American Idol - Idol Gives Back: Miley Cyrus segment

[Talodie]

i like her, but i think shes more of an album singer rather than a stage person. no offense to her or anything, its just her voice does sound a bit out of tune at times... other than that you have to admit, she is pretty good

[sweetandspicy2008]

Oersinally, I am not a miley fan. I don't like her singin. However, I do respect that she doesn't lip synch. I just don't think she did a very good job. But then again, she was dancing alot. Soooo I'm not hating on her at all! Everyone is entitled to there own opinion. I appreciate her raising awareness for this though.

[blackstar096]

man she is sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­ooo SEXC i love her man fudge all u haterzs

[JBforever91692]

so if this video made you cry, you don't know the full story. Miley told these kids she would help them build a new house, and never came back. My youth gruop just took a mission trip there and the kind people at Big Creek Missions,and youth groups frm churches across the country, helped fufill the promise miley failed to keep. Those children are so sweet and greatfull for everything they have and it broke their hearts that Miley never helped them again. Great Job Miley, keep up the good work.

[AngelDust155]

She's helped by donating millions of dollars to charities, plus truthfully, how would YOU know the full story cause I've never heard of that.

[Naksa2]

those kids creepd me out

[ckw039]

The poverty video is so cool and sad.

[DanielleeeeJ]

i love how she just holds her butt at 1:29

..so random

[devangna16]

she......is tryin to HARD

[hannahsBIGGESTfan99]

she was sick during this performance but at least she still went out and sang

[livelaughlove91692]

she sounds really sick

[drdouble5]

This is some freaky shit.

What is up with 1:27-30

Weird butt grab thing?

woahhhh XD

[shutupandplay22]

It's hard to sing and dance at the same time, obviously, so it's not gonna sound perfect.

[BryloveSnapandMin]

that nearly made me cry

[chixxgirl]

OMG, HOW COULD THEY LIVE LIKE THAT? POOR THEM. OMG NOW I REALIZE THAT IT IS OKAY IF I DONT HAVE EVERYTHING I WANT CUZ I GOT ALOT OF STUFF, AND THESE KIDS HAVE NOTHING NOT EVEN BOOKS, video like that make you crying and thinking before you say what you want

[bridgetmiller80]

wow that is nice of her to go there and do wha she did an billy ray she is awesome and i have never seen that before well i have seen where people got flooded in,but that was really nice and im proud of her

[XoReneex8o]

she also took our her earpiece which means she cant hear herself..she is just hearing people screaming and the band, and stuff..

[lettergirl94]

haha. well at least we know that she doesn't lip sinc.

[twnklestar]

it sounds like she has a cold

[DylaZx]

god..she almost spinning me! u're terror!!

[SMoonEmpress]

I would love to know what the basis for comparison is when people diss this performance. There are very few singers who could perform that much choreography and still maintain the quality of singing that Miley does here. I'm not really a fan, but I think this is great for a live performance with heavy choreography.  Her vocals would certainly improve if she just stood there and sang it, but that's not very entertaining now, is it?

[Renthead966]

EXACTLY! Even if people don't like her - I'd like to see them try to maintain any singing voice when dancing like that, let alone the quality she manages!

[Powerpufflaus]

what difficult choreography? it was easy as pie! she just walked around stage it isnt as if though she had to make difficult spins or jumps or whatever. besides she didnt sing even acceptably. it was terrible! and this is coming from a fan of this song (when sung correctly)

[tcshadd]

she is soooo hot

[ILoveMileyCyrus14]

yeah Miley, you rock, you do the right things, i love you so much, You go, ignore all of the haters

you have a lovely voice and dont let anyone tell you otherwise, you countine what your doing

[ZeldaOcarinaForever]

@ILoveMileyCyrus14 you fail

[PonyProductionz]

ok in my opinion miley cyrus sucks at singing

she pretty i guess

but not good at singing

in my opinion

[kunochikuti]

depends on the song

[TomBakerIsMyHero]

she has an excellent gorgeous shapely body.

[TomBakerIsMyHero]

she has the voice of an angle and the body of one too.

[Luchrocksmysocks24]

OMFG I AGREE WITH YOU 100% shes soo beautiful. . . .

[AListerUnlimited]

omg she sounds so good

i dont know what your talking about

she sounds like the best omg just the best live singer ever..you guys are just so jealous when you all see talent!!

o.o

J/K!!!

