omg the highest pitch is so amazing, but i am only impressed by that. Maybe this song is really hard to sing, plus most of the pitches are falsatto, so you need to have a very attractive falsatto to be able to impress people with this song
very nice, but u got to work on the steadiness of ur tone, and since u ar imitating faye, try to do it with greater detail, but overall, very impressive, especially with ur 海豚音
whistle part no deny that u did well...but else of that, it shows u suitable to sing oldies song and definately not FIR...only faye could sing well of FIR's songs...no offend ;)
since u can sing this song, i think ur voice is better than a lot of HK singer. i kind of stopped listening to cantonese songs because the singers can't really sing, compared to mandarin songs. have you thought about being a singer??
i can sing the whistle register, however, i cant really control to sing the high tone in 實現的承諾, so my voice is not really very good. but i agree that many canto singers are not really singing, so i love mandarin songs more. haha~ in fact i have thought about being a singer, but it needs lucks & chances...
Great voice and skill! While you have a canto accent in your mandarin..you pulled the song off very nicely with your singing skills, which I think was pretty impressive for an ameteur. Keep up the good work!
Comment removed
aikp2n 7 months ago
好強喔~
這世界太多人太會唱歌,我算爛爛啦!
我想說的是,你別放棄歌唱,找到你適合的路,開通你的未來巴!
YangSan65 7 months ago
不错听,海豚音有到。
只是还不够圆。
加油,你是可以的。
^.^v
KaceEinstein 11 months ago
omg the highest pitch is so amazing, but i am only impressed by that. Maybe this song is really hard to sing, plus most of the pitches are falsatto, so you need to have a very attractive falsatto to be able to impress people with this song
chiawz1314 1 year ago
Oh my god, you're so good. Now I feel like deleting my own video on this song hahah. you're good girl :D jiayou!
s49s2pid 1 year ago
很好喔~~
judoyiji 1 year ago
唱得很好.+油......唱不到的人請不要再說那麼多的屁話....人家真的唱得很好...(最睇唔起d唱唔到又係度彈3彈4ge人.咁叻你唱比人聽下.)
ivybritney 2 years ago
nice
xaychen 2 years ago
Nice voice. Jiayou, with practise you'll become even better!
discomonk 2 years ago
umm, that wasn't that great at all..
BlueBear26 2 years ago
the last voice of 海豚part 你怎麼做聲到
MiewFigaro 2 years ago
哇!!!!怎麼練的
算是很厲害了
ycrd 2 years ago
not very strong at the chorus,but awesome voice all the same:D
xomybrokendreamxo 3 years ago
你成手歌高音D會好D
ying5950 3 years ago
檳婚、輟
哦原來係咁, 我的普通話不算太好, 勿怪喔~
singingwincy 3 years ago
要有海豚音更加好
ying5950 3 years ago
唱得不錯!不過高音位你好像有點緊張,我想放鬆點可以唱到的!首歌好難唱,你已經唱得很好~^^++oil
XXXsella 3 years ago 3
great voice...sounds like faye in d 1st part
christarboy 3 years ago
Wow~ 你的海豚音唱的很好啊!!
EllaFAN3296 3 years ago
很厲害了 原唱海豚音那段 你也唱得不錯
ben810404 3 years ago
說得沒錯..."無法去實現的承諾"係我全首歌最唔滿意的一句...
我會努力的~
singingwincy 3 years ago
okay wor!!, have alook at my try as well!!
+oil!
sonleopard 3 years ago
very good
nip5bbh 3 years ago
不錯呀
:"無法去實現得承諾"
係呢句個高音唱得不夠實在
仲有ha個度因為你要透氣上高音所以斷左
但算好聽啦,繼續努力!
l01208 3 years ago
very nice, but u got to work on the steadiness of ur tone, and since u ar imitating faye, try to do it with greater detail, but overall, very impressive, especially with ur 海豚音
showmegame 4 years ago
你前面低音位太快收
到副歌唱得太急 "無法去實現的承諾"去唔到果音
感情太少 好似只係想挑戰高音only
但係不得不提 ha果度最高果個音唱得幾好
但前面個透氣聲聽到 有d可惜
anyway 首歌真係好難唱
你算唱得幾好 低音要加油
高音前面ha果度唔好斷開
妳既音質幾好 加油!
zstniy 4 years ago
to : wincy, 我沒有惡意的, 最後想向你說聲 : 加油呀!
arsheir 4 years ago 5
這不是海豚, 只是咽音
anyway, 太刻意去追求也不一定是好事
好聽的歌不一定要有海豚音 / 咽音
本身就唱得不怎麼樣的話, 即使你憧了海豚音, 也不代表好聽, 只能說 "好勁"
arsheir 4 years ago 11
.. brilliant ~ up coming F.I.R
kitzhai90 4 years ago
i just make a "vocal cut" with a software~
singingwincy 4 years ago
you sound abit like faye..
but your voice broke a little right?
work on it okay?can go far.join some singing comp! :D
whizz12 4 years ago
love this song, it's a hard to sing but u did a pretty good job, love the whistle!!!
mmelodyz 4 years ago
whistle part no deny that u did well...but else of that, it shows u suitable to sing oldies song and definately not FIR...only faye could sing well of FIR's songs...no offend ;)
kuaytiaoteng 4 years ago 4
wa the whistle part u do until so nice la=DD jiayous!! xDD
magicianyj 4 years ago
hello
u sing nice for such a hard song like this.. :)
jieen92 4 years ago
i give you 5 starts
flyck9163 4 years ago
very nice, but not stable at mid-low part.
gambate!!!
d(^o^)b
lit6219 4 years ago
lOls. cannot be la. If its high high f sharp, i cannot sing le, but i still able to reach.
