Added: 4 years ago
From: pinkclimax
Views: 463,432
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (902)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I love how he goes straight from killing it on an unbelievable slide guitar solo to an equally mind-blowing acoustic solo at the end - genius.

  • Gilmour >>> Waters

  • I'd like a drummer that doesn't mind hammering a bell too.

  • This song makes me so happy. I would die in peace.

    can not describe my admiration.

    Rest in Peace Richard.

  • Best solo in history!!

  • i guess my favorite from Pink floyd.. maybe the only one of them i like

  • This is the "High hopes" of my life...Thanks David.

  • 16 mother fuckers

  • I love David's acoustic guitar solo at the end

  • 16 bieber fans !

  • Comment removed

  • ok seriously... WHO CAN POSSIBLY dislike this? These people are lost...

  • @BBLORD1234567890 right.. i see how people disike hard rock and heavy metal, cause maybe they jsut cant listen to it, i love it, but this... this is perfect, heavy metal fan, or whatever u calthat crap out today fan, there is no way this should be disliked... come on listen to the crowd while he's playing

  • What A Beautiful Feeling He Makes Your Soul Feel....

  • Love u, my Idol!!

  • I know that the title says David Gilmour, but nevertheless, I have to say that Pink Floyd are the only group of musicians who I categorize simply in MUSIC. No need to say that they are rock, prog, art or whatever...Simply music, at its unique state of sheer perfection.

  • @LastFreeManStanding yeah! just thinking that myself.

  • From 7:37 to 9:20  .. music at its best! sheer awesomeness!!

  • justin beiber was here 12 times..

  • 11 idiots !

  • @fatdrummerSC 16 ;)

  • THE SOUND OF THAT BELL IN BACKGROUND KILLS ME! SUCH AN IMAGE I GET IN MY HEAD, DAVID IS AMAZING

  • one of the best song of all time !!!!!!! BEST BAND EVER ...my heart its for pink floyd !!!

  • pretty much the coolest hombre on the planet

  • grosoooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooo

  • a truly awe inspiring piece of music,the lap steel at the end is spine tingling,its music for the soul that makes you so emotional and proud.a masterpiece.

  • I'm fairly certain from 7:39 until the end is the lobby music in Heaven... I hope the waiting line is long and slow up there so I can just enjoy that acoustic bliss!

  • DAVID GILMOUR is my GOD and PINK FLOYD is my RELIGION

  • Can this man ever make a mistake!!!!!! dosent sound like a live version!!!!!! guitar should be spelled as GILMOUR!!!!!!!!

  • how many tears ? oh pf ... so many tears of the world ...

  • & Syd is forgetten ...

  • Wondeful song now i can yalk about a real art :d love it

  • one of the most beautiful and perfect music.I can't stop crying,it remind me all memories,specially when we took trip with blue bird.

  • @mamoshnaz

    English, please

  • David Gilmour Is NOT playing guitar!!! God is through his fingers.

  • you need lots more than just rate this piece of magnificent music, man, even the Greatest comment here is small

  • Pink floyd est connue partout meme en france partout je vous dit I love pink floyd

  • Me pregunto que carajo saben de musica los idiotas que dieron voto negativo a este tema por Dios que pateticos que son...!!! PINK FLOYD FOR EVER THE BEST....!!!!

  • Thanks... no more words.... GOD playing here!!! David & Wright

  • Wow what a blessing to have this talent in this life!

  • PERFECT

  • we are not worthy! DAVE GILMOUR IS GOD!!!!!

  • Also credits to the lyrics of Polly Samson \.

  • The sadness and peacefullness of the song make it most fitting song ,,, that with the passing of Rick ,,, will be the last Pink Floyd song ever made ,,, and it will go on forever

  • Co za solo ... nogi się uginają .. Gilmour jest moim idolem jeśli chodzi o gitarę. Fenomenalny gość!!!

  • David and Wright... Perfect match

  • stupenda!!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • Oh, Brother Gilmour, what a song then and still. Why can't the United State's congress hear what I hear?

  • I think there is 9 Justin bieber fans that needs to appreciate real music

  • Tremendous song,having it played at my funeral,no better way to leave this place..

  • That man can play more by playing nothing at all than most guitarists can play in 1000 notes. This solo goes right into my soul and turns it inside out....unbelievable.

  • Whenever I listen to Gilmour or Pink Floyd, my eyes become filled with tears. <3

  • why are your floyd videos in mono and dynamic range a bit lacking....

