I've watched this clip a million times and just noticed something. Watch Miles' mouth at 1:21. He opens his mouth, cracks a smile and it's like he's about to say, "Damn Trane', you're one bad MOFO" . Also, watch the trombone player at the same point in the video. He takes a second glance after Trane does some more 'gymnastics' on the horn. I bet that doesn't happen when Kenny G takes a solo LOL...............PRICELESS CLIP!
BTW this vid FAILS.....not only does it not have Miles Davis solo (really dont care im a tenorsax playing Coltrane listener).......but it doesnt even have the complete Coltrane solo.....aww man....but yea...these are teh GREATS
Pure powerful genius talent like Clifford Brown was. What a quintet that would have made! They would have 'blown' their brains and our minds right out of our heads or something like that.
@AresCassell yeah i was lol, i wanted to see how many thumbs down i could collect, and how many people would actually take that seriously. johns my favorite tenor saxophonist...
@dvnstvn9 It's cool, man. Anyone who really does think kenny g is better than coltrane needs a kick in the balls. Besides, i could be wrong but I think 7 thumbs down is the most any message can receive.
Look at the other musicains at 1:10 checking Trane out. they are thinking "would you listen to this MF playining his ass OFF!!!" Most musicians don't group together and look at you like that !! Trane had (has) that hypnotizing effect that DEMANDS that you listen.
i'am only 18, one year ago, i've start to listen new things, exploring...i have to say that i'am in love by Jazz and Blues...absolutely amazing. John Coltrane and Miles Davis are legends. Jazz is really deep, is the best music style to express our feelings. thats why some songs touch us...just amazing, i can't say much because i don't have words to describe my passion by jazz...People, continue to talk and posting because i want to know more...thank you!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Hey BoneyMurphy, if you're smart you'll take my advice and stop watching these old black and white videos. Nobody listens to this out dated stuff anymore. Jazz has come a long way.
Check out my band's updated and improved version of the Miles Davis song "So What" if you want to see what MODERN jazz is all about. After seeing the video most folks say our version is better than the original and they are probably right.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Obviously, this guy is just jealous that I'm in a kickass band. Hey rainybaby2000, I advise you stop leaving comments on youtube and use this time to practice. Then myabe someday you'll be able to swing like we do.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
To be honest, my band only recently decided to start recording jazz videos. My drummer's Dad had a record with Miles Davis called "So What" so we learned that song. But other than that, none of us really listen to this kind of music (we used to play all rock and roll). I just thought people would like our new version better.
Perhaps, or are they Lydian? At that time Miles was harmonically influenced by a.o. pianist George Russell, who was deeply into Lydian.
I haven't given up playing, but playing modern jazz solo is difficult for a pianist when it comes to keeping correct time. However, I now ordered a book on Monk and how to play his tunes...
No So what is definitely based upon the dorian mode, the 'so what' chords are based on quartal harmony where the chords are built up of fourths. For some reason in fakebooks and lead charts they tend to put minor 7 chord signs but I think thats so people will assume to use a dorian scale
ausome i have vid of me playing my piano just type in saxtom1 and it will come up with a fore-teen year old boy playing infant eyes a jazz solo by wayne shorter!
They are a Musician's musician. I recently saw Santana wearing a T-shirt with the great Coltrane on it. So I decided to check out Coltrane and I got more than I could have imagined!!!!
Miles Davis, John Coltrane WOW!!!
They are true pioneers and the Best of the Best!!!!!!!
oh they deffinately are. If I infered correctly, your new to the genre...SO you should check out Charles Mingus, Miles Davis's Bitches Brew, Brecker Brothers, Joe Pass.....etc etc
Mattytheman, I think you are right about Adderley. BTW, do you know who was Buckshot LaFunke?
IMO Monk was the heart of bebop. His chord structures were stepping stones for Diz and Bud. An expert once showed me the intro of 'Round Midnight', i.e. how Dizzy played it. A knowledgeable amateur pianist, I was stunned; who in the world would call the chord Eb-Gb-C a C Minor 6? Monk did.
Trane plays so much shit on his solo, that the trombone player had to take a double look. Also, Miles kinda smiled if you look closer at his expression. Trane couldn't have been no more than 30 when this was recorded. His sound is so fresh even after 50 years! Whew!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
RE:peppersax-Trane man-great solo:-D what´s wrong with it? It is your opinion-so I guess-u know what exactly is shit*I can´t help myself- I cannot critisize sound-music of guys like Miles Davis or John Coltrane...
