Added: 4 years ago
From: Chrissie644
Views: 503,203
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (341)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • The Stories cover version is better

  • 70`s funk these guys was kings

  • #1 song when i was born..lol

  • @badastinner Me too, but it was the Stories version. I like each version for different reasons.

  • Fab !

  • The band was and has always been Hot Chocolate. The record company felt that they needed some caucasians to broaden the bands pop audience appeal. Famously, the studio powers demaded the addition of "some marshmellows", hence the two white boys.

  • @chronodiver300 yeah right, they were probably the brains behind the op.

  • louie ck brought me here... :)

  • Hi youtubers, kool to read some of good things about this song !

    For me the best Version still the cover from Undisputed Truth.

    The vocal is just amazin' and give a better emotion than Hot Chocolate. (personnal opinion)

    But i like the original one :) it's a pure dope !

    If you guys like real soul/funk music. sub to my chan, peace :) !

  • WHOA! Just when I thought I had listened to just about all of the essentials.....

  • @Annamandabella I just fell into the Alexis Korner WikipediaHole

    

  • There's just some kind of soul to Ian Lloyd's voice that makes the Stories version my favorite. I grew up listening to that version on the radio....love it! "Aint no difference if your black or white - brothers you know what I mean"!!! KILLER!!

  • @AceFrehleyArchive

    "no difference if your black or white"

    you + are = YOU'RE

  • @SoundOfYourDestiny - Ooooops, you're right!!!

  • funny here in holland we had a commercial who used this song but changed it as juli july. it was i think a commercial of the beer brand heineken.

  • Always been my favourite band.....

  • These two white guys look so out of place lol. They don't even look like they should be in a band. Look more like computer nerds.

  • Comment removed

  • @MightyZarkon

    Bit of a racist remark, no doubt if I posted a comment stating that the other four wer out of place..I would get plenty of remarks !

  • @lonergan24681 Well they outnumber the other two significantly, so your comment wouldn't really make any sense. If it makes you feel better they don't look out of place because they're white rather because they're standing/sitting with their arms crossed awkwardly while the other four look rather casual.

  • song speak for life and love re 60s/70s .We still blind not a whole lot change!??

    BIG up bbrother Lewis Hamalton a WINNER F1 good luck next season ya hot !

  • I like Stories better..

  • First grade teachers made us listen to this while we watched them blow stuff up on t.v. in Vietnam, every night Vietnam was on t.v. and this stuff and all the riots were going on, and they really tried to make kids feel like they and their families sucked. One teacher put up violent people in foreign governments up on her chalkboard, lol --4 awhile, we lived where weather undergr. blew up a house in nyc. the adults never cared how any of it affected kids, they just "did their thing."

  • i like this version better than any other atleast 100 times

  • IF IM NOT MISTAKEN THE STORIES DID THE ORIGINAL VERSION

  • I disagree. This version sounds like a cover sorry. I grew up in the 70s - born 1961 and the version I remember the radio playing all the time was way better!

    From The Sounds of the 70s - won't let me put the link here.

  • @Dragonslayer1361 well that depends on where you grew up i guess...americans would be familiar to the Stories' version, whereas europeans would know the Hot Chocolate version. as it has happened with a lot of songs.

    either way, this is indeed the original.

  • @Dragonslayer1361 nah..i agree with the other guy. this is definitly the best version of this song

  • brilliant

  • tuuuuuuuuuunnnnnnnnneeeeeee

  • @TheSouITwins

    Alexis Korner was NOT responsible in the slightest for discovering Hot Chocolate. After briefly being signed to Apple Records (they had impressed John Lennon with a cover of "Give Peace A Chance") their success was down to hard work and their relationship with producer Mickie Most.

  • good song!!!!

  • Love it!

  • Does anyone else think the guy on the right looks a lot like Nick Kroll.

  • @TheR4k3 Hahaha, good call.

  • Emma is very much like this. An urban tragedy.

  • awesome

  • c.r.a.z.y.

  • Get it, no spook in my family!

  • @hershelmccoy The "no spooks in my family" voice-over was done by the late, great DJ/promoter Alexis Korner who was largely responsible for discovering Hot Cho0colate and making them the success they were in the 70-80's

  • Is the lead singer with Hot Chocolate a bit snooty? That's the impression I got from an article I read about him years and years ago. Lord Snooty!

