i tell you what i was thinking: I think people are simply BRAINWASHED by the society and media. Seriously, how the hell we wanna know, what kind of women he prefers? to me he doesn't seem to be a shallow person to me.
ok he is with anna kournikowa but that doesn't mean anything. after seeing this i truly believe that he doesn't give a shit about the look. people need to change including myself. i also was shocked when he kissed her. but it's a beautiful thing.let's be honest
@joejonas886 ...I know what you mean, and you are correct. But I think of it like this...it shows what a nice guy he really is. HE has. YOu know he could have ANY girl in that audience...and around the world. I know that she wouldn't be picked by most people....but what does that say to the guy who could have ANYBODY? I mean really....he could still my wife right now! Lol
i don't know her personally, but i've spoken to her through his forum and she's very sweet a true fan and deserves it good for you melissa!!! now this year it's my turn >=) haha
@HongPhuongNguyen she is not ugly she is different!!!and that says a lot about him!!!!it would be cliche to choose the thin girl!!!he is not discriminatin!!!besides real women have curves!!!!!!
There is no way I would contain myself for 5 minutes!!! He is a sweetheart, how he made this truly beautiful girl feel. I bet he smells so good, definitely the perfect man I would like to have.
She was pretty calm considering the sex god Enrique was touching her. >.< I would be like hyperventilating or something. Lmao. But goodness, he is so fricken sweet. :) I'll be so happy if I were her. Lucky.
Oh dam that lady is so lucky! Grrr I live in NYC too and am SO jealous that wasn't me! Haha seriously though good for her! She's got millions of us women who wish we could've been in her place lol
He does this at the end or Hero in most of his concerts...its not a big deal. Spainards are very passionate people. Plus he has a girlfriend. So its just an act for him.
All of of you who are picking on the girl... calling her fat, a bitch, even making racist comments you all are PATHETIC. It is a song he does it in just about every ending of that song.
And I gurantee you even if you did meet him he would not want to stay around you for long because all you haters are completly disgusting and ugly on the inside. And it will not get you anywhere in life.
Oh, man!! I wish I were that girl...well, not literally...but I wish I was in her place there. I would have gone BUNKERS!! Enrique id talented, SEXY and HOT!
hahahaha wtf??????????????? ok thats fucking weird im trying understand that cause i cant its ridiculous that girl is a nigga ugly fat and he kissed her? :O im shocked ok
@91359075 WOW YOU ARE A DUMB FUCK. BY THE LOOK OF IT YOU PROBABLY HAVE GOTTEN MADE FUN OF YOUR WHOLE FUCKING LIFE. END YOURSELF DUMB FUCK. YOU BEEN BLOCKED. AND TAKE CARE OF YOUR OWN LIFE CAUSE ITS PROBABLY SHIT ANYWAY.
@Universal237 FUCK OFF YOUR A FUCKING ANNOYING PIECE OF SHIT STOP SENDING MESSAGES TO ME FUCKING FAG QUEER YOU ARE BLOCKED NOT ME AND NOW YOUR PLAYER ARE IGNORED FUCKIN BITCH
Oh mulher de sorte....todos os artitas deveriam ter esse carinho e respeito que ele tem com as fãs.....Ele conquistou o meu carinho por isso.....oh homem lindo.....
@Daniele21love Concordo com você Daniele. Todos os artistas deveriam ter esse carinho e respeito pelos seus fãs! ... Nossa eu adorei ver esse vídeo... Isso só me faz adimirá-lo cada vez mais. É um cantor maravilhoso! E LINDO demais!!! ... Que mulher de sorte! Quem me dera ter uma chance dessas!
I would have just simply melted from happiness if Enrique sang to me. :-) He is so handsome, everything is so attractive about him: his voice, looks, inner kindness. If there were more people on this earth like him, world would have been such a great place.
That is awesome! How cool of him to take it to the fans:) I would love to be her, so happy for her, I could not keep it together as much as she is:); I would turn bright red lol. How amazing of Enrique, it would be weird, I think, though to sing a song written for someone else to someone you don't know, good job.