If Miles was overrated then why did all of the great musicians cover his tunes and play in bands with him? It is interesting however that he always said he could never hear the fast stuff which is why his style is more lyrical.
...get your fuckin shit together bro.....dont come here bullshitting everyone just because you think you know alittle something about wat your saying.......take ur shit else where and stop fucking with people.....get a fuckin life man.......ur sick for picking fights like this dood...chill the fuck out and keep these thoughts to ur self....respect the musicians...respect otheres...and most importantly....try to respect yourself.......u've overlooked something major here bro....unforgivable......
What royski9 said was pretty bad, embarrassing and ridiculous. I do get your point, but he just took it way too far. I'll have you know that I rarely comment on any video though, not like you care.
Aha, that's why I couldn't understand why someone who knows the 'changes' could not distinguish So What from a blues. No bad joke, though. don't worry.
At 62, after 40 years, I have given up trying to play modern jazz piano and am reverting to play mainstream jazz and cocktail music. But I still love Getz, Trane, Ornette and Dolphy. Best to you!
haha.. no way do you not know this tune with the name Minor7b5b9. Good try to piss people off... but if you really need to know.. it's called Freddie Freeloader...
Sorry, but no, it's not. Freddie Freeloader is a blues that ends on an inverted diminished chord (when you play in C: Bb 13 instead of C). Here we have the 32 bar AABA pattern of 'So What', A part in D dorian, B part in Eb dorian).
Please notice that i was making a joke off of the Joke that minor7b5b9 made.. I was successful of getting someones attention... I said this dumb comment just so I could show how easy it is to piss people off on here... You really don't have to explain anything.. I was hoping you would get my joke.. This is one of the greatest tunes ever... Hopefully I will one day have the such a great understanding of the triad pairs and what not like trane.. I love this recording. It was a bad joke. DORIAN!
stupidly cut tease... what the h????? i mean... jc is pure... pure soul.. and jazzman 303 is right - they're just getting into his soul when it ends... jc would set it up and take some time to do so... you had to listen... i wonder if miles ever really did. "i can't stop" john said. Miles: "try taking the horn out of your mouth." Contemptuous and vain. why else would he love evans? evans was no challenge to his ego.
Depends what perod you are looking at. I thought Miles was the best at bebop ballads, & some of the stuff he did with his quintets was pure genius."Kind of Blue" in 1959 was a jazz landmark. His use of space in his solos was remarkable. It's not how many notes you play in a given amount of time, it's what you say with the ones you do. I think your own sense of your jazz knowledge & taste is overrated......by you.
.... today is the day Miles left us.... heaven is filled with his sound....17 yrs and I still miss him....now, I'm still buzzin' from this awesome footage...so rare, and extraordinary....every frame, just awesome, and their sounds.... miles.... and trane rippin' up the tracks... I'll be sleepless now.... thanks so much for taking the time to post this priceless footage.!... :)
They Look like they are looking into Trane's Soul at 1:12-17... they also have giant question marks on their face... thinking "How does he come up with such beautiful patterns?"
This is the master exhibiting his craft. I have spent my life (and I am a violinist) trying to get the feel and life in my music that Trane had in his. So many of us were touched by this giant. Thanks so much for sharing this.
Why this short version, when an 8 minute mother is here on yt? Who is kenny g?
This "so what" number is on the "kind of blue" album. It tops jazz sales still. The visual makes it even better. Miles claimed he had the ability to put good people together. Clip saved with thanks.
That kenny g thing is a joke. I dont know how any who appreciates real jazz can like that crap. Trane and Dolphy were the best. Cant forget Hank Mobley.
im gonna pretend like i never heard anyone desecrate John Coltrane's memory with the corporate sellout known as Kenny G. No comparison between the two at all
ello all I finish raising youtube, 2 concerts of the thousand MILES DAVIS one in ROME 1969 AND ANOTHER ONE IN PARIS the quality is good, I hope that you like to look for by PAKOMUSICA
hola todos acabo de subir a youtube, 2 conciertos de miles davis uno en ROMA Y OTRO EN PARIS la calidad es buena, espero que os gusten buscar por PAKOMUSICA
Thanks okavipra. I actually play guitar myself (and not even jazz to tell you the truth), but quality music is quality music. It's so hard to balance instrumental virtuosity with listenability; Coltrane makes it sound easy.
