it's as if bach jumped 250 years into the future to compose this aria. considering the text, i find it much more appropriate than the faster dance-like tempi that most other performers take.
a very touching performance which can easily bring me to tears.
Though this version clocks in nearly three minutes longer than most, I have never heard it sung with more gentility , fluidity and pathos. To me, Luxon expresses the text better than I personally have ever heard. Luxon's interpretation takes away the more "dance-like pastorale" feeling, and replaces it with a devotional quality that allows his rich voice to express and savour each phrase. Thank you so much for posting this. You have given me new life to an old aria.
his interpretation in the most natural I heard. Just beautiful simplicity. This narration is so honest. you get the full matthaus before and after this song inside his singing. balance of organ and oboi is so delicate.
@interpreterr Can't say I find it too slow - the phrase has a wonderful sense of elasticity, and allows Ben's voice to caress the words in that magical way of his. As for it not being historically informed - to me, if it's a choice between hearing the piece exactly as Bach might have expected to, or with the benefit of modern instruments and a technically perfect singer - well, I know which I go for. Chacun a son gout, of course.
it's as if bach jumped 250 years into the future to compose this aria. considering the text, i find it much more appropriate than the faster dance-like tempi that most other performers take.
a very touching performance which can easily bring me to tears.
blueeyedbehr 10 months ago
Though this version clocks in nearly three minutes longer than most, I have never heard it sung with more gentility , fluidity and pathos. To me, Luxon expresses the text better than I personally have ever heard. Luxon's interpretation takes away the more "dance-like pastorale" feeling, and replaces it with a devotional quality that allows his rich voice to express and savour each phrase. Thank you so much for posting this. You have given me new life to an old aria.
redbrian3655 1 year ago 5
Benjamin Luxon est sublime comme à son habitude!
tidaliumpelo 1 year ago
his interpretation in the most natural I heard. Just beautiful simplicity. This narration is so honest. you get the full matthaus before and after this song inside his singing. balance of organ and oboi is so delicate.
gilad1arnon 1 year ago
certainly on the slow side - but a lovely, elegant voice.
mcgill3432 1 year ago
omg kann man das noch langsamer singen?? das ist ja fürchterlich schnell! da kommt ja niemand mehr mit!!!
assertLime 1 year ago 2
This man had the most beautiful baritone voice ever. Thank you for posting.
bassfanne45 1 year ago
Wonderful. moving and elegant performance by B. Luxon. Thank you!
mariandelochs 1 year ago
This is such a monumentally comforting moment in the Passion. Beautiful singing.
drtmuir 2 years ago
Luxon has one of the most beautiful voices I have ever heard...elegant, effortless, and crystal clear.
redhead529 2 years ago
Very slow and certainly not very historically informed :), but who cares - it's wonderful (Luxon sounds fantastic here). Thanks for sharing!
interpreterr 2 years ago
@interpreterr Can't say I find it too slow - the phrase has a wonderful sense of elasticity, and allows Ben's voice to caress the words in that magical way of his. As for it not being historically informed - to me, if it's a choice between hearing the piece exactly as Bach might have expected to, or with the benefit of modern instruments and a technically perfect singer - well, I know which I go for. Chacun a son gout, of course.
allybari 1 year ago
@allybari Agree!
interpreterr 1 year ago