This female judge really is the only one who judged professionally and not base on emotions or favoritism but base on singing quality, stage performance and proper dressing and she said Jia Wei is really great and the only one who can sing live so beautifully. Kudos to this lady judge~she was spot on!!! Jia Wei later became the Million Stars Avenue 7 Champion and now known internationally.
If not mistaken,当下非常替她不值很不值。莫明奇妙,唱到拼了,不是每个人都能这样用心,当然要有好音色,她应该可以翻生的。我那时候都也哭了,没记错的话。if nobody posted it up I hv totally forgotten and judges those gv xxxx among them also hv some producers I think.
Terrible.......! Thank u for posted this so called competition at that moment. I did watched this comp. And I recall this episod, I was so amazed n touched at that moment as she really sing toughly with her best and I was listening... Really listening but end up the judges talk nonsense and if not mistak
Stupid judges, idiot judges. Pity of Malaysia judges even im malaysian. All the judges talk cxxk and sing song, what their know??? Their know nothing, a group of idiot, lucky she willing to tried for Taiwan competition. Compare with Taiwan and Malaysia judges, I only can say, Malaysia judges really ridiculous. 還有,哪位 Ms. Tsang 說佳薇瘦一些比較好看,那她干嘛不去整容?這樣的樣子做 judges 會影響市容,影響參賽者的心情!真是 WTF. TMD.
Do u all know how well she performed this song "Izinkan"? I,ve recommended tis & Xing Guang's "Gemilang" clip to many of my Malay frens. Excellent...was their response! They r even more impressed with "Gemilang"! Jess is one of the most VERSATILE singer I ve seen. I really do not wish to belittle our local judges here, but I wonder if this the reason that many of our talented local singer(Chinese i meant) prefer to showcase their real talent elsewhere. Hmm.......What a SHAME!
who are all the judges here ...are they reliable musician & artist in Malaysia ?? I feel like a gun point to " David Khoon " when he speak out the comment after jia wei sing the song ......is thsi the so call ....rubbish judges make the rubbish competition in Malaysia ? ?
马来西亚的astro新秀大賽 most of the judges know how to give comment but dont know teach contester improve their technical, sometimes felt they like to talk rubbish and select some singer be champion according to their TASTE ...me and my frens dont support this RUBBISH competition since year 2007!!!
wwwwwwwwoooooooooowwww.....NOW I KNOW IT, WHY JESSLEE dont feel like giving it all out in previous contest, cox the value of the competition (malaysia idol & astro新秀大賽) is not there she knew it cox she was there & no doubt she improved lot.. she found her stage, she straight becoming ACE in the 超級星光大道 (taiwan).
hahaha.... m'sia judges seriously fack tup. Maybe they only looking for people that handsome/pretty or black $. But its good coz now i know that Astro talented is a useless place.... but good for training...!! Means no need waste money go Karaoke...!! Go train there...!! Yeah... Jia Wei boleh.... JiaWei Boleh.... Astro Tak boleh.... Astro tak boleh....!!!
What the bull sh't judges!!!! Your ears got problem? I'm so touching with her great voices. Don't be a judges for this show, you make me so shame with your low quality of judgement. The show became low class!!!! low quality!!!! because of your this low stupid judges. I can't believe just 1 judge recognized jess lee, how terrible!!!!! How low class of judgement!!!!!!! Bull sh't.
betul-betul, all judges who gave x to Jia-Wei, all bull sh't 1. Jia-Wei, you are the best for us!!! don't feel sad / dissapointed on the stupid comment by astro coz they bodoh 1. I saw u cried in 星光, i felt very up sad too. don't cry anymore k, we see n hear you and will support u forever! really can't wait for ur new album. while waiting ur new album, i can only watch u tube loh...忘记过去向前进k! 谢谢星光给佳薇一个这么好的舞!!!