You know who that is on that video LordGothmog? That's Coltrane and Davis, two of the most influential jazz muscians in history. I think your the one who is tone deaf. What kinda music you listen to? How can you not respect them?
I like jazz, man some people don't understand this music but i think it is beacuse you have to listen to many jazz songs before beggining to like it. Other types of music is much easier to like beacuse they are designed for masses
these guys are obviously talented, but there's something missing in the connection of music. It seems like alot of the improvisation is just cycling through a scale without a distinct fluid connection between each note. I know there's more to jazz than just going from A-Z through a scale.
lordgothawhatever, not liking certain kinds of music is your perogative but hurling insults and judgments is childish. Not recognizing talent and genuis in these Jazz players wether you like them or not shows a
weak mind. Coltrane and Davis possessed mind boggling talent.
lordgothmog...its all about improvisation...with this type of jazz...that bullish that people call jazz aka KENNY G is not jazz at all...its easy listening...open ur mind
Thank you man. I love jazz, you can see that from my comments. But this really isn't that great. Wow, Coltrane can can ascend and descend through a few scales with a tone that can be achieved by any 8th grader with proper equipment. And the trumpet solo was pretty bad too.
u idiot kevim, u obviously dont understand train, u got a lot of guts raping train through those comments, train isnt like these smooth jazz bitches that only care about tone, he expresses himself harmonically and through melodys, i think this is a amazing improvisation by miles and train, and i also think that if u love jazz that you should really try to understand
for some people, jazz just truly makes you feel good. i can't help but smile and relax when i hear a swell tune of bebop goodness. i mean hey, some people are just born classy.
this is cool....
desastermaster2010 1 year ago
Trane's solo - most wonderful i've ever heard
bohdanf 1 year ago
wow
andrewcramer13 1 year ago
MILES COLTRANE FOREVER
hugebodylover 1 year ago
"peppersax"... it's so true man!!!!!!you right!!!!!!!!!trane and miles like mozart and beethoven!!!!
marlondavis1000 2 years ago
This is LIFE!!! Thank you SO much for posting!
molinmusic 2 years ago 2
still think this is one of the uploads that validates all of youtube. thank you, vagmez, youtube, ma google
flanissimo 2 years ago
I've watched this clip a million times and just noticed something. Watch Miles' mouth at 1:21. He opens his mouth, cracks a smile and it's like he's about to say, "Damn Trane', you're one bad MOFO" . Also, watch the trombone player at the same point in the video. He takes a second glance after Trane does some more 'gymnastics' on the horn. I bet that doesn't happen when Kenny G takes a solo LOL...............PRICELESS CLIP!
peppersax 2 years ago 4
BTW this vid FAILS.....not only does it not have Miles Davis solo (really dont care im a tenorsax playing Coltrane listener).......but it doesnt even have the complete Coltrane solo.....aww man....but yea...these are teh GREATS
TenorSaxBreed 2 years ago
sax player here........trane ....awesome .......
ebillyboi 2 years ago
Pure powerful genius talent like Clifford Brown was. What a quintet that would have made! They would have 'blown' their brains and our minds right out of our heads or something like that.
adeduction 2 years ago
Coltrane is bad!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
JOLEVONONDRUMS 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
how john coletraine better than kenny g, idont think he is. songbird better than this crap.
dvnstvn9 2 years ago
y did u reply to me!?
JOLEVONONDRUMS 2 years ago
@dvnstvn9 I hope you're joking. Coltrane is one of the best saxophonists ever and kenny g is easy listening.
AresCassell 2 years ago
@AresCassell yeah i was lol, i wanted to see how many thumbs down i could collect, and how many people would actually take that seriously. johns my favorite tenor saxophonist...
dvnstvn9 2 years ago
@dvnstvn9 It's cool, man. Anyone who really does think kenny g is better than coltrane needs a kick in the balls. Besides, i could be wrong but I think 7 thumbs down is the most any message can receive.
AresCassell 2 years ago
You're right. I just tried to give another thumbs down but couldn't.
Kenny G... isn't a pimple on a boil on the ass of Coltrane.
Good lord. What fools these mortals be.
