Who is the better Live Act? Britney, Rihanna, Nicole or Xtina?

[ilovebritandriri333]

RIHANNA AND BRITNEY <3

[MsRussianIdiot]

But i wanna say, that Nicole dance not bad.

[MsRussianIdiot]

eww... Christina Aguilera is the voice of our generation. And Britney, Nicole, Rihanna - they just singers. bad singers.

sorry fans :(

[Bliies]

Britney comes at first for her ability to captivate audiences with an average singing voice. Christina has the best voice, but most of her career has been imitating other popular singers and styles. For example, her not myself tonight video. She was the best during the back to basics era. Rihanna is alright live, though she doesn't have too many hits without being featured in some other person's song. Nicole has her moments, but it just seems like she tries too hard to imitate the rest.

[MsTreysongz1]

are you serious? . Christina is one of the best singers in the world , wtf take her out of this , she is a vocal legend

[parrotrjl95]

Xtina is the shit.. PERIOD!

Amazing

[matheusmpcd]

1. Nicole !

[martinr345345]

i m sorri but britney is the worse ¡¡¡ She never sing live ¡¡

[martinr345345]

who is nicole ?

[martinr345345]

ja ja ja i think ...... hum cristina jajajajaj She is definitly the best ¡¡¡

[3218quin]

01) Christina #THEBESTEVER

02) Britney

03) Rihanna

[AwsumAnna13]

1.Christina

2.Rihanna

3.Britney

[aguilerafanaz]

Haha...it's cute and the the VOICE arrives and the whole montage changes. LOL luv the other girls too

[ladislavpompa]

performace and voice CHRISTINA good looking BRITNEY AND CHRISTINA dancing CHROSTONA,BRITNEY,NICOLE,RIHAN­NA

[ladislavpompa]

CHRISTINA AGUILERA

[alerich20]

1.Christina

2.Britney

3.Christina

4.Britney

now you see why are these 2 the only pop princesses...they are just supreme!!!!

[megnor]

Britney, Rihanna, Christina, Nicole

[godseesnocolour]

1. Christina Aguilera the rest of these talentless idiots need to take major lessons from Christina there just awful.

[TheRussianDiamond]

1. Christina

2. Britney

I love Nicole's style & hate Rihanna!

[Thalles6769]

1.RIHANNA

2.RIHANNA

3.RIHANNA

4.BRITNEY S.

5.CHRISTINA A.

[giani108]

Voice: Christina

Performance: Britney

Nicole & Rihanna are good, but not like the others..

[SuperSweetNiNi]

1. Britney!

2. Christina

3. Rihanna

4. Nicole

[pizzcui]

1.christina

2.britney

3.nicole

4. rihanna



[Juniorthemusic]

chrisina

nicole

rihanna

britney

[TheZoRetro]

we need an updated one because rihanna's live shows have gotten better christina umm she's not really not performing anymore and britney's are wack!!

[brigakakiri]

Legendtina!!!

[vanyjulepils]

There was only one part of Britney that was live.. Better search next time!

[troupe131992kz]

Christina is the best current singer in the world...Britney use to be the best performer solely for her dancing...NIcole sucks at singing yet her choreography is entertaining. Rihanna, her songs are catchy but live she sucks!!!!!

[JoseloSpears]

1.Britney

2.Christina A.

and if i had to choose them others.......

3.nicole

4.rihanaa

[irontoyvn]

X-TiNa is absolutely my queen, Rihanna is the Princess of mine, Britney Spears and Nicole ?..........No Thanks !!

[Niirorance]

i both like christina and britney!!!! and a liitle bit fo rihanna

[buffyyoun]

BRITNEY

BRITNEY

BRITNEY

[Tyr666777]

I really dont see the point in putting Xtina in the same category with this average singers.

[Niirorance]

@Tyr666777 yeah christina's line shoulb with mariah carey etc

[SoberLilith]

1.CHRISTINA

2.CHRISTINA

3.CHRISTINA

4.CHRISTINA

[Bartulos92]

Christina

Rihanna

Nicole

Britney

[azz0rogue0oliver]

VOICE Xtina Nicole Britney Rihanna DANCING Britney Nicole Rihanna Xtina LOOKS Britney Nicole Rihanna Xtina MUSIC Britney Rihanna Xtina Nicole

[keithc42oo]

christina with that voice BOOOM 

[LlewynLlewDixon]

i'd say

1.christina

2.nicole

3.rihanna

4.britney

[pedroivoverissimo]

1 christina

2 britney

3 nicole

4 rihanna

christina best <3 britney has a very beautiful voice

[mileycyrusclubperu]

OMG yeah xtina hit that notes babe !

