Added: 1 year ago
From: BritneyFansSite
Views: 85,026
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (530)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Really good video. You are so sweet with the comments You put on screen during the like a virgin performance :-) and yes...ofcurse she can sing live.. she has a beautiful voice. I will always love and support her. Thank You for the great video.

  • 04:07 não é Live, é Playback

  • Hmmm Circus was pre recorded.... Like a Virgin and Everytome too.

  • Everytime on the Circus Tour wasn't live.

  • of course that she can sing! and has a beautiful voice!

  • like at 4:20 when she says "when ya dancin this" in stead of saying the "yeah" she was supposed to, she went straight into the chorus. so she was lip synching at the david letterman show.

  • I love britneys songs cuz her ptoducers r frikkin amazing but if u think what she is singing into a mike is what u r hearing, ur drunk lol

  • of cos britney can sing.........^^

  • like a virgin isnt live. xtina was and madonna was but not britney. shame

  • @mrinvincible2001 she was live lol

  • the slave part the same, like a virgin the same

  • the Oops part it's not live it's a pre recorded vocals

  • @soylakekagalindo yes is live

  • love everytime live

  • Britney Spears could sing before. But not anymore! With last christmas a concert of her was on TV. She playbacked all of it and she could not dance like she always did! But still love her! :)

  • unique voice, good singing doesn't have to be just a strong voice

  • circus isn't live! it's just a tour version, becouse this version is on all videos of this performance just in the other citys

  • its hard to sing live and dance at the same time ...

  • She can sing live but it doesnt sounds good!

  • whatever she is lypnsync all the circus tour...the world cant be wrong...sorry..ok she can sing live but in circus she didint

  • I've seen and heard her sing live on quite a number of other occasions which are not even on this video. I'm a huge fan and seen heaps! She's amazing live.

  • she has a beautiful voice even know she can sing 100% beautiful dont judge someone you dont even know its rude and disrespectful

  • Thanks for this. She's fantastic.

  • She could sing when she was 10. But stop trying to prove she can sing when she was famous, even the performances that you say are good are awful.

  • @jjoeshaw dont judge someone you dont know she had a beautiful voice when she was young and her voice became more beautiful now 100%

  • @ania44445 No it isn't, it's incredibly weak and shaky...

  • brit is great. I'll always support her. <3

  • The last thing im going to say is that at ther "satisfaction/oops" vma perfomance she's singing live the first minute, when she's like " i can't get no, satisfaction, when im watching the tv..." that it's all pre recorded too. Don't belive me if u don't want to, all u can do is do the research in internet and by hearing other stuff, u'll know

  • Slave on letterman 3:53 it's the exact same "live vocal" from mtv vma's 2001 and the DWAD tour so if ur smart enought to tell, u'll know she ain't singing live there. Also, at 8:02 she's again NOT singing live, she's doing playback over the live studio vocals from her circus tour....im sorry to be the one telling you this but it's just so obvious to me. Sorry

  • @abdalaoviedo umm she is singing live i think your blind ok

  • @ania44445 Wouldn't you mean "deaf" not "blind"?

  • @ania44445 But I agree Britney does sing live. She did lipsync most of Circus but it had it's moments. Femme Fatale though was almost all live. :)

  • well done

  • @MsUnknown220 have u heard of all her songs and seen all of her LIVE performances? She has a GREAT voice!!!

  • Britney is an horrible singer, maybe at the beginning of her carreer she could sing and dance but now she is fat, and she cannot sing nor sing at all!!

  • sorry but the circus tour was in totally playback =S!!

  • @JMFG92 i was their at the tour she sang live

  • @ania44445 is not true!! was a great show but..she dont sing live sorry =)

  • @ania44445 she can sing live..but circus was in lypsinc

  • love this video...Beautiful. Talented. great personality. Of course there will be haters.

  • LOL KELLY OSBOURNE! @5:50

  • she can't sing like a pro

    many peaple here can sing so much better than she/ 

  • She doesn't sing when she is dancing like a pro, she doesn't dance when she's singing like a pro. :(

  • Comment removed

  • she looks prettier with brown hair who agees with me

  • And yes she did or still does smoke

  • boys wasnt live I guess but yes she can sing live and in femme fatale tour whe pooved it! : )

  • @givi1991 She lip-synced femme fatale...

  • She used to sing very well, BUT NOW SHE SUCKS!!

  • Comment removed

  • good

  • lovely

  • Hardly any of these are live...