  • 5:10 This is God playing guitar :X Absolutely out of this world.

  • Is official: David Gilmour is God.

  • Quite possibly the best rendition of the best song by the best band ever?

    Pink Floyd are incredible!

  • 9 people are stoopids

  • Just tell me who cilicked the dislikes i will perssonaly kill them...

  • who says that every solo needs some fast guitar licks? get out of the stereotype. embrace the Gilmour.

  • i don't know how many times i have clicked the replay button to hear it again n again...just truly amazing...especially the solo at the end........

  • David Gilmour is a huge inspiration for my playing."Comfortaby numb" and "Shine on.." are my personal favorites solos. His flawless technique and his soulful licks are unique. Everyone these days can play fast guitar licks but only a few can touch your soul.The right note at the right time.Pure genius.

    Some days ago I wrote a song named "Likvidator(the warning)" where the solo is mainly influenced by the way he plays.In some way is my humble tribute to the master(you can listen it on my channel)

  • @edmusicchile I enjoyed reading what you had to say. Gilmour, is a you say, "the master". Your words are tribute enough as far as I'm concerned.

  • What i like is that nine people didn't like the song and everybody respects that. Nobody did silly jokes about that. This really shows something.

  • Simply beautiful.

    This song soothes my tortured soul.

    I wish they implemented the wonderful acoustic solo in the album version.

    Pink Floyd songs are timeless masterpieces and David an immortal legend.

    Peace

  • Since 7:37 excelence becoming music

  • This song has more and more meaning each day

  • David Gilmour is incredible

  • Comment removed

  • I was a union stage hand thoughout highschool and college and I can testify that he has the best sounding concert ever put on stage. There is no studio mix sound like the modern day turds...all the techno rips of today and lip synching is such a joke. Crosby Stills and Nash, Greatful Dead...only other groups of 90's-2000 that can compare. They sounded the same on stage as they did in studio with no help. There is nobody in the top 100 of Rock or pop today that can hold their jock strap.

  • David shows it's not required to die young to be a legend

  • @cedcad who told you that? that you need to die young to be a legend. Thats wrong

  • In the comments of this video:

    People getting trolled by sonoofgungog

  • thats fucking music right there

    

  • live forever David

  • !!! ABSOLUTELY DLISH !!!

  • this is surely one of the best concerts I've ever seen :)

  • I check the top 100 best guitarist player in the history of the rolling stones magazine and David Gilmour is 82th.WTF! He should be in the top 15!

  • @randyrds92 Well it is rolling stones magazine.

  • @randyrds92

    Agreed, this is amazing,....

  • @randyrds92 : I think you don´t understand that list. These guys on that list are THE 100 BEST guitardudes in the world. It´s not a ranking. ;-)

  • @randyrds92 nor does it matter m8:) gilmour i playing for music and for the music only ;)

  • @randyrds92 rolling stones magazine has some of the worst rated stuff

  • No doubt

  • @randyrds92 DAVID SHOULD BE TOP 3 TOP 5 FOR ME ANYDAY!

  • @randyrds92 Your right. angus young for example is 96th... 62 places behind thurston moore from sonic youth... WTF????

  • @randyrds92 the best guitar solos for me are pink floyd's one. it's pure, perfect put in a transe

  • @randyrds92 In top 5 I'd say! :D

  • one single man, one fantastic song, no eletronics, no bling bling and no gaga. What else to say?

  • Socrates, Platon, Aristotle and Heraklitos of Music, or else David Gilmour, Roger Waters, Nick Mason and Richard Wright, the Philosophers of Music. And upon them, God Apollon giving them the inspiration!

  • @sonofgungog What, in the name of around the world Musicians you are talking about? Man do you have any idea for whome people are you talking about? You compare the Philosophers of Rock, the people who play Music, (with the whole meaning of word), with a small piece of shit, that even his mother will not remember him in some years, Bieber? Man, have you any idea of music? Have you ever played, listened or feel music? Do you know what is music? What kind of people exist in this world....

  • 5:09 to end is a masterpiece..he makes it look so easy..thumbs up if u wish to see him play this solo live..

  • The voice, the guitar playing...

    Wow what a gift.....AMAZING!

  • 9 dislikes???!! BLASPHEMY!!!

  • @all

    YOU PEOPLE ARE SOO TOTALLY LOST, NOT ME ! David gilmour is a fool who thinks too much of himself. This song is a blaspheme to music in its entirety.