Hahahaha the girl was randomly choosen....I have been to two of his concerts here in Mexico and in both of those concerts he choose random girls from the audience and kissed them...hes really nice, he always like to interact with the fans and in one of the concerts he choose a couple who were celebrating their like 3 month aniversary and he brought them up on stage and took tequila shots with them
Dam people respect him he's been in pause since his last hit, DURING 9/11!!!!! Besides he's just singing this song too for the 9th anniversary in 2 months
Dear God. If he can look at a complete stranger that way, and kiss her like THAT, what in the CRAP, can he do to his wife? I mean, he'd have totally fooled me. He's so freakin' hot, I swear. Lucky bitch!! (:
Nowwould udiefor the one u love ? Absloutley i wouldnt
Hanmoz 3 days ago
he sings will all of his HEART !!! :)
Awesome song.. Awesome Singer.. Awesome GUY !!!
Sweetybboy 3 weeks ago
Now would you die for the one you love? I would
melissawarrenx 1 month ago
i tell you what i was thinking: I think people are simply BRAINWASHED by the society and media. Seriously, how the hell we wanna know, what kind of women he prefers? to me he doesn't seem to be a shallow person to me.
ok he is with anna kournikowa but that doesn't mean anything. after seeing this i truly believe that he doesn't give a shit about the look. people need to change including myself. i also was shocked when he kissed her. but it's a beautiful thing.let's be honest
TheJenny8888 1 month ago
ohmygooooosh i wish i was that girl
fairytalecookies 2 months ago
wTf!! I want TO be THT GIRl!!!!! i wAnt TO BE WIT eNrIQUE!!!
nickyhenriques 2 months ago
that Motherfucker is Smart
FifahacksOnly 3 months ago
she is gorgeous y'alll of insecure bitches
lou18is 4 months ago
she is so beautiful inside her heart
ChinLeeTeamSwift 4 months ago
Lucky fan... She is the luckiest girl in the world and if that were me, I wouldn't have had a better time in my life. <3 I love you, Enrique.
wizardsrule88 5 months ago
Lucky fan... She is the luckiest girl in te world and if that were me, I wouldn't have had a better time in my life. <3 I love you, Enrique.
wizardsrule88 5 months ago 2
I would have frenched her
MrPapabush 5 months ago
he said he picked her, because he saw her before at a his concert and knows that's a true fan
waterLily091 5 months ago
............
pinkskatepiano 5 months ago
That was awesome, she should be more than happy for living that experience :P congrats lady you deserve it :)
Racrucion 5 months ago
the girl is so ugly. why pick her
joejonas886 6 months ago
@joejonas886 ...I know what you mean, and you are correct. But I think of it like this...it shows what a nice guy he really is. HE has. YOu know he could have ANY girl in that audience...and around the world. I know that she wouldn't be picked by most people....but what does that say to the guy who could have ANYBODY? I mean really....he could still my wife right now! Lol
Mellomel 3 months ago
she is one of the luckiest girls alive and lovely looking to boot
lollyyoung1 6 months ago 2
lucky fan :( Enrique remember u :DDDD
delux600va 6 months ago
that's fuckin' unfair :( i should be the girl standing next to him while he's singing-.-
hopefully some day..
DersimLicious62 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
they can say what they want...she was the luckiesst girl alive today!!!on Today!!!
crwebb61 6 months ago
they can sya what they want...she was the luckiesst girl alive today!!!on Today!!!
crwebb61 6 months ago
omfg, he did not just kiss her at the end. I'm so jealous!!!!
ShellyBellyDbcccc 6 months ago
shes soo happyy shes ganna remember this moment for a very long time :) happy for her.
jemnjojo1 6 months ago
y i couldn't be enrique so i could of get all the girls i want
youth732 6 months ago
lucky lucky lucky lol. Girl i hope you cherish this moment 4ever :)
qbanchick17 6 months ago 3
whooooo SOOO jealous of her xD
adampilotf22 6 months ago
he such a sweetheartt ^.^
23addie 7 months ago
you go girl!!!!!!!!!!!!!XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
mariapol17 7 months ago
hey EVERYONE ENRIQUE IS GONNA BE LIVE AT THE TODAY SHOW SUMMER CONCERT SERIES AGAIN!!!!!!!!! AUGUST 19!!!!!!!!! I HOPE HE SING HERO AGAIN!!!
sarafranco100 7 months ago
happy for her =)
Adelynnie 7 months ago
i don't know her personally, but i've spoken to her through his forum and she's very sweet a true fan and deserves it good for you melissa!!! now this year it's my turn >=) haha
kitkat718 7 months ago
I didn't expect that at the end! He is hot. lol
BeckyIsWanted 7 months ago
OMG I wish that was me he's sexy as hell
MsHappyface6 8 months ago 8
why he always pick the ugly girl when he performs this song?
