And I would also like to add, that the Chinese people have been one of the greatest motives for me to learn Mandarin, since they are very friendly and tend to overstate my progress in the Chinese language, which I am not quite used to. Oh, and the most important: Yangyang's videos are great. She almost never replies to comments, but if you have not yet watched all of her videos, you should do it right away. Because not many teachers can explain the grammar like she does. And she is so cute!
I speak Russian, English, German and fluently. I also speak a few similar European languages a little. The Chinese language is very different from all of these ones and this fact makes it very beautiful. I fell in love with it long ago, but I have got a real chance to learn it only recently. I do not agree that it is easy, as there are so many characters to learn and tones are very difficult to distinguish (at least for me), when listening to somebody talking fast.
i learned polish (i'm spanish) and i was always told it was one of the hardest after Chinese, so now i'm starting with Chinese and so far I can say Polish is by far way much harder than Chinese. Chinese is pure logic and simplicity but for entonation and writting.
@TubeGuest5178 Hindi is not as hard as Finnish or Hungarian, because hindi is one of the indo european languages, but finnish/hungarian/estonian isn't. Arabic is really hard, they have soooooo many dialects.
As an English native speaker studying Korean and Japanese, I have to agree that Mandarin is easier by an extremely huge margin mostly due to the grammar alone. People who say Chinese is the hardest language to learn don't study or have not tried to study Mandarin or any other Asian language.
Are the characters simplified? I know that a lot of Japanese 漢字 is the same as Chinese, but when she showed telephone, it looked different from 電話 but still looked similar. I always thought that speaking is harder than reading or writing because of the pitches. Japanese is easier (for me), but Mandarin sounds interesting.
@alynkaipalomo Japanese kanji was adopted from China before the simplification of the PRC. While Japanese kanji has undergone simplification it was different and more modest than the one made by the PRC.
those tones are killer stuff... and Chinese symbols are so complex, i studied a little bit of Japanese and their symbols are simpler and easier to write.
Omg I think I'm gonna buy your DVD. So far, I like your practical and direct approach. What I mean is you think of what your students might questions and answer them before we even ask it instead of continuous BS'ing. Thank you
The hardest chinese letter for me to pronounce is the 'e', i can't do it! is there's any trick or something? it's really really hard. I speak spanish and english.
Well I just started learning, and compared to when I first started learning Spanish it's easier gramatically, but much harder in both pronounciation and writing. Also spanish shares a lot of similar words with English, where as Chinese shares very few. I have heard that once you get past the early hurdles of Mandarin it does become more manageble, so I'll see, but Spanish is definetly easier.
please, stop comparing languages (everybody knows that Spanish is better and easier than English and Chinese, specially for me that i'm from Spain...) and try to learn some Chinese here!! :) this course is great!
First, you can't say a language is 'easy' because IT IS SIMILAR to English.
Second, you can't say at one moment that Chinese may be difficult for its writing system, and then say that 'words are very transparent'. Diàn Yǐng or Fēi Jī doesn't make any sense IF YOU DON'T KNOW the Hàn zi...
Third, having one or two syllables doesn't make words easier to learn. Take for example shòu shí (授时), shǒu shí (守时), and shōu shí (收时). If you don't have enough training with tones...it's almost impossible!
@BlackCloud21509 (1) Opinions are different to facts. Which linguistic basis is she using for saying that i) a language is "easy", and ii) even to compare english to chinese and conclude they are similar? I studied english long ago (my english is not perfect) and I have been studying chinese for 2.5 years. I also studied japanese for a long time. And know what?
@BlackCloud21509 (2) Japanese has far more loan words from English than chinese. Take "Kompyūta" (Computer) and "diànnǎo", take "Aisukurīmu" (Ice cream) and "bīngqílín", take "Isopuropanōru" (Isopropanol) and "yìbǐngchún". Taking vocabulary into account, her statement is more accurate for japanese than for chinese. Yes, english and chinese are SVO languages and... what else? Please, tell me, thou who art perfect as I ca not see, maybe due to my imperfection!
你好怏怏。我有一个问题,英文:You state that sentence structure is the same in Mandarin as it is in English, however, I have an example where this is not always the case. It has just created confusion with me and I feel it would mislead your viewers.
你在做什么?What are you doing? Literal = You are doing what?
In English, that structure would be used to clarify an answer to the question "What are you doing." IE, if the answer is a surprise. Where the proper question would be the non-literal.