  • yes she did sing back in day but after babies it is known that ur vice can change i don't believe she sings live anymore but onhwell she still makes great music

  • The Like a Virgin, Circus, Part are NOT LIVE!!!

  • very week voice. maybe she smoke...

  • She can sing, but shes inconsistant live. Probably touring too much.

  • Ofcourse she can sing! She is after called the princess of pop :)

  • @I2HS

    No, she can't sing!!!

  • obviously now it gets harder for her to sing live because of the nerves and emotion you feel on a stage. I know it because i sing. obviously it's not the same , but simillar... :)

  • the QUEEN of POP britney spears. and she can still sing live .

  • It's a shame that Britney fans still have to show the world she can sing. It only tells how much prejudice there is against her. People take for granted that pretty much any other singer can sing, but deny that Britney can and when she does and it's pitch-perfect, they say that she's lip-synching all of it. The truth is she can sing perfectly in tune, she masters many techniques and she's a pro in singing. Plus, I think her voice is beautiful, unique and one of the very few that are expressive.

  • @aldisbrit

    Well, one thing you made clear; you are a big fan of britney. So was I when I was a little kid and didnt know the real essence and beauty of music.

    Everything I said is indeed my opinion, its not that I spoke about the second law of thermodynamics. What can I say; Res Ipsa Loquitur.

    The only one who seems to have a problem here, is you. Take it easy. I totally do not agree with you, but I would have years ago when I knew few about music.

  • @Masherin well, I'm 30 and for me the real essence and beauty of music is in hers. And trust me, I've listened attentively to hundreds of CDs of different genres and periods and got information about artists and their music. So, if your idea was belittling my opinion and making me look like a stupid 10-year-old kid with no musical culture, sorry for you. Try that with little monsters. You may be much luckier.

  • @Masherin and no, I got no problem. But I certainly don't allow people to write things that are completely wrong and make them look like the bible of music or express their opinion and make it look like facts. Some of the things you wrote are completely denied by facts (for instance, the number of songs she wrote, which shows that either you don't have her CDs or you can't count) and others are just personal opinions.

  • @aldisbrit

    And one big thing: Seriously, how can you say that there are not any singers who never playback!? How can you say that? :S Just to name a few; Tarja turunen NEVER playbacks, Anneke van Giersbergen etc etc etc, I can name sooo many! Sarah Brightman also never does! I believe also Aretha Franklink, but I am not very sure about her.

    We can discuss about this for many years but Britney spears ruined her voice by not rehearsing/training and taking care of herself. And yes, my opinion.

  • @Masherin first of all, you can't have possibly seen all of those artists' performances, so you can't say with certainty that they NEVER lip-synched. And even if they didn't, I was talking about BIG NAMES, and except for Sarah Brightman (up to a certain extent) and Aretha Frankin, you mentioned none. I'm sure there are thousands of singers who have never lip-synched, but they have never even had a chance to.

  • @aldisbrit lip-synching has been a part of the music landscape at least since the 60's. TV performances were all lip-synched at the beginning. Live pop performances traditionally blend music and singing with dance, acting, costumes and many other show elements. It's obvious that singing is just one element of it. Sometimes it's 100% live, sometimes it isn't. If you want to listen to vocals attentively, you listen to the CD. That's the way it is, like it or not.

  • @aldisbrit

    Thats the way it is for you, since you listen to very different music than I do. I find many bands much better life because of the voice. End of discussion, have a nice day.

  • @Masherin WHO ARE YOU 'END OF DISCUSSION'?! Playback....WHO CARES!!!!!!!???????SHE IS STILL AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!LIVE WITH IT.

  • @aldisbrit

    I know they never playback, never ever. The names I mentioned are very BIG in a certain genre, + they are not commercial. Ray Charles, Kurt cobain...elvis?...stevie wonder, Bob dylan... I can keep going on but the main point is; yes there are singers who dont playback and you said there were not any.

  • she used to be smokin!

  • A real singer improves, trains her voice and never comes up with some splayback. Dumb sheep buy all commercial shit and keep going to her concerts, yelling oh-so-happy, while its just a dance show on a music tape. If you only knew the beauty of true music..

    britney spears is NOT an artist/musician. In here whole career she wrote 8 songs, which totally failed...she cannot even write a note. if she had great vocals it wouldnt matter but she has not. She's an entertainer for an average soul.

