep appreciation to you vanriz for this CLASSIC GENESIS 5*S Moment!! Big Thanks to PsychedelicPsuzie...for the LOVE!! PEACE!!
u know my friend, a great song is great when an artist leaves room for others to add in their own taste. i have heard the disturbed version and i think they added in some interesting feel to it. made it even darker the genesis had in mind. i dont think it's better but more as it is just another great veriation of an already great song.
phil vocals where the best on here. after this he has always done a very low toned vocals. but this has a lot of passion. this is very much like heat on the street, lyric wise. both songs about making a change in a damaged and messed uop world. to make it a land worth fighting for. music like this from great artists should be a wake up call to people. our leaders, not just in the u.s. but over the world need to be removed. they are corrupt of money and power. yes even our beloved leaders.
Greatness! I love the synth voices "oooooh ... oooh" at around 2:30 - 3:00. =]] I love the bass too. And then the lyrics and the lightshow at Wembley. WONDERFUL!
phil does that as an add-on when he does it live. Basicall phil collins wants to give as much as possible in each of his songs... when he does the ohhh part in this after every chorus hes portraying tha pain that people can go through in that tone, he studied alot of english and how to use words, he does it in every gig and is also a very big star becuase of it.
phil does that as an add-on when he does it live. Basicall phil collins wants to give as much as possible in each of his songs... when he does the ohhh part in this after every chorus hes portraying tha pain that people can go through in that tone, he studied alot of english and how to use words, he does it in every gig and is also a very big star becuase of it.
This has been flagged as spam show
its sad to see the issues in this song still happening in the world today & the song was written over 20 years ago....... :(
DarkAceEnt 1 day ago
If the dictionary had a definition for "tight band", this would be it
gunneralquist 2 months ago
Genesis with Phil Collins was more a "pop/rock" group to me and that's not an insult in my mouth. Queen also evolved into pop territory during the 80s and used the keyboards as well. Did not prevent both bands from making masterpieces like "Invisible Touch" or "A Kind Of Magic"
MisterBigJones 5 months ago
Chester Thompson is beast.
dj30harw 7 months ago
Phil looks like a young Pontus Enhörning.
MetalEliot 10 months ago
disturbed fucked this song. Genesis ownds all <33
RezzKalozzTV 1 year ago
fuck disturbed, go write a song yourself .... don't copy or cover it because only Phil can sing this EPIC!
MrPhil46 1 year ago
Can't we all agree they are both good, disturbed's version does do this justice. Can't we be glad that we have bands out there that make music with meaning unlike the rest of the manufactured shit out their?
Agree?
TheOriginalBrightIs 1 year ago 2
for me its better the disturbed cover, the original version its idk like boring
alexzcorpio17 1 year ago
@alexzcorpio17 You're seriously kidding right?
pajasper 10 months ago
You have great taste in Deity and Music!!! :-) Thanks for pulling me into the Rock Stream!
PS - I think I accidentally hit a flag for inappropriate on your Captain Video...Not sure but if so SORRY!!
8noteflight 1 year ago
Is that Dr Spock from Star Trek at 2.04?
It's weird.
alpal2002 1 year ago
An amazing song by one of the greatest bands of all time!!! We are really inspired by these guys, and would love your opinion on our material, any feedback would be greatly appreciated, keep on rocking man!!
Gingerarse100 1 year ago
Great song.
alpal2002 2 years ago
Bono's Mullet was the Alpha Mullet in the 80's. Phil was to thin on top to pull off a true Alpha Mullet.
ligerbomb 2 years ago
Phil Rocks that mullet! Awesome performance. This is definitely on my "must get" list of DVD concerts.
DisasterPiece73 2 years ago 2
That is the alpha mullet, all lesser mullets must bow down to it.
NotDuncan 2 years ago
What's even more awesome about his 1986-87 era mullet is that his puppet from the LoC video was an exact replica of his real one!
DisasterPiece73 2 years ago
@DisasterPiece73 I don't know if you have it but the DVD is missing the "Cage" medley (was meant to take place after "The Brazilian" and before "Land Of Confusion") :)
SPeacock 1 year ago
Phil and the ridiculous 80's MULLET
kirkmach32 2 years ago
es una canciòn muy buen de un gran frupo de rock
bonerang 2 years ago
pronto viene un video mio con tema propio
TheGustavofire 2 years ago
QUE TEMASO LOCO¡¡UNA LOCURA¡¡
TheGustavofire 2 years ago
wow , full of power !!! like this song !
taraneh81 2 years ago 3
This song sounds way better live than on record (thanks to 'live' percussion).
nuncjusz1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
why the live version always starts with the lyrics at the second verse?