[meryemhallo1993xl]

the title is saying who is the better live act so act you know!! so not only the voice the whole thing dancing, singing, performing, acting

and i have to say that Britney may not have the best voice, but her shows are never boring to watch and she dances so much that she would be out of breath to sing with it too soo

she has defiantly the whole package!!!!!

[hitz1093]

xtina 

[katyac2008]

блин, ну в чем вопрос, последняя вообще не должна быть в этом списке, т.к. все остальные поют на своих концертах в живую, или хотя бы под плюс, типа николь, но она емеет петь лучше бемспирс- они не сравнимы. тем более нечег отут сравнивать агилеру и спирс- это тоде самое что сравнивать палец с *опой. безголосье нынче только тупым малолеткам нравиться.!!!!!!!!!!

[mancminx2]

1..christina

2.rihanna

3 nicole

4 britney.....brit wud of been highter if you wud have sound her actually singin and not playback and that performance of everytime was weak as! shameful!

[peoplerevolutions]

Defenitely Rihanna

[jontaylor1986]

You mean OLD BRITNEY, new britney sucks, can't dance or sing now..have you seen how she dances now, just walks around the stage, while her dancers put on the show

[mariotl]

they are all the best in something: Vocally: xitna nicole rihanna britney dancing: nicole britney xtina rihanna Better songs: rihanna britney christina nicole show: britney xtina rihanna nicole total (for me): xtina britney rihanna nicole (i dont know one song from her)

[thebritneyfan09]

1)BRITNEY SPEARS

2) xtina

3)nicole

4)rihanna

[IntoxicatedAndy]

Slave 4u VMA is Lip-sync ="=

X-tina lives the best of course (can't believe that i have to say this)

and Rihanna's the worst

[datdo95]

britney

[twilightmommy75]

1)Xtina

2)Britney

3)Nicole

4)Rihanna

[hedieh6]

1.Nicole

2.Rihanna

3.Britney

4.xtina 

[earlearlerica]

@hedieh6 you KNOW your hating U can't watch this video and have that as a line up. I understand its ur opinion But why are u the odd man out? Exactly Ur just Hating None of these girl are better singers then XTINA period so for her to be last of Ur list says alot! Especially when nicole is first. NO 1 Knows her outside of PCD. u should b embarrassed Go kill urself

[mancminx2]

@hedieh6 how can you place the voice of our generation fourth???? the latter of the list would even tell you themselves that christina has the better voice face facts xtina has the voice brit had the dance moves, rihanna has the more catchy music, nicole well.... she got the attitude

[dewdrop29]

Nicole's pretty good. Rihanna's voice and stiffness on stage is unbearable. She's gotten better tho. Britney can't sing for shit but she's great to look at and puts on a great show. Christina's got the voice, image, and commands the stage well, so Christina wins for me.

[HugeFanOfBritney]

Vocally - Christina Aguilera

Performance quality - Britney Spears ALL THE WAY!

[bnqt8ez]

XXXXTTTTIIIINNNNAAAA ALL THE WAY!!!

[yasgirl1998]

rihanna

[MiaTwilightFan]

Before Britney ruined her life with drugs she was the best perfomer ever. Now the top 4 goes like this:

1. Christina

2. Britney

3. Rihanna

4. Nicole

[xtinaandravenfan]

1) CHRISTINA AGUILER BY A CLEAR MILE

2) Nicole

3) Rihanna

4) Britney

[xtinaandravenfan]

Christina obviously EVERYTHING is live there's no competition. You shouldnt have put her in this cause shes a better singer than all 3 put together! I do love Rihanna, Britney and Nicole, but they are amateurs live compared to Christina, and you wouldnt know that unless you had actually seen and heard Christina live yourself. She sounds exactly like her CD but it is all live. Ive seen her live and it was the best concert Ive ever been too.

[GoeatMacnCheese]

As Far As Performing and Putting on a good show...Its COmpletely Britney

Vocally..i guess Christina Would Get it..

[RASHAD19able]

you know wat i dont understand why ppl think rihanna can sing better than ciara she shouldve been in this rather than her but my opinion its def

1. BRITNEY SPEARS

2. Xtina

3.Nicole

[oSUNRISEo28]

Mit großem Abstand an erster Stelle: *Christina!*

[missozkasim]

Xtina is the Diva i think she's so beautiful and has a great voice....

[elprincipito11]

madonnna!

[donj1115]

Britney...

[MrJsmoore]

xtina!!!