HongPhuongNguyen 8 months ago
@HongPhuongNguyen
The notion of beauty is different, depending on one's point of view ;)
JDlamusique 8 months ago
@HongPhuongNguyen yea he does.
MiCorazonDeOro 8 months ago
@HongPhuongNguyen she is not ugly she is different!!!and that says a lot about him!!!!it would be cliche to choose the thin girl!!!he is not discriminatin!!!besides real women have curves!!!!!!
mariapol17 7 months ago 2
@HongPhuongNguyen She is not ugly...NOBODY IS UGLY!
pinkangel0222 7 months ago 6
my lord !!! he must be has a soft lips. i am so bloody jealous . enrique mi amor !!
callmechineseplis 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i just want the last part hahahaha....why he did that made all the girls go crazy jealous!
rubriklitanea 8 months ago
OH MY GOD!!!!!!I'n really jealous her so much!!! TT
Fergiedo9 9 months ago
Omfg she is sooooo lucky!!!!!
ZAINAANNSAMHOUN 9 months ago
he rocks. That probably made that woman feel extremely sexy.
Jonasgirl1964 9 months ago
There is no way I would contain myself for 5 minutes!!! He is a sweetheart, how he made this truly beautiful girl feel. I bet he smells so good, definitely the perfect man I would like to have.
Pure1278 10 months ago
i knew it now y enrique is loved by millions of people..he is knd hearted and down to earth person...lov u enqique..m ur no. 1 FAN!!
MrRyuichi1123 10 months ago
I'M DYING IN HERE OMG I SO WANNA BE HERRRRRR.
MiimiDiiablitax3 10 months ago
She's sooo lucky.. <.< I WANNA BE HUURR :D
LibbyandNikki1 10 months ago
She was pretty calm considering the sex god Enrique was touching her. >.< I would be like hyperventilating or something. Lmao. But goodness, he is so fricken sweet. :) I'll be so happy if I were her. Lucky.
pukuwang 10 months ago
Oh dam that lady is so lucky! Grrr I live in NYC too and am SO jealous that wasn't me! Haha seriously though good for her! She's got millions of us women who wish we could've been in her place lol
musiclovr6599 11 months ago
I WANT A KISS!
PolaroidBianca 11 months ago 4
I'm wondering what kind of perfume he wears....he's soo sexy!
JillSander90 11 months ago 2
He does this at the end or Hero in most of his concerts...its not a big deal. Spainards are very passionate people. Plus he has a girlfriend. So its just an act for him.
AntonioisHot13 1 year ago
Holy crap!! I love this guy xD AND I NEVER MET HIM BEFORE!! hahah.
OR been on any of his concerts xD BUT HE'S AMAZINGGGGG!!!!
Wish I could be that girllll. She's super lucky :)
BeliveDavidJArchie 1 year ago
he is beautiful inside and out. <3
xokilluhkate 1 year ago
this is the first time of my life i really want to have sex with a pop star
kaminey77 1 year ago 20
@kaminey77 so true! he is absolutely gorgeous <3
tiammcw 11 months ago
@kaminey77 never will
MrMOTA1230 3 months ago
that man's so down to earth.. big like :)
rallsyy 1 year ago
whats up with the fat chick???? couldn't he get anyone better???
MasihCA 1 year ago
HE KISSED HER AHHHHH!!!!!
MsChoriz0 1 year ago
omg she is sooo lucky
projecthowl4 1 year ago
OMG lucky girl T_T
0futys0 1 year ago
And for all you people saying she's ugly, I'd like to see what you look like.
RandomBologna 1 year ago 6
CAN A GIRL BE ANYMORE LUCKIER THAN THIS IN HER LIFE?! I almost died watching this.