I would say, luckily she was out in this competition! Otherwise, she won't be recognise in Sing Kwang Da Tau! And she won the competition in Sing Kwang, which is must better, better future and well recognition now in taiwan and in malaysia. Better than anyone else who won this competition or even in malaysian idol....she definitely has an eyes for God who gave her so much of test and she nailed it to in the end, she deserved to be the champion in Sing Kwang Da Tau!! Jia Wei/Kar Wei rock!! :)
I am completely agree with you. 我完全同意你的看法。 来了星光, 佳薇證明,astro新秀大賽评审不合格. I have never seen any of the local winners have success themselves to other countries. Remember our Malaysian Idol2, what his name again...Daniel?
SHIT WHO IS THE DAVID KOON.........PLEASE lah,,,,,,,,近来因为李佳薇在台湾火红,所以看到很多人留言翻旧账,心里本来不认同佳薇迷所说的,至少不全相信。听了这首歌后,就单凭这一首歌我就觉得david koon 和其他的评判都真得很烂耶,(除了说话那美女以外),佳薇唱这首歌虽说不是完美,但听起来非常舒服,声音和音乐非常融合,而且飚高或低音时都非常稳健,以星光的标准来说也该有20分LEH,为何他们给分那么低,真奇怪耶。。如果你们真的是滥竽充数的评判,可以闭上眼晴听好好的感受一番,别老是看着别人的身材思考可朔性的问题,真是的。。拜托你们“在其位就好好的谋其事啦!激气啦。。。。。
That herd of jury panel are all doll. Make decison also need to cover face. Guilty consciense. Stupid they are. Musical industry are losing one talent in Malayia. Jess Lee eventually will develop it music career in Taiwan. Just like Eric Woo and many others. This is why we are the best exporting talent country in the world. See how many other talent venture outside, especiallly to Singapore. Stupid Malaysia, a lot of resources all gone out. And eventually become best importing refugee country
i think that she sing 永远等待 better in 超级星光大道。 Can see that she is more stable when she is singing there. Pity that she was rushing the song here. Jiayou Jiawei!!!
So unbelievable with such a voice so touching and lovely and yet not being recognized~simply these people must be out of their minds to kick her out in this competition.
betul-betul!!! Jia-Wei, we love you! astro新秀大賽can call useless大賽, dont go back to astro if they invite you coz no 1 like to watch astro新秀大賽now as all judges bodoh 1!
佳薇 我爱你!!
Qvoldy 4 weeks ago
佳薇進步了很多哦~親愛的,你加油:)
MsJosie95 1 month ago
从第一届的Astro新秀大赛我都不会想看,每次看了几分钟就转台了。因为我无法认同与享受听评审评语。我以为只有我不喜欢看,后来发现到原来有很多个和我一样有学唱歌的都很不喜欢看这个节目。参赛者的质量,好的没有几个,根本没有一届是让我想看下去的。因为这个节目真的很烂,很多届以来已经印证了,有几届的第二名到了国外比赛都拿第一名。。。
fattyesther 3 months ago
Jess, you are the best always n forever...!!! ^.^
LFZ123100 3 months ago
其实她当时的歌唱技巧真的没那么的纯熟。她很会把歌声放出去,但做不到收敛的部分。显然她在星光学了这点,也让她赢得更多的掌声与支持。当然,Astro当时的比赛制度还真的让人不解,非常商业化。但都事过境迁,不必在追究了。
换另一个角度来看,当初的挫折才能造就今天成功的她。如果当初她赢了Astro,她可能就不会参加星光了。
kcche17 3 months ago
我覺得不需要去數落astro吧,她在畢竟astro的失敗也才能造就現在的李佳薇。
只是個成長的過程^^
weeeeewaaaaaaa 5 months ago 3
This female judge really is the only one who judged professionally and not base on emotions or favoritism but base on singing quality, stage performance and proper dressing and she said Jia Wei is really great and the only one who can sing live so beautifully. Kudos to this lady judge~she was spot on!!! Jia Wei later became the Million Stars Avenue 7 Champion and now known internationally.
jacksona333 5 months ago
妈的鸡蛋糕!!!!!看到最后,简直会失控。。。。!
damienLOVEs 6 months ago
我本来都还在说服自己说李佳薇以前实力不够所以被淘汰。。。。
看了这个过后。。。
我选择以后都不看astro新秀
damienLOVEs 6 months ago 4
If not mistaken,当下非常替她不值很不值。莫明奇妙,唱到拼了,不是每个人都能这样用心,当然要有好音色,她应该可以翻生的。我那时候都也哭了,没记错的话。if nobody posted it up I hv totally forgotten and judges those gv xxxx among them also hv some producers I think.
