The crowd sucks, the sound engineer sucks, and this is supposed to be Paramore's most epic song. Such a fail of a concert. Poor Paramore. At least they've got a million other shows to make up for it.
Well.. remember that there was maybe only 1000 people who was there to see Paramore. Rest of the people sitting in the back was those who came to see Billy Talent, Rufus Wein, Madrugada etc... There was alot of energy in the front!
One of the best days of my life. Wish they could come back
Kupalisko Vlachovo ! BOL som tam, super bolo, hlavne ten nastup som si zapamatal, super nastup, nastup ako ma byt, perfektne nacasovany nastup, dynamicky nastup, a hlavne nastup by som zvyraznil
Do you know how much Paramore relates to what's going on in the UK? "I give it all my oxygen, To let the flames begin To let the flames begin. This is how we'll dance when, When they try to take us down This is how we'll sing it. This is how we'll stand when When they burn our houses down. This is what will be oh glory." Let The Flames Begin...
when i think of paramore this is the image that comes to my mind.......with josh and zac, with hayley tshirts, jeans and snickers.....on fire hair, amazing voice and killer drumming ..........with the amazing real vibe that you could feel when you went to their concerts
@AngelsOfSilence6 Look, I'm going to keep this simple because this is about music and not fighting some moron across a computer screen. Winning a fight over the internet is like winning the Special Olympics; either way you're retarded. I was simply using an expression. Besides either the SE can correct his errors or he's out of a job, that's how it usually is.Most people would use common sense and not see that I was being literal about "kicking him in the nuts".
@NewsChanel i think its just the sound track of the video. everything kicks in at once and a sound engineer would raise only a few things at a time and the drums kick in at that point as well.
@NewsChanel It is still disrespectful to be sitting while a band is playing, you came to hear music and it's okay to sit and just enjoy it, but why not stand up, feel it, put your hands in the air and be part of it?
this crowd sucks. no offense norway, but there were people SITTING in the back. that shouldnt even be allowed at a paramore concert! if i was there i would be headbanging till i got a concussion! lmao (again, no offense norway lol ;) )
@paramorefanforever4 In defense of the crowd I do not know, they do NOT suck. They were sitting comfortably in the back. Half of them may not even have liked Paramore, would you rather them boo at them and throw shit? For the fans in the crowd I respect them being quiet. Loud and annoying crowds ruin live recordings.
@NewsChanel ok, ok, i get where ur coming from. but still, some enthusiasm would be nice...but whatever, thats just what i think. (and yes ur right, i wouldnt want them booing and throwing shit... :P )
Whenever I hear the outro I, as it's reaching the ending note I always think 'There's no way she's gonna be able to do that, she won't be able to breath!', impressive.
@concussedcarneous Hahaha, I knew it! You came here, and you watched this video, and you loved it. Admit it bro, you can't get enough of this shit. Check out The Final Riot! version in Chicago, it's even better. Our tech death can't touch this. You love it, admit it.
My uploads have their comment section open to everyone, and I believe in free speech but if you continue to post useless immature comments I'm going to start deleting them.
Honestly, dude. If you don't like Paramore, the fans or Me, you're free to leave.
Also, you can insult Paramore all you want, but saying "hippy emo cock loving sucking shitheads lol this is so gay" makes you look like an IDIOT.
If you're going to insult something please make it insulting!
@concussedcarneous LOL. You're still here buddy! Why don't you just admit it - you fucking love Paramore, like the rest of us. Maybe you even have a crush on Ms Williams too huh? It's ok, we all do nigga.
its too bad the crowd aint there for awesome alternative music! The norwegian crowd was 50 times better this summer, at Hove festivalen! But Norwegian Woods dont host much Alternative.. so not that many who actually knew this music at that time!
i luv them here here, my fav. song by them by far, ROCK ON PARAMORE!!!!! nd can someone tell me exactly wat she sings at 5:16 to the end cause i've been trying to sing it as a tribute but i can only make out half of it :P
I would say we are listening to the soundboard mix being fed to the video. Often the mix from the sound check is good for the stage monitors and PA but any extra mixes might have to be done on the spot because things change when you fill the house etc. First get the drums leveled out, then vocals and so on. Notice how after Hayley's mic is up, the guitar, then the bass rise and fall in the mix for a second while the sound engineer puts the whole band together. It's common for the first song.
wow her voicee is the best here !!!!! i wonder what she did but she sounds better than all the live videos I've seen. Dont get me wrong , shes amazing in all her concerts but this one ...just something that makes me drop my jaw for a long while lol!