  • @squirell1952 what a weird comment.

  • thanx MUM :)

  • I like the Version from the Group S T O R I E S better

  • Stories remake is waaaay better, but this one still rocks.

  • @selgahmi thumbs up if people think ur an ass & people got here because of the band!!

  • @selgahmi :  :)))

  • @selgahmi I heard this as a kid but I dont think I ever heard the full lyrics, only the end chorus. CK's show brought me back, in many ways.Though this isn't the version I remember. The chorus is much shorter in this.

  • @FrankDamage My mate sez the version u [and i] are thinking of is by Stories.

  • @4bibimimi Yeah he's right! I found it shortly after seeing this. My guess is this one is the original. Still a good version in any case.

  • i wish i lived in the seventies

  • @DirtyMikeballin It was great....good music,kung movies and good people...you would've had a really good time!!

  • woooo hooo good song!!.....xD

  • i guess this is really a song. gg louis ck. whiter than white!!!

  • bombay bombay..

  • Damn......they bring this so HARD!!!! Wooooooo

    PEACE

  • This is the original, and as usually the original is the best, by far...

  • @MrDimikor -- Hot Chocolate invented and wrote this song and they did a good job but the Stories version is better.

    Just like Blue Swede re-did the great song Hooked on a Feeling a little better than the original from BJ Thomas.

  • @BeerHits I respect your opinion but there's no way to change mine. Once I heard both of them was enough to compare.

  • @MrDimikor

    Agreed: just listened to 'The Stories' version and its not even in the same league as Erroll and his crew

  • this is fire some 1 need to sample this

  • I like hot chocolate's version better than stories. Just sayin

  • WOW. I didn't know Hot Chocolate made this. I guess The Stories version is more popular.

  • kiedy biorę za mikrofon, to frajerzy się smucą..

  • This song is good, but you have to admit the Stories version has ALL the character. The song was mediocre until they got hold of it. Now it's a classic that everyone can recognize. Original is not always best.

  • @newBIGmedia give respect where respect is do stories knew that this song is a hit & the potential of it if they put their twist on it dont get me wrong i love stories version too but i cant say its better then the original thats blasphemy

  • i like the music in this version better, but ill take stories vocals.

  • for some reason this song reminds me of Phil Lynott

    ....I guess maybe because it's about a boy who falls in love with brown sugar....

  • I'm very familiar with the story's version. This is the first time I've heard Hot Chocolate's original version. I must admit I like this one better. This should have been a big hit for them here in the US.

  • Stories' original way better

  • Stories' original way better!

  • @Chariss40 See you`re just try`n to cause a scene cause you know Hot Chocolate was the original

  • ilove bon jovi versions

  • sounds like one of my ancestors

  • The song still is about interracial love, a hot topic then. I myself am a product of this and have pretty much been eschewed by my black side as I am so white looking and acting to them. Their nickname for me was "Carlton"

  • the good old fucked up days

  • They just funked this thing up so well. The original is from 1963 sung by the Kingsmen. The song was initially banned then as people thought the instrumental duh, duh, duh in the original was about him fxxking his wife. In fact the song is about interracial love, a controversial topic in the early 60s, but quite acceptabel by the mid 70s when Hot Chocolate did this version.

  • @princette 'Louie Louie' by the Kingsmen is a completely different song :) This is the original of 'Brother Louie', written by Errol Brown and Anthony Wilson. The Stories covered it.

  • @princette The Kingsmen did Louie Louie, not Brother Louie

  • I tkink that it´s not the original record!

    I didn´t like it! I prefer Stories!

  • ...Prior to the "Disco invasion",Hot Chocolate had Really Good Recordings that was affiliated w/Funk & Rock, "Emma-line" & "You Could've Been a Lady"(later a top 10 for "April Wine") were much an early milestone For the Bands beginnings.it was John Lennon That admired their up beat reggae version of "Give Peace a Chance"!

  • @wabankik the song isnt called emma-line its just called emma

  • The band should be called "Hot Chocolate with Two Marshmallows"

  • @MrGysbertiHodenpyl LOL this is too funny HAHAHA

  • If this would be the original... and too bad... it isn't :'(

  • the clue of this number is NO discrimination

  • And here I thought that 1200 Techniques were original.

  • Great and from BRIXTON

  • I'm 15 and loving it!!!!