SAMYMuslc 4 years ago
LOLS! my maximum is only a c6!
SAMYMuslc 4 years ago
it seems the highest note of this song is F#6
singingwincy 4 years ago
you're very good =)
speedstarx 4 years ago
it'd be better if you're not using falsetto for all the chorus parts. but, the whistle was very nicely done :)
keweiii 4 years ago
Great work =D
icyblaster16 4 years ago
wow... so high
sacredfire999 4 years ago
你唱嫁..?
唱得幾好喎
唱到高音@o@
michelle7798 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
個個都唔係海豚音...
海豚音係海豚先至有
saku169 4 years ago
great work on the whistle register!
shermaineonline 4 years ago
ooo okay i believe you haha.
since u can sing this song, i think ur voice is better than a lot of HK singer. i kind of stopped listening to cantonese songs because the singers can't really sing, compared to mandarin songs. have you thought about being a singer??
vickie16ehss 4 years ago
i can sing the whistle register, however, i cant really control to sing the high tone in 實現的承諾, so my voice is not really very good. but i agree that many canto singers are not really singing, so i love mandarin songs more. haha~ in fact i have thought about being a singer, but it needs lucks & chances...
singingwincy 4 years ago
omg.. i just heard this song like 2 to 3 days ago. i was so amazed at faye's voice.
is that really you? you sound just like her, that's amazing
vickie16ehss 4 years ago
it is really my voice, thx~
singingwincy 4 years ago
Great voice and skill! While you have a canto accent in your mandarin..you pulled the song off very nicely with your singing skills, which I think was pretty impressive for an ameteur. Keep up the good work!
sdkram 4 years ago
the sound quality of video in youtube will not be very good, even if i record it in studio~:) anyway, thx ur comment~
singingwincy 4 years ago
你錄這個之前,有無開聲?
我都算學過一點點唱歌既...
如果無開聲,小心傷了聲帶 =]
lhwhelen 4 years ago
謝謝提醒, 我有開過下聲呀, 不過可能唔係好夠~=]
singingwincy 4 years ago
--以下純粹個人意見..不滿勿插--
我曾經被一啲文章誤導左海豚音同埋咽音既分別
就係因為自己學粵曲識唱咽音..一直以為自己識唱海豚音
之後先知自己既無知
其實你唱果個只係咽音..並唔係D咩海豚音
正好似哈林咁..都唔係海豚音黎
FIR既faye呢個都唔係..只係咽音..加埋D迴音米製造出類同海豚音既輕浮感
mickeyto 4 years ago
我可以話你唱到咽音..但係演唱呢首歌真係一般
高音唔穩定..唔係好夠氣
mickeyto 4 years ago
嗯~我後來都search過, 都發現了海豚音同咽音既不同, 我想更正不是海豚音的, 不過既然post都開了, 一般人當是海豚音就由它吧~
singingwincy 4 years ago
不過聲底唔差的..可去多練
mickeyto 4 years ago
咁張靚穎唱的loving U 係唔係海豚音?
lhwhelen 4 years ago
it's amazing! probably will sound perfect if you did it in a studio. =)
shoushitai 4 years ago
表達不到情感,唱高音時好像手波車轉波似的,非常明顯是不夠氣,所謂海䐁音就像鬼叫,硬要將高音部分唱出,相信你唱完之定必會咳兩聲,唱得又不流暢,像是將歌詞逐字呼出,難聽
bbbpaf 4 years ago
我只能說我唱完之後直至今天, 一聲都沒咳
singingwincy 4 years ago
不如你又唱下
j0Eeey 4 years ago
u ask me i came from what country ma??
from hk ar~
singingwincy 4 years ago
wow....to be able to sing a song of this difficulty....amazing
a0zu 4 years ago
u'r great. Very few singers can strike the whistle note. u did it effortlessly. really nice =D
Ir0nX 4 years ago
i just record it at home~ thank you~
singingwincy 4 years ago
wow is that really u? sooo nice, i really love that song, the high pitch is not perfect, but hey ur still great ;D
frozensky 4 years ago
of coz it's me, and all pitch was sang by me, thx ur comment~
singingwincy 4 years ago
哇..
d咬字同音準好似................
我個fd唱得好聽好多
shiilovemoon 4 years ago