Added: 4 years ago
From: ericbxl1963
Views: 365,452
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (155)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • those arrangements are just marvellous, honestly, got to give the Kolacny Brothers some real credit for arranging those songs for choir. They ALWAYS make something very unique out of songs one has heard so often before

  • Shivers are running down my spine...

  • I would cry at the feet of any of these girls.

  • This sounds so beautiful! I miss being in choir.

  • ζημια. . .

  • Nothing like a good cover!!

  • WONDERFUL!!

  • actually gasped when it started, they're amazing!!

  • im very surprised at just how broad of a musical pallette they actually cover across all their albums. These girls are amazing.

  • OMG, this makes the song sounds so much more sad....I love this song!

  • NOBODY FUCKS WITH PLACEBO!

  • I think this could have been a lot better if:

    When the tempo changed and they went into the Cannon, there was a break, and 2 or three girls singing a high pitch cannon during the break.

    I hope that sort of makes sense to anyone?

  • this cover does misses the feeling :/ their covers of mutter by rammstein or yellow by coldplay are much better.

  • great great great song & greatest cover!

  • the original song is emo as balls

    this version is peaceful

  • echt gut :D

    aber placebo ist unschlagbar

  • @Musicfreak121314

    ein kleiner Tip von mir:

    "Go to a concert of these, close your eyes and enjoy the angelic sound!"

  • @Dodgewc051 ich hab doch nicht gesagt das sie schlecht sind , ich find sie sogar sehr gut.

    aber ich finde placebo bringt bei dem lied einfach mehr gefühl rüber.

  • @Musicfreak121314

    Sorry das mein Kommentar missverständlich war. Ich habe das Stück Live genießen dürfen und es kommt natürlich deutlich wärmer und mit mehr Gefühl herüber als hier auf dem Video. Das Stimmvolumen eines Chores kann leider ( oder vielleicht "Gott sei Dank" ) nicht in ein paar Bit's gequetscht werden. Solltest Du die Möglichkeit haben ein Scala-Konzert zu besuchen, lege die 30€ dafür an, glaube mir, die sind es wert, insbesondere das Repertoire aller Musikrichtungen überzeugt.

  • I'm in love with it...

  • No, the original version is better! I listened to creep, the blowers daughter and yellow before and I both like the originals and the covers, but that are slow songs, but the girls sing to fast and I don't feel the emotions. You can't convert every song you want from every band, some songs don't work, and some do very well - like creep.

  • wow

  • Ich bin wirklich ein großer Placebo- Fan. Un' auch von Scala war ich bis jetzt immer begeistert gewesen. Trotzdem weiß ich nich', was ich von diesem Cover halten soll. "The Bitter End" ist eines meiner absoluten Lieblingslieder, un' ich find' es schwierig zu interpretieren. Ehrlich gesagt finde ich, dass die Gesamtstimmung des Liedes nich' so gut rüber kommt. Dazu sind die Mädchenstimmen zu "weich". Sonst finde ich es eigentlich ganz gut (:

  • ololo xDDD

  • Like with most of the covers I don't like the piano.

    This cover is much better in the end and it is always more fun to combine a choir with the original style of music. You can see what I mean if you hear the Can't always get what you want cover by Scala.

    Or just do it accapella.

  • die cover von anderen liedern find ich größtenteils wirklich sehr gelungen... auch rammstein ist klasse... aber hiervon bin ihc absolut nicht überzeugt worden... ich hätte es ja kaum erkannt obwohl placebo zu meinen absoluten lieblingsbands zählt... also mir persönlich gefällt hier das cover überhaupt nicht

  • wo kommen die eigentlich her?

    da sie ja scheinbar auch sehr gerne deutsche songs cover...

  • @Zombiepull Belgien

  • aus belgien kommen sie.

  • belgië

  • Awesome Version of the Placebo Hit!!!

  • thats soo cool ;D

  • Wonderful, words just fail me.

  • war heute bei denen zum konzert !

    das war einfach nur geil !

    die sind der wahnsinn !