LazlosPlane 2 years ago 2
@AresCassell and Kenny G is a sellout
zm61 2 years ago
What are YOU smoking?
LazlosPlane 2 years ago
he means the good "bad"
TenorSaxBreed 2 years ago
ofcourse
JOLEVONONDRUMS 2 years ago
Look at the other musicains at 1:10 checking Trane out. they are thinking "would you listen to this MF playining his ass OFF!!!" Most musicians don't group together and look at you like that !! Trane had (has) that hypnotizing effect that DEMANDS that you listen.
mumbleora 2 years ago 3
excelente amigo
ernesto336 2 years ago
wow.
Bluessax1 2 years ago
Autodane , you are confusing them with James Brown , the Godfather of Dubbo
ilikezappa 2 years ago
i'am only 18, one year ago, i've start to listen new things, exploring...i have to say that i'am in love by Jazz and Blues...absolutely amazing. John Coltrane and Miles Davis are legends. Jazz is really deep, is the best music style to express our feelings. thats why some songs touch us...just amazing, i can't say much because i don't have words to describe my passion by jazz...People, continue to talk and posting because i want to know more...thank you!!
JonyMurphy 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hey BoneyMurphy, if you're smart you'll take my advice and stop watching these old black and white videos. Nobody listens to this out dated stuff anymore. Jazz has come a long way.
Check out my band's updated and improved version of the Miles Davis song "So What" if you want to see what MODERN jazz is all about. After seeing the video most folks say our version is better than the original and they are probably right.
number1trumpet 2 years ago
Don't get discouraged from listening to these timeless music pieces... he's just trying to get you to listen to his crappy jazz band.
reynababy2000 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Obviously, this guy is just jealous that I'm in a kickass band. Hey rainybaby2000, I advise you stop leaving comments on youtube and use this time to practice. Then myabe someday you'll be able to swing like we do.
Go ahead now, git goin'.
number1trumpet 2 years ago
why are you hating on the old stuff?
the old stuff is bad ass.
especially Davis and Coltrane
trevjazzmajor 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
To be honest, my band only recently decided to start recording jazz videos. My drummer's Dad had a record with Miles Davis called "So What" so we learned that song. But other than that, none of us really listen to this kind of music (we used to play all rock and roll). I just thought people would like our new version better.
number1trumpet 2 years ago
It's not better.
ckyisyourfuture 2 years ago
I am laughing so hard reading about how you are even mentioning yourself in the same sentence as these great!! LMFAO!
lylyprell 2 years ago
Wow you are cocky as hell. I watched that video and its really bad.
guitardude1230 2 years ago
Perhaps, or are they Lydian? At that time Miles was harmonically influenced by a.o. pianist George Russell, who was deeply into Lydian.
I haven't given up playing, but playing modern jazz solo is difficult for a pianist when it comes to keeping correct time. However, I now ordered a book on Monk and how to play his tunes...
BuckshotLaFunke 2 years ago
No So what is definitely based upon the dorian mode, the 'so what' chords are based on quartal harmony where the chords are built up of fourths. For some reason in fakebooks and lead charts they tend to put minor 7 chord signs but I think thats so people will assume to use a dorian scale
Mattytheman91 2 years ago
stellar.
Geoffzx 2 years ago
ausome i have vid of me playing my piano just type in saxtom1 and it will come up with a fore-teen year old boy playing infant eyes a jazz solo by wayne shorter!
saxtom1 2 years ago
god is here
iperuranioangela 2 years ago
Miles Davis and John Coltrane!!!
They are a Musician's musician. I recently saw Santana wearing a T-shirt with the great Coltrane on it. So I decided to check out Coltrane and I got more than I could have imagined!!!!
Miles Davis, John Coltrane WOW!!!
They are true pioneers and the Best of the Best!!!!!!!
Thanks for posting this clip!!!!!!!!!!!
breeskybreesky 2 years ago 11
oh they deffinately are. If I infered correctly, your new to the genre...SO you should check out Charles Mingus, Miles Davis's Bitches Brew, Brecker Brothers, Joe Pass.....etc etc
jeffloomis123 2 years ago
And cannonball addereley, he's on the studio recording of this song, He's a stunningly good player, different to all the other alto players.
Also you want to check out Thelonious Monk, a legend
Mattytheman91 2 years ago
Mattytheman, I think you are right about Adderley. BTW, do you know who was Buckshot LaFunke?