MYEvelyn2 6 months ago
Terrible.......! Thank u for posted this so called competition at that moment. I did watched this comp. And I recall this episod, I was so amazed n touched at that moment as she really sing toughly with her best and I was listening... Really listening but end up the judges talk nonsense and if not mistak
MYEvelyn2 6 months ago
请...请...请, 快....快...快 收掉马来西亚的astro新秀大賽. 我一点也不想看..
lkh438 6 months ago
Stupid judges, idiot judges. Pity of Malaysia judges even im malaysian. All the judges talk cxxk and sing song, what their know??? Their know nothing, a group of idiot, lucky she willing to tried for Taiwan competition. Compare with Taiwan and Malaysia judges, I only can say, Malaysia judges really ridiculous. 還有,哪位 Ms. Tsang 說佳薇瘦一些比較好看,那她干嘛不去整容?這樣的樣子做 judges 會影響市容,影響參賽者的心情!真是 WTF. TMD.
yongwhong 7 months ago
以前唱歌没有抖音~
applemeow0407 7 months ago
har?? this type of voice wasn't perfect? the judges deaf !
Vicky7616 7 months ago
评审说这么多废话,是因为M'sia的这些选秀节目都很黑暗,最后的结果早在audition后就已内定,参赛者多努力都只是门外练功。真的幸好她去了台湾,加油!!!
JJYENN 8 months ago 5
好感动。。。我等你的专辑!!!加油。。
tdlovedb 8 months ago
Omg did the judging panel get bribed or something? They require serious need for eye surgery!!!
panophobia11 9 months ago
讲真的~评审的耳朵到底是干嘛的?
xtkok14 10 months ago
拍子走的有点太多了吧,而且马来音也混进去了。但是现在真的进步了很多。
mikka1986 11 months ago
Do u all know how well she performed this song "Izinkan"? I,ve recommended tis & Xing Guang's "Gemilang" clip to many of my Malay frens. Excellent...was their response! They r even more impressed with "Gemilang"! Jess is one of the most VERSATILE singer I ve seen. I really do not wish to belittle our local judges here, but I wonder if this the reason that many of our talented local singer(Chinese i meant) prefer to showcase their real talent elsewhere. Hmm.......What a SHAME!
KoperPine 11 months ago
astro新秀大賽评审 jiak sai la....
chinweicw 11 months ago
再瘦一点点就好 okay ?
唱歌 跟什么身材外表 根本是两回事嘛
oscartong92 11 months ago 2
呸!马来西亚的astro新秀大賽, 放屁啦!每个评审都乱乱来。阿pig ,阿dog。都可以拿冠军。像佳薇那么好歌声,去那找!!!!看看你们选出来的冠军参赛者,唱得歌能听吗?rubbish.... astro 的评审 你们应慨向台湾超級星光大道 多学学。。
michaeltengkienonn 11 months ago 11
佳薇!加油。。。自从看了 超級星光大道7,发觉你正的很会唱。。 佩服!!好希望你的个人专辑。
michaeltengkienonn 11 months ago 2
the judges such a crap
21mooncake 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
kanasai astro competition! !!!!!!!!
loh901026 1 year ago
kanasai astro competition! !!!!!!!!
loh901026 1 year ago 2
外表??? 那個死評審 自己也沒長的多好看!!! 佳薇比你好看多了可愛多了 新秀選垃圾拉
人家唱的多好阿??? 喔 對不起你們的ears有問題 sorry about that
Kazesun1 1 year ago
所谓的评审又不是很厉害唱歌啦。。。他们的评语更加的kanasai。。。冠军又怎样,过不久又不红了。
佳薇去台湾发展更好,这就是为什么人才都会外流的原因。
oscarkee 1 year ago
@oscarkee
astro新秀不是一個國際同等標準. 儘管她是一個勝利者, 她也只是停留在這裡與她的職業生涯。Good luck to her won the 超級星光大道.
jasonjsim1 1 year ago
佳薇得到星光冠军,我真开心。我还以为她在Astro的表现不好,所以没入选!原来是评审们吃大便!真想把当时的评审一个一个找出来,叫他们“草枝摆”!