2:34 sweet jesus, that's better..
ParamoreClips 4 days ago
The crowd sucks, the sound engineer sucks, and this is supposed to be Paramore's most epic song. Such a fail of a concert. Poor Paramore. At least they've got a million other shows to make up for it.
KaraDelonas 1 week ago
the outtro is amazing(: my fav song by them!
mizzariel1996 1 week ago
wow, this crowd sucks...
esmoreee 1 week ago
the outro is just so emotional and powerful! it gives me chills everytime C:
itsolive1 1 month ago
That outtro is just so fucking epic
IPodGuyism 1 month ago
Well.. remember that there was maybe only 1000 people who was there to see Paramore. Rest of the people sitting in the back was those who came to see Billy Talent, Rufus Wein, Madrugada etc... There was alot of energy in the front!
One of the best days of my life. Wish they could come back
TheHattkals 1 month ago
wahhhh zac:(
i mish him
imadinosur 1 month ago
this is one of the best moving performances by them itfb is my fav:)!!
minipant1 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
watch?v=SF0_QJgtcD0
FUCK
SWAG.
iaaaannnn 2 months ago
From all her cool t-shirts, this is the one I love the most.
afterapple9 2 months ago
This is my favorite performance of this song. Gahhhhh.....I'm in love with it. <3
TheManutd4ever 2 months ago
What happened to Paramore -__-
isaiashimself26 2 months ago
@isaiashimself26 what do u mean?
paramini08 2 months ago in playlist More videos from NewsChanel
@isaiashimself26 why you say that?
MrSamantha2010 2 months ago
I never thought I would have trouble hearing Hayley, of all people.
NauticalxPsychos 3 months ago
@NauticalxPsychos te amoooooooooooo hayley
lorraine450 2 months ago
omg those people sitting down are pissing me off -___-
DemonicAngel619 3 months ago
genial paramore amo esta cancio
Stephanyyist 4 months ago
shes wearing a shirt of the little mermaid and thats my favorite prinsess :D
demirulz12 4 months ago
taylor 5:29 lol
TheColorado1997 4 months ago 2
i live 2 hours from Nashville and i love paramore and never got to see them live!! is that wierd?!?
horselover0730 4 months ago
The outro is the paramore way to worship god and jesus!! I love u god for making such an awesome band!! <3
horselover0730 4 months ago 7
i love paramore for the reasons that she can really sing and they all get into the song
they are FANTASTIC.
TheSxcbiatch 4 months ago
Bad sounds :-P
ZecharyWI 4 months ago
Kupalisko Vlachovo ! BOL som tam, super bolo, hlavne ten nastup som si zapamatal, super nastup, nastup ako ma byt, perfektne nacasovany nastup, dynamicky nastup, a hlavne nastup by som zvyraznil
seventhOFsix 4 months ago
Hayley surely has the power to turn us into lesbians! <3
TheParamoreTiger 5 months ago 4
paramore
XparawhoresX 5 months ago
I LOVE THEM!!!!!!!
abbyyallzh31427P 5 months ago
5:12 <3
creepiiiexd 5 months ago
Nice Intro & Ending... :D
<3 Paramore
ZecharyWI 5 months ago
why does she always kneel down when she does the outro?
MissStrawberries0 5 months ago
@MissStrawberries0 because she's singing to God. Hayley usually gets really emotional during the outro of this song.
MelodyKateS 5 months ago
@MelodyKateS Ah Okay. Thanks
MissStrawberries0 5 months ago
@MissStrawberries0 no problemo! :)
MelodyKateS 5 months ago
@MissStrawberries0 Shes kneeling down in prayer.
EireannH 5 months ago
Kinda seems like woodstock here.... interesting
theslayermatt 5 months ago
2:20 what the hell that audio sucks they fuk the guitar that´s so mainstream fail
MsWhiteshark 5 months ago
TheManutd4ever 5 months ago in playlist Paramore
when i think of paramore this is the image that comes to my mind.......with josh and zac, with hayley tshirts, jeans and snickers.....on fire hair, amazing voice and killer drumming ..........with the amazing real vibe that you could feel when you went to their concerts
renrove 5 months ago
Why can't I stop replaying this??
