Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (138)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • mejor voz tiene taylor hanson(from hanson)

  • Extraordinary! A beautiful voice!

  • Simply Beautiful.

  • MORE MORE MORE MORE PLEASE

  • Wow! The two of you are just amazing together. I would have to agree with those who said it is both spine chilling and heavenly. How that is possible, I am not sure. Saving to my favorites and sharing with more than a few friends.

  • Whoa when she started singing it sent shivers down my spine, what a cool voice!

  • What  shall we say - soooo treasured

    Arthur Klemt from Europe, Bavaria.

  • Hopelessly in love with the voice

  • This is the best version of Summertime on Youtube. It is better than the full scale orchestras. I can hear fealing in yours. You aren't just belting it Opera-style, which is one of the strong suits of your performance.

  • As good a rendition as I've ever heard. Outstanding, absolutely outstanding.

  • Your voice is perfect for this song!

  • A truly beautiful and sensitive rendition of a song whose roots extend much further back in time than most are aware of.

  • I cannot find the words to express how this heavenly version touched me

  • wow escalofriante

  • Feels like some kind of magic flowing through my head!

  • heavenly! can u guys do "My Funny Valentine" :)

  • Great voice. Good rendition

  • Hey I love this version of the Gershwin classic--lovely voice. When I try to share the link on FB it takes up the whole page. Can you fix it?

  • OHHH MY! I could not believe this.

  • OH MYYYYYYYYYYYY HEAD HAS BLOWN AWAY.I find it dificult to end this sentence, i have went into a trance.

  • Wow, that was amazing! It reminds me of the first time I heard Eva Cassidy's Autumn Leaves.

  • This is one of my faves on youtube, beautiful & haunting, kinda like Portishead does Gershwin!

  • Beautiful voice. Great sound.

  • I like your take on it! Thank you.

    This old Ukrainian lullaby song came to life.. ;)

  • У Edith есть, по меньшей мере, один поклонник в России.

  • @Kostrov86 как минимум два !

  • Love you baby... It's great.

  • So nice and sensitive...Where can I find this piano-notes version?

  • I agree with all the good things said on here. Most people try to change the song someway or another and even though you made it your own its more like the original I dont really know what Im trying to say here but wow.

  • This is the best cover of this song I've ever heard!

  • fact.

  • Wow... this is, simply beautiful, the vocals sent shivers down my spine seriously xD I love being able to hear one of my favorite songs still sung this well after all these years :3

  • Outstanding!

    Very sexy voice and really cool keys!

  • Beautiful! Great voice and great piano! You're gorgeous!

  • Zdunić !!!! Croatia awesome cover

  • ew, sounds depressing

  • Awesome... I love the way you brought the solemness and beauty to the song... pure talent

  • lovely

  • Only one problem!

    NOT ENOUGH OF YOUR INCREDIBLE STUFF ON HERE!!!!

    Creep was awesome too - more please, pretty please with sugar on top :)))

  • tell you what i was not expecting that! beautiful. I reckon that would work better than any lullaby, certainly makes me want to go to sleep! :D

  • This is so intense and beautiful. I love it.

  • Beautiful playing & beautiful singing!

    Bravo5*****

    Greetings from Canada!

    Amelia:)

  • wow,your good!

    im lost for words...

  • what a breathtaking remix!

    wonderful rendition :] <3

  • Loved it. Edith has a great 'breathy' singing tone. Bang in tune too, well done

  • wow, this truly encapsulates the perfect mood of this song! Angelic voice is incredible with the right choice of piano dynamics! 10/10! best cover of this song ive seen in a while.

  • NICE JOB!!!

  • I love this voice

  • the voice of an angel!

  • omg!! What a voice!!!

  • 5/5 ...lovely version. great piano and voice. grats

  • good voice! grat!

  • AMAZING!!!

  • her voice is enchanting

  • nice voice

  • best cover i've found yet!!

  • love the song my mom used to sing it to me when i was little...but i think that this girl is going out of her vocal range her voice keeps cracking on the really high notes but other than that she is a pretty good singer

  • wow!

  • her voice,,is like soo breakable

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Sent shivers down my spine. Thank you.

  • PWN SAUCE

  • If Gershwin were alive today he'd say..

    .."that's the note......and my leading lady'

    Magnifique!

  • beautiful :-)

  • thanks! ( :

  • All I can meerly say is ""Wow an Amazing""were can I get a copy of this please>

  • We have plans for such ventures. WIll keep you posted.

  • please do ,Thank you.

  • Absolutely beautiful voice! I like the breathiness but it could be just a touch less. Having said that, tthe ensemble is one of the best I've heard recently :)

  • yeah, i was too close to the mic. and not controlling breath well. thanks for the compliment.

  • No problem. Good work.

  • Es una de las mejores versiones que he escuchado. Me encanta!

