Added: 3 years ago
From: Eurostar710
Views: 31,147
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (163)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Oh God this makes me want to cry every time I hear this...

  • wtf why are there so many people who hate Rose?

    Nobody is perfect okay, so no, rose neither.

    Everyone has their own opinion, and I don't mind but please don't be rude.... in the beginning I didn't like the 9th doctor, now I do though and I really do, but in the beginning I didn't say he was the worst and sooooo stupid, right? why would I ??

    besides, they're actors <w<

    I'm sorry but I had to say this. I'm a 14-year-old, I LOVE doctor who and I think it's just pathetic how some react.

  • I love all of the Doctor's companions, but I mean come, true love! I just about cried when I heard this cuz I may or may not have sobbed when the Doctor got cut off before he could tell her that he loved her! It was so sad! Didn't any body else bawl their eyes out when that happened?

  • I love them all.

  • Brb, crying to death...

  • my vote for companions:

    (1)rose

    (2)amy

    (3)martha

    (4)donna

    love them all. they are asome

  • Companions in my opinion:

    1.) Rose----true love, guys. Come on.

    2.) Amy and Rory

    3.)Donna

    4.)Martha

    But I love all of them. I love Martha almost as much as Donna, even.

  • How can so many people like Rose?

    She was by far the stupidest and WORST Doctor Who companion.

    She didn't even know what a black hole was!

    And Billie Piper is a terrible actress...

    Romana is THE BEST Doctor Who companion.

  • @TARDISEnterprise I don't think it mattered that she didn't know a lot. She was the most ordinary girl in London. Worked in a clothing store. And then she was the Doctor's companion, traveling through time and space. That's what made her so special. It's what makes all of them special! The companions are all brilliant on their own levels and Rose was the first. <3

  • @TheRoxster No, Rose was not the first. Susan Foreman was. Just look at Nyssa, Martha, Liz Shaw, Romana and the rest of the companions. Rose is clearly inferior.

  • @TARDISEnterprise I'm talking about how Rose was the first of the new DW. Also, Martha was annoying until "Human Nature" and she totally gained my respect in that episode. Rose isn't inferior. All of the companions are just different.

  • @TARDISEnterprise WHAT THE F***! YOU THINK ROSE IS THE WORST! WELL TO ME YOUR THE WORST!

  • @doctorwhogirl88 How kind of you to say that.

  • @TARDISEnterprise FOR SHAME. That's ROSE TYLER you're talking about!

  • @Purufufuru Yes it is. Her relationship with the Doctor was completely wrong. And to all of you Rose lovers out there- watch original Doctor Who. Then you'll understand.

  • @TARDISEnterprise I don't think it's your place to tell the people who make the show their relationship was wrong - I do agree to some degree, though. There was a reason for why he couldn't say "I love you". The Doctor can't fall in love, because it hurts too much.

  • @Purufufuru Okay, I think I'll just give up on this argument. To anyone that I might have offended: sorry. Rose is not inferior, she's just another companion, and she's her own self. :)

  • bad wolf, doctor donna, god i miss them. i think this new doc is really weird, amys alright i guess. but its lost its touch.

  • To be honest, I think she cries a lot. So did the 10th doctor. Maybe he lost his touch in 9-10 regeneration, and got it again in the 10-11 one. Ah i dunno... i'm an idiot.

  • @1PoorSoft1 Your not the idiot tardisenterprice is the idiot

  • @doctorwhogirl88 No, TARDISEnterprise is not the idiot. Rose is.

  • i doubt she will ever return to dw thats the saddist part

  • Doctor Who makes me want to cry and laugh and scream all at the same time!