TheManutd4ever 5 months ago in playlist Paramore Live In Norwegian Wood 2008
Omg..Can you guys like stop saying that the crowd sucks? This is from 2008 and paramore weren't that popular in Norway at that time.
DaniellaaKarlsen 5 months ago
Hayley Williams is an awesome headbanger
BandaDK 6 months ago 5
para mi esta cancion y born for this son las mejores canciones de paramore
victornomada 6 months ago
Her hair is so flat and greasy! HOT.
hyperballad5 6 months ago 2
She is so good at singing that even in the midst of the sound problem she sounded great. Always one of my favorites, Paramore is.
foreverarocker 6 months ago
MMMMMM recording fail?? i love this song!! i can't stop it xDD
jpetrillo13 6 months ago
I loove this live performance !! it's awesome!:D
ExnerAJ 6 months ago
Love her shirt. And I wanna play tha drums like that :)
xoxomiraclexoxo 6 months ago
I do miss Zac on the drums tho damn. He's a beast
jblaze600 6 months ago
What the hell! I can't hear Hayley's voice... EPIC FAIL NORWAY! no offense.. peace
lykako26 6 months ago
Does anyone else get MAJOR shivers through their entire body whenever you watch a live performance of Oh father ? Or is it just me ? ♥
paramore4ever1024 6 months ago
@paramore4ever1024 ME TOO!
BandaDK 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the best band of the world como 100pre paramore nunk decepciona arriba paramore woahhhhhhhhhh q muera justin bieber
x mi WHP
sevas666 6 months ago
the best band of the world como 100pre paramore nunk decepciona arriba paramore woahhhhhhhhhh q muera justin bieber
sevas666 6 months ago
that microphone doesn't look rlly fine...
ReneeKillerGirl 7 months ago
I love how she goes into her own little world when she performs(:
billkaulitzluver09 7 months ago
Ok. i'm crying. it's too strong for me. And i LOVE IT.
MiSsSkEvAmPirE 7 months ago
dude you can feel the energy of hayley from the stage to your pc :')
rojopedmin 8 months ago
nice shirt
oliverrocks158 8 months ago
this made my cry. Its outstanding. Josh and Zac are amazing, want them back!:'(
ashleeeighbrown 8 months ago
@AngelsOfSilence6 Look, I'm going to keep this simple because this is about music and not fighting some moron across a computer screen. Winning a fight over the internet is like winning the Special Olympics; either way you're retarded. I was simply using an expression. Besides either the SE can correct his errors or he's out of a job, that's how it usually is.Most people would use common sense and not see that I was being literal about "kicking him in the nuts".
16vMR2 8 months ago
Phoda sem palavras!
wallacegilo 8 months ago
someone kick the sound engineer in the nuts...the vocal track barely comes across and all you hear is the drums until halfway through... fail..
16vMR2 9 months ago 66
@16vMR2 And this is one of their best songs Live, so it sucks even more.
NewsChanel 9 months ago 49
@NewsChanel i think its just the sound track of the video. everything kicks in at once and a sound engineer would raise only a few things at a time and the drums kick in at that point as well.
music0channel 7 months ago in playlist Paramore Live In Norwegian Wood 2008
@16vMR2 i think its just the video
DefyTheSkyline 1 month ago
@16vMR2 This was the first song of the webcast, and usually it takes a couple of minutes to get everything right.
speculative182 1 month ago
@NewsChanel It is still disrespectful to be sitting while a band is playing, you came to hear music and it's okay to sit and just enjoy it, but why not stand up, feel it, put your hands in the air and be part of it?
pattopurific 9 months ago
this crowd sucks. no offense norway, but there were people SITTING in the back. that shouldnt even be allowed at a paramore concert! if i was there i would be headbanging till i got a concussion! lmao (again, no offense norway lol ;) )
paramorefanforever4 9 months ago 44
@paramorefanforever4 In defense of the crowd I do not know, they do NOT suck. They were sitting comfortably in the back. Half of them may not even have liked Paramore, would you rather them boo at them and throw shit? For the fans in the crowd I respect them being quiet. Loud and annoying crowds ruin live recordings.
