梁靜茹 夢醒時分 原唱陳淑樺 (2007李宗盛理性與感性作品音樂會)

[bsa00794]

be ding secae yeseae yes day so in did can by mudican xcpc eng did celecae yeste mind se . so inbesdu me can elecae yes dacc an mind seeap yc and cp in highecaeyec air so . hosk aece anc all cianec ay klacyc and class in be do be moshuse did can ? thad in did cancay kecae yes do be can did in be do mocan it get be dohosdidin day so by make dcegea cll gecagwan get be taoyuacuc an po

[ll966967]

真的...超好聽的啦~^ ^....好喜歡聽喔~~

[ll966967]

@ll966967 

[ProJackD]

我在靜茹歌聲聽到的是切切實實的夢醒時分, 傷痛過, 好夢惡夢也都該醒了, 算是一種釋放吧

[ganlenin3]

最後老李的文字讓我哭了

[keithleung2009]

佢唱得好SMOOTH, NOT BAD, 不過原唱樺姐~ 把聲好清同埋有種淒涼既感覺.. 係呢度搵唔到

[a3188598]

後段..薩克斯風與留言.真是絕配..



[CUIWEIFENG]

梁静茹的鼻音太大了

[ufozhai]

@CUIWEIFENG 所谓的鼻音是？

[karen51438]

一個字  好~

[yuim1123]

每天不聽個幾次 會難過

越聽越上癮

~

[vampire1029]

梁靜茹唱歌的風格比較輕盈，感覺起來比較快樂，給人鼓舞的感覺!­!

陳淑華的風格比較沉重，感覺起來比較沉悶、悲傷，自然給人有那種­失去那種痛苦的感覺!!

每個人的唱歌風格不同，沒有必要去做好壞這種比較吧!!

聽歌的時候的心情不同，自然也會喜歡不同的風格!!

[ganlenin]

李宗盛的留言讓我看了真的很感動!!

[rs7863981]

唱快了其實有另一種味道

都市女孩十分渴望愛情的感覺

節奏快 心情也不太一樣

[yoursaremine]

这首歌毕竟是悲情歌..唱快了始终失去它的煽情

[jcchoong]

Happy birthday my beloved wife, SY!!..God bless u

[ggski]

梁靜茹確實唱功差陳淑華很多,不過這裡伴奏的感覺比原版的節奏豐­富多了,還有加薩科斯風~有點爵士風的感覺,陳淑華原版的感覺就­很單調,完全就是靠陳淑華的功力在唱XD

[Addicted2SarahChen]

其實梁已經唱得很不錯，只是可惜原唱是陳淑樺啊！再也沒有了，如­此用心來演唱的歌者。

但我還是很喜歡這個版本，因為梁靜茹把這首歌獻給淑樺，她祝Sa­rah生日快樂！

還有老李的那段文字，大屏幕里的Sarah翩翩起舞，很感動。

[shareleneking]

說的真好! 感動!

[clistyloveyou]

問題出在..............節拍也太快了@@

[neogerm]

@clistyloveyou 所以能减少跟前辈的比较啊

[ben065566]

GOOOOOOOD

[slowmind216]

李宗盛的这段留言真是让人感动！配上Sax，道出了老朋友之间的­真感情。李宗盛是真正的煽情大师。

[tomjtucker]

best saxophone performance!!!!

[mlifsi]

yes, he really plays well (and sexy)!

[li41269]

好難看的字哦，不過内牛滿面....

[neogerm]

@li41269 什么字啊？

[thinman2007]

The original is too too good that very hard to compare.

這首歌太經典啊 要超越前人很困難, 她己經唱得很好啊 just miss the taste

[gogoggo355]

陳淑樺那時候,應該是要表現新女性的灑脫個性吧,他整個造型也是­比較帥氣的感覺,至於靜茹這次表演,我絕得他沒有進去歌裡面耶,­就真的是演唱而已,她在享受舞台吧

要市真的有錄製翻唱,一定會更有味道

[rccx]

wow, she's pretty good

[odyssey12345678910]

this song has the best intro ever...gives me goosebumps

[baileypei]

great song!

[din3786]

淑樺姐的是無奈的

梁靜茹的是釋懷的感覺 , 「療傷系」歌手嗎?

[senthyril]

love the sax

[Raymondwong0908]

這首歌太經典啊 要超越前人很困難, 她己經唱得很好啊

[5oh2]

好歌...真是好歌...