RandomBologna 1 year ago 4
@xXxJBxLoverxXx If I was her I'd pounce on dem girls like chigger
PeanutBunni 1 year ago
performances of this song are always fun to watch. just to see how those girls react is entertaining on it's own
PowerRedBull 1 year ago
Oh my god. I cant decribe my feelings now. WOW. I love him.
Ginniej 1 year ago
ugh i wish i was herr
efronfanx99 1 year ago
All of of you who are picking on the girl... calling her fat, a bitch, even making racist comments you all are PATHETIC. It is a song he does it in just about every ending of that song.
And I gurantee you even if you did meet him he would not want to stay around you for long because all you haters are completly disgusting and ugly on the inside. And it will not get you anywhere in life.
Keyashaterry13 1 year ago 47
@Keyashaterry13 yeah u are truE!
nickyhenriques 2 months ago
lucky bitch =]]]
INLOVEINJB 1 year ago
Oh to be in her shoes.....
lifeluvmusic16 1 year ago
we watched this in spanish class and i thought it was sweet. but maaan i would kill to be her.
ArddvarkkMarie 1 year ago
SHAMEE ON YOU ENRIQUE !
alba9o 1 year ago
SHAMEEEEEEE!
orche123123 1 year ago
does he always dance wif sme1 for this song?
LoveColtonAndDan 1 year ago
Oh, man!! I wish I were that girl...well, not literally...but I wish I was in her place there. I would have gone BUNKERS!! Enrique id talented, SEXY and HOT!
SweetaRoxious 1 year ago
Does he kiss them at the end at every show?! That's so cute!
Lmccor09 1 year ago
KE AFORTUNADAAAAAAAAAAAA YO ME MUERO SI ESTUVIERA EN SU LUGAR !!
lunarysh 1 year ago
lmfao im trying understand...
91359075 1 year ago
hahahaha wtf??????????????? ok thats fucking weird im trying understand that cause i cant its ridiculous that girl is a nigga ugly fat and he kissed her? :O im shocked ok
91359075 1 year ago
@91359075 Why you insulting her cause shes black. everyone else was insulting her cause she is overweight and kind of frumpy. But her race?
Universal237 1 year ago
@Universal237 FUCK YOU I INSULT WHO EVER THE FUCK I WANT GO TAKE CARE OF YOUR LIFE SHE IS A FAT UGLY NIGGA ANYWAY
91359075 1 year ago
@91359075 WOW YOU ARE A DUMB FUCK. BY THE LOOK OF IT YOU PROBABLY HAVE GOTTEN MADE FUN OF YOUR WHOLE FUCKING LIFE. END YOURSELF DUMB FUCK. YOU BEEN BLOCKED. AND TAKE CARE OF YOUR OWN LIFE CAUSE ITS PROBABLY SHIT ANYWAY.
Universal237 1 year ago
@Universal237 FUCK OFF YOUR A FUCKING ANNOYING PIECE OF SHIT STOP SENDING MESSAGES TO ME FUCKING FAG QUEER YOU ARE BLOCKED NOT ME AND NOW YOUR PLAYER ARE IGNORED FUCKIN BITCH
91359075 1 year ago
@Universal237 YOU ARE THE DUMB FUCK ASSHOLE RETARDED GO FUCK YOUR FUCKING FAT UGLY NIGGA GIRL BITCH U PROB WILL LOVE LOL
91359075 1 year ago
quem me dera ser uma dessas escolhidas!
esta frente a frente com ele e de tirar o folego.ui
jessicastar019 1 year ago
NOW HE HAS CLASS!
Twilightcrazyteen 1 year ago
I love how he said "would you laugh".
Universal237 1 year ago
Oh mulher de sorte....todos os artitas deveriam ter esse carinho e respeito que ele tem com as fãs.....Ele conquistou o meu carinho por isso.....oh homem lindo.....
Daniele21love 1 year ago
@Daniele21love Concordo com você Daniele. Todos os artistas deveriam ter esse carinho e respeito pelos seus fãs! ... Nossa eu adorei ver esse vídeo... Isso só me faz adimirá-lo cada vez mais. É um cantor maravilhoso! E LINDO demais!!! ... Que mulher de sorte! Quem me dera ter uma chance dessas!
She is so lucky!!!
vivianesantos17 1 year ago
i wanna be in his arms for so long too :( Shes so lucky!!!