IMO Monk was the heart of bebop. His chord structures were stepping stones for Diz and Bud. An expert once showed me the intro of 'Round Midnight', i.e. how Dizzy played it. A knowledgeable amateur pianist, I was stunned; who in the world would call the chord Eb-Gb-C a C Minor 6? Monk did.
BuckshotLaFunke 2 years ago
i love how everyone that isn't playing is smoking...
rb204 3 years ago 2
Trane plays so much shit on his solo, that the trombone player had to take a double look. Also, Miles kinda smiled if you look closer at his expression. Trane couldn't have been no more than 30 when this was recorded. His sound is so fresh even after 50 years! Whew!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
peppersax 3 years ago 2
RE:peppersax-Trane man-great solo:-D what´s wrong with it? It is your opinion-so I guess-u know what exactly is shit*I can´t help myself- I cannot critisize sound-music of guys like Miles Davis or John Coltrane...
sowhatxy 3 years ago
the song is So what by miles davis
zig007penn 3 years ago
What song is it?
HippieBubbaPower 3 years ago
Comment removed
Raymond66Revalee 3 years ago
This is what jazz is all about. This is the best of the best. They breathe life into jazz music. You feel it as they play it.
2LisaP 3 years ago 8
agreed. Those two guys were among the best musicians to come from Wales. We are very proud of them here in Swansea.
ilikezappa 3 years ago
awesome tunes. every musician's a genius...and its only right to honour each and every one of them. yeo...this is like genius much. lol thanks
ammu765 3 years ago 6
And then He said let there be Cool...and it was Cool... and it was Good
robertclemon 3 years ago 6
fuck, i just LOOOVE Coltrane!!!!!
Sheiswhatithinkheis 3 years ago 2
royski9
If Miles was overrated then why did all of the great musicians cover his tunes and play in bands with him? It is interesting however that he always said he could never hear the fast stuff which is why his style is more lyrical.
dennisoneill4 3 years ago
royski,
Let me guess; you don't care for Picasso or Dylan for the same reason as your disdain for Miles, right !
EAT ME !
The fact that you watched this and looked for fault says everything. You self-riteous little $hit ! I laugh in your general direction, HA !
aammirr 3 years ago
Comment removed
royski9 3 years ago
...get your fuckin shit together bro.....dont come here bullshitting everyone just because you think you know alittle something about wat your saying.......take ur shit else where and stop fucking with people.....get a fuckin life man.......ur sick for picking fights like this dood...chill the fuck out and keep these thoughts to ur self....respect the musicians...respect otheres...and most importantly....try to respect yourself.......u've overlooked something major here bro....unforgivable......
Coltranized 3 years ago
"Dont come here bullshitting everyone just because you think you know alittle something about wat your saying"
"Respect otheres, keep you thoughts to yourself?"
Isn't that talking against youself?
flaxys112 3 years ago
What royski9 said was pretty bad, embarrassing and ridiculous. I do get your point, but he just took it way too far. I'll have you know that I rarely comment on any video though, not like you care.
Coltranized 2 years ago
miles davis se va a fumar un cigarro
asi de siemple
ninorap 3 years ago
miles is crisp sharp and clean but Trane: Train is truly truly beautiful.
KingMinosxxvi 3 years ago
Dude he is my idol! (John Coltrane) I play the alto sax.
Klynn1022 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
dont read this.u will get kissd on da nearest
possible friday by the love of ur life.however
if u dont post this comment to aleast 3 vidioz
u will die in 2 days.mow uv read started
readin dis dunt stop dis iz so scary. send dis
over to 5 vidioz in 143 min, wen ur done press
F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APEAR IN BIG
LETTERZ,IT ACTUALY WORKZ.
wheelywilson 3 years ago
Aha, that's why I couldn't understand why someone who knows the 'changes' could not distinguish So What from a blues. No bad joke, though. don't worry.
At 62, after 40 years, I have given up trying to play modern jazz piano and am reverting to play mainstream jazz and cocktail music. But I still love Getz, Trane, Ornette and Dolphy. Best to you!
BuckshotLaFunke 3 years ago
anyone know the name of this tune?
minor7b5b9 3 years ago 2
haha.. no way do you not know this tune with the name Minor7b5b9. Good try to piss people off... but if you really need to know.. it's called Freddie Freeloader...