NewsChanel 9 months ago 29
@NewsChanel ok, ok, i get where ur coming from. but still, some enthusiasm would be nice...but whatever, thats just what i think. (and yes ur right, i wouldnt want them booing and throwing shit... :P )
paramorefanforever4 9 months ago
@NewsChanel I agree. You can't hear the singer when the crowds screaming there butts off.
Browneyesisme 7 months ago in playlist Paramore Live In Norwegian Wood 2008
@paramorefanforever4 im from Norway, and i freakin agree with you! i wasn't there, but if i had been there, i would NOT sit whatsoever!! xD
nathe2296 4 months ago in playlist Paramore Live In Norwegian Wood 2008
5:16 o.O !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Sirist10 9 months ago
everyday i wonder....how can she not get brain damage ?
she just must be emune ! love paramore x
nzparamorelover 9 months ago
The most epic moment in my whole life 4:21 till end
GGirlShorty 9 months ago 2
Zac is a really lost for Paramore...
GGirlShorty 9 months ago 4
Fucking amazing.....like holy shit.....i love paramore so much
DemonicAngel619 9 months ago
Jeremy at 5:40 :P he's so cute!
lalaland1508 9 months ago
the little guitar part that taylors playin at 4:50 sounds alot like the one in aday to remembers - secound sucks
AlejandroZrOX 9 months ago
what was up with taylors pedel board??
fireflys127 10 months ago
v Learn how to spell, it's Hayley.
xLiveWithoutWarningx 10 months ago
I want to fuck with halley
mrseletus 10 months ago
zac is a beautiful man.
twileyprodxo 10 months ago 2
A.MA.ZING.
WeAreBullets 10 months ago
I FREAKING LUV LUV LUV PARAMORE <3
AndreaVolleyBall82 10 months ago
if i was in the audience i would have been chucked out for doing some crazy head banging.
TheSxcbiatch 10 months ago
Oh Zac, you are amazing. Why did you have to leave?
TheUpsidedownsmile 11 months ago 6
haha wow i love her shirt
Septapphirix 11 months ago
HOLY SHIT i feel sorry for zac's drums in this song.
wompo67 11 months ago
Whenever I hear the outro I, as it's reaching the ending note I always think 'There's no way she's gonna be able to do that, she won't be able to breath!', impressive.
EatMyCrayonzz 11 months ago
Intense...I love it
applebug 11 months ago
nice ,love it!
bavmbav 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
emo, DIE!
concussedcarneous 1 year ago
@concussedcarneous Hahaha, I knew it! You came here, and you watched this video, and you loved it. Admit it bro, you can't get enough of this shit. Check out The Final Riot! version in Chicago, it's even better. Our tech death can't touch this. You love it, admit it.
harmonicminorshred 1 year ago
@harmonicminorshred fuck you EMO
my JAVAscript is disabled HAHA
concussedcarneous 1 year ago
@concussedcarneous Suure, sure.
harmonicminorshred 1 year ago
@concussedcarneous Paramore aren't Emo, they're passionate.
So... No. YOU!
NewsChanel 11 months ago 4
@NewsChanel fuck you too! fucking passionate hippy emo cock loving sucking shitheads
lol this is so gay
concussedcarneous 11 months ago
@concussedcarneous Alright.
My uploads have their comment section open to everyone, and I believe in free speech but if you continue to post useless immature comments I'm going to start deleting them.
Honestly, dude. If you don't like Paramore, the fans or Me, you're free to leave.
Also, you can insult Paramore all you want, but saying "hippy emo cock loving sucking shitheads lol this is so gay" makes you look like an IDIOT.
If you're going to insult something please make it insulting!
NewsChanel 11 months ago 4
@NewsChanel you are insulting. i don't need to do anything.
i believe you're a queer. you can't be a girl, you're too ugly. HOMOs have fun with your crappy music.
concussedcarneous 11 months ago
@concussedcarneous LOL. You're still here buddy! Why don't you just admit it - you fucking love Paramore, like the rest of us. Maybe you even have a crush on Ms Williams too huh? It's ok, we all do nigga.
harmonicminorshred 11 months ago
@concussedcarneous hahha emo? you are emo....paramore is the best band in the world so shut the fuck up
ICaughtMyself92 11 months ago 3
@ICaughtMyself92 Amen buddy.
harmonicminorshred 11 months ago
Haley is hardcore.