对不起,我太激动了。
wychu81apr 1 year ago 3
馬來西亞boleh ? 許多人才在外拿到好成績才來珍惜已太遲了!外流太多了!
engkengchew 1 year ago
什麽叫再瘦一點就好了!??!
HappyPeace4Eva 1 year ago
Who said Jess Lee at Astro song not good performance. same like Xing Guang also. I said not good performance is Judges go to hell eat shit.
hhgoodable 1 year ago
David Koon??? Who r u???? rubbish talk. Go back n eat shit
ssng2191 1 year ago 2
betul-betul!
yeemee26 1 year ago
Malaysia Judges should go back home and sleep... This kind of voice not better than Wan Chien & Hao Ren? Babi...
deadscream88 1 year ago 4
who are all the judges here ...are they reliable musician & artist in Malaysia ?? I feel like a gun point to " David Khoon " when he speak out the comment after jia wei sing the song ......is thsi the so call ....rubbish judges make the rubbish competition in Malaysia ? ?
MrJClove 1 year ago 2
唱得咁好都係得一票???? 內定你出局,整定你快啲過台灣比賽!!!
riggsyip 1 year ago
马来西亚的astro新秀大賽 most of the judges know how to give comment but dont know teach contester improve their technical, sometimes felt they like to talk rubbish and select some singer be champion according to their TASTE ...me and my frens dont support this RUBBISH competition since year 2007!!!
chowcl2020 1 year ago 3
WAH!!!! Her vocal sooooo NICE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and she really improved alot in 超級星光大道
kimtatt78 1 year ago
佳薇就算没拿到星光7冠军,都已经胜过我们大马astro新秀大赛任何一届的参赛者了,因为她的实力完完全全已经超出astro新秀大赛参赛者的实力了...
v2ultra 1 year ago 3
不知道从第几届开始觉得astro新秀大赛不好看了
还好佳薇没赢不然就被埋没了
像这届的冠军现在也不见人影了
pyrann1123 1 year ago 3
speachless
12e1121 1 year ago
wwwwwwwwoooooooooowwww.....NOW I KNOW IT, WHY JESSLEE dont feel like giving it all out in previous contest, cox the value of the competition (malaysia idol & astro新秀大賽) is not there she knew it cox she was there & no doubt she improved lot.. she found her stage, she straight becoming ACE in the 超級星光大道 (taiwan).
vincentweb 1 year ago
翻身賽时的佳薇是没有压力的表演。。。
还有,上天不让她在astro新秀大賽成功是因为觉得佳薇要在更大的舞台发光发亮!
jamescya 1 year ago 6
hahaha.... m'sia judges seriously fack tup. Maybe they only looking for people that handsome/pretty or black $. But its good coz now i know that Astro talented is a useless place.... but good for training...!! Means no need waste money go Karaoke...!! Go train there...!! Yeah... Jia Wei boleh.... JiaWei Boleh.... Astro Tak boleh.... Astro tak boleh....!!!
smoke887853 1 year ago 2
马来西亚Astro新秀大赛,应该改成马来西亚Astro外貌协会大赛才对。
评审们,明明是外貌协会,还要装音乐的高深莫测,太可笑了,呵呵!
佳蔚,你的坚持是对马来华人乐坛的一个很好的警醒,佳蔚boleh,Malaysia Boleh!
nikkosaw 1 year ago 4
Don't expect me to watch this Astro talented show again!!!! I will never watch this show again!!!!! as this show is a rubbish show in Malaysia.
stvchan8989 1 year ago 2
david老師說的很好~
不過才1票~
馬來西亞不識人才~失敗!