Jazzman303 3 years ago 4
Sorry, but no, it's not. Freddie Freeloader is a blues that ends on an inverted diminished chord (when you play in C: Bb 13 instead of C). Here we have the 32 bar AABA pattern of 'So What', A part in D dorian, B part in Eb dorian).
BuckshotLaFunke 3 years ago
Please notice that i was making a joke off of the Joke that minor7b5b9 made.. I was successful of getting someones attention... I said this dumb comment just so I could show how easy it is to piss people off on here... You really don't have to explain anything.. I was hoping you would get my joke.. This is one of the greatest tunes ever... Hopefully I will one day have the such a great understanding of the triad pairs and what not like trane.. I love this recording. It was a bad joke. DORIAN!
Jazzman303 3 years ago 2
hey minor the tune is called "So What"
chazsaysrelax 3 years ago
Thanks Chaz.....I knew I had heard this Coltrane solo before, but just couldn't think of the basic tune; must be getting old :)
minor7b5b9 3 years ago 2
stupidly cut tease... what the h????? i mean... jc is pure... pure soul.. and jazzman 303 is right - they're just getting into his soul when it ends... jc would set it up and take some time to do so... you had to listen... i wonder if miles ever really did. "i can't stop" john said. Miles: "try taking the horn out of your mouth." Contemptuous and vain. why else would he love evans? evans was no challenge to his ego.
dangervich 3 years ago 2
Comment removed
royski9 3 years ago
Relax..just listen
chazsaysrelax 3 years ago 6
Depends what perod you are looking at. I thought Miles was the best at bebop ballads, & some of the stuff he did with his quintets was pure genius."Kind of Blue" in 1959 was a jazz landmark. His use of space in his solos was remarkable. It's not how many notes you play in a given amount of time, it's what you say with the ones you do. I think your own sense of your jazz knowledge & taste is overrated......by you.
minor7b5b9 3 years ago 4
Comment removed
royski9 3 years ago
Comment removed
royski9 3 years ago
jazz is all about listening and enjoying it
jazz requires some learning to enjoy it
dont be mad at the world...
let the world learn it...
jazz is life
live it
nivrin13 3 years ago 6
.... today is the day Miles left us.... heaven is filled with his sound....17 yrs and I still miss him....now, I'm still buzzin' from this awesome footage...so rare, and extraordinary....every frame, just awesome, and their sounds.... miles.... and trane rippin' up the tracks... I'll be sleepless now.... thanks so much for taking the time to post this priceless footage.!... :)
steelcitysong 3 years ago 3
Good stuff. Miles is burning a cigarette and Trane is burnin' down the house
gianc123 3 years ago 5
Miles davis and john coltrane were millionaire's right?
Rapture7171 3 years ago
Miles Was... Trane not so much...
Jazzman303 3 years ago
Monsters!
salitre3 3 years ago
greatest trumpet player + greatest greatest saxaphonist = beautiful music
ElTiant 3 years ago 2
what a duo!!!
pipistrello64 3 years ago
this is more than music.. its a way of life
alx562 3 years ago 4
We are not worthy
Querster 3 years ago 3
Trane... Wow, I just don't have the words.
lancerandy 3 years ago 4
the bunch of jazz cats watching Coltrane at 1:17... they look so sophisticated, I luv it ;)
THEMJZ 3 years ago
lol. those bunch of jazz cats are the rest of the band.
EndlessMike44 3 years ago
LMAO!!...Including Miles!!
YANHAP1 3 years ago
LOL. It seems like everybody was cool back then, don't it?
Poetryisalive 3 years ago 2
They Look like they are looking into Trane's Soul at 1:12-17... they also have giant question marks on their face... thinking "How does he come up with such beautiful patterns?"
Jive Turkeys
Jazzman303 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i am here to refresh the post comment
cosmosfile 3 years ago
Up there...and forever
fruity01 3 years ago 4
This is the master exhibiting his craft. I have spent my life (and I am a violinist) trying to get the feel and life in my music that Trane had in his. So many of us were touched by this giant. Thanks so much for sharing this.
jazgeo 3 years ago 3
This jazz is so 'laid back' there are people talking to each other in the background.
ptpmcc 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
FriendlyFlirts _ COM J0in -> Search Friends -> Chat -> Cam -> much More moxoz kwvzgiyce
Woodyfdggd 3 years ago
FKN..... SUPERGOOD... yin and yang... Miles goes for a lucky strike in the back ground .. those were the days.. baby!
