Don't get me wrong, I love Morny, and he's a much better hitter then Hamilton, and I'm a Die-hard Twins fan, but Hamilton hit a lot more homers then Justin, and Everyone thinks he should have won. I think hamilton should have won, but i was rooting for J the whole time. Justin easily could do that in a regular game.
ummm....MORNEAU....he was not some dumb ass and us all his pawer to set a record and then hit like 3 in like the last round....morneau got and he dersered it
Morneau Morneau Morneau! Rules are set for a reason! Morneau won and did it by playing by the rules set by MLB... No debate here! Congrats Josh on your 35 homeruns
Yeah because Morneau is a fucking beast fuck Hamilton Josh Hamilton performed when he didnt need to Morneau went to win when it actually counted in the last round dont make up excuses because he lost he hit more home runs when it actually counted. Oh and its not Justin Monroe. It's Justin Morneau.
it doesnt matter how many homeruns hamilton got in the first round..he could of got 100..i dont care..the first round doesnt even really matter..u just have to get enough to advance to the 2nd round. in order to win the whole thing..u have to get the most homeruns in the LAST round...which hamilton didnt do because he was probably tired out...it may not be fair in your eyes..but thats the way it has always been...GO MORNEAU!
It is what it is. Hamilton set the record and has got a lot more attention than MORNEAU did for winning the derby. However, as someone else said, rules are rules and Justin somehow pulled it off. Get over it!
Hamilton = Record setting HR's for the derby and huge amounts of recognition (No trophy).
Morneau = HR Derby Champion, less home runs, much less recognition (Trophy).
The rules are the rules. It's not Morneau's fault Hamilton 9and maybe his pitcher) ran out of gas at the end. There have been many instances in the past where the person who puts on the best show in the early rounds do not win. The rules have basiclty been the same, except this year they allowed the home runs to carry over in the first couple rounds this yar. Justin was the tortoise in this race.
All he really got was a trophy, Hamilton still has they glory and adulaton. You can't have it all.
Don't get me wrong, I love Morny, and he's a much better hitter then Hamilton, and I'm a Die-hard Twins fan, but Hamilton hit a lot more homers then Justin, and Everyone thinks he should have won. I think hamilton should have won, but i was rooting for J the whole time. Justin easily could do that in a regular game.
EmanTHEeman 2 years ago
JUSTIN MORNEAU BABYYYY
kathisaballer 2 years ago
morneau ;)
stuwiii93 2 years ago
morneau!!
ianmader1 3 years ago
ummm....MORNEAU....he was not some dumb ass and us all his pawer to set a record and then hit like 3 in like the last round....morneau got and he dersered it
baseballdude1930 3 years ago
Morneau Morneau Morneau! Rules are set for a reason! Morneau won and did it by playing by the rules set by MLB... No debate here! Congrats Josh on your 35 homeruns
rustyvette1998 3 years ago 2
Hey bud, its not who should've won,
its who won.
JUSTIN MORNEAU
MVP MVP MVP MVP MVP MVP
ATLvikesfan 3 years ago 5
JUSTIN MORNEAU Won!!!!
DINKnDIVE 3 years ago 3
Morneau won and did not waste his homruns in round 1
TwinsGomez22 3 years ago
Yeah because Morneau is a fucking beast fuck Hamilton Josh Hamilton performed when he didnt need to Morneau went to win when it actually counted in the last round dont make up excuses because he lost he hit more home runs when it actually counted. Oh and its not Justin Monroe. It's Justin Morneau.
adambomb811 3 years ago
even if Justin won I will remmber Josh alot more.
Dankeelova8087 3 years ago
it doesnt matter how many homeruns hamilton got in the first round..he could of got 100..i dont care..the first round doesnt even really matter..u just have to get enough to advance to the 2nd round. in order to win the whole thing..u have to get the most homeruns in the LAST round...which hamilton didnt do because he was probably tired out...it may not be fair in your eyes..but thats the way it has always been...GO MORNEAU!
toriihunter4821 3 years ago
It is what it is. Hamilton set the record and has got a lot more attention than MORNEAU did for winning the derby. However, as someone else said, rules are rules and Justin somehow pulled it off. Get over it!
Hamilton = Record setting HR's for the derby and huge amounts of recognition (No trophy).
Morneau = HR Derby Champion, less home runs, much less recognition (Trophy).
smza0601 3 years ago 3
Morneau won... Look at the description of the derby
larsen550 3 years ago
that boy is cute
corgan1999 3 years ago 2
The rules are the rules. It's not Morneau's fault Hamilton 9and maybe his pitcher) ran out of gas at the end. There have been many instances in the past where the person who puts on the best show in the early rounds do not win. The rules have basiclty been the same, except this year they allowed the home runs to carry over in the first couple rounds this yar. Justin was the tortoise in this race.
All he really got was a trophy, Hamilton still has they glory and adulaton. You can't have it all.
vrjustin82 3 years ago
I like how you call morneau monreau. I thought that was funny but i vote morneau.
browniepoints37 3 years ago
When I have 100 votes I will give the results
catcherboy80 3 years ago
I think Hamilton
catcherboy80 3 years ago