[SmilyGirl99]

i love her

[sftballbabe257]

she did amazingg!

but it does sound like shes sick

[Arbiter1231]

i thought the performance was good but it sounded like she had a cold because it was nasally

[cheys94]

i think that she is beautiful but she sucks

[musicjunkie13]

she sounds like theres something in her nose, i just think she's awful

[December91991]

jezz... to much moving around lol.

she could do better

[12audreyj21]

Miley rocks! :D

[sharpayshow]

i felt so bad for all of the kids it made me cry me and my mom donated $150

[sillyblonde49880]

i like it at 2:32 she is like pfft wht ever lol

[MileymakesmeSmiley]

i love her but she sound like shes got a head cold, but she still sounds super good

[Jillibean90]

go to 2:19... hahaha

[jonasmanaic]

wats up the dance moves wat the hell

[zizmo227]

so i guess "she's just being miley" LMAO

[youlookCANCEROUS]

limp wrist syndrome around 1:47

[madizawesome]

shes trying to act sexy and its wierd

[missbossy94]

yeah im like miley's fan but this vid she just sucks at singing... hahahha but yeah chakashi i wonder wht simon will say... lol

[BuffyCharmedForever]

Can anyone just say this for once...

MILEY CYRUS ROCKS!!!!!!!!!

[911adamboy911]

although I do agree

[flyyhustler]

you can tell shes sick...when shes not sick the song sounds way better. The performance sucked.

[911adamboy911]

what are you her mommy?

[funkdafresh]

why is she trying to be sexy? shes like freaking out. p.s. ur like 15 and ur not sexy. im not a fan. but i like the song. lol.

[alhurstchiomemc]

sah probly had alergees

[beachygirl65]

miley had a soar throat when she did this thats why it sounds weird !!!!

[audreyisamonster]

she sounds so hoarse

[confusedain]

anyone knows wats the title of the song they were playing on the poverty part?? it was a guy singing a country song rite??

[CaMaverick]

The song is called Ain't No Reason by Brett Dennen

[confusedain]

thank you ...thank you so much!!!!! ;D

[xnileyxfanxx]

1. she has a cold

2. she got her teeth fixed that changes her voies miley u rock

[03cristi]

ok so i do like mileycyrus. but she didn't really sing that good. i'm guessing she was kind of sick or something but w.e. and the video of the family was cute.:)

-cristina<3

[Mihoriel]

This reminds me of my community service in Crank Creeks, Kentucky. They too were affected the coal mines. It was nice to see that someone portrayed poverty here in Chicago and someone so young as well. I rarely like Miley/Hannah Montana but I give her credit here.

[wingedlizard]

Wow. I didn't get to see this on TV, but jsut wow. I think she's an excellent role model, and she's jsut having fun. She obviously connected with the kids in the video. :]

[KodyBoye]

And I just want to say this:

She has a heart of gold, a lot bigger than anyone who's calling her a tramp and other such names.

[KodyBoye]

I like the spunk she's getting. I mean, no one acts like a girly-girl anymore. I'm glad she has a good family to back her up, and anyone who thinks she's going to turn into Britney is weird. She's obviously intelligent.

[cookieCRUNCHER2]

Whatever her reason was for sounding the way she did i totally love her. Everyone who tries to find something horrible about her performence should really keep it to themselves, no one asks for your opinions. All you guys care about is how 'horrible' she sounds, if you are so great yourself and such a nice person why dont you even notice the charity video at the end? its so great that shes only 15 and shes helping change the world. Do you see other 15 year olds do that? <3 u miley.

[SeLRahC17]

when you sing dont dance.

your voice sounded like a horseantula (horse f*cking a tarantula) singing a song

[freakfor1drama]

Not her best performance... Sorry Miley.. :/

Good and broken wasn't too great eithier

Same with the KCA's...

[lilmizsmarty]

oh shut up people! gosh! she does a good thing for charity and your making it seem like something horrible! cant someone just give it a freakin break? shes 15 and shes making a difference. you dont see other 15 year old celebs doing that lately! just give it a rest! its all for a good cause and thats what matters.

[xnileyxfanxx]

i agree 100 persent

[maddiehyh]

about time miley did something useful. but the performance ruined the poverty video. no offense, but miley and billy ray kinda seemed fake during the video, like they were doing it for the cameras.