KUKU4103 2 years ago
That was a concert in wembley in july 1987. Queen was there exactly one year before in they're best concert. The eigthies was a very nice time!! here in mexico city genesis was in the charts in 1987. i was 11. thanks
justicia1 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Great song. Disturbed did a great job covering it too, but Genesis gets all the credit.
cheezeburgerpl0x 2 years ago
they did i just heard it
CarCrashHearts247 2 years ago
82 phil still had hair!
jimmybfan 2 years ago 2
which year is this
MlakaVotka 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
vodude 2 years ago
1987
matich111 2 years ago
genesis version is always better, mainly cuz they wrote it, there the ones who brought the issues up in the 1st. place plus the video makes the song more political because it critizes the president at the time (Ronald Reagan) and it also makes fun of all the pop stars at the time (example a knocked up madonna)
Traductus5972 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yea, disturbed version is better
rickyster111 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i like tha disturbed version better
rikiemoss 2 years ago
madre mia, oh my God, super expectacle,super show...y yo creia que los mejores eran Pink floyd,espero que toquen en españa...alguna vez, la ultima me los perdi.
santyrush 2 years ago
love this song no matter who does it... its a good fucking song...FACT! thats the truth..
DMEB 2 years ago
what the words mean for the 2 versions ( genesis and disturbed) are totaly different. disturbed's version has something to do with the chaos of the world and stuff. as for genesis i have no freaking idea what the words mean.
tehpizzaman 2 years ago
They mean the same thing dude.
frinkmhey 2 years ago 2
Since I love disturbed and didn't know about genesis since recently, I think Disturbed's version is better but this is great!
IFeelLikeRocking 2 years ago
nice song
medieval1377 2 years ago
not the best of them, but good enough...
b62rzv 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I like Disturbed version better, but this band takes all credit for the song.
rebeltshead 3 years ago
Gee why would they take credit for a song THEY WROTE and a song that was their massive hit single before disturbed ever thought of being a band.
danimal97520 2 years ago
I was saying GENESIS takes credit but I like Disturbed's version better. Read the comment right.
rebeltshead 2 years ago
You said "I like Disturbed version better, but this band takes all the credit for the song". And I commented as to why. Read what YOU said before telling someone else to read it right. Genesis takes credit for it because THEY wrote it. They had a hit with it. And did so when members of Disturbed were in middle school. I like both versions but your original comment was foolish.
danimal97520 2 years ago
"but this band takes credit for the song"
THIS BAND is referring to the one in the video. Aka GENESIS. Lol don'y try and correct me b/c you cant.
rebeltshead 2 years ago
yeah and THIS BAND in the video, aka Genesis WROTE IT. THUS TAKING ALL THE CREDIT NIMROD.
danimal97520 2 years ago
"I like Disturbed version better, but this band takes all credit for the song. "
Exactly what I said.
I simply stated my opinion and then gave Genesis props for the song.
You rly need to calm down...3 consecutive comments is a bit unnecessary. And I dont give a fck about negative responses.
rebeltshead 2 years ago
Hey if your giving Genesis props for it, great. But read your phrasing. Your phrasing makes it sound like your bitching about Genesis taking that credit, as opposed to giving them "props".Thus my initial correction. You wanna give props, give props. Choose your words alittle better so that people know thats what your doing.
danimal97520 2 years ago
Well I see where you're coming from but I didnt mean it like that at all. Just tryin to post fast cause I got a tight schedule
rebeltshead 2 years ago
Cool man. I misunderstood you. My appologies. Have a good one!
danimal97520 2 years ago
Its all good
rebeltshead 2 years ago
i was at this gig at omg it was pure heaven i think i was maybe 19 i think god it was so long but it is one concert i will never ever forget xxxxxx
sexyclaire1969 2 years ago
I mean your seriously dense. Genesis wrote it back when your heros Disturbed were barely hitting puberty. So your damned right they take full credit for this song. It's THEIR song.
danimal97520 2 years ago
Oh and as far as correcting you. Notice the original comment you made has gotten 6 negative responses, 5 of which before I found it. So obviously either your clueless as to what you say, or your a dense moron. You were corrected, because you said something foolish and inaccurate. You wanna be pissed and childish about it little boy, then feel free. But your comment was idiotic and I have no issue telling you so.
danimal97520 2 years ago
Of course genesis takes credit for this song it's their song
MilesofColtrane 2 years ago
no shit
rebeltshead 2 years ago
You wrote
I like Disturbed version better, but this band takes all credit for the song.