Internationally, Mandarin and Cantonese are considered two official languages. The other dialects are just considered dialects. Ive noticed before that Chinese people call it all dialects. Kinda important though, if you wanna watch a chinese movie it's always either in Mandarin or Cantonese audio. Or go to Chinese class or things like that :p
@paddotk hmmm, i thought cantonese is now considered a dialect? since hong kong was retuned to china in 1998 so its no longer the language of an independent 'country'. the only two places that speak cantonese as its main speech are hongkong and guangzhou. But because hongkong has flourished s much in the past decades in terms of entertainment and movies, cantonese became immensely popular.
@baiorinshoujo I know, but as i said, internationally. Chinese people have told me before that it's a dialect and i suppose that in China itself, it is. But you know, if you want to study Chinese you have to choose Mandarin or Cantonese. If you watch a Chinese movie (i watch a lot of em :p) it's Mandarin or Cantonese audio.
But yeah i can understand that you'd prefer to call it a dialect because it basically is.
Telling from your name, i assume you are Chinese yourself?
@FJUD Soy alemán y aprendito frances y un poquito espa~nol. Para mi, espa~nol es mas facil que frances. Y la pronunciation es ca. como alemán, porque la pronunciation es como de latin. Pero ingles no tiene una reformation. La pronunciation de letras ingles son una catastrofe. No reglas! Se usar letras latinas pero no pronunciar correcto. A es como ä, r es como a, u es como a. No sistema! Porque no "I hate to clean my room" = "Ai heit to cliin mai ruum" ?
@WCiossek Sí, en inglés no usamos las letras apropiadas, y nosotros los estadounisenses las usan peores que los ingleses. Pero, si nosotros criamos usando este sistema, claro que a nosotros nos parece más facil usarlo. Debe Ud. saber que, un alemán como a un inglés, ningún de los dos pronuncia la 'r' como dicen los americanos. Pues, aunque hablemos diferentemente, todos los idomas se parecen extraños. Claro, a tí te parece extraña la 'esszet?' A mí sí, pero creo que tú lo usas frecuentemente.
@toughbama Well, humans have a tendency to think we know what we know and we assume that our way is the best. We (latinos) think that too, when learing English but then you get used to it.
Spanish (also Italian) has its advantages, how words are written while maintaining a nearly one-to-one relation between characters and souds, makes its orthography easier than English one or French one where characters combinations are often pronounced in multiple ways.
@bitesh To bad that doesn't make any sense int he english language. What you just said converted to english: is idiot all day. Spanish is a stupid language and I'm still committed to my opinion.
@toughbama well just so you know, the structure of a sentence in chinese is also completely different from english, so I guess all other languages are stupid according to you.
too bad your opinion doesn't make sense in any language at all.
and also, you could not have hated learning spanish, because you haven't, apparently.
@ramdom909py I suppose, but english is way easier to learn the spanish. And by easier to learn I mean by its way easier to learn english enough for people to understand you.
@akireshaun I ment it as a joke :p But you know what, for us, English is backwards as well... Languages depend on people many times. Some people have it easier than other to pronounce in certain languages. I am taking mandarin right now and it is very interesting , however, I took Japanese in the past and their pronunciation was easier for me because there where actually not many new sounds. Practice and involvement with the culture is the best way to keep up with languages
@kingjameswww Seems like it with pin yin huh? Even though I'm a native English speaker with one class in French and the majority of my co-workers are Mexican, and I've been trying to study Spanish with a bit of help from them.
@tannguyen1981 yes i have heard that about vietnamese as well as some other SE asian languages, however, i am not very familiar with those. im having a hard enough time just learning mandarin at this point :)
learning to speak it is not that difficult so far, but listening to other mandarin speakers, and understanding them and the tone.... is proving quite challenging :)
Well I have to say that short words are rather a disadvantage. They might be a little easier to memorize (even though I dont believe they really are), but its way much harder to understand them in spoken language. If you miss one syllable youre often totally lost. Even if you understand the whole word its sometimes difficult because there are so many words that sound similar to the inexperienced ear.
I'm always glad of long words when someone talks to me in a foreign language.
most of what you said about chinese apply to Vietnamese as well. We too have only 1 or 2 syllables in most of our words. Our grammar is that easy as well - no conjugations.