  • Rose/Ten will always be my otp

  • Companion Rating:

    1. Rose

    2. Amy

    3. Donna

    4. Sarah Jane

    5. Martha...

  • @kuchkat1 no wrong proper order is 1. martha 2. donna 3. rose 4. sarah jane 5.amy

  • @doctorw2 there is no "proper order" because everyone have different opinions. personally, mine is

    1. donna

    2. rose

    3. martha

    4. sarah-jane

    5. amy

  • Rose is my fav Dr Who companion

  • What I loved about Rose was that she wasn't perfect. She was quirky and fun-loving and young and kind of innocent and smart without being a genius. I miss her character so much! I'm still secretly hoping that she'll come back somehow . . .

  • :'( rose

  • oh I cried... again... Doctor Who is the only show that can make me go from laughing to crying in under ten seconds.

  • This song sounds beautiful on almost every instrument, especially piano. I played it for my piano exam.

  • @oneill2001 Omigosh! she totally is a Peri! And she was rude to Sarah Jane! I totally agree! :D

  • I HAVE to learn this on piano! and im terrible at piano!

  • ROSE + TEN forever and ever and ever.

    kill me this song is killing me already.

    oh doctah rose needs you :'(

  • I love Rose! This song makes me want to cry.

  • Oops I meant -3

  • Rose got her Doctor in the end -3

  • @funkyhippo123 Yeah, she got her meta-crisis human-time lord Doctor in the end. Thats all a women really wants in the end!

  • The Doctor has a thing for blondes whose names start with R. River, Rose, Reinette...

  • @ThisbyBooks River, Rose, Reinette, Romana... Rory?

  • @TheAfroThunder1 In my mind, definitely Rory ;D

  • @ThisbyBooks YOUR SICK... I like your style!!!

  • @TheAfroThunder1 Why thank you ;D

  • @ThisbyBooks Your welcome. Thank you for thanking me ;D

  • yep. in crying at 1:31 in the morning cause this song is so sad. merry frikkin christmas

  • i miss rose tyler and the 10th doctor

  • @c1rcu1tn3rd So does everyone...

  • This music makes me feel all the feels. Most make me cry, but this one makes me feel really peaceful.

  • @oneill2001 Your right, River was so caring to want to kill the doctor only to change her mind when she found out she WILL change her mind in the future (Lets Kill Hitler), and Rose was so shelfish to absorb the time vortex to save The Doctor and the universe from the dalexs, and to save Jack from death, what a b**ch! And when she save Donna from the time beetle! Uh! Learn some respect Rose! (If you haven't noticed, I was being sarcastic, but your open to your own opinon).

  • Rose was a pretty good companion. She wasn't the best, but she definitely wasn't the worst. My theory is that at least half of her haters are Tennant fan girls who are mad because she took him.

  • @MusicLoverOtaku I know right? seriously some fan girls need to grow up. I love david tennant but I also love how well they played their characters on dr who. there's no need to get obbsessed over an actor because chances are you're never gonna get them.

  • @jonesfan2008 David is engaged to Gerogia Moffet, who acctually played Jenny (The Doctors daughter) in The Doctors Daughter. Sick right! No, but whats facinating is that her dad is Peter Davidson, the 5th doctor. So, The Doctor fathered her daughter, only for his future incarnation to marry her. Wierd... Jokes, I know there actors!

  • @TheAfroThunder1 Omg what did i say! I can't remember lol. so your reply made no sense to me cuz i don't even remember my comment lol

  • @MusicLoverOtaku I don't think she was that bad to be honest...i mean they could have picked a worse companion. I'm not much of a fan of Martha she just gets on my nerves...although my all-time favorite is Donna she was the best P:

  • @MusicLoverOtaku Actually I don't hate Rose because of Tennant. I don't even really hate ROSE as a character, I just don't like her hardcore fangirls/boys.

  • @MusicLoverOtaku I didn't love Rose, but I don't hate her. She was just badly written in some episodes. Some writers *cough*Moffat*cough* wrote her as being really mincing and stupid and I think that reputation just stuck with her for some people. People also ignore who she was; a 19 year-old shop girl traveling with an older, smarter, very attractive man. So some shortcomings she might have had could and should be forgiven.