  • @Masherin you're wrong about everything. Britney wrote some 10 songs that ended up on CD and hundreds more than didn't make the cut. She plays the piano and uses it to write songs. And if for you she doesn'ty have great vocals, then that's your problem. It's certainly not a scientific fact. It depends on personal tastes. Luckily enough, some like me don't care about pointless acrobatics and displays of power and care about expression and interpretation.

  • @Masherin unlike those big-voiced singers you probably think are great, who spit out high notes and evolutions at random, just to show how good they are, her vocals match the lyrics. It's producers and songwriters themselves who say that she's a pro when it comes to vocals. And if you think that a "real singer" "never comes up with playback", then I'm afraid there aren't any real singers out there. Name one artist and you're sure she lip-synchs here and there.

  • @Masherin and don't play the game of Mr Know-it-all who can tell what real music is and what isn't, who's a professional singer and who isn't. Music is always a matter of tastes. There's nothing scientific about it, except for the strict definitions (range, type of voice, techniques mastered, etc.) and the numbers (chart positions, numbers sold, etc.). The rest is open for discussion and your reasoned opinion is as good as mine. Nobody's right or wrong.

  • @Masherin the problem is your opinion stems from ignorance. What you say shows that you don't know the artist you're talking about. If you know her, it's very superficial knowledge. If you knew her well, you'd know that she's been studying singing since she was 3, that she won a lot of singing competitions, that she attended the Professional Performing Arts School in New York, that she writes a lot and that she taught herself to play the piano.

  • @Masherin one last thing: the most pathetic thing one can say is that an artist he doesn't like isn't an artist. It's really immature. It means that you're so naive that you believe you're in a position to say what everybody should think. But anybody with some brains knows that nobody is in such a position. Everybody can speak for themselves only. The only facts that everybody MUST take for granted and nobody can object to are scientific facts. There aren't any here.

  • @Masherin by the way, I counted all the songs co-written by her and released and they're 24. And she didn't even have to write them because she's a singer and a singer is by definition somebody who sings professionally. Writing isn't part of the definition. A singer might or might not and if she doesn't, it doesn't make her a worse singer. Then again, if you don't like her vocals or voice, it's your taste, but it's not a scientific fact, so it counts as much as my finding them great.

  • There are some places where she's not singing in your video........ ;) But, I saw her in her Femme Fatale Tour this summer, and she was singing live (Not all the time, but..) ! We love Britney, no matter what happen.

  • funny cause at da end of the day while people r talking smack she is still rising n she wouldnt b up there for nothing so lmfao n also people fucken swear they know she dont sing like dam really r u with her 24/7 to know this...

  • so if u want a singer always screaming 2 da top of her lungs then u want a opera singer n brit is not in that category, da girl can sing people always wanna talk shit but seem 2 forget she's also a dancer n she does have talent n da girl can surely put on a show i've been 2 a couple of concerts n she makes ur money worth....

  • Bitch cant hit a high note. Period.!!! NOOOOW MOTHER MONSTER ON THE OTHER HAND!! (GAGA) FORGET ABOUT IT!!.....SHES AMAZING! THE REAL QUEEN OF POP BITCHES! p.s(she never uses play back!!) EVER!

  • ok in "Everytime" I guess she was under something..LOL

  • I saw her on november 24. She didn't sing anything live.

  • This woman sings horrible here shows that all it does is to exploit beauties united states no matter how you look just sing her ass

  • she can sing ok but her image sucks.

  • A lot of those were live, but a few weren't. OIDA tour was not live, the entire show was prerecorded "live" vocals, hence why every city sounds exactly the same. So was the Like a Virgin, and Circus. There's more to singing live than just having non-album vocals and you can just tell if you watch her lips, expression and body language. She keeps her torso and lips very stiff when she's actually singing.

  • still gives me goosebumps... everytime.

  • So sad that she lost a lot of that confidence she once had! Love her to pieces!!!

  • the circus performance isnt live... just sayin.

  • whets the name of the song that britney spears is singing at 05:28 i'd really like to know please tell me

  • @princess8950 Madonna's like a virgin.

  • @princess8950 like a virgin by madonna

  • shes really good!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • did you REALLY have to put a description of the video OVER the video. people like to WATCH the video as much as they like to listen to it.

  • @Just90sPop Rihanna has had more number ones than Britney HAHAHAHAH! And watch Rihanna's AOL sessions and tell me she can't sing...