  • last verse is just great!!

  • des schlagzeug is minimal das lied is einfach geil ich finde es fast besser als das orginal

  • Interessante Version!

    Was mich stört, ist das Schlagzeug. Wenn man vergleicht - ich finde, das hätten sie bei "Smells like teen spirit" hundertmal eher nehmen können - da hätte es vielleicht gepasst. Hier passt es nicht, finde ich.

  • Skala is sooo geil :)

  • der geilste ist immer noch der Dirigent

    wie der abgeht

  • ich finds sehr emotional !

  • also die anderen gecoverten lieder von den fand ich ja echt klasse aber das hier kommt einfach nicht ans original ran..vie zu wenig emotionen.

  • dem stimme ich zu

  • och nöööö, das mussten sie echt nich covern -.- ... klingt doof!

    hungriges herz, rammstein alles in ordnung aber es gibt lieder da sollten man es echt lassen...

    meine meinung!

  • It's well sung, but it doesn't transport ANY of the song's emotions.

  • @DeepEyes87 thats what im talking about. there just some song on this planet you should not cover!

  • @DeepEyes87 I agree. It's the same with a lot of their covers. It's awesome that they covered it, and they did a good job, but there isn't the same feeling.

  • @crippledfrombirth Of course, it isn't the SAME, but it's antoher...

  • @DeepEyes87 oh but it does, just perhaps different emotions in an entirely different manner

  • @DeepEyes87 I've never heard a choir that had anywhere near this much emotion, which granted, compared to Placebo isn't much, but it's hard to transfer the emotion from what is essentially a pop song, to a full choir. The strings are beautiful though.

  • @DeepEyes87 yes it does

  • Thats awesome !

  • great, just great!!

  • Mon Dieu ça m'a donné des frissons ! =O

  • they're awesome and I really like most of their stuff, but the incredible energy that makes this song so special to me doesn't really come across here...

  • Um... Boring.

  • oh my god.. its soo beautiful .. oO

  • scala is awesome...

    many different songs, but always awesome

    chapeau !!!!

  • Comment removed

  • it isn't better than placebo, its new, its fantastic, placebo also, but thats a kind of sound which i see for a music revolution (POP*Orchestre/classic+new)

  • Wow! They're all really really great singers and the Kolacny Brothers are really cool too! I love them! I want to be a singer, or part of a larger group, so that I can be just like them! I'll get my brother to conduct because he is bald! lol (He had cancer.)

  • beautiful! great cover

  • ehe they are good just different way of listen to music i ncie to hear something different time to time

  • ph....

  • tnx

  • fantastic!

  • SCALA !!!

    I'm The biggest fan !!! <3

  • i'm too :)

  • i didnt know they covered placebo!

    hui!

  • Waouh... C'est magnifique <3

  • wow theyre all grown up!

    good stuff

  • like the song,but i think the end with the drums don´t fit to the rest of the song

  • Comment removed

  • This is too amazing. they took an already amazing song by an amazing band and made it gorgeous in a completely different way.

  • I'♥ ♫

  • loved it!

  • I'm not denying this is good but it just didn't do it for me....At least it wasn't nancy boy.....

  • Wow, that's jolly good-I'm a huge Placebo-fan...this is realy great!

  • ich liebe placebo und ich liebe dieses lied! hörs grad zum ersten mal und es is wirklich richtig geil geworden!

    LOVE IT <3

  • Thank you Placebo for this song ...this is great performance

  • lol

  • sorry but i miss the guitars and drums

  • I agree. And Molko's voice. But it's still cool.

  • They are wonderfull, there piano singing is so amazing, though this song gives them no place to show it but also in this song they are great!

  • wow scala is brutal! They sing muse, i love muse, they sing placebo, i love placebo, they sing radiohead, i love radiohead, the sing nirvana """", the sing U2 """"!! They are just great

  • agreed! ^^

  • hey....scala war bei mir daheim...also eine von ihnen...ich selber simge auch in einem mädchenchor..und dieses lied habensie auch geseungen....ich liebe dieses chor..sie sind die besten..scala i love you !!!