  • @MusicLoverOtaku I love Rose and I miss her! I'm only on season 3 right now, so I keep hoping she comes back!

  • back when dr who was AWESOME, i mean its good now but thats just it, it's good, it used to be AWESOME

  • Only two companions the Doctor had a romantic relationship with: Rose and River. And now he gets to be with both of them at once, in two seperate universes.

  • @kaizoisevil I wonder what happened to The Meta-Crisis Doctor when The 10th Doctor regenerated?

  • @TheAfroThunder1 he is still living his own life. If the walls break down again, and the doctor sees his meta-crisis clone, we will have an episode starring both David and Matt

  • @kaizoisevil I know hes livin' his own life, but did you watch "The Almost People" episode. The ganger Doctor was having trouble with his past incarnations, I was just wondering if he would do them same.

  • i nearly cry when i hear this. Rose was definitely the mostly beloved companion on DW

  • @billyharriss I agree, but Billie Piper who plays her quit, so the BBC wanting her back probably won't do squat, but its a good thought...

  • Rose.... i miss her

  • @EffyRules David Tennant... I miss him

  • Love Rose's theme Rose Tyler best companion ever as well as Martha Jones and Donna noble best companions ever! It was so sad when she left doctor who espeically I cryed at the end of the army of ghosts the episode where she's crying and listening at the other side hearing the doctor and the doctor listening too o.o when the doctor cryed in army of ghosts when rose had gone in the tardis it made me cry too also made me cry when all the other Compainions left Espellically when Donna left

  • @missmiley78 Same here. But Rose and The Doctor are separated in "Doomsday". Sorry, i'm just a (Revived Series) Doctor Who super-fan.

  • @TheAfroThunder1 yeh I know there seprated same here im a doctor who super-fan

  • The Bad Wolf. She was dope as hell at the end of Season 1. One big Eff You to the Daleks.

  • rose is the best companion ever

  • Comment removed

  • Martha was WAY more awesome than Rose.

  • @Mythezza sorry other way around

  • @Mythezza but martha was cool in her own way

  • @Mythezza I liked Martha because she never got arrogant like Rose did towards the end

  • @Mythezza I know right! She's one of the toughest girls I know. Okay, the other girls were feisty but that was all attitude. With Martha, she fought for honour, justice and what was right, she went out there, fought and made a difference, she didn't just flirt with the doctor 24/7.

  • @theamvgirlx Neither did Rose :/

  • @SmileChicky ...Rose didn't flirt? In Tooth And Claw, The Impossible Planet, Rise of the Cybermen and School Reunion? Especially in School Reunion and Doomsday too.

  • @theamvgirlx She did flirt, but thats not all she did and was good for. She was a great character. She literally started out as an everyday girl, and ended up as someone worth working for Torchwood. The Doctor wouldn't fall for a bland skank :P

  • @SmileChicky Whoa! I wasn't going as far to call her a skank! Gosh.

  • @theamvgirlx ..its okay mate.. i wasnt raging :P

  • @theamvgirlx Except Doomsday, that was just playful, but in Doomsday she loved him, not flirted with him.

  • @Mythezza I what way?

  • so tragic!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • never liked Rose (sorry now every ones going to hate me)

  • @652thedude You're fine. I used to hate her too, simply because she was the dumb blonde who ran around and was all-love-duvey with the Doctor. But I realized that she's actually not so bad- okay, maybe not as intelligent as Martha or witty as Donna, but there was nothing particularly horrible about her except she was somewhat of a stereotype.

  • @narwhal17 ...yeah your right.

  • @652thedude Nobody hates you... Now let me just get my shotgun...

  • @652thedude Love her, or hate her, you got to admit this is some tear-jerkin' music

  • Rose is, was and always will be my fave companion :') 

  • @Number1Gamergal I don't know. For me, its either Rose or Donna... Or mabye Jack... Or mabye Micky... It's hard to descide!!!