    You people havent grown enough to get over this kind of music and start appreciating legends like JUSTIN BIEBER. And dont you think i am kidding. He really is the only person worth being called a music GOD.

  • @sonofgungog

    go and die sick person!!!really,u are a big motherfucker for thinking those things!!!

    i hope u and gay bieber die slow!!!!

  • @sonofgungog Haha, you certainly succeeded in your attempt to piss people off. Everyone got different taste and Bieber is another world and dimension in music, so just leave it be. People like Justin Bieber and people like David Gilmour and Pink Floyd and that's perfectly fine. The good thing about music like this is that you don't have to continously serial rape your radio to pieces by repeating the song over and over 'cause people will actually like the song after a few times. Cheers!

  • 9 people have no soul !

  • By far this is the best version of this song I've heard - absolutely orgasmic!

  • A True Master At Work! RIP Richard!

  • 5:10

  • Ears are not enough for Pink Floyd, you must use your heart to listen this music...:)

  • Gestatten, Gott.

  • Guitarist cant be ranked by their speed. and u need to watch gilmour to see wht matters..best guitarist ever..his hand floats on the strings..i wish i cud watch him live.

  • If god heard this, no doubt he cried !! Gilmour got it all <3

  • David Gilmour is much more that a guitar player. He is a singer, composer as well as an innovator. There is more to playing guitar that being able to shred a zillion notes per second. When he plays, it is pure emotion that his fingers are playing. Many of todays shred artists have also learned that feeling is a major part of playing, and if that means playing SLOW, then so be it. There is no single best guitarist in the world or style that is best. If the music makes you feel good, then it is.

  • i just love this song and the lap steel solo is just perfect

  • there are 9 fools on youtube; well, it´s a good average ´cause youtube is big...

  • This song is actually so depressing, listen to it but think about roger waters and syd barrett and flyd in the 70s and before they were famous and still young its basically the conclusion to the band.

  • Is Perfect!!!

  • ABSOLU!

  • Questa è musica. Punto! il resto non conta (per me)!

    David Gilmour is my god!

  • @everyone Alright. Whatever you people say, i wont be convinced. Because everytime someone puts this kind of music, i doze off within seconds. I dont see any kind of energy in this guy as much as any of other rapper has. After all, music is meant to cheer you up. This kinda music is nowhere near cheering me up.

    Moreover, if one listens to the lyrics of the rock songs, most of them would be depressing to the core. Who wants that??HUH?

  • @sonofgungog @sonofgungog you are ABSOLUTELY lost !!! and very simply do not understand the concept of REAL music, and a dumb ass for bringing up rap which IS NOT music, why are you EVEN on this video anyway with remarks like that. wake up swine!

  • @sonofgungog: shut the fuck up and drown yourself

    

  • The man's a god!

  • lap steel solo *.* ...it doesn't get better than this...

  • rap and pop are indeed taking over rock music.. the reason why 1960-90's music became popular might be due the advances in recording technologies... there might be good music before then but we dont have good record of them.. rock (60's to 90's) was influenced by psychedelic drugs and the music which came is quite unique

    anyway speaking of 21st century .. can so called rap lovers suggest me which album could be the best musical piece , so that i can know whether i am listening to shit or not

  • @farban All i want to say is pop and rap are taking over rock. And definitely people of the future generations would appreciate rap/pop/hip hop as great music. They wouldnt like the music that came 5 decades ago, just as you dont listen to the music of 1920's.

    Still if u think this shit is great music, definitely you people do not belong to the 21st century

  • @sonofgungog you want to bet that pink floyd will be heard in 50years time and jay z beyonce bieber gaga or whatever is pop now will disappear? did i say 50 years.. thay will all be gone in 5...

    pop and rap taking over rock. have you ben drinking?? you really believe that bieber will last longer than led zeppelin, pink floyd, deep purple, the who, ramones..i'm writing this and the solo just began.. the solo is my answer, forget the above, just listen to the masterpiece..

  • Only Gilmour can judge me.

  • Comment removed

  • I like this version better because of the Acustic solo David plays at the end of the song... it's just perfect

  • This solo was nirvana.

  • from 7:30 the most beautiful, sad and perfect guitarplaying ive ever listened to!

  • @imthefatcat bittersweet melody... amazing playing indeed

  • at 8:09 gilmour is like "wtf to play next"....

  • Gestatten, Gott.