Chookiman 4 years ago 4
those sax combos r light years ahead of its time!
dexxxhunt 4 years ago
best solo........coltrane
tomisvkupjs 4 years ago 5
Just sublime! Legends.
pepseman 4 years ago 2
paul chambers one the best walking bass players of the jazz era
dreadtodred 4 years ago 4
this song is one of the best jazz songs ever made (so What)
seanieboy2725 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Two racist assholes together. They suck ass!
jimmy5x 4 years ago
Why this short version, when an 8 minute mother is here on yt? Who is kenny g?
This "so what" number is on the "kind of blue" album. It tops jazz sales still. The visual makes it even better. Miles claimed he had the ability to put good people together. Clip saved with thanks.
philjquitt 4 years ago 2
Kenny G? LOL!
impactology 4 years ago
That kenny g thing is a joke. I dont know how any who appreciates real jazz can like that crap. Trane and Dolphy were the best. Cant forget Hank Mobley.
cubeguru 4 years ago
hahaha kenny g, that cracks me up
homicidalaficianado 4 years ago
heh yeah, obvious joke :p
IGSXIII 4 years ago
Im sure the Kenny g guy is joking. No person who respects real jazz can stand his bullshit.
Straichen 4 years ago 2
yep
saxophone31 4 years ago
im gonna pretend like i never heard anyone desecrate John Coltrane's memory with the corporate sellout known as Kenny G. No comparison between the two at all
kawazaa 5 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
kenny g is the best ever,coltrane was one of the teachers ,still kenny g is #1
jakopo68 5 years ago
are you nuts, man?!
PenfieldEspinosa 5 years ago
you couldnt be any more wrong, i'll just hope your kidding around.
squintzzz 4 years ago
TWo GODS OF JAZZ..this is a shit hot piece of classic jazz
jazzman2107 5 years ago
ello all I finish raising youtube, 2 concerts of the thousand MILES DAVIS one in ROME 1969 AND ANOTHER ONE IN PARIS the quality is good, I hope that you like to look for by PAKOMUSICA
hola todos acabo de subir a youtube, 2 conciertos de miles davis uno en ROMA Y OTRO EN PARIS la calidad es buena, espero que os gusten buscar por PAKOMUSICA
pakomusica 5 years ago
danh515o
Than i guess that Coltrain has a thing for guitarists which dont play jazz :)))
okavipra 5 years ago
That's understandable. Jimi Hendrix was inspired by John Coltrane's sheets of sound style when Miles played all this stuff for him.
MilesTrane21 4 years ago
Perfect combination
twinchimneys 5 years ago
thanks
hasancihatorter 5 years ago
two giants!!
It´s wonderful
Filirillo 5 years ago
I dont play sax but you have a point danh5150
okavipra 5 years ago
Thanks okavipra. I actually play guitar myself (and not even jazz to tell you the truth), but quality music is quality music. It's so hard to balance instrumental virtuosity with listenability; Coltrane makes it sound easy.
danh5150 5 years ago 2
from what i understand, they just pretty much winged it, have fun everyone, and merrry erxmarxc
gerble1365 5 years ago
two giants! let us now praise famous men!
Hgclaw 5 years ago
thanks
cabritex 5 years ago
never saw him live this was great
dowabo 5 years ago
this is fantastic..true musical expression..this is the music that keeps going, long after commercialized music fades
talon311 5 years ago
my role model
mcabellero 5 years ago
Coltrane is the man. Every time I listen to him, I can't decide whether to hit the woodshed and practice, or just give up. LOL! Thanks for posting ;)
danh5150 5 years ago
You know who that is on that video LordGothmog? That's Coltrane and Davis, two of the most influential jazz muscians in history. I think your the one who is tone deaf. What kinda music you listen to? How can you not respect them?
CFMPmadSfX 5 years ago
I wish i could've heard the whole tune... great great stuff
marclois 5 years ago
gracias
jan000 5 years ago
Supposedly there is a Miles Davis movie coming out!!! Does ne one know when???? Rumor has it that the guy from Hotel Rwanda is gonna be Miles!
PhineasZimbardo 5 years ago
That would be super awesome. The guy you're talking about is Don Cheadle.
