Guru Nanak visit to Mecca -Reply to Br Imran Part 1of 4-Tiger Jatha Uk

[yakuza982]

I can't understand most of the brocast. English please.

[SinghKd81]

Why are you calling him "brother" imran. He is no brother !

[yuvrsj123luton]

Very good thanks

[gill21]

just because guru nanak dev ji went to mecca for his friend. bc mardana followed him all over. this time he went to mecca for his dear friend mardana. just bc he went to mecca doesnt mean he did haj. he stayed on the outskirts of mecca. did not perform haj. ppl called him kafir so how could he perform haj. just use your brain, that muslims were calling him kafir than how could he perform haj. he didnt perform haj.

[symna]

Guru Nanak was a true saint and being Pakistani muslims I've no doubts if he not gone to Mecca. Anyway Guru Nanak have respect for Islam and we all know that. I don't know what indian muslim talking so insane.

[MultiKhalsa1313]

LISTEN BOTHERS DONT LISTEN US LISTEN UR RELIGION HISTOIRANS ALLAH YAAR KHAN read him . if guru ji didnt went dere hw cumz dere is gurudawar in baghdad and now king of dubai given land for gurudwara on guru nanak darbar . so dnt say wrong things

[M52envy]

typical muslims, all they do is slander other religions. All they want to do is convert the whole world to Islam.. pathetic fools..

[leedo12]

Ask the christians, the muslims take a sentance out of the bible and fit to the quran, in order to make their faith correct. They never take the whole paragraph into context, they take bits out and fit it to their own needs. and this is what these muslim scholars are doing now with sikism. Oh, by the way Abbed. Not all chrisitna demoninations are the same, same with islam you are not all th same. And not all christians believe Jesus is God, God is God Mr Abeed

[puneetstar1]

brother imran da dimaag hill gaya .....

[bajwagurwindersingh]

bale oh shera kush kita . well done. Best way to ans gamandi Mulim

[krishnaistruth]

Bhai, Kyuon itna time waste kiya is chutia immam ki baato ka reply dene ke waste, ISLAM ki neev hi wrong baato per rakhi gayi hai toh wo sach kaise bol sakte hai...There is no allah, muhamad sirf ek sant the koi pagamber nahi the..unki death ke 200 saal bad toh ye relegion paada hua...

[DALIARIBADSHAD]

Bhai Imam Imran . Needs to be not some fundamental or facist muslim. As many other muslims have belief that Baba Nanak did attend Mecca. As well his follower Baba Frieda witnessed it. When many muslims during the time of baba nanak were called Kafirs. It shames me of a man of God like Imam Imran sahib is so tuned toward islam. He needs to open to the true reality. God home is open to everyone. Not just a specific inclined race or religion.

[arvinder114]

really u r right i m agree with u and thanks to apload this video.

[RawalpindiBrittania]

i am quite suprised that someone thinks that guru nanak didnt go to mecca. Whoever said this is very ignorant and got his info from unofficial sources.

[krakoosh]

I am an Ahmadi Muslim and it's true that Hazrat Baba Guru Nanak ji Makkay gai sun Tay Hajj wi ki Ta!! I love Baba Guru Nanak ji!!

[khoobsurtpunjab]

@abbekhan after reading your statement all i understand is that you don't know a bit about SIKHISM. as Muslim say Muhammad Muhammad same Sikh believe that GURU NANAK DEV JI was Profit or God's messenger. we only worship One

God. so don't try to teach us what we already know. our Guru Ji taught us that. just try to teach all the Muslim who worship Masjid of Kaaba. tell them God is everywhere so pray anytime anywhere. God has no restriction.

[abbekhan]

WELL budish says budda is god,Hindus says rama and krishna is god,Christians says jesus is god,Sikh says gura nanak is abel to worship because he was great gru but question is WHAT SHELL WE DO WITH LORD ALLAH ALMIGHTY HE CREAT EARTH,UNIVERSE AND HEAVENS AND CIVILIZATIONS,CREATURES HE SPREAD AMONG THEM,Why we all human dont worship and belive one OUR CREATER, Why we have many belives and stories,If guru nanak jee went to mecca then why sikh dont go to mecca ???????? and worship one lord,

[dilpreetasht]

thnxxx for givingg these .. proofss.... .... 

[karansingh186]

jab kush pata hi nahi guru bani ke bare mai mr: IMRAM bhashan de rahe ho guru nanak dev ji ne jo us time kiya hai wo bani mai likha hai bina bani ke sune or pade or 1 baat baba farid ke bare mai jo kaha mr : mai hota to wahi batata ........

[brokbod]

What BS is this. First, Mecca is a place. A city. Anyone can visit it. The restriction on non muslims entry could not have been forced so stringently in those times. Lack of technology, you see. Guru Nanak looked like muslim too so I dont see why he would have faced any problem entring Mecca. Second, He moved Kaba,is totally amusing. Physically not possible, unless you believe in magic. So both parties are wrong. Like many sages of that era, he went there and preached his religion. No big deal.