  • Best concert I've ever seen :)

  • Comment removed

  • If only 10 people in the world were granted Immortality. I would pray David Gilmour was one of them..

  • listen to this atleast 10-15 times a day ..i just wish "Sir" David Gilmour was immortal ;)

  • excellent. Liked / faved :)

  • music that tell tale

  • 9 people has no life...

  • @sonofgungog and if you think its so easy to learn guitar ..how about you do that and post a video and show us

    and maybe when you come back here you will of not only learnt guitar but also learnt to be less ignorant.

  • @sonofgungog What evidence have you got to back that up apart from making up random figures and using childish words such as "gazillion." Rock is not dying. If you think it is then answer me this: Why have ACDC just played to sold out audiences all over the world? Why have U2 played to Sold out audiences all over the world? I would like to see these "Pop" artists you mention play to over 3 million like Rod Stewart and INXS and Rolling stones did on separate occaisions, as well as many more!

  • @sonofgungog It's about the quality of those 1000 people compared to the gazillion. Good things,are always underrated, because there are not enough Great people to vote for them....

  • 9 people have severe brain damage

  • @rodriguezmasis

    This doesnt have anything to do with the media. Right from when i was born, i have never been influenced by rock, even though my dad and many of my friends were into it. Most of us today are into rap or pop because its the music of today. It is the music attracts this generation. But, as always there are a hand full of people still stuck in the past, braging about the "glorious" rock era. Its like being in the 21st century and asking for a 12th century suit.

  • @sonofgungog

    The reason you think that is because you're just ignorant and the massive media has influenced you to the point of not having a personal opinion, you see it´s not about a music genre fight, it´s just about appreciating art, this is art it´s beautifull music that causes emotions, that is made with emotions, everyone can learn how to sing as well as to play guitar, but not everyone can do it from the heart, i´d like to see any american idol or Justin Beaver compose a song like this

  • @sonofgungog  fuck you!

  • @sonofgungog anyone can learn to sing aswell. and in pretty much every song of today's music, they use auto tune. sometimes veryobvious, like with kanye west, but sometimes for subtile, so that it sounds "perfect" without anyone hearing autotune. rock is no where near dead. Music has never been about showing off instrumental skills and its not all about the singing. singers would be nowhere without intruments. and no, not anyone can learn to play guitar well. rock has always been above rap n pop

  • @sonofgungog Why is gilmour praised? because he has produced songs which are considered beautiful and for good reason have stayed timeless and are still played today. He is a great role model as he gives to charity. He has written many songs which have hit number one and have broken various music records.

    Last time i heard rock and roll is still alive

    Music is not about instruments? if people understood that then we would just have singing over silence

    

  • @sonofgungog Dumbass fuck

  • if i didnt have this video on my hard disk, it would have had 7908710279968621232212 views

  • This is just Amazing ... I'm speechless ... Lets just music talk for us !!! Gilmour is narrator <3

  • how can somebody dont like this?

  • @fckdahlloff I was just thinking about that, how is it possible to dislike a video like this one?

  • lol who is the guy that yells at the end?

  • @scrawnylonjohn

    that s part of the music too man.loved it.lol

  • Brilliant. Good to see Richard on the keys. R.I.P.

  • 8 idiot...

  • can someone pls make tabs for this acoustic solo!? plsss

  • Great song! Definitely the best ever produced by Pink Floyd after the Waters era. This version and its grand finale give me the chills!!! Great concert too!

  • INCRIVEL SOLO

    

  • I feel sorry for the 7 people who dislike this song. You must be very hard to please.

  • the 7 must be fckin deaf

  • the 7 must be deaf

  • Wait wait wait wait wait... Who's the seven people who hit the dislike button?

  • I love this song - saw this concert back in '94 in San Diego! division bell tour!

  • Comment removed

  • Just... exceptional!

  • Wow! If only Rodger wasn't such an asshole he could have been a part of a great legacy!

  • high hopes,una obra maestra

  • Shine on you crazy diamond, also in Royal Albert Hall:

    watch?v=-ar6rgxevIM&feature=fv­sr

    simply perfect

  • I love this music more than every woman or something in the world :-)

  • is god

  • The ending guitar sequence is pure genius. Gilmour is one of the greatest musicians in history he stirs the emotions better than anyone and as ever you don't listen to Gilmours music you experience it.

  • What scale is he using? I can't figure it out. I don't think it's just the normal pentatonic or major scale.

  • What a song... damn...

  • it's my favorite solo!! PERIOD....