There's a movie about Charlie Parker, but I haven't seen it yet.
BassThrasher 4 years ago
I think that movie is called "'Round About Midnight". I never got a chance to watch that yet
PhineasZimbardo 4 years ago
Actually, I was referring to a movie called "Bird", directed by Clint Eastwood.
I really want to watch it.
BassThrasher 4 years ago
that sounds promising as well--have to keep my eye out for both
PhineasZimbardo 4 years ago
"Actually, I was referring to a movie called "Bird", directed by Clint Eastwood.
I really want to watch it".
It's fantastic. Tragic (well it would be, I suppose) but fantastic nonetheless. Its the best thing I've ever seen Forrest Whittikar in, certainly.
SeanVernell 4 years ago
Man, Coltrane smokes on that riff. The guys in the background definitely know they're in the right place.
tellysarmy 5 years ago
lord gothmog , do you prefer 50 cent??? lol
slashisnotdead38 5 years ago
Beautifull!
kocisko 5 years ago
I like jazz, man some people don't understand this music but i think it is beacuse you have to listen to many jazz songs before beggining to like it. Other types of music is much easier to like beacuse they are designed for masses
asusnjar 5 years ago
YES! YES ! TRUE CREATORZ TILL THEIR END..
I HAVE THIS ON VHS. "THE WORLD ACCORDING TO JOHN COLTRANE" Dam it ! I love it. not like the prententious stuff you get now a dayz..
eddiemambo 5 years ago
improvisation is more about what u feel than what u know
Saxophonic 5 years ago
it has nothing to do with looking smart, it's knowing whats good music and bad music. this is good music.
animalmother16 5 years ago
these guys are obviously talented, but there's something missing in the connection of music. It seems like alot of the improvisation is just cycling through a scale without a distinct fluid connection between each note. I know there's more to jazz than just going from A-Z through a scale.
spidermonk23 5 years ago
lordgothawhatever, not liking certain kinds of music is your perogative but hurling insults and judgments is childish. Not recognizing talent and genuis in these Jazz players wether you like them or not shows a
weak mind. Coltrane and Davis possessed mind boggling talent.
joeylittle 5 years ago
Sublime...
IceFloeHyoga 5 years ago
Man that was enjoyable! Lordgothmog, you just don't get it. Africarolina has it right.
dazedandconfucious 5 years ago
i love john coltrane but i have to say that every solo sounds like a solo from blue train
CPBach 5 years ago
hurts your ears!!! your talking about miles and train here
blackcatbone 5 years ago
The masters!
nameisunique 5 years ago
masters in a delve we are so glad-smirky to recieve .... dang, beat
seleluxtc 5 years ago
exactly!
rogeryvon 5 years ago
lordgothmog...its all about improvisation...with this type of jazz...that bullish that people call jazz aka KENNY G is not jazz at all...its easy listening...open ur mind
Africarolina 5 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This shit hurts my ears! Are you pretending to like this because you think it makes you look smart, or are you all tone deaf. This sucks.
LordGothmog 5 years ago
so wtf are u doing here?
kobethefreak 5 years ago
you thick bastard
rowanrow 5 years ago
go back to playing dungeons and dragons fuckbomb...
negroidster 5 years ago
Thank you man. I love jazz, you can see that from my comments. But this really isn't that great. Wow, Coltrane can can ascend and descend through a few scales with a tone that can be achieved by any 8th grader with proper equipment. And the trumpet solo was pretty bad too.
Kevim8 5 years ago
You are an idiot
trumpetman1970 5 years ago
u idiot kevim, u obviously dont understand train, u got a lot of guts raping train through those comments, train isnt like these smooth jazz bitches that only care about tone, he expresses himself harmonically and through melodys, i think this is a amazing improvisation by miles and train, and i also think that if u love jazz that you should really try to understand
Saxophonic 5 years ago
for some people, jazz just truly makes you feel good. i can't help but smile and relax when i hear a swell tune of bebop goodness. i mean hey, some people are just born classy.
Powerbomb12288 4 years ago
truth. listening to jazz makes me feel damn good. almost as good as when i play it
squintzzz 4 years ago
thats music !
gabrielgabriel2000 5 years ago
man, trane was so inspired, he couldn't have had a better name, like a "train"
sysphus13 5 years ago
Abslutely!!! Called train...
vgamez19 5 years ago
no substitute for him