  • @Just90sPop I'm not a "nigger" hahahaha. And Britney doesn't even dance. Watch her on the billboard awards with Rihanna, Rihanna sounds amazing while Britney just lip syncs...

  • @jjoeshaw LMAO @ britney doesn't dance. britney could outdance rihanna in her sleep, and outsing her too. cry about it. go watch britney's TRL 2003 performances and her ABC special in 03... none of your faves could ever. never mind her LEGENDARY vma performances. i feel so bad for you fans of these flops. britney was the last TRUE pop star.

  • @bgirlfan1 yes, but what year was that? And what year is it now? OH WAIT. That was 8 years ago. Britney can NOT sing.

  • @jjoeshaw Look up "up n down live abu dhabi" she CAN sing and LIVE too(: crappy video but great audio lol

  • @jjoeshaw lmao. She still can sing live she's been doing it on tour this whole time and if you go and listen to her raw vocals on the femme fatal cd it sounds really good.

  • @bgirlfan1 THANK YOU! haha Britney is Amazing! (:

  • I HATE HER BABY ONE MORE TIME's PERFOMANCES ON 90's!!!!!!! ARE SO BORING!!!!

  • 06:13 MY EARS!

  • all the actual live vocals in this are still horrible...

  • @jjoeshaw who are u stupid piece of shit ????? britney SINGS ,DANCES AND MORE !!! what do you do for a living ??? complaining about someone that has a better life than you ??? please grow up stupid piece of shit ,britney is a performer not a SINGER ,if she sings in a performance is actually and extra thing that she does for us , if u wanna listen to someone go to a lady crapga concert or to a floptina aguilera concert , brit is in a different level ,she´s goddess of pop , get it ??? ASSHOLE !!

  • @Just90sPop Hahahaha this is hilarious. Britney doesn't dance, she just moves around. And Britney doesn't have a better life than me, after all, have you heard about her breakdown? And please type properly uneducated cunt!

  • The fact you need a video to prove she can sing is really, really sad...

  • i love the video.. only problem is circus was 100 % play back and pre recorded vocals.. femme fatale there were alot of live vocal.. great job on the video :D

  • Terrible.

  • @46spoony exactly, it's still not even good.

  • FACT: this way back in the 90's it is now 2011, she cant even sing anymore caz she being forced to perform and make music.

  • britney is beautiful with brown hair! 6:41

  • 02:32 - 04:30 , 05:20 - 06:06 , 07:30 - 08:31 , 09:00 -09:49 definitely not live! is pre-recording..

  • When i saw britney she sang live and was beautiful

  • very nice !! i so love brit !!!1

  • Most of the videos you posted are playback. I honestly think that she can sing, but she hasn't do it a long time ago. The part from I can't get no satisfaction, and when she sings with madonna her voice is pre-recorded. That's why it sounds as if she was singing live.

  • Most of the videos you posted are playback.

  • Britney's voice is unique & I love it, I hope she sings more live though 

  • ma andate a cagare!

  • people dont u understand shes an act!!!!???

    she doesnt know how to fucking sing not even when she was little!!!

    she s just a pruct! a pretty one!!

    she is designed to hiptotize us through her stupid voice!

    she even messes up during lipsinging and dancing!

    u can see it 3 times whn she sings im a slave for u in 2001 she nonly sung 3 seconds of the song and she sounded horrible!

    please wake up !

  • my all time fave.....:)

  • I wish I could see her Onyx Hotel Tour .. :(

  • does it really matter what these assholes think about britney?WE LOVE YOU BRITNEY.you are my inspiration!people are always talking about her,so talk,keep our idol in the news,we love it.i just don't get why people spend time even watching her videos and then pick apart everything and talk about how terrible she is if THEY DON'T LIKE HER?wtf is that about?the folks doing that are the ones who look like effing comic book guy on the simpsons :) WE LOVE YOU BRITNEY SPEARS!!!

  • whoever made this is dreaming. most are pre-recorded and lip-synched. get over it.... SHE'S A HACK!!

  • Avril Lavigne ♥

  • think about half of them are pre recorded and  the other half are lipsinging.........shes ok..... thumbs up if u agree with me

  • @movicangel mmmm I Think nobody is agree ! so BACK OFFFFF !

  • think about half of them are pre recorded and the other half are lipsinging.........shes ok

  • I'm sorry but the Donny & Marie vocals were "awesome?" Really? Half of these are lipped by the way. She lost her voice when she hit puberty, truly.