[84gsingh]

if i see imran i will kill hm!!



[zubermca09]

sikh has no knowledge about his relegion and islam. i dont know who is this singh but he is fake. Imran is true. Iam 100 percent sure gurunanak didnt went to mecca. Bcoz he is nonmuslim . Without permission of muslims gurunanak cant enter to kaaba.

[jotrandhawa01]

@zubermca09 Guru nanak dev ji wasn't a sikh not a muslim not a hindu..lemme tell you one thing...we got out religion from Guru gobind singh ji...our first 9 gurus never had SINGH as their last name...so yea Guru gobind singh ji gave us SIKHISM as our religion.

Guru nanak dev ji said "NA KO HINDU NA MUSALMAAN"....I HOPE YOU NOW UNDERSTAND

[jaylakhpury]

@zubermca09 guru nanak was not need permission from any body, becuse he was messenger of god.

[jaylakhpury]

@zubermca09 looks like u r fake. if u want to talk read history 1st. dont talk rubbish.

[panjdrya]

very gud bro ,,,,

[rathour5]

Excellent! very benificial especially for young sikhs, keep up the great work

[khoobsurtpunjab]

well done!! good answers to this hate spreader person.

[ustadpedro100]

This is very good discussion. I am always fascinated by Guru Nank Dev Ji.

We can learn a lot about our religions.

[kulk4471]

Tuger Jatha definitely needs to put out a video like this explaining why Guru Nanak Dev ji was not a Muslim, because many are spreading the propaganda that he was which is clearly a lie.

[arshyanky]

veerji i appericiate your answer,it was well prepared and answered with enough proofs.wkk wkf

[skymedia11]

@ mrpsingh throughing water in the opposite directions 500 years back, when he came back to Greece. who wrote a poem about Guru ji in Roman about 500 years back.

Guru sahib Ji ethe he nahi, if you read granth sahib, all the 9 guru's have praised him, etho tak ke es brahmand he nahi, sare he brahmanda which ohna de je je kar hundi se, all the bhagat's have praised him.so point him he did not move the mosque or something like that, yes is he did it 1000%.he was against all the karm kand's.

[skymedia11]

@MRPSINGH81, not only ''Nirankar'' himself appeared physically in the form of Guru Nanak Sahib Ji, he went to all the religious places of different religions to end all the ''karm kands'' rituals people used to beleive.Yes, he went to Mecca/MadinaI have read Sandy Travels, and Pontanoo's poem, he eye witnessed guru ji at Haridwar, on the bank of Ganga ,

[drkamran313]

Sir Jee,

Mannaya Guru Jee Makka gae sun. He also believed in Prophet Muhammad Peace Be upon him. Tusi wee ik Rubb noon manno tai Prophet Muhammad Peace Be upon him, tay Iman Lai ao. Gal hi mukki. Sikh te Muslim ik ho jaan ge.

Sirf Ikko ee Rub

Tay Prophet Muhammad PBUH Allah de Rasul

Gal hee mukkee

[indrajeet]

@drkamran313 Guru Nanak dev Ji makkey gey, is dha matlab aye nahi key oh musalmaan si. Sadi Guru Granth Sahib vich muhammed dha naam hi nahi likhia.

[TheBajwaSandeep]

@drkamran313

Why can't Muslims become Sikhs?

[mrsimrat04]

very well explained ....thanks

[mrsimrat04]

his video shows a very strong evidence of guru nanak dev ji went to mecca ......thanks for explaining the whole scenario....

[ranasingh]

The Ottoman Empire ruled by the law of Hanafi and they were responsible for the cities of Mecca and Medina and the empire lasted from 1229-1923. In an article of mughal-ottoman relations during the reign of Akbar an interesting note on Hajj stated in an early document state that:

'No Muslims and believers in the unity of God', proclaims an Ottoman imperial firman, 'should be hindered in any way if he wishes to visit the Holy Cities and circumambulate the luminous Ka'ba.'42

[ranasingh]

In the Hanafi school, it is permitted for non-Muslims to enter all mosques, including the Haram of Mecca, as they interpreted the Quranic verse-009.028 O you who believe! The idolaters only are unclean. So let them not come near the Inviolable Place of Worship after this their year. to be a specific prohibition against them entering as they did before Islam in the Days of Jahiliyya.

[9922605]

1st part and 2ND part is good. 3rd and 4Th part try good too. But Some point made up but try good. Guru nanak dev ji want mecca and turn mecca too. But very good work.

[jackinghh]

veer prabdeep!!! tusi adna daada (beard) uncut rakho ta bahut hi sohne lagonge...

[gosillygirl]

Guru nanak never went to Mecca.....sikhs made it up. Sikh need to get a life.