[Catsaline]

#1. Christina

#2. Rihanna

#3. Britney

#4. Nicole

[TheGenatsvali]

тю канешна Кристина!!!!Спирс может тоже неплоха пела бы если не спилась бы и не скурилась бы!!!

[surmavadaniko]

1-christina

2-britney

3-rihanna

4-nicole

[JiaJiaaLoveTH]

Voice Christina Britney Rihanna Nicole Performing Britney Rihanna Cristina Nicole Populairity Rihanna Britney Christina Nicole. as you see, i don't like nicole.

[snsakura]

i think

1 Christina

2 Britney

3 Nicole

4 Rihanna

[ziduga]

Xtina's voice is better but Britney does it better. Oh I love them both. I can watch their performances again and again

[Uglylera]

HAHAHA

Who is a FLOPtina???

Who is Rihanna?

Who is a Nicole?

Legendarian Miss GODney Spears of course!

[tencha1928]

´1) Britney

 2) Brit 3) Britney J. Spears 4) Bit - Bit

[tencha1928]

para mi britney en todo, da igual la peculiaridad de las demas voces y de la supuesta más potencia .... sin duda prefiero a britney en todos los sentidos... muxo mas vistoso

[tombraider3333]

1. Xtina

2.Nicole

3.Rihanna

4.Britney

[Androwoods]

voice: Xtina

Performance: Britney

♥

[brently21]

vocally-

1-christina

2-nicole

3-britney

4-rihanna

better concerts-

1-britney spears

2-nicole

3-christina

4-rihanna

[earlearlerica]

HOLY SHIT when CHRISTINA AGUILERA STARTS its like the main event started

[lrctricardo]

britney no canta en vivo, lamentablemente! Chris es la mejor sin duda!!!

[MrBspearsfan]

1) Britney

2) Britney

3) Britney

4) Britney

Conclusion: Britney is the best singing and performing

[MandyhBr]

1. Nicole (DIVA ♥)

2. X-Tina \o/

3. Rihanna

999999999999999999999999999999­999999999999999999999999999999­999999999999999999999999999999­999999999999999999999999999999­9999999999999999999999999999. Britney oops

[britneyFes]

1)britney

2)xtina

3)rihanna

4)nicole

[marysexrueda]

i said the best and the better and the unic is.............BRITNEY SPEARS.

[BlondyLIKEukr]

voice:

1.Christina

2.Rihanna

3.Britney

4.Nicole

Performance:

1.Britney

2.Christina

3.Rihanna

4.Nicole

[pantelas578]

without a doubt britney and xtina are the best (i dont wanna admit it but its the truth :s)

[muahmusic91]

BRINTEY IS ALL TIME!!!!

[booty95310]

christina aguilera !!!!! britney lol she doesn't have any voice lol

[DavidSpears26]

Are you kidding me?

BRITNEY?! she can't sing live ...

And xtina is amazing!

[martijn4life1]

oke the voice of christina is with 100% the best voice here. and she can give a fantastic show. maybe she doesnt dance that much as britney but christina sings live.

then britney she always does playback. and if you see the everytime. come on! her voice is crap! its nothing.

rhianna can sing but dont like her that much

i like nicole but something about her voice i dont like, and i cant say what//. soo

1.christina

2.rhianna.

3.nicole

100. britney

[aMasoudTorabiFilm]

Britney Spears <3333

[lyrosely]

For me:

1-Sweet Voice, Best Performer: Britney!

2- Christina

3- Nicole

4- Rehanna

[jotave007]

a maioria dos videos da britney é dublagem

[aguilerafanaz]

X and B the greatest ever.

[WHOsBAD13]

Zdecydowanie najlepsza jest Xtina. Co do Britney.. everytime zaśpiewała okropnie, ona nadaje się tylko do tańczenia.

1)Xtina is the best.

2)Nicole and Rihanna

4)Britney

[WHOsBAD13]

Zdecydowanie najlepsza jest Xtina. Co do Britney.. everytime zaśpiewała okropnie, ona nadaje się tylko do tańczenia.

Xtina is the best.

[adeneptune1]

christina no doubt about it vocaly performer and everything

[Wilxtinarg86]

Christina all the way.

[XristinaGodess]

duhhhh christina aguilera is the best performer and live!!!!!!!!!!! best voice best performance and pasion singing eaven if u put the only 2 best performances from britney she cant compete, no offense try to put the best christina aguilera performances shell beat her ass hahahahah it was so funny britneys live gross singing

[GISSELLEPEDRO]

CRISTINA AGUILERA IS THE BEST!!