Cantonese is a much better language. Of course, that's just my opinion.
ginsinsan 3 weeks ago
People: she is being nice by giving us free education. Show some respect.
quotron8 1 month ago 3
@quotron8 first of all, it's a sample, basically a demo for her paid product
second of all, retard, the comment section of youtube is for people to express their opinions
just now I called you a retard, that's my opinion, you probably have something to say to me now, but show some respect
dsadawrware 2 weeks ago
we need to practice
MrVic0208 1 month ago
Chinese is very easy because they don't bother with grammar especially like articles "a" "an" and "the".
TubeGuest5178 1 month ago
Comment removed
DarkAniux 2 months ago
I guess it's easier than English...
kiwoned 3 months ago
@kiwoned Definitely!
vigorwoods 2 months ago
And I would also like to add, that the Chinese people have been one of the greatest motives for me to learn Mandarin, since they are very friendly and tend to overstate my progress in the Chinese language, which I am not quite used to. Oh, and the most important: Yangyang's videos are great. She almost never replies to comments, but if you have not yet watched all of her videos, you should do it right away. Because not many teachers can explain the grammar like she does. And she is so cute!
YarrMeHeartey 3 months ago
I speak Russian, English, German and fluently. I also speak a few similar European languages a little. The Chinese language is very different from all of these ones and this fact makes it very beautiful. I fell in love with it long ago, but I have got a real chance to learn it only recently. I do not agree that it is easy, as there are so many characters to learn and tones are very difficult to distinguish (at least for me), when listening to somebody talking fast.
YarrMeHeartey 3 months ago
@YarrMeHeartey I'm not even bothering with characters anytime soon. I'll stick to my pinyin. lol
TubeGuest5178 1 month ago
i learned polish (i'm spanish) and i was always told it was one of the hardest after Chinese, so now i'm starting with Chinese and so far I can say Polish is by far way much harder than Chinese. Chinese is pure logic and simplicity but for entonation and writting.
avegase 3 months ago
@avegase I challange you to learn Estonian/Finnish :P
Rauno315 2 months ago
@Rauno315 to me the most challenging has to be the Eastern languages like Hindi or ummmm Arabic.
TubeGuest5178 1 month ago
@TubeGuest5178 Hindi is not as hard as Finnish or Hungarian, because hindi is one of the indo european languages, but finnish/hungarian/estonian isn't. Arabic is really hard, they have soooooo many dialects.
Rauno315 1 month ago
grammatically Chinese is much easier than the family of Roman language, in Chinese I just hate learning the tone
vic1974jkt 4 months ago
As an English native speaker studying Korean and Japanese, I have to agree that Mandarin is easier by an extremely huge margin mostly due to the grammar alone. People who say Chinese is the hardest language to learn don't study or have not tried to study Mandarin or any other Asian language.
hubomba 5 months ago
@hubomba yep!
TubeGuest5178 1 month ago
Are the characters simplified? I know that a lot of Japanese 漢字 is the same as Chinese, but when she showed telephone, it looked different from 電話 but still looked similar. I always thought that speaking is harder than reading or writing because of the pitches. Japanese is easier (for me), but Mandarin sounds interesting.
alynkaipalomo 5 months ago
@alynkaipalomo Japanese kanji was adopted from China before the simplification of the PRC. While Japanese kanji has undergone simplification it was different and more modest than the one made by the PRC.
OrangeD00D 5 months ago
those tones are killer stuff... and Chinese symbols are so complex, i studied a little bit of Japanese and their symbols are simpler and easier to write.
Evenst3vn 5 months ago
OMG you are way so helpful
rishtar145 7 months ago
i dislikes it must have language learning inability!
kfki 7 months ago
Wo ai ni YangYang :D
sospornofreak101 9 months ago
Omg I think I'm gonna buy your DVD. So far, I like your practical and direct approach. What I mean is you think of what your students might questions and answer them before we even ask it instead of continuous BS'ing. Thank you
yukipham18 9 months ago
I have regard to you because I learn to mandarin chinese language.Thank you very much.
lwoisamsip 10 months ago
The hardest chinese letter for me to pronounce is the 'e', i can't do it! is there's any trick or something? it's really really hard. I speak spanish and english.
Shainkov 10 months ago
Well I just started learning, and compared to when I first started learning Spanish it's easier gramatically, but much harder in both pronounciation and writing. Also spanish shares a lot of similar words with English, where as Chinese shares very few. I have heard that once you get past the early hurdles of Mandarin it does become more manageble, so I'll see, but Spanish is definetly easier.