  • Never heard this one the instrustment are cold blooded

  • it dont matter if your black or white......its all pink in the middle!

  • white guys in black bands and black guys in white bands. Ahhhh the 70s

  • prefer this to the stories version

  • Awesome. I DO enjoy the angst in the vocals of the Stories cover.

  • we in Coventry call him the singing Maltesa... Errol...lol.

  • GREAT SONG!!!!!!

  • Which version do they play on the brilliant Fox comedy series LOUIE staring LOUIE C.K.?

  • @vratis69 The Stories and yea i love that show too!

  • @vratis69 Louis C.K. re-recorded the song with a backing track similar to the Hot Chocolate version (done by Reggie Watts) and hired Stories' Ian Lloyd to sing the vocals.

  • @sonnyjjchiba

    Uhhh... Stories did a cover of this WAY before Louis C.K. ever did anything. Just saying... But, he used their version for his show on FX "Louie"

  • @joshuamiller419 Yes, of course Stories did a way earlier cover, but Louis, on a recent Opie and Anthony appearance, said that it was way too expensive to pay for the Stories cover itself, so he actually looked up Stories singer Ian Lloyd and paid him to re-record the song with Reggie Watts' background music (he mentions that Lloyd probably lost money by doing this, since he would have gotten a bump in royalties from the Stories' 1973 cover).

  • @joshuamiller419 The other way to tell the difference is that for the Louie credits you can hear Lloyd sing one line as "Louie, Louie, you're gonna die!", a lyric that isn't in the original (where the lyric stays "Louie, Louie, you're gonna sigh/cry!"

  • Didn't know this was the original band. Learn something new everyday (try to anyway) dig?

  • The colored were definitely better dressed  :-)

  • There are many vastly inferior versions of this song if you are thinking of doing a cover please don't bother! like most songs the original is by far the best & does not need covering. From1973nitram

  • According to Wikipedia the song "Brother Louie" was written and sung by Errol Brown and Tony Wilson of the group Hot Chocolate, and was a Top 10 hit in the UK Singles Chart for the band in 1973, Alexis Korner has a spoken part in this version of the song.The song was COVERED by the American band, Stories, (featuring singer Ian Lloyd) about six months after Hot Chocolate's UK hit, and the Stories version made number one on the Billboard Hot 100 in the US. So there you have it! From1973nitram

  • y r ppl so racist :(

  • stories version sucks hard compared to this..

  • @fasima ORIGINAL is 1000 times better

  • @qsbird This IS the original. Hot Chocolate did it first in 1973, then Stories ripped it off.Written by Errol Brown (of Hot Chocolate !!! ).Pax to all from 73soulboy.Xxx.

  • @73soulboy Stories performed it FIRST in 1973 ~therefore it is the ORIGINAL (always the one who introduced the Song to the PUBLIC first) ~ the song was written by Errol Brown ~ HOT CHOCOLATE released it in 1974 on the Cicero Park Album

  • @qsbird I'm sorry to contradict,but in England 'Brother Louie' by 'Hot Chocolate' was hit in April 1973,reaching number 7. It was also recorded by 'Stories' in 1973, but their version did not chart in England although it did reach number 1 in America also in 1973 not 1974. 'Hot Chocolate's' version was,is and remains the ORIGINAL. Pax to all from 73soulboy .Xxx. :-)

  • @qsbird You're wrong matey boy!!!!!

  • @qsbird this IS the original, made in BRITAIN!!!!!!

  • @qsbird sometimes original isn't always better. not too bad though.

  • alot more angst in the stories version of this song

  • Great band! Great song!

  • I like Hot Chocolate and I like this song a lot, too. Thanks for posting!

  • i like the stories version. it always makes me hurt inside. in the stories version i feel the racial tension of the seventies and the pain ofit. with this version it seems like just a song

  • @whitestag1963 more tension in h. choc. version, cause they say the real word, i dont get u?

  • @whitestag1963 I love your answer ~ STORIES made that song THEIR SONG because they put all the pain in there ~~~ HOT CHOCOLATE did a same great Job with their Emma Song

  • please see the version of the fantastic french singer CLAUDE FRANCOIS the title is 'dis lui pour moi' he 's the best thanks!!