Even in an Ariel t-shirt.
TheJohnOHolic 1 year ago
Hayley definatly deserves an award for best headbanger.
ilovetcyrus 1 year ago 7
Goosebumps.
dreamingkangaroo 1 year ago
Goosebumps. Ok can someone please back the real Paramore the Group that pines for God and don't fake it!
dreamingkangaroo 1 year ago
Goosebumps.
dreamingkangaroo 1 year ago
this song is always better live, <3 :)
ImiiNotOkay25 1 year ago
That was great...but Hayley could do without getting on the floor every time she sings that part.. LOL
aquarose16 1 year ago
@aquarose16 She gets lower down on this version than any other I've seen haha.
harmonicminorshred 1 year ago
This is their best song by far, the intro and oh father outro are amazing!!!
pbWebb92 1 year ago 2
Sometimes i always wonder ; Is she gonna fall ?! Is she really dizzy ?! Is she gonna pass out ?! D:
noheilym 1 year ago
This is always my favorite song they perform. I mean i love all their song but when they perform this there is so much power to this.
I just love them :)
xxloloxxful 1 year ago
1:54
That boy. Fuck yesss.
At 2:36 you can hear her, that's why around 2:22 that guy ran on stage.
And 5:16. Just... wow.
nomnomnomsterr 1 year ago
AAAA THAT IS SO FUCKIN' AWESOOME !!!
YelyahWilliamsGG 1 year ago 2
its too bad the crowd aint there for awesome alternative music! The norwegian crowd was 50 times better this summer, at Hove festivalen! But Norwegian Woods dont host much Alternative.. so not that many who actually knew this music at that time!
csi13x 1 year ago
shit!!! hayley is so biuteful!!!!!!i love hayley!!!!
raulsk8r 1 year ago 2
Paramore is the best group that ever exist!!!! xD xD xD
96Lisbeth14 1 year ago 2
Ang angas grabe!!! ASTIG O.o
winxanne13 1 year ago 2
@winxanne13 tama !
xxloloxxful 1 year ago
0:42 she doesn't know for what she was screaming
JCesarDT 1 year ago 30
@JCesarDT So true, hahaha. Good find :D
NewsChanel 1 year ago
Hayley is soo perfect, PARAMORE IS SO PERFECT ♥
gustavob26 1 year ago 2
Damn. This performance was SO Intense !! 5:16 SHE'S ON THE FLOOR !!!!!! I've never seen her perform like that !!! Ever.
JustTHEDavina 1 year ago 2
@JustTHEDavina
warped tour 2006 and glasgow 2006
back when josh actually had some stage presence.
glendoi 7 months ago
5:46 awesome hair!
293Laie 1 year ago
DRUMMER=SEXY
luvmiley95 1 year ago
how all the people start screaming after hayley is laying on the floor :D:D
VeDdERsChe 1 year ago
i wish i could sew Let The Flames Begin live :)))
Lame crowd -.-
VeDdERsChe 1 year ago
i want that drum kit so badly....
nonononon1 1 year ago
that crowd is awful.
DNAELLNAD 1 year ago
Apresentação insana! Gostei! \o/
Marcuspitu 1 year ago
OMG!!! She's so fuckin' amazing *-* <3
DaniellaKarlsen 1 year ago
HAYLEY IS SO AMAZING.
iluvtwilight32123 1 year ago
Spam WILL be removed from all my uploads.
Feel free to love/hate, comment and argue.. but link to a website and your comment will be removed and you'll be reported & blocked.