[Jodi105]

X-TINA !!!!!!!

[Roxas660]

well i love brietney more all them but anly the Everitime song was live

so i dont know

[jana010]

CHRISTINA AGUILERA DUUH!!

[Scherzinger91]

Please folks, be honest with yourself.... Who do you think has the real talent?? Her name is NICOLE!!! It's a shame that she's in the same category as brit and rihanna

[xxxAnetkaa99xxx]

Obviously Christina!<3

[Glamorousdu78]

britney

rihanna

xtina

nicole

[unofficialanonbabe]

if you're looking for singing, then christina

but if you're looking for performance and entertainment, then britney. if britney sang all her songs live like she usedto, then i'd say britney cos she has got an amazing voice x

nicole is good, and i don't like rihanna she's satanic says vigilant citizen (dot) com

;/ bless her, glad my britters hasnt sold her soul to the devil to become successful, it obviously just came naturally for her x

[khukthail]

1.- CHRISTINA AGUILERA

2.-Britney Spears (The old britney ;)

3.-rihana

4.-nicole

[khukthail]

CHRISTINA is the THE BEST of these days,,and one of the best of ALL TIMES ,,, Glam her new song FEb 2010 and Bionic her new album March 2010

[ahotare23]

For me

1.nicole

2.xtina

3.rihanna

4.britney my love(^-^)

[l0os3nup]

Nowadays, it's Nicole that gives the remaining 3 a run for their money

[IdolRossiFreak]

Vocally I say Christina. But Brit is the best over all  performer.

[xtina4ever23]

i really think that the ears of some peopels dont ok...christina is the own of this stars who can sing live really i love u

[fauffe]

1.Britney

2.Christina

3.Rihanna&Nicole

[giladddddsex]

1.christina

2.britney (of the past)

3.nicole

4. rihanna

[popsingerstar]

definitely britney! britney iz the best opening act!

[contrastevideos]

Please everyone knows that Christina is one of the best singers because comparing

britney, rihanna with her

Nicole to be evolving a lot in the acute

aguilera compares with Beyoncé, Celine Dion, mariah, alicia

[TheRocNation]

Vocally:

1. Christina

2. Rihanna

3. Nicole

4. Britney (<- she even can't sing live)

[MrMs8ismail]

1-rihanna

2-britney

3-x-tina

4-nicole

[anselmo1415]

definitivamente CHRISTINA!!! the best

and britney can sing live??? come on everytime sounds terrible

[damicroquete2]

All of them are great, but here's my rank:

1- Britney

2- Nicole

3- Rihanna

4- Xtina

[Scherzinger91]

Nicole all the way.... You haven't seen nicole perform if you put these girls over her... NICOLE ROCKS!!!!!

[XBoby91]

Ofc Christina... Nicole is good and Rihanna sound very bad live.... Brit is OK... =)

[arrivdddrssssssshy]

aMmm i tHInK THe BeSt IsS

cHriSTina AwWIlera

BrITneY sPEarS

NIcoOl

rIhaNNA

i`M sURe ABOuT my RanKIng

kiSsEs

[leansoyyo]

Cantando... Christina..

En General.. Britney..

Rihanna tambien,,

y ultima Nicole,, q mucho la voz en vivo no le da

[OnyxDragon01]

Please it's:

Christina

Rhianna

Nicole

and I don't know what the hell Britney is doing here, she can't flow like the rest of them. I mean has anyone heard her live recently. She sucks! I like her songs, just not her voice.

[DADANIEL100]

everybody knows Christina aguilera.

#1 xtina

#2 nicole

#3 rihanna

#4 britney and her voice suck.

[imabadboy03]

well...i think britney is the best performer..she has the moves, the sound, and she is the most original...i have to say that christina has the better voyce even went it gets a litlle too loud...even when she has the best voice i would not listen to her voice all the like i would do with britney that has a lower range voice!!!

1-britney

2-christina

3-rihana

4-nicole

[nanushkananushka]

Y para poder compararlas hay que cantar ne directo y hay dos actuaciones de britney que son playback como siempre

[nanushkananushka]

por favor sin ninguna duda LA MEJOR ES CHRISTINA pero con solo un soplo de voz las tumba a todas en directo en playback y en el disco y como sea

[Rye669000]

in all honestly luv them ol,,.

but i really luv nicole scherzinger coz i actually proof it 2 myelf i saw her live n her other videos singing live she is really hot, she has the poised! that any1 is looking 4 a performer,.