I interpreted that to mean that Genesis takes credit even though they shouldn't. I obviously misunderstoond but in fairness I'm not the only one and you weren't very clear.
MilesofColtrane 2 years ago
he means that he likes the disturbed version better....but genesis deserves and gets all the credit for writing the song.
musicman1794 2 years ago 3
Genesis is without a doubt one of the best rock groups ever, certainly the best progrock group. It's songs like LoC that cemented that reputation! Of course, it's a great song, so unless you totally screw up , most covers are good ;)
AphoticCosmos 3 years ago 17
@AphoticCosmos
The best progrock group is certainly Rush.
Pyro4414 8 months ago 3
@Pyro4414 I agree with this statement.
Annonymus121 6 months ago
disturbed better than genesis? haha what a joke
slick3222 3 years ago 4
Nah, Distubreds is too metally...loses alot of its pazazz for me
WarusGumble 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is ok, but i prefer Disturbeds cover alot better :D
Grukash1393 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ya man, disturb's version is alot better
cmillax2 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is ok but i prefer Disturb's cover
this seems almost fake and they dont seem together as a band live :/ but they are still awsome
disturbed are just better
:P
9ragdoll9 3 years ago
it's a great song in any cover i've heard except for a swedish band called Alcazar who've stolen the chorus but nothing else (dont ask me why, they're just stupid if u ask me). The 3 most famous versions of the song would be this (obviously), disturbed and in flames. all 3 versions are great and worth listen to. its no wonder why there's been so many covers of it
machmarc 3 years ago
mike draiman (the vocalist of disturbed)was 13 years old when this song came out
jesus
MeetEragon117 3 years ago
you mean david draiman, right?
thatoasta 3 years ago
oh fuck
i fail
lmfao
was thinking of the drummer as well
his name is mike wengren :P
MeetEragon117 3 years ago
lmao :P
thatoasta 3 years ago
I wouldn't say that either is better. Depends on what you like more. Genesis is electronica, and Disturbed is heavy metal. The song itself, in any rendition, is awesome: a song ACTUALLY about Revolution, out of the confusion.
VampireYoshi 3 years ago
this is LIVE AID?
frikiloco140 3 years ago
no it isn't...this is a date of INVISIBLE TOUCH TOUR in July 1987...
EnryD1 3 years ago
thank you
frikiloco140 2 years ago
1st class performance by a 1st class band, i wasnt born in this generation but i wish i was..and i wish there was bands like this now days.
paracite121 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
omg this is cover of disturbed lol!!!
snemul 3 years ago
no its not, Its a genesis song which disturbed covered.
Gingerarse100 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
lol i herd disturbed yestrerday nd its d same!! fuck u man!!1
snemul 3 years ago
Genesis = way better
123DTRAY123 3 years ago 4
Is the fact that this occurred while most of Disturbed was in Grade School mean nothing to you? Oh wait, you can't differentiate between the words herd and heard, so I am fighting a losing battle.
johnfudrow 3 years ago
i am hat
snemul 3 years ago
It's a Genesis song which disturbed covered, you idiot.
UrsiesBear07 3 years ago 2
Brilliant Live Performance Gr8 share
Laura Cheers
Phil Is Brill lol!!
DieHardBeatlesFan 3 years ago
Thanks for sharing this one,Laura!!Phil is great!!!
dxakis 3 years ago
This is a happy moment! Thanks Laura for sharing! WoooooooHooooo!
Pinchysandcrab 3 years ago
It is an awesome moment to be able to have front row seats to see Genesis in 2009...what an honour and deep appreciation to you vanriz for this CLASSIC GENESIS 5*S Moment!! Big Thanks to PsychedelicPsuzie...for the LOVE!! PEACE!!
sherrylynn70 3 years ago
i'd sell my laptop just to have been there
bindoggus 3 years ago
I noticed they tuned the song down since this song is pretty hard to sing those high notes live.
seventiesunstar 3 years ago
ok, when was chuck norris a member of genesis?
pause at 1:22
rossthebassmonster 3 years ago
Lol. Maybe they got together for a worthy cause.
haierdell 3 years ago
chuck norris is not a member of genesis, chuck norris IS genesis
DEEPSFAN 3 years ago
Chuck Norris was in every legendary band that ever excisted...Because he's just that great. ;)
Statto53 3 years ago
timeless music!!! good!!!
pimklaver1 3 years ago
this concert has been beeb awesome
thanks for posting
KingVfb 3 years ago
in my opinion its the best live version of this song ever!!