Chris25698 10 months ago
Sie sie :)
marielitah91 11 months ago
@marielitah91 xie xie
305319 10 months ago
It's like Thai language.
flying machine , movie and other !
and in Thai we also have tones.
but chinese is very difficult for me to memorize the words.
now i still learning mandarin then i will learn Teochew later.
i learn because my grandma is Thai-Chinese.
Thank for the video !
yraiyzen 11 months ago
please, stop comparing languages (everybody knows that Spanish is better and easier than English and Chinese, specially for me that i'm from Spain...) and try to learn some Chinese here!! :) this course is great!
teresika05 11 months ago
Spanish is easier to learn
leoqaz003 11 months ago
wow i'll definitely be getting your course, this is excellent!
rallyboy88 11 months ago
First, you can't say a language is 'easy' because IT IS SIMILAR to English.
Second, you can't say at one moment that Chinese may be difficult for its writing system, and then say that 'words are very transparent'. Diàn Yǐng or Fēi Jī doesn't make any sense IF YOU DON'T KNOW the Hàn zi...
Third, having one or two syllables doesn't make words easier to learn. Take for example shòu shí (授时), shǒu shí (守时), and shōu shí (收时). If you don't have enough training with tones...it's almost impossible!
Shakamuni 1 year ago 9
@Shakamuni She said it was a matter of opinion. You're not perfect, we get that.
BlackCloud21509 1 month ago
@BlackCloud21509 (1) Opinions are different to facts. Which linguistic basis is she using for saying that i) a language is "easy", and ii) even to compare english to chinese and conclude they are similar? I studied english long ago (my english is not perfect) and I have been studying chinese for 2.5 years. I also studied japanese for a long time. And know what?
Shakamuni 1 month ago
@BlackCloud21509 (2) Japanese has far more loan words from English than chinese. Take "Kompyūta" (Computer) and "diànnǎo", take "Aisukurīmu" (Ice cream) and "bīngqílín", take "Isopuropanōru" (Isopropanol) and "yìbǐngchún". Taking vocabulary into account, her statement is more accurate for japanese than for chinese. Yes, english and chinese are SVO languages and... what else? Please, tell me, thou who art perfect as I ca not see, maybe due to my imperfection!
Shakamuni 1 month ago
@Shakamuni
be helpefull or stop doing that coz everything id doable
greenbookful 1 week ago
@greenbookful Wo bu neng liaojie ni de yingwen, qing xie yidian bijiao hao!
Shakamuni 12 hours ago
u are the best Chinese teacher so far - u should teach in the United States.
4GreenEarth2 1 year ago
@4GreenEarth2 she does
305319 1 year ago
Do most people in Hong Kong still know Mandarin?
StreamingKnowledge 1 year ago
你好怏怏。我有一个问题,英文:You state that sentence structure is the same in Mandarin as it is in English, however, I have an example where this is not always the case. It has just created confusion with me and I feel it would mislead your viewers.
你在做什么?What are you doing? Literal = You are doing what?
In English, that structure would be used to clarify an answer to the question "What are you doing." IE, if the answer is a surprise. Where the proper question would be the non-literal.
Thoughts?
mmacgearailt 1 year ago
"backwards"... how idiotic.
bitesh 1 year ago
Internationally, Mandarin and Cantonese are considered two official languages. The other dialects are just considered dialects. Ive noticed before that Chinese people call it all dialects. Kinda important though, if you wanna watch a chinese movie it's always either in Mandarin or Cantonese audio. Or go to Chinese class or things like that :p
paddotk 1 year ago
@paddotk hmmm, i thought cantonese is now considered a dialect? since hong kong was retuned to china in 1998 so its no longer the language of an independent 'country'. the only two places that speak cantonese as its main speech are hongkong and guangzhou. But because hongkong has flourished s much in the past decades in terms of entertainment and movies, cantonese became immensely popular.
baiorinshoujo 1 year ago
@baiorinshoujo I know, but as i said, internationally. Chinese people have told me before that it's a dialect and i suppose that in China itself, it is. But you know, if you want to study Chinese you have to choose Mandarin or Cantonese. If you watch a Chinese movie (i watch a lot of em :p) it's Mandarin or Cantonese audio.
But yeah i can understand that you'd prefer to call it a dialect because it basically is.