Nicole all the n she is the best!!!

xcuse the hu post ths video i cud say that,.. dat is not the best per4mance of nicole,,,./ check it out on net, peace ebry1. ^_^

[stopisebas]

a mi realmente me encanta britney pero no hay muchos shows que cante en vivo i si canta en vivo no canta mui bien

rihanna es exelente pero no me termina de encantar

de nicole no puedo decir nada porque nunca segi su musica

Christina es exelente sin duda la mejor vocalmente:)

[stopisebas]

me parece que estan preguntando qien es mejor en vivo no en la industria

[AUGUSTOSPEARS]

brtieny por siempre 1

[MrToxicboy1]

Christina should be comperd with the greates; mariah, leona, beyonce.

[MrToxicboy1]

love britney. but is'nt it obvious that Christina has the best voice in the music industry ?

3:06 - goosebumps all over my body !!!!

[VisnjaMaksimovic]

Love your video! ;)

4th Rihanna - she's a bit over doing the whole thing, and honestly, nothing special on her live act

3rd Nicole - she has a really good voice, but she's showing more her ass than her voice

2nd Christina - I love Britney and everything, but Xtina has stronger voice, but she doesn't have to show it off, we all know how strong her voice is

1st Britney - only because her live acts are all AWESOME! Scenery, dance moves... Everything!

[norgito]

The only one with Talent.

~ Christina Aguilera

[WalkLikeALegend]

no doubt christina aguilera, shes on a whole other lever then those other girls u posted.

[serenotres]

1 Cristina Aguilera

2 Rihanna

3 La otra

4 Britney Spears

[serenotres]

jaajajaj britney is a shit.

[shinyana]

Vocally:

1)Christina

2)Rihanna

3)Nicole

4)Britney

In terms of putting on a great show:

1)Britney

2)Christina

3)Nicole

4)Rihanna

[linora5]

rihanna(L)

[alexlai0618]

1) christina aguilera

2) rhianna

3) nicole scherzinger

4) britney spears

[Nathaa1]

Nicole ! love u ! <3333

[slaviteo]

I think the best is Christina Aguilera. But the other three are good, too.

[BritneySpearsIreland]

BRITNEY BRITNEY BRITNEY

[oddmatt13]

There is no competition to Xtina's voice .-.

She's the best. .-.

[christinafansclubIT]

I'm agree with you... Xtina is the best!

[alfrosy]

senza nemmeno guardare.....indubbiamente BrItNeY sPeArS.......è LA MIGLIOREEEEEEEEEEEE

[iamindirax33]

Britney spears , the best ..

still love her

[thejokerrm]

Nicole hands down! While I still respect the others, no one comes comes close to Nicole's overall performance. I saw her performance last night and it was unbelievable!

But I think its more of a group effort with PCD. Because they are all so energetic and each contribute in their own ways. PCD rulez!

I think Britney also puts on a good show, but alot of it is lip synching. But I still love her :)

[pcdangelpinup]

Nicole Scherzinger of course!!

She's a great live singer (I was at the concert so I can proof it myself (;) an awesome performer and dancer. And it's not so easy to sing live and dance the entire song at the same time :)

[chesterbj]

christina and nicole =) 4 me

[JohnThomsonn]

Rihanna

[R8XLE]

obviously its christina

[liginhasz]

1° Rihanna

[Vannyliciousx3]

nicole

[shee108]

Nicole Scherzinger !!! ;'D

[ellew12]

1) nicole scherzinger

2) britney spears

3) christina aguilera

4) rhianna

i love them all but thats my favs

[angeldelcalavozo]

xtina

[audylipsy]

Vocal: xtina

Total Performance: Nicole!

[TYEWE]

Nicole is the best overall performer live:)

[xtinarocksmyworld4]

Christina is the best!!

[Britneyfanhungary]

Britney!

[TheHotPCD]

Nicole

[Terrormieze19]

1.Britney

2.Nicole

3.Christina

4.Rihanna

[bspeppe88]

Britney... Is Number 1

[alincumintzel]

1.Christina Aguilera...she is the best

2. Nicole Scherzinger- she is also very hot

3. Rihanna but she can't control ger voice very well

4. Britney Spears..she sucks...she can't sing live and dance

[xOxMissRamizaxOx]

Rihanna Totally!

[rajibdavid]

I mean, all of them are cool. Nicole is just awesome, she's really amazing, Britney was totally stunnig in her live performances due to only her choreography, Rihanna, i don't really like her that much and CHRISTINA! AMAZING, she does it all perfect!

[rajibdavid]

Christina Aguilera!!! She's the best!