MJJKingdom 3 years ago
genesis is better live then disturbed.
sillua1 3 years ago 24
he always wears sweats and a tank top
on the reunion tour, everyone had on black cept for him and his blue t-shirt
jlg1009 3 years ago
@sillua1 just becuz disturbed uses a shit load of effects
BloodSoulja500 1 year ago
is the drummer only wearing underwear at 1:13
stumpstandard 3 years ago
Nice haircut Phil!
GBGPUNX 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
disturbed version is better imo :P
Korvos666 3 years ago
u know my friend, a great song is great when an artist leaves room for others to add in their own taste. i have heard the disturbed version and i think they added in some interesting feel to it. made it even darker the genesis had in mind. i dont think it's better but more as it is just another great veriation of an already great song.
nannynicklife 3 years ago 2
I dont think its better, but its a damn good cover. Rock On!!!
alicecoop9009 3 years ago
phil vocals where the best on here. after this he has always done a very low toned vocals. but this has a lot of passion. this is very much like heat on the street, lyric wise. both songs about making a change in a damaged and messed uop world. to make it a land worth fighting for. music like this from great artists should be a wake up call to people. our leaders, not just in the u.s. but over the world need to be removed. they are corrupt of money and power. yes even our beloved leaders.
nannynicklife 3 years ago 3
kewl!
FIIXER 3 years ago
I like so much!
When did they perform at Wembley?
PressF4togoon 3 years ago
1986/87 on the invisible touch tour. sold out 4 nights if memmory serves.
jcrawley1 3 years ago
thx
PressF4togoon 3 years ago
I love this song! És tan de bon rotllo!
kisses to everybody!!!!
minaztirit 3 years ago
I think this is the best live version.
reixian 3 years ago 7
definitly
i rememebr this exact same video on you tube... exceot it sounded alot clearer... i wonder what happened??
milkybar100 3 years ago
Already here, the song is performed in a lower key. Or maybe the origianl recording was simply too high right from the start
mulleops 4 years ago 2
they slowed it down for all the tours actually,,,. don't know why... I do like this version though!!
emiel4sma 3 years ago
Eesh, compressed to the max! I might as well just go get the DVD and watch this there!
Performance wise, this is a gem.
AeroZach1029 4 years ago 2
Collins is singing this beautifully
miss2tone 4 years ago 5
the was anothewr vidoe of this same one...and it sounded better too ..what happened to it???
milkybar100 4 years ago
agreed, sublime
thejbl 4 years ago 3
best live performance of the song on youtube
elevenames 4 years ago 5
This is the best live version of this song from Genesis!
Zhane16 4 years ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
thanks visit my site
vanriz 4 years ago
Everything was perfectly in sync for this song, but the keyboards dominated this and it sounds awesome. Props to Tony.
awesomedude1133 4 years ago 3
Greatness! I love the synth voices "oooooh ... oooh" at around 2:30 - 3:00. =]] I love the bass too. And then the lyrics and the lightshow at Wembley. WONDERFUL!
jcmcgeekster 4 years ago 4
thank visit my tube
vanriz 4 years ago
Huh? But he does the "ohoo" after EVERY chorus. :\
renoo27 4 years ago
phil does that as an add-on when he does it live. Basicall phil collins wants to give as much as possible in each of his songs... when he does the ohhh part in this after every chorus hes portraying tha pain that people can go through in that tone, he studied alot of english and how to use words, he does it in every gig and is also a very big star becuase of it.
milkybar100 3 years ago 2
phil does that as an add-on when he does it live. Basicall phil collins wants to give as much as possible in each of his songs... when he does the ohhh part in this after every chorus hes portraying tha pain that people can go through in that tone, he studied alot of english and how to use words, he does it in every gig and is also a very big star becuase of it.
milkybar100 3 years ago
Huh...? I know that. That was.... very random. Oh wait. Dang this was meant to be a reply to jmcmgeekstar.
renoo27 3 years ago
Best version of this song live from Genesis
Zhane16 4 years ago 2
thanks bro
vanriz 4 years ago
Best version of this song, Genesis or Disturbed, hands down.
awesomedude1133 4 years ago 3
yeah baby
la puteria!
yoyoma22 4 years ago 3
awesome
AntyUB 4 years ago 3
thanks bro
vanriz 4 years ago
why are you thanking people? loser
CrunchToastMan 4 years ago