  • even in this video, there are pre-recorded ones.

  • Her Circus performance was playback. Her real singing voice was pre-recorded then she just sang with it. But Everytime I will probably believe.

  • And You know that artist will record their voices live before a performace and then play that back right so they can dance...Beyonce does that all the time too.

  • Ok, so why can't she sing live now? People do pay to see live music.

  • i don't get why she was able to sing and hit a HI! note and now she can't hardly sing good i mean she sings live at her FF tour but she had some chops on her when she was a child how come she doesn't have them now as an adult?? probably all that stupid smoking...

  • she can sing. :) she sound like the young taylor swift when she's young :D

  • MIN ;027 OMG!!

  • Circus Tour she sung nothing!!!! other then sitting on a sing for like 1 min over a track and that was horrible!!!!

  • She was good BUT Now she is crap! no passion just doing what she is being told, just like a puppet. She seems she has lost her spark.

  • The Slave Letterman performance is most playback with her occasionally singing along

  • youtube.com/watch?v=P9zGEzY9Oh­Q

  • And to all those she's not as good as-ers...Are you s good as Britney or Lady GaGa? I didn't think so :)

  • Wah wah wah...she's not as good as...Gosh it gets annoying hearing that all the time, on every Britney video. Yeah, she's not like GaGa but who cares? I'm a GaGa fan and I love her just as much as Britney as I love Mariah and Selena...not Gomez. If you're a real fan you'll love Britney because she's--well..Britney she may not meet everyone's demands but you can't please everyone. I love Britney, I loved her 2007 VMA performance and even if she hits rock bottom I'll love her!!!!!!

  • Shes good, but not as good as Gaga.

  • honey..not everything you say here its live is really live...sorry

  • @salvationDANCE prove it

  • @cool4790 just listen!!!

  • @salvationDANCE i did and they all sounded live

  • @cool4790 just to make that sure....i also like britney...but she is not a good singer...and in your video are A LOT fullplayback moments..sorry for you..

  • this is a great video.....

  • OMGGG i could not take my eyes off of her!! Thank you so much for posting thing!! the world need to get over her break down! Britney has been back for a long and she has been giving it to us everytime :) She Is 100000000% amazing! and she always will be!!!! SHE IS THE FREAKING QUEEN of POP! Do you know if there are any videos of Britney and Justin? live performances or anything when them both together??

  • lol

    

  • OMG!!! Jayden looks just like her!!!

  • Her voice is still pretty strong.

  • Yea. Not arguin! Awesome! She definitely use to have a good voice.

  • britney is the true queen of pop yeehheyy

  • I'M GOING TO WRITE IN CAPS THAT'S DEFINITELY GOING TO GIVE MYSELF AND BRITNEY CREDIBILITY AND NOT MAKE ME LOOK WEIRD.

  • I JUST LOVE BRITNEY SPEARS. I DON'T CARE TOO MUCH IF SHE SINGS EVERYTIME I HEAR HER VOICE. I FEEL LIKE HOME (8)

  • her voice does not sound natural. it sounds very forced

  • who cares if she can she can sing live?? i just wanna see her dance like a whore

  • "its beacuase of her smoking" .... AND drinking and drugs lol damn her! she's still the goddess of pop and every woman!

  • "I'm a Slave 4 U" at David's, "Like a Virgin" at VMA (Madonna was furious when Brit lipped it on the final performance, she didn't in the rehearsals) are lipsynch... I'm really surprised watching her singing Live at Circus Tour :O I'm excited for the DVD of Femme Fatale cuz she sang more songs live than on the other shows :D

  • 8:53 thats where she lip synced, great video though :)

  • she can sing live but not when she dancing because it's so hard to do that you sing perfecly when you dance and sing in the same time well yes she can but she don't sing all the time in live

  • i love this videoo!!

  • Singing live or not BRITNEY STILL SUCKS.LOL

  • @KatieMc618 So you're calling one of the best selling female artist in AMERICAN HISTORY suckish? Britney is our generations queen and has influenced a decades worth of people. She is a living legend and no one will defeat her. Yes i admit now she is not like she was.She used to be a kick ass dancer and singer and a mega star. either way she is an honorable name in music and how dare u insult her? -.- ignorant bitches..

  • I love Britney, but sadly, she didn't sing live on the Circus tour. Except for maybe a few occasions. And I'm pretty sure the Everytime video is fake.