Froschherzchen 1 year ago
wowwwwwwww great
Oroszfan 1 year ago
i would pee my pants if enrique iglesias sang to me. my goodness he's amazing!
SomeHeartsMusic 1 year ago 5
I would have just simply melted from happiness if Enrique sang to me. :-) He is so handsome, everything is so attractive about him: his voice, looks, inner kindness. If there were more people on this earth like him, world would have been such a great place.
VeronikaD22 1 year ago 7
Omg shes so lucky
jordanian14 1 year ago
omg enrique is so damn hot!<3 i would like to be with him on the stage!!! and i hope he would give me a kiss!!! =)))) i hpe that happen someday!! =))
kickboxinggirl18 1 year ago
maybe hes just a nice guy :P
Nblue444 1 year ago
he only picks the women that has never been in love...
austderstine1 1 year ago
@austderstine1 what??
liljayfludd 1 year ago
@liljayfludd i mean he only choose the women that haven't been in love before...
austderstine1 1 year ago
@austderstine1 how do u know that woman has never been in love?????!!!!!!
liljayfludd 1 year ago
hahaha, I SOOOO would be grabbin his ass !! Damn he heats me up, he's so fukin hot !!!
MmmMusicLOVER 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hahaha look at that fat bitch
MrAli393 1 year ago
@MrAli393 i wouldn't mind being fat and a bitch for him LOL
dalal122 1 year ago
I wish i could have touched his ass :( and kiss him. she's so lucky!
rasbery14 1 year ago 5
hahahahaha
wolf0531vf5 1 year ago
yes.....she´s luuuuckyyy!!!
pablho14 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
whats with him and fat bitches ??
worldcomander 1 year ago
***femaleboner***
bevk2004 1 year ago
@bevk2004 LMFAO !... yeah same here ...he's so hot and she's so lucky
dalal122 1 year ago
facking nigga
ShoxaAmerican 1 year ago
That is awesome! How cool of him to take it to the fans:) I would love to be her, so happy for her, I could not keep it together as much as she is:); I would turn bright red lol. How amazing of Enrique, it would be weird, I think, though to sing a song written for someone else to someone you don't know, good job.
TheTamRich 1 year ago
I'm so jealous at her.... :(
tonnna01 1 year ago
JEEZZ AT 3:38 SHE ALMOST TOUCHED HIS COCK!!!!
indianguyd12 1 year ago
aaaah, i wannaa cryyy :( hes mineee (L)
Lozziie4ZacEfron 1 year ago
ew shes ugly . why did they pick her
?
shannonlovsurscarf07 1 year ago
@shannonlovsurscarf07 I think he tries to pick ugly girls so it's not considered harassment :P
worldcomander 1 year ago
kocham go:D:D :))
balujaca 1 year ago
kocham go:D:D
balujaca 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
can't sing live...
RonTahan 1 year ago
OMG! SHEISOLUCKY
kellll33 1 year ago
OH.MY.GOSH.
he kisses her on the LIPS????
i thought he had a girlfriend lol
KUiscaliente 1 year ago
0mg! she is so lucky! <333333333
vassupkrikri 1 year ago
How sweet
jamesyll 1 year ago
havent heard this song in forever i like it better live than music videos
ymir1991 1 year ago
omggg i was there front row... so lucky
allisonalli9 1 year ago
OMG I LOVE ENRIQUE SOOOOOOOOOOOO MUCH IM HIS BIGGESTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT FAN EVERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
Enriquelover00 1 year ago
Hahahaha the girl was randomly choosen....I have been to two of his concerts here in Mexico and in both of those concerts he choose random girls from the audience and kissed them...hes really nice, he always like to interact with the fans and in one of the concerts he choose a couple who were celebrating their like 3 month aniversary and he brought them up on stage and took tequila shots with them
AleRubalcava612 1 year ago
haha 3:09 - 3:15 that lady's like shooing those girls away from touching his butt.
xXxJBxLoverxXx 1 year ago 23
@xXxJBxLoverxXx
Hahahahahah!! I thought that was funny! But what a lucky girl!!
