Evanescence - Cloud Nine live a Rock am Ring

[tcakoc20]

oh come on guys!can anyone of you or anyone else do what amy does???she's the best i know!she's a real live stage singer!she never autotunes or anything else and she gives whatever she has!show some respect to these talents!

[karimmok91]

at least she does not lip sing and she's willing to go all teh way to please her fans! thumbs up if u agree



[evanescence9314]

OW, Man! Will rocks so hard! I love him! <3

[prettysoldier523]

i wonder how she does it without busting out into tears.. she puts so much emotion into every performance, and the songs themselves are so emotional o_o she's amazing<333

[evafan92]

incluso en la muerte evanescence !!!!

[TDGRoach]

I think she does a great job until the last chorus. There she gets a little bit worse.

[zainabsalah]

will rocks..love him

[Monrosefreak91094]

Hard song for live performances, right.

Still, she does it quite good.

Just notice the fact no one from you could ever sing it like that!

[Zerolagg]

It was quite good... still think Amy should do some changes to the live version, this song kinda kills her vocals, she said its the hardest to sing live but well she still did good after all, managed to end the song without losing her voice! :)

[alonegothicgirl]

love this song. love Amy. love Will. love this perfomance)

[axxz03]

@alonegothicgirl this is the best song from tod

[guitarsoloist07]

There's a difference between different from recording and straight up off key. She's tolerable in the verses/pre chorus... but chorus? She's way off key and flat.

[alarmclockmonster]

Definitely not her best... I like her glittery dress though :P I'm glad Evanescence is back, Amy's voice sure has improved a lot, their recent NYC concert sounds amazing!

[axxz03]

i love this song in the cd but in live it doesnt sound so powerfull

sadly

its a of my favorites song

[BowDownToTheQueen]

the best thing about evanescence live performances is that they are imperfect. They don't always sound like recordings. why pay to go concert to hear what you can at home. i think it was amazing because she struggled with it. it made it sound real. it made the emotions stronger. its not easy getting on a stage everyday and singing the same songs over and over. shes gotta change it up or she'll get bored. no ones perfect guys. chill out.

[Jescm124]

ok so all of you are saying she sucked ? try doing that and not mess up then...

[misscharliebrown123]

well why write a song you are not capable of singing, its a lie

all her live performances of this song suck

tbh i dont think she is that good of a singer only her acoustic songs are good

[liz280793]

have you seen them live for yourself? or just on youtube videos

when you hear it first hand her voice is incredible

[tidus919191]

OMG!!!! The worst live performance of this song!!!!! esp after 3:40!!!

[cimen1981]

AMY LEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

[fcwsoccergirl]

this is the worst performance shes had

[imafanofamylee]

she messes up coz she headbangs and moves everywhere.. but she sing rily rily good in live almost better than her records

[lane8tergurl]

i think she sang this song the best live (in my opinion) in febuary 2007 in Melbourne Australia

i was there =)

[nerdy5746]

i think amy lee has a good voice, but her songs require too much air. even she sometimes messes up.

[Rukia1523]

¡ i love this song i just adore this! a love evanescence!

i love sign this!

amy lee should be in the dictionary

[keisuke534]

actually evanescence is in the dictionary (evanesce to be exact) it means "to disappear"

[PutrescentSoul]

cloud nine is the BOMB!!!!!!!....