MsJosie1995 1 year ago 4
@MsJosie1995
David老师说得好,有个屁用啊,还不是投落选票,呵呵
nikkosaw 1 year ago
What the bull sh't judges!!!! Your ears got problem? I'm so touching with her great voices. Don't be a judges for this show, you make me so shame with your low quality of judgement. The show became low class!!!! low quality!!!! because of your this low stupid judges. I can't believe just 1 judge recognized jess lee, how terrible!!!!! How low class of judgement!!!!!!! Bull sh't.
stvchan8989 1 year ago 4
betul-betul, all judges who gave x to Jia-Wei, all bull sh't 1. Jia-Wei, you are the best for us!!! don't feel sad / dissapointed on the stupid comment by astro coz they bodoh 1. I saw u cried in 星光, i felt very up sad too. don't cry anymore k, we see n hear you and will support u forever! really can't wait for ur new album. while waiting ur new album, i can only watch u tube loh...忘记过去向前进k! 谢谢星光给佳薇一个这么好的舞!!!
yeemee26 1 year ago 2
==評審真的在說廢話,颱風你骨頭啦
shinfirefly 1 year ago
好在佳薇堅持下去, 讓我們聽到你的好聲音 ^__^"
htteng1976 1 year ago
so bad asstro... I can't believe the outcome like it.
wifiman22 1 year ago
I would say, luckily she was out in this competition! Otherwise, she won't be recognise in Sing Kwang Da Tau! And she won the competition in Sing Kwang, which is must better, better future and well recognition now in taiwan and in malaysia. Better than anyone else who won this competition or even in malaysian idol....she definitely has an eyes for God who gave her so much of test and she nailed it to in the end, she deserved to be the champion in Sing Kwang Da Tau!! Jia Wei/Kar Wei rock!! :)
janeto5 1 year ago 7
复活赛到底是谁在举牌子啊????干嘛只有1票???
MmmixxX 1 year ago
similar song sang in Sing Kwang, however she presented much better in Sing Kwang.... She is really get valuable experience from d contest lah... +U
lhk8888 1 year ago 2
收皮啦astro!!人家当人是宝你们就当人是草!!一次又一次!!曹格!!陈美娇!!别叫新秀大赛啦!!叫astro垃圾大赛啦!!
ahsiang8232 1 year ago 14
马来西亚每次都不珍惜人才,搞到每个歌手都要从外国出发,等到人家红了,马来西亚媒体才会开始抢着关注他们!真是现实的一堆媒体。╭(╯^╰)╮
KeQing0601 1 year ago 7
malaysia ma...normal lor
jack813 1 year ago 3
曹格與張棟樑也就是在马来西亚没有市场了,
全部也搬来台湾咯!
declanbeh 1 year ago 5
lol...malaysia judges useless la~ no ears kah???
fortressevil 1 year ago
lol...malaysia judges useless la~ no ears kah???
fortressevil 1 year ago
瘦了~~
mrhamhom 1 year ago
除了歌声感动我们之外,佳薇在星光说“马来西亚能,我能”是最令我感动的,虽然我国走宝了,但她还是不忘祖国。。。。佳薇很努力的在外国发光发热,不会因为在我国的失败就气馁,这才是我们大家要学习的。。。。。
Jyouie 1 year ago 7
She sang this SAME song in 超級星光大道 and IS appreciated. TSK! ASTRO ''TALENT'' SHOW, ARE YOU REALLY CAPABLE?
TheWonderwomanme 1 year ago
declanbeh 1 year ago 62
@declanbeh
曹格與張棟樑好像也是astro出來的耶
umiseaz 1 year ago
马来西亚Astro新秀大赛,应该改成马来西亚Astro外貌协会大赛才对。
评审们,明明是外貌协会,还要装音乐的高深莫测,太可笑了,呵呵!
佳蔚,你的坚持是对马来华人乐坛的一个很好的警醒,佳蔚boleh,Malaysia Boleh!
nikkosaw 1 year ago 3
betul-betul, all astro新秀大賽judges gave x to Jia-Wei, pls balik kampung! Jia-Wei, we love u!...don't feel sad on all the stupid comment k.
yeemee26 1 year ago
@declanbeh
I am completely agree with you. 我完全同意你的看法。 来了星光, 佳薇證明,astro新秀大賽评审不合格. I have never seen any of the local winners have success themselves to other countries. Remember our Malaysian Idol2, what his name again...Daniel?
jasonjsim1 1 year ago 2
@declanbeh 讲得对 , 身为本地人都觉得astro新秀很烂 ..... 还是星光比较好 ~
QinChaiLa90 5 months ago 2
他们一定后悔了啦!人才都往外跑了!