NewsChanel 1 year ago 10
@NewsChanel youtube.com/watch?v=qS7nqwGt4-I
karlt10 1 year ago
miss that day so friggin' much.
mrpyttpytt 1 year ago
why do they attract so much emo people :p
palmpje11 1 year ago
YUP. ITS OFFICIAL. i REFUSE to die until i see them in concert.
brianaceleste1 1 year ago 4
horrible crowd but kudos to the first few rows :) she seriously got on the ground for them and they still do nothing!!
minnow26 1 year ago
@minnow26
She does that in all of the performances of this song. xD
XximonlymexX 1 year ago
@XximonlymexX yeah she gets on her knees but like shes literally lying down in this one!! i love her <3
minnow26 1 year ago
zac! i ♥ u!
dAmAcA92 1 year ago
Her teeth are.... SSOOOO COOOLLLL
ZeroSkater1997 1 year ago
hayley pours her heart out on the stage and people calmly tan on their towels at the end? tsk tsk tsk
munky3691 1 year ago
I'm glad they got the sound worked out! LOL
a7xrockchick92 1 year ago
i luv them here here, my fav. song by them by far, ROCK ON PARAMORE!!!!! nd can someone tell me exactly wat she sings at 5:16 to the end cause i've been trying to sing it as a tribute but i can only make out half of it :P
tjkid54 1 year ago 7
@tjkid54 Here's what she sings.
Oh Father (x4)
Father, well I am ready
Won't you let it begin
Cause I am here now
I want to dance in
The Mighty palm of your hand
NewsChanel 1 year ago 52
@NewsChanel I thought it was (2nd line) - "Father, are you ready?" I looked it up and that what i said and it seems like thats whats she saying.
LinkinLover01 1 year ago
@NewsChanel love that part
16kikibby 1 year ago
@tjkid54 Oh father, oh father, well i am ready, wont you let it begin? cause i am here now, i want to dance in.. the mighty palm of your hand.
pirulina246 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@tjkid54 Oh father, oh father, well i am ready, wont you let it begin? cause i am here now, i want to dance in.. the mighty palm of your hands.
pirulina246 1 year ago
HIT THOSE SKINS ZAC XXXOOX
TheAmandaxHeart 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
5:47 Holy hell
ice9willENDusall 1 year ago
5:47 holy wow
ice9willENDusall 1 year ago
omg i held my breath during the 'oh father' part! i didn't realize it until it was over ahah
minnow26 1 year ago
The band may not have noticed a thing, the stage monitors are mixed totally separate.
dano247365 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I would say we are listening to the soundboard mix being fed to the video. Often the mix from the sound check is good for the stage monitors and PA but any extra mixes might have to be done on the spot because things change when you fill the house etc. First get the drums leveled out, then vocals and so on. Notice how after Hayley's mic is up, the guitar, then the bass rise and fall in the mix for a second while the sound engineer puts the whole band together. It's common for the first song.
dano247365 1 year ago
oh my god what a shite sound man this song rocks so hard i bet Hayley was pissed!
gumba12 1 year ago
wow her voicee is the best here !!!!! i wonder what she did but she sounds better than all the live videos I've seen. Dont get me wrong , shes amazing in all her concerts but this one ...just something that makes me drop my jaw for a long while lol!
katty96a 1 year ago
This is probably one of the best vocally-done concerts Hayley's done that year.
ElectroSkies 1 year ago
the stage is too big. xD
alicerocelle 1 year ago
i love the end because you can tell they passionate about their music. i mean when she lays on the stage floor !!!
TheSxcbiatch 1 year ago
OMG Zac is so good
GGirlShorty 1 year ago
awesome O_O
fkwithmaces 1 year ago
<3 5:19
minnow26 1 year ago
Zac is such a beast on the drums. ♥_♥
TheUpsidedownsmile 1 year ago
the intro and outro made me love the song so much more than i already did. beautiful. simply beautiful.
TheNutMeg26 1 year ago
Comment removed
TheNutMeg26 1 year ago
I am like, in love with this. Can't stop listening to it!
sherryahovey 1 year ago
THIS PREFORMANCE DUDE IT GIVS ME THE CHILSS EVERY TIME I LISTON TO IT THE LAST PART....MAN ITS TOO COOLTHEY HAVE A WAY WITH WORDS
mastroga21 1 year ago
I really love their boldness in their faith at the end
MetLHed4GZus 1 year ago
zac is such a great drummer xo
paramore is too awesome ^^
stevenvdp24 1 year ago
Oh my goodness..I love Hayley Williams <3 <3
MusicFreak485 1 year ago
this is the best preformance they did for this song. <3
hyphyxgurrl 1 year ago 4
i love how she starts the outro laying on the stage floor
MissMakaylaDW 1 year ago
omg. i am in love with this woman.
Alicia17Alicia 1 year ago