  • Been looking for this one for quite some time. My parents used to listen to this in their car. As soon as I found out the title, and heard Stories' version, it just felt wrong. Then I found out Hot Chocolate had covered it, and remembered we also had a Hot Chocolate cassette. So I looked this up, and after 2 seconds I immidiately knew it. This was right. Awesome piece of music right here..

  • @HooliganDeem the stories covered hot chocolate by the way

  • LOve this song from years ago. Still play it on my tape player. Thanks for posting.

  • Great stuff

  • this is a great band! when the stories did this song they took the meaning away, the race issue words were missing, like honky & spook. the radio was way to strict back then. this band has several great songs. the stories had 2. mammy blue /long version is great. by the way i wonder wat words hot chocolate would of used if the lovers were mexican & arab?

  • What a utterly brilliant Song,I was only a Kid when this was in the charts.I didn't take

    much notice of it.However I now know exactly what I was missing.A truly great Band

    and lead singer. Rock on Errol you are great mate.

  • HC was great for ever

  • Both versions are great, but Hot Chocolate's ORIGINAL version definitely has the better instrumentation while The Stories version really has got the vocal passion.

  • @mothra1000

    I agree with you. My sentiments exactly! Both versions have good qualities to offer.

  • @mothra1000 totally agree with ya bud

  • classic

  • goods souvenirs !!!!!!!!! i'am french man in PARIS  in FRANCE !!!! 57 years !!

  • I like this song a lot, it's my absolutely No. 1 hit of Hot Chocolate! This song makes me happy!

  • "i don't want no spook, in my family!"

  • @jackheaney then you should leave.....

  • @sassysizzle I was actually making a point at how good the lyrics portray a relationship torn apart by the racism of their families.

  • great song , great band

  • This is the hottest chocolate!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • This wasn't a cover.

    The Stories covered this song from Hot Chocolate.

  • @goerickago I dont knew that! Anyway, The Stories version is more powerfull. 

  • My man there in the striped blue shirt is definitely some HOT CHOCOLATE

  • @GetOffMyNutsac LOL!

  • Hot Chocolate: Emma, You Sexy Thing, (my fav. Everyone's a Winner) I never knew they covered Brother Louie! Weird? Now I'm going to sound like Robert Plant it makes you wonder....

  • No wonder they never played this version on the radio!

  • These guys were tight. Great band !!!

  • GOOD SONG that WAS freaky when the said that i don't want no spook in the family mom and dad's is racist

  • It was John Lennon who gave them their name

  • @originalpauper really?

  • @valladezzy615  sure dude

  • 1 of the best r.n.b tracks of all time!!!

  • Great music is colorless

  • wow never heard this version ,i like it too very different. but trip on the the one of stories.

  • lovin' it <3 it was my first LP song, on vinyl it's even better!

  • Sooooo soooooth!

  • music from heaven

  • Awe man, I love this rendition...dig that funkadelic beat to it!!!...

    How about that funky The Cat In The Hat piece that soul brother No. One has on at the bottom roll, heh?!!!

  • Hot chocolate singing about Brother Louie...ain't that funny :)

  • is this the original version of this song

  • @jadedheart30 this is original . loved it when it was first released still sounds good x

  • @jadedheart30 Yep, it sure is!

  • I love the look of the dude on the far right. Nice shirt and belt brother man! Never heard this before Fxs show Louie and loved it instantly. Sounds like a slightly different version though. Jungle fever!

  • Te cover by bert heerink are better.

    Bert heerink - julie july

  • samplé par scred connexion " trop saouler"

  • Louis CK!

  • The theme song from fx's Louis, Love it!

  • Do you know why Brother Louie has issues? Because...He's a SCOT!

  • Comment removed

  • This was a top 10 single in the UK for HC in 1973. The spoken bits really drive the point home for me (compared with The Stories version). Plus, you can hear the pain in Errol's vocal.

  • @TheJessefan 10/10, couldn't have said it better!

  • aye !!!! no scotsmun !!!!

  • I ALWAYS LOVED THIS SONG!!

  • Bert Heerink reproduced it in to Julie, for the dutch heiniken commercials

  • one blood

  • no offense, but since i heard the stories version first, as a kid and it was so impactful, i love it more. it was so raw. Hot Chocolate wrote it though, kudos. i wonder if they liked the Stories version

  • i want no kilt wearing scotsman in my family, you dig!