  • This is great!!!

  • wow get so much shivers! im a huge placebo fan

    congrats!!!!!!!!!!!

  • where can i download this song someone tell me please!!!!!!

  • If you find out, plz, get in touch! I love it too! =)

  • You can download it on iTunes. :)

  • nice choir

    nice performance

  • this doesn't really rock. what they do is cool though

  • well it's a choire... why should it rock?!

    but it's a nice version...

  • this is so beautiful, watched them live in neerpelt at the european music festival for the youth in belgium

  • top

  • super geil gemacht......

  • they covered well smells like, and sweat dreams, but this is almost cheap- this song is again desparate-

  • the group needs some male voices. I amatourly feel the lack of altos in the song.

  • O stary..

    O.o

    Chyba jednak wolę normalną wersję..To placebową..

  • Scala rock, i love them! {>

  • grat

  • ciekawe czy Brian to widział

  • myślisz ze by się wkurwił? :D

  • myślę, że byłby zadowolony

  • Hehe I watched this for a laugh but it's actually really good! Nicely done...

  • i would love them to cover something like Raining Blood by Slayer...or something ridiculously heavy, just for entertainment perposes....but i reckon it would still sound really good

  • this group is great.

    a girl choir covering songs like these, the idea is great.

    The voice is very beautiful. They sing songs, i couldn't imagine a cover version like this....

  • this group is great.

    a girl choir covering songs like these, the idea is great.

    The voice is very beautiful. They sing songs, i couldn't imagine a cover version like this....

  • beautifuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uul

  • this is so kickass

  • Gedurfd, maar geslaagd! :)

  • that is real rock ^^

  • i like all their songs (with or without you, someone new, schrei nach liebe), but this song ... i dunno ... i don't really like it.. it's perhaps because i really love placebo and nobody can be as good as they are anyway... but i think the girls are too 'sensitive' to sing this song^^

  • Wierd... and quite pointless.

    Anyway it's too fast and the words come out like from a camera shutter

  • This is a Belgian girls choir that covers pop/rock songs. They're GOOD at it!!!

  • lets agree ... u dont like it. if u say it is bad, you dont have respect of talent.

    i also like placebos version more than this ... but it is a great cover version

  • That's funny :-)

  • this gave me shivers its so good.

    i do love scala and the kolacny bro's.. but this song, i dunno, its not as good as the original version this time. but they are amazing. and this version is great :)

  • i really love scalat they are fantastic but most of them show no emotion whatsoever! some of them just look like there in another world! its a real letdown for what would otherwise be a flawless performance...they could take a leaf out of there conductor's book!

  • well. . . interesting . . . but where's the fucking anger? "See you at the bitter end!"

  • i really like this song and instrumental it's good too. and i like the funny way how kolacny leads the choir :-D

  • it's okay... somehow beatyfull different. It's a very nice song. But you're right. Brian Molko sounds better.

  • Beautiful voices. But they don't fit the song. Placebo rocks!!!

  • very nice sounds very good

  • A bit strange and very diffrent from Placebo. But great done work.

  • I miss something from the original. this version is nice but a bit boring.

  • i love placebo and this is really great

  • :( Placebo daha güzel söylüyo bunlar iğrenç söylemişler.

  • placebo is great but this version of that awesome song is bad. thats my opinion

  • like it. Placebo and scala are great

  • i can't believe. ha-AAaaaa. kul

  • wow ;D

  • Wow, completely haunting and absolutely beautiful...

  • magique magnifique merveilleux génial ouiiiiiiiiiiiiii j'adore

  • Still lokking for the video of their version of with or whitout you o/

  • Placebo!

  • uuummm wow

  • great ^^

  • wow

  • Very beautiful... I can take on the world after I listen to this

  • Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha­hahahaha

  • awesome...!

  • in a world where angry frustated boys are serial killing alikes in churches of knowledge, this girls are painting the world in beatiful chorus notes!! AMAZINGLY BEAUTIFUL!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more