[emilyim817]

is she like sick? she sounds kinda nasilyy

but still ithink she's pretty good :)

[TheDemarkinator]

she like added her own harmony it was weird not her best work i really don't like miley she is soooo full of herself

[lilflip26]

i think this was amazing for a 15 year old...

she looks sexy and she her dancing was ...hot. i dont think she is trying to grow up too fast i think she is having fun like all 15 year old girls now a days...

[madisonxmurray]

Who really cares if she didn't do all that great? it was all for the right cause, so cut her some slack...

You've got to admit, she's doing a great deed so don't hate on her!

[cydonaireproductions]

I think that Miley did a great job! Although some parts and at the beginning of the song she kinda sounded (in See You Again, she sounded like she has a flu or was she sick?) bad but still I think she's great!

[jenLUFFSnickJAY]

i got meh hater blockers on.

[LTHSGIIRL21]

ummm miley quit trying to grow up 2 fast,, it was nice what u did in the end with the video but ummm u were dancing like a tramp,, is that the example you want to give,, please clean it up,, or you are gunna go on a path that nobody is gunna like,, ohh and umm what did yr dad have to say about that performance?

[mariaandvalerieshow]

Mileyroxs145 you should calm down and admit to what happened on that stage! it ws a miniature Britney type disater gopefully she straightens out her path and goes back to the way she used to be remember shes a role odel and nho little 7 yr. old girl should be thrusting with her legs wide open ont he floor. Just my Opinion i've seen her do much better. and Heard her sing much better.

[Arbiter1231]

lol learn to spell

[SuperNova077]

whoa... miley, i did not see Jesus my lord and savior in that dancing...... remember? you wanted to thank a certain Jesus for your award before??? I love you, seriously, but please... clean up your dancing, your kid fans dont need to see all that.

[ilive4Johnnydepp]

its not bad

[4414744056]

ughh..she has a coreographer

[x0wowx0]

i love miley but idk about this vid i mean i thought it was a little..over the top, she has rele changed but this was the first time ive seen her like this. BUt she was probabaly just trying to ahve fun...i hope she doesnt changeee =[

[jenLUFFSnickJAY]

hah, she sucks.

she's like being all "rocker" and she's not.

then she dances sluty when she's sposta be a romodel.

THEN she coppied Nick Jonas with the "2,3,4!" thing.

so yeah.

[mileyroxs145]

u no wat........ ur probably just jelous of miley because she has more talent than u. I'd like to see you do better than that. Ur such a hater. U can go fuck ur self because if miley sucked they wouldn't even invite her to perfrom on american idol.

[mileyroxs145]

ok first tell me this.... y would american idol invite miley to sing if she sucked. She came on oprah, ellen, regis and kelley, jay leno..... so shut up and dont talk if you can't even match up to what she is doing.HATER!

[mariaandvalerieshow]

They invited her cuz shes famouse and little girls love her but you got to admit it wasn't that good.

[Arbiter1231]

ya i agree it was only ok... but it didnt suck

[Kempfer18]

Damn straight

[Kempfer18]

You don't even know what you are talking about in the first place so don't talk

[mariaandvalerieshow]

i kind of do.

please don't be in denial im not ring to star troblems with anyone .

but if your going to stick up

for some one have good reasons behinde it

shes half ruined her good girl

image and this

show

wear she sang poorly

doen't make her any better.

IN MY OPINION.

[jonasmanaic]

miley sucks so much she is soooo bad!!!

[Kempfer18]

your a frickin retard if you think she is really bad, you don't know anything anyway and are you famous thought not, so don't talk

[LeanaDemi]

yeah thats right i agree with Kempfer18

and if your gonna act like that why

look at her videos?

[mileyroxs145]

I agree with u kempher18!! The r just haters. They can just go suck balls because they have no talent and they are just jelous of miley.

[Kempfer18]

precisely, they are all just mad because they don't have any skills, and Miley IS the BEST!!!!!!!

[manny32091]

ROLMAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[ilive4Johnnydepp]

ya so much thats y shes on there and thats why she sings 4 charty tard

[Arbiter1231]

lol lets see if u can sing anybetter

[helenLouise92]

you can tell she is singing live

[KoloroweSmerfy]

Wow Miley sings awsome!

Wow!

Great video Thanks!

[iheartjonas123]

and shes doing a great thing for those not a fortunate

[iheartjonas123]

miley is such a great artist i love it

[Kempfer18]

Miley is soooooo great and beautiful as well. She is amazing, I loved it!!!!!!!!