  • Muchos gracias, Senor.

  • So talented!

    Oh, and so pretty....

    More!!!

  • ( :

  • I really love it, congratulations both of you!!!!! give us more songs!!!!!!

  • ( :

  • wonderful! ur voice sounds magical n is very tender...i'd love to do a duet with you sometime! extremely soothing and delicate too! you make the listener think of words to describe your voice with! great vocals and brilliant accompaniment too!

  • how sweet. thank you

  • Agreed. She really strikes a chord deep down - that voice could melt stone.

  • There is a little shy singer, but her voice is delicious.

  • haha, thank you. very sweet.

  • absolutely wonderful. thank you.

  • Little gem.

  • I like the tone and the melody you sang it so well! It's one of my favourite songs

  • tender, and angelic yet seductive and even a bit pensive.

    a beautiful duo! thanks again - worth a cd of covers and originals, if you ask me.... get working on it!

  • thank you, j.

    means a lot to me that you like it.

  • wow !!! it's beautiful

  • Beautiful voice. The piano is very complimentary. You two sound great together on this.

  • beautiful....

  • awesome!

  • Bellissima interpretazione, bravi.

    Edgar

  • When is your album comin' out folks?

    ...Sounds wonderful!

    Great talent both of you!

  • aww, thanks. that's too sweet of you

  • beautiful voice and the sounds of the piano!

  • thanks

  • You have a lovely voice. It sounds like without the mic, it could be quite quiet, especially on the low notes. Anyway, beautifully done x

  • thanks. my voice was very weak at the time, as i've mentioned. i've been starting to work on it.

  • Thats okay! And dont worry about your voice being weak, you cant tell. I had this terrible cough a few months ago and when the cough finally went away I had to work on my voice every day for weeks to get it strong again. I still havn't quite recovered from it though I had it in February. It's extremely irritating. Oh well, i've been told that my throat should be completely recovered by the end of the year which is good. Maybe then i'll put a few videos on, if not before. Look out for me! xx

  • thanks. i'll look for you.

  • Thats truly amazing!!!!

    This is the first vocal cover of the song i've heard so far that actually sounds like what it's supposed to be... a lullaby!! Your voice is so pure and sweet but slightly haunting! Its Gorgeous! Blew me away!

    Do you get the bluesy voice with your head voice or chest voice?

    God Bless! x

  • I dont know for definite but by the sounds of things, it's in her head voice. That's where you get the real breathy quality so im assuming thats what shes using. xx

  • Comment removed

  • Hi :)

    Thank you :)

    i have heard many people sing this song, famous singers.

    I can not listen to any of them after i listened to yours lovely passion for what you sing and what you play.

    Im talking too much now, cause i am elated with your voice :) again, THANK YOU

  • this is encouraging to read. thank you

  • I would like to say: Fine Art! ;)

    Very well done,

    Roland

  • very nice of you to say. ( :

  • beautiful....this is great work to see..very inspirational...as I am in early days of vocal training...where I discovered I could actually sing after many years of thinking I didnt have a voice...your work is amazing!!! thank u

  • Vocal training can work wonders. I'm hoping to do some soon.

  • Loved it !

    Keep doing...

  • thanks

  • This song lends itself to so many different style voices, it really is one of the most flexible songs ever composed. I LOVE the breathiness in your voice, very cabaret style and I envision you singing in some smokey, laid back french cafe with a boa around your neck and you laying on top of the piano with sultry eyes..something out of "Casablanca". I'm more of a classical singer BUT I love this version too. Sing on Edith, sing on...

  • oh thanks. it's mostly breathy because my voice is weak after years of not singing and my soprano voice was only ever ethereal at best--enya style.

  • blissful melancholy

  • congratulations, I like your version very much

  • First of all, this video is amazing. Your voice is soft, but very beautiful! Second- What key did you sing this in?

  • I'm fairly certain we did this take in D minor.

  • Thank you. I really need to work on strengthening my voice, but I love hearing any feedback.

  • awesome

  • 5 STARS!!!

  • Wow. Your voice is amazing. Hesitant but amazing nonetheless. I hope you do more of this.

  • Thanks, Santi. I'm probably hesitant because it's been so long since I last sang.

  • AMAZING! This is totally not what I was expecting!

  • nice.

  • thank you

  • so you are edith :)

    you have the most beautiful voice i've ever heard. i'm serios, loved your style and you look cute too

  • Thank you ( :

  • edith's voice is like melted gold.

  • that might be the reverb effect on the mic though of course i'd like to believe i sing that well

  • are you edith? the singer?

  • Fantastic! Love it!!!!!

    Good job!

    z

  • thanks!!!

  • real smooth!!

  • For the singer...And the pianist...

    One thank you of France because your vidéo is very fascinating....

    Lucien♪♫

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more