  • I have a friend who looks very much like Billie Piper. I met her only a little bit after I got into Doctor Who, and I got into Doctor Who during the fourth series, so I only saw a little bit of Rose near the end... It wasn't until I rewatched the show that I saw the resemblance between my friend and Billie. Now, though, I can't unsee it. I look at Rose and all I can see is Carlee.

  • As a kid living low class, into old school hip hop, doctor who is my weakness, i was a kid when i watched 2005 for the first time and fell in love with Billie Piper. saddest thing when she left, still can't get over it

  • @22657428 I still have nightmare about when Rose left... LOL! Just jokin'! Was sad though... :(

  • After I saw the Doomsday episode on Netflix, it was honestly difficult for me to listen to this song...Like, I would try and play it on my iPod, or my phone, and I would start tearing up and have to turn it off...I'm FINALLY able to listen to it without crying!

  • :(

  • am i the only one who doesn't think rose is the best companion? i prefer the others, honestly.

  • I miss Rose!!! And I miss David Tennant...they were the best together. Seriously this song makes me cry :(

  • the best companion,rose marion tyler

  • the best companion

  • it was rose and the doctor, she needs to come back and the doctor needs to regenerate back into eccleston or tennant

  • @Eurostar710 cussing is not nessecary. Some people just don't like that type of writing. So, instead of cussing at you and telling you how to type, she/he asked you nicely to stop, noting how those aren't words. She/he didn't mean any offense. You're kinda overreacting... no offense. Just please be careful on the internet. how would you like it if someone went cussin up your video? yeah. thought so. and again, no offense intended.

  • @Eurostar710 wow. Let's calm down kids.

  • When will they ever release a Rose Tyler: Earth Defense series???

  • @NewPhoenixFilms No. I know it's prety sad to want to reply to a comment from 3 months ago, but i'm a sad person. How's September?

  • he is absolutely the best companion ewa

  • There's just something about Rose I don't like that just spoils her for me. I loved the relationship with her and Nine, but I personally think they overdid the whole romance thing with Ten.

  • I love Rose...my middle name is Rose and I cut my hair on Friday, causing my brothers to all tell me I look like Rose. I don't care <3

  • This gives me chills :'( Oh Rose please come back to us!

  • Did this play in S4 E12-13? Can't remember.

  • Rose, we love´s you!!!!!!!!

  • @Eurostar710

    ur right

    i want her to stay she might come bak in 2011

  • @Eurostar710

    ye ur sooo right

    i want her to stay she might come bak in 2011

  • @Eurostar710

    ye ur sooo right

    i want her to stay she might come bak in 2011

    ???

  • we can only hope that we see her again in season 6

  • I love all the Doctor companion themes. All brilliant for different reasons. This one reminds me how much time has past already since we first saw Rose, and how companions have come and gone so soon!

  • such a touching beautiful song, perfect for Rose. I miss her :(

  • which episode was this? or episodes ?

    i cant remember hearing this and ive just started watching them all again

  • she is beautiful

  • Series 1 to 4 are my favourite!! although I still love the series now but something ended when David Tennant regenerated and the Tardis exploded. Russell T Davies was the guy who brought back Doctor Who! Stephen Moffat will never beat him

  • I loved Rose and David Tennent as The Doctor. Now there both gone :'(

  • Great music

  • the only one 2 of his companions that he loved was sarah jane smith and rose his best friend that under stood him was donna

  • Oh yeah, and then there's Prof Riversong somewhere in the future. I wonder how they'll write that in?

  • true that is but she only recognized him because of his eyes and shes probably his last companion

  • Maby with that part on The end of time where he says "I did a lot of stuff" maby it ment he met her then they will bring her in a few times...

  • I doubt it... But hey, "the end of time"? That hasn't even aired yet! What spoilers did i miss? Oh, i hate not living in GB sometimes.

  • Xd nothing realy..jade a blond lady saying "he returns" and a few shots of a freeked out donna

  • Hmh... Still, that IS something...