Kaite1230 1 year ago
i hate her! good for you girl!
kyky1308 1 year ago
boy he is trying hard to sell his album.
brandonleesgirl87 1 year ago
Comment removed
Sweeetyyy56 1 year ago
who is that girl? and how did she get picked to do that?? haha she is sooo lucckkkkyyy!
MRSDJDANGAAATRAINE 1 year ago
no fair!!!!i wish that was me!
enriqueluver98 1 year ago
they always pick a fat chick and make everyone else jealous lol
happy2we 1 year ago
@happy2we
don´t be soo mean okay you´re just jealous
austria141 1 year ago
he veryy verry sexyyy!!!!! just sayingg!!!!! he should kiss meee!!!!!!!!!
men7008 1 year ago
Is incredible how one artist can unite so many people!
PancakeGir 1 year ago
WTF who is that girl and why in the world did Enrique kiss her ????!!!
bubbleys38 1 year ago
i would have passed out
chaddy91 1 year ago 4
Dam people respect him he's been in pause since his last hit, DURING 9/11!!!!! Besides he's just singing this song too for the 9th anniversary in 2 months
BmanNYC14 1 year ago
Why is it though he always has girls who exchange saliva with him on his videos? :L Kinda spoils him a bit
MJfan101ful 1 year ago
My mums friend knows that girl
MJfan101ful 1 year ago
OOOH..my god..hahaha..that woman is fuckin lucky..i sooo..wish that was me up there..ahaha...
spangurl15 1 year ago
whos the girl?? SHE IS FRICKIN LUCKY!!!
banana2184 1 year ago
SHE'S THE LUCKIEST GIRL !!!!!! OMG I WISH I WAS IN HER PLACE
Fatu013 1 year ago 2
AHHHHHHHHH! LUCKIEST GIRL ALIVE!!!! THATS LIKE MY DREAM!<3
EvOuKnO 1 year ago 2
awe!! Lucky girl!! It's so cute that he still does that!
hockeychick1171 1 year ago
Lukiiiiiiii women ......So jealous.......:)
Kelly9347 1 year ago
he makes me melttttttttt
princessjuicy94 1 year ago
APPAlling!!! TERRIBLE!! SO CHEAP!!!!!!!!
kinoing 1 year ago
he's so sweet(:
forgottenwings3 1 year ago
omg...
dreamthompete2009 1 year ago
OM! i went to the early show... damnnn i should have went to the today show haha this girl is so lucky!!
Shecks18 1 year ago
oh my god that was HOT. lucky girl!
simplyeverything101 1 year ago
oh my God.what i would do to be her.i love him♥
nkotbrox10 1 year ago
did he just randomly pick her out of the crowd?
acd1030 1 year ago
okay. that girl was sooo lucky!!!! i wish that happened to me!!!!! I'm such a huge fan of his!
814CaliGirl 1 year ago
Dear God. If he can look at a complete stranger that way, and kiss her like THAT, what in the CRAP, can he do to his wife? I mean, he'd have totally fooled me. He's so freakin' hot, I swear. Lucky bitch!! (:
lalalauraish 1 year ago 5
omg!!! thats amazing!! i wish i was her!! lol
NickJisdefoffdachain 1 year ago
Damn, I think it's every girls dream to be serenaded by Enrique Iglasias. I would pretty much die if this happened to me
oOrebeccaemilyOo 1 year ago
ohh she was so lucky!!
great for her!
axct95 1 year ago
omg im so speechless
IpromotheusI 1 year ago
Lucky Bitch!!! im sooooo jeally!
LuxAeterna5 1 year ago
LMFAOOOOOOO @ COMMENT
U ALL FUCKIN NO LIFE AND HAVE BRAIN PROBLEM
STFU
U DONT SEE ITS A PLAYBACK STUPID DOGGY
acc1x 1 year ago
he's so hot. She's so lucky
arebelangel 1 year ago
I'm so jealous...............she is the most lucky women in this planet.....P.S(I HATE HER)
suyensevilla 1 year ago 2
@suyensevilla Do you even know her?
smileforshirley 1 year ago
I was there!! Ah she's so luckyy!!
allisonalli9 1 year ago
LOL!!!!! oh enrique.
apie77 1 year ago
Comment removed
pichulon123456 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
what a dirty, fithy, ugly bitch. jealous.....
angeleee11 1 year ago