FannyPook 1 year ago
Comment removed
KsRaymondz 1 year ago
SHIT WHO IS THE DAVID KOON.........PLEASE lah,,,,,,,,近来因为李佳薇在台湾火红,所以看到很多人留言翻旧账,心里本来不认同佳薇迷所说的,至少不全相信。听了这首歌后,就单凭这一首歌我就觉得david koon 和其他的评判都真得很烂耶,(除了说话那美女以外),佳薇唱这首歌虽说不是完美,但听起来非常舒服,声音和音乐非常融合,而且飚高或低音时都非常稳健,以星光的标准来说也该有20分LEH,为何他们给分那么低,真奇怪耶。。如果你们真的是滥竽充数的评判,可以闭上眼晴听好好的感受一番,别老是看着别人的身材思考可朔性的问题,真是的。。拜托你们“在其位就好好的谋其事啦!激气啦。。。。。
TANLINFEIANNABELLE 1 year ago 12
@TANLINFEIANNABELLE
主要是Astro主办当局,没有好好赛选评审,归根究底他们每一个都没有做好本分,所以看不见他人的努力,可是内心深处又怕他人胜于自己、超越自己,因此排挤人才,这是很正常的,但也是可悲的事实...
nikkosaw 1 year ago
Judges is a big losses!
UKtalentchannel 1 year ago
无言。
sharp2518 1 year ago
感覺評審的意思說唱歌幾好聽也沒用,
外表不討好就不能進級...
quickmusic123 1 year ago 5
judges! Are you deaf?
hueychyi 1 year ago
That herd of jury panel are all doll. Make decison also need to cover face. Guilty consciense. Stupid they are. Musical industry are losing one talent in Malayia. Jess Lee eventually will develop it music career in Taiwan. Just like Eric Woo and many others. This is why we are the best exporting talent country in the world. See how many other talent venture outside, especiallly to Singapore. Stupid Malaysia, a lot of resources all gone out. And eventually become best importing refugee country
kingtyan1 1 year ago 5
i think that she sing 永远等待 better in 超级星光大道。 Can see that she is more stable when she is singing there. Pity that she was rushing the song here. Jiayou Jiawei!!!
turtlecmy 1 year ago
佳薇, 不要理那些不珍惜你的评审, 你有我们这群爱你的粉丝!!!
maxnmax1996 1 year ago 5
得1票有沒有搞錯呀?????
mk29999 1 year ago 2
评审们看不到她的可索性。。。。可惜
gearofwar1230 1 year ago 3
WTF ALL 'X' SIGN
talented one usually doesn't be appreciated
jinsheng1993 1 year ago 11
Comment removed
jinsheng1993 1 year ago
So unbelievable with such a voice so touching and lovely and yet not being recognized~simply these people must be out of their minds to kick her out in this competition.
jacksona333 1 year ago 23
@jacksona333 cause the judges low standard. compare the 超級星光大道
vincentweb 1 year ago
I guess those judges that voted Jia-Wei out are a bunch of morons.
Anyway the Fallen has Risen again. Jia-Wei won the Taiwan Talent show recently... Kudos Jia-Wei !
Looking forward to your album!
Cheers! tanep65
tanep65 1 year ago 2
betul-betul!!! Jia-Wei, we love you! astro新秀大賽can call useless大賽, dont go back to astro if they invite you coz no 1 like to watch astro新秀大賽now as all judges bodoh 1!
yeemee26 1 year ago
she is good! support u in million star 7!
owachibu 1 year ago 4
Simply so touched by Jess Lee's voice!!!
jacksona333 1 year ago 3
唱不错可是有一点油!
tomcraze 2 years ago
u r really talent!!!!nice!!!good job!!!cant believe that!!
almondchan 2 years ago