  • if you go onto the doctor who website and look at the preview for next series she is in the teaser with short blonde curly hair

  • You do know the clips on that site won't work unless you're from the UK? Sadly, I'm not. Ah well... So she is there, huh? Interesting :)

    Hey, look! It's Ood Sigma! -> :=¤

  • @HazyJonny that is so true. when sarah jane left him, he was upset, because he wanted her to keep on travelling with him. when rose left him, it was like he'd been hit by a bus at high speed.

    lol

  • @TheDunHorse ...into a volcano...

  • @HazyJonny you got it down so right, I agree completly...

  • @HazyJonny You forgot River Song. The only woman who's caring enough to almost destroy time to save The Doctor and badass enough to make a friggin' Dalek scream "Mercy". Aside from ALL his major villains, River knows The Doctor better than anyone. Rose was the Peri Brown of the New series. She was a selfish character who wanted to leave her family and boyfriend and stay with The Doctor because his 10th incarnation just HAPPENED to be cute. And how dare she talk down to Sarah Jane like that?!?

  • @sandmanzcommin08

    said comment was not out when river was a companion of the doctor

  • @HazyJonny Well apologies. But even still, why do people love Rose Tyler? She's a selfish, pointless, arrogant, spoiled brat. It's like Russell T. Davies took Bella Swan from Twilight and somehow made her more of a bitch.

  • @sandmanzcommin08

    yes but have you seen her transformation in the later series,one of the most compitant of the doctors companions.

  • @HazyJonny Yeah I seen the Journey's End Two Parter. So, Rose gets a gun.......what else? She may have mellowed out but she still has that mannerism. When all of the 10th Doctor's companions are on webcam, she started being mouthy to Martha because: "Whaa!!! I was in the TARDIS first!!! Boo Hoo Hoo!!!"

  • @sandmanzcommin08

    Martha sucks anyway :P

  • @HazyJonny Any reason why?

  • @sandmanzcommin08

    Well untill after she leaves the doctor shes just an annoying character.

  • @HazyJonny Ahh. Well, compared to River Song, Sarah Jane, Ace, Amy Pond and K-9, Martha's not the best companion but to be fair she's not as bad as Rose, Mel, Grace or Kamilion and Series 3 was the best of the David Tennant Era in my opinion. Same thing for Donna but I found her a bit more entertaining. I like Catherine Tate anyway and she's proof that you don't have to be young and sexy to be The Doctor's companion.

  • @sandmanzcommin08 r u kidding me? Mel just wanted 2 see the doctor and she talked about him all threw Lets Kill Hitler! Then all of a sudden she wanted 2 kill him!

  • @LilSquonker If you paid attention, It was all beyond her control. The Silence brainwashed her from birth and trained her to be the perfect assassin for The Doctor. After realizing who she is and what's been going on, she changed her ways gave up all her regeneration powers to bring The Doctor back to life. In the end, River or Melody became one of the most important people in The Doctor's life.

  • @HazyJonny Martha can be annoying sometimes and technically she was responsible for bringing back The Master, but I also feel sorry for her. I don't mind The Doctor having a "closer" relationship with his companions but I think the Rose storyline was pushing it. The Doctor and Martha seemed like they would've had an even stronger bond like Sarah Jane or Amy Pond, but he was too busy moping and crying over Rose to even attempt at moving on. Insert Titanic joke here, and where done. :P

  • man i can't still beleive david tennant is leaving his tardis

  • nor can i. = [ TEN 4EVA.

  • I really love this music, its simply beautiful and makes me want to cry. I miss Rose so much, she was awesome! :(

  • this is the best companion theme. :)

  • love it!

  • sad song.sad story.

  • Poor Doct0r... he always looses his loved companions, when he is the only 1 who deserves them. :'(

  • wow this vid has been here for a while and no 1 left a coment... well i think its a good song and rose was good 2... shame we dont get to hear this on doctor who no more

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more