[rs1081]

@gosillygirl lol. this coming from a girl that has subscribed to another muslims channel who has a video that states 100% proof Nanak was a Muslim. ROFL - Hypocrites

[harryforu11]

@gosillygirl WELL WHAT MAKES YOU SAY THAT ..WERE YOU PRESENT THERE..ANYWAYS THE DOCUMENTS ARE STATED IN THE TEXTS AND THE CLAY TABLETS ARROUND MECCA IN ADDITION TO GURUDWARA MADE THERE ON REQUEST OF THE NAWAB AFTER DISCOURCES WITH HIM. WELL I GUESS THE SIKHS HAVE A PRETTY GOOD LIFE ...ATLEAST BETTER THAN YOUR'S ....LOOK ARROUND YOU AND ULL SEE ...MAY NANAK BLESS YOUR SOUL .....TAKE CARE SISTER.

[vixter1980]

@gosillygirl Quran was made up by muslims too. The real revelation is always the oldest revelation which is given to the first humans and that is Vedas. No scripture in the world can be older than Vedas, hence only Vedas are the real word of Allah

[indrajeet]

@vixter1980 Yes, Vedas are the oldest scriptures of mankind, and Guru Granth Sahib is closest to Vedas in terms of philosophy.

[C0PYRIGHTS]

@indrajeet

dude i guess it was but now people have discovered EBLA TABLETS which is now the oldest religious scriptures :)

[SuperSteeltube]

@C0PYRIGHTS 11-After Hindus and Musalmans went their different and separate ways, lost their true spiritual path, engaged in revenge of each other and drowned in materialism. God summoned and instructed Guru Nanak, first Guru of the Sikhs to appear in human form to preach the humanity, the true path to Worship and Redeem ...One God....Doim kayam hoie rahey ghera ghuman khai.....Duien thee hoa kamm ko fir kita hukam Khudai....Doh key uper tisra Nanka tuh hee

[SuperSteeltube]

@C0PYRIGHTS jaey....Dunia ander jae kar iko nam japaye....Utam sabh badrah hai tum pavo sidhey rah.....Dhar (dharm)chalawo sach da devo kurh uthae...Jo sarni avey do vicho tis noon lavo millai.....Nahak jeean na mareay rakh karoh greeban jahey...p250

God also advised Guru Nanak...that whosoever from Hindus and Muslims or else, repents and comes to join your Faith (Panth) ...embrace them gladly into your fold......(page166, 250)

[sabhi006]

Great work sir....

[skgurmeet]

very nice and logical reply...

bole sau nihal sat sri akal...

[goodboyla]

Whether or not Guru Nanak visited Mecca is of little or no consequence to me , by far more consequential is his universal message of love and understanding for all mankind and a way of life which anyone any where can folow and find happiness.

[rs1081]

@goodboyla fantastic reply! :)

[virk1000]

waheguru ji ki fahte paji,,can u plz upload the video of the debate which u had wid neeldhari sadh,,i will be very thankful to u ,,

[ranjha1970]

Shri guru garnth sahib is a symbol of human rights

[NismoCA]

Who cares if Muslims deny his visit. The majority of them deny Sikh history in general and only a few aren't as ignorant.

[harks68]

To the unloader, brilliant work... could you please do a video response to original imrans video on youtube. thanks

[khalsa3125]

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa  Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Congratulation on a reply to a question that had to be answered.Keep up the good work. My support is always with young learned sikhs like Tiger Jatha Uk

[sify20007]

Wonderful, a fantastic video.

I am a Hindu, but great repect for God figure GURU NANAK DEV JI.

What an answere to those who does not have any respect for other's religions and faiths.

Chiriya nal je baaz larau, tab Gobind singh naam dharaun.

Wahe guru ji da khalsa, wahe guru ji di fateh.

Love u Guru Nanak Dev Ji.

[khalsa3125]

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa  Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Congratulation on a first class reply to a question that had to be answered.keep up the the good work of awakening the sleeping KOM.

[desiladu]

Wahaguru ji ka Khalsa Wahaguru Ji Kay Fateh. Thanks Tiger Group UK well done Good job.

[yaarpunjabi4u]

very gud

[theimmortalsinghs]

good

[theimmortalsinghs]

Well , good videos . i think there should be separate videos subtitled in English for those, who can't understand punjabi.So that the message can reach more and more doubters

[jagmandeepsingh]

Guru Nanak had now been on his Udasis (travels) for at least twenty years, since his sudden disappearance (around 1497) which had alarmed his followers and given some who were jealous of his growing influence to start all sorts of mischief, even accusing him of being a thief and stealing from Daulat Khan's stores.

[jagmandeepsingh]

During that time he had visited most of India going to the east as far as Assam and Burma; to the South as far as Sri Lanka (known also as Ceylon and Saran Deep) and to the north he had even crossed the Himalayas visiting Tibet and China. He and his tireless companions had traveled on foot and lived off the land and the generosity of others, Many of whom had become his followers. What a tireless traveller he was!

[jagmandeepsingh]

and je eh book THE GURU NANAK AT MAKA uk cho leni hove ta mil sakdi ee

[khalsa3125]

@jagmandeepsingh

[jagmandeepsingh]

bai ji who is this person br imran and eh sab ehne kado te kyo boleya

[jagmandeepsingh]

sirf first part hi chal reha