[0301531]

梁靜茹唔係唱得唔好,都好有feel,但總係覺得冇左淑樺姐帶出­黎果種無奈ge feel

[fugiwashi]

is a great songs

[epmud]

兩種不同的風味

[s0erika]

This is such a beautiful classic song! I love her voice.

[tmskyblue]

找不到可以相信的人...

你說你感到萬分沮喪,　甚至開始懷疑人生...

[isacjvdov]

經典中的經典，太好聽了

[drew1489]

Fish演繹這首經典歌曲發揮得很不錯！

[raywong19800824]

梁靜茹唱得好好..

[cbx123]

theres no way we can compare a live performance to a well-recorded version, at least when both of them are profoundly talented!

[straitcheah]

how can you compare Fish with Sarah. Sarah has an excellent voice....emm Fish not bad too...

[packpassenger]

Sarah Chen, so nice, so subtle, I do not want to forget you, please don't let dementia take you away from me.

[sholo35265]

Hoped really her classical song may be sung by the people for a long time.

[sholo35265]

如果李宗盛大哥能邀请到淑桦姊亲自来唱这首经典歌曲，这样当然是­最好不过了。

[vergil51414]

是另一種味道....歌手聲音的分別....

[kittencat1983]

@redppl 也很好聽喇 ~

音色很美 ~

[fionman6]

@redppl

你說的對

陳淑樺真的唱得很好

[polchung]

@redppl 

梁静茹的版本不是沒陳淑华好, 只是沒有哪仲蒼涼, 寂寞的感覺.

可能是音樂編曲不同.

[jany55660]

@redppl

嘖

[armiearm]

Brilliant interpretation by Fish, it's always a treat hearing her sing

[sholo35265]

This song has quite aroused people's sympathetic chord.

[packpassenger]

I have listened Sarah Chen singing this sound thousands of time just like many of u, I can say 梁靜茹 was singing too fast, the original feel is not there! Still she tried.

[sholo35265]

You said rightly. Although 陳淑樺 even more has the feeling, but 梁靜茹 had already made the attempt which the average person does not dare to do.

[yiyinuk]

thx for upload!

[sholo35265]

Thanks your response and the support once more.

[withOphelia]

what is the writing at the end of the song about? has the original singer passed on?

[sholo35265]

That is 李宗盛 sent regards to 陳淑樺, and hoped for that also has the opportunity to sing together with her.

Although 陳淑樺 already withdrew from song world many years, but many people still fondly remember her.

[yvette74731]

對淑樺姐和靜茹獻上最高敬意~:)

[sholo35265]

希望淑樺姐的經典好歌可以不斷地被傳唱下去~~

[budding20]

陶醉在靜茹的歌聲中...

[sholo35265]

真的聽越好聽，猶如餘音繞樑...

[Cattytea]

She handled this really well. Singing someone's songs can be difficult but it seems so easy for her.

[sholo35265]

Before singing this classical song, Fish should have made many practices.

[devlancer]

The original song is very good and Fish wouldn't be able to sing it without the original, but I do believe her version is superior. Very rarely, we get a cover version that is better than the original. I believe this is because we have live instruments such as the saxophone as opposed to the synthesized instruments of the original that was iconic the that era.

[sholo35265]

Thanks your profound opinion. This classical song is really worth singing repeatedly by the different generation's people!

[jason18619]

梁静茹 singing this song much more better than the original snger of this song!!! I love 梁静茹's voice really good!!!

[sholo35265]

Thanks your response, I thought that two kind of editions are very both good! Fish Leong should be wants to express the respect to the senior!

[jackkchui]

在這裡我們祝她生日快樂。一起唱這首歌吧！」

[sholo35265]

陳淑樺是5月份生日，希望她可以收到大家給她的祝福喔！

[123195413]

Melody

[sholo35265]

Beautiful music lingering in the air.

[conceal1]

i really like her voice

[sholo35265]

This song is really more listens to be more moving!

[panshiun]

雖然梁靜茹音色與陳淑樺不同，但能演繹這首歌，以淑樺的方式，真­是令人讚賞。謝謝梁靜茹。

[sholo35265]

這是靜茹向偶像致敬的歌，就像靜茹在影片開頭時所說的：「淑樺姊­這個月生日，在這裡我們祝她生日快樂。一起唱這首歌吧！」

[oscaraoe3]

one of the best short-movie on utube!

I like the words Lee wrote to Lin ,

so touching

[sholo35265]

This is the classical song which is worth repeatedly listening!

[cypher2nd]

hao ting la~~

[sholo35265]

Indeed pleasant to hear!