Telling from your name, i assume you are Chinese yourself?
paddotk 1 year ago
@paddotk ah yes i am, i was born there but have been living oversea for more than 10 years now.
baiorinshoujo 1 year ago
this video made me want to learn Chinese even more
I hate having to learn all the Latin based languages of Europe. There's conjugations, gender, BACKWARDS. Chinese seems to be more simpler.
the written language is what seems impossible haha...
has anyone bought this teacher's lessons? if so.. how are they..?
SquishyCandyftw 1 year ago
oe tío, el español es recontra fácil, no se porque se hacen tanto problema con mi idioma jejeje arriba Perú carajo!!!
FJUD 1 year ago
@FJUD Soy alemán y aprendito frances y un poquito espa~nol. Para mi, espa~nol es mas facil que frances. Y la pronunciation es ca. como alemán, porque la pronunciation es como de latin. Pero ingles no tiene una reformation. La pronunciation de letras ingles son una catastrofe. No reglas! Se usar letras latinas pero no pronunciar correcto. A es como ä, r es como a, u es como a. No sistema! Porque no "I hate to clean my room" = "Ai heit to cliin mai ruum" ?
WCiossek 1 year ago
@WCiossek Sí, en inglés no usamos las letras apropiadas, y nosotros los estadounisenses las usan peores que los ingleses. Pero, si nosotros criamos usando este sistema, claro que a nosotros nos parece más facil usarlo. Debe Ud. saber que, un alemán como a un inglés, ningún de los dos pronuncia la 'r' como dicen los americanos. Pues, aunque hablemos diferentemente, todos los idomas se parecen extraños. Claro, a tí te parece extraña la 'esszet?' A mí sí, pero creo que tú lo usas frecuentemente.
dhicks3 1 year ago
wow. more simpler than japanese.
josefu0 1 year ago
seems easy so far! I like the music. NO Conjugating!!! thank god
sk8rdaniel 1 year ago
seems easy so far! I like the music
sk8rdaniel 1 year ago
refrigerator
Fuck.. when do we ever call a 'fridge' a refrigerator XD
It's probably an american thing..
Lukeyblades 1 year ago
@Lukeyblades I'm American. I usually say "refrigerator". XD
SaiKoSeSu 1 year ago
well duh chinese is the language 4 the chinese people
fuckxmehh 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
study chinese and English ,,add this msn group group410319@msn.cn we have 600 friends here
anansecurity 1 year ago
study chinese and English ,,add this msn group group410319@msn.cn we have 600 friends here
anansecurity 1 year ago
I lke chineass cause it makee me goodd
kingjameswww 1 year ago
I just started learning mandarin this year and these videos really help me! Thanks! :)
AnimenerdMuffin 1 year ago
I hated learning spanish. You have to say everything backwards. So stupid. I like Chinese better XD.
toughbama 1 year ago 13
@toughbama Well, humans have a tendency to think we know what we know and we assume that our way is the best. We (latinos) think that too, when learing English but then you get used to it.
Spanish (also Italian) has its advantages, how words are written while maintaining a nearly one-to-one relation between characters and souds, makes its orthography easier than English one or French one where characters combinations are often pronounced in multiple ways.
Mandarin is awesome!
suerteeterna 1 year ago
@suerteeterna THIS is a good comment worth all your thumbs up, not those idiotic statements about latin languages being backwards.
bitesh 1 year ago
@toughbama és idiota todos os dias.
bitesh 1 year ago
@bitesh To bad that doesn't make any sense int he english language. What you just said converted to english: is idiot all day. Spanish is a stupid language and I'm still committed to my opinion.
toughbama 1 year ago
@toughbama well just so you know, the structure of a sentence in chinese is also completely different from english, so I guess all other languages are stupid according to you.
too bad your opinion doesn't make sense in any language at all.
and also, you could not have hated learning spanish, because you haven't, apparently.
bitesh 1 year ago
Comment removed
bitesh 1 year ago
@toughbama therefore, I'm still committed to my opinion that you are an idiot.
bitesh 1 year ago
@toughbama better yet: "Tu és um completo idiota"="You are a complete idiot"
oh, exactly the same order! this language just got intelligent! how amazing is that?! :O
bitesh 1 year ago
@bitesh PRETTY DAMN Intelligent :3.
toughbama 1 year ago
@toughbama we think the same about english (i'm from a spanish-speaking country)
ramdom909py 10 months ago
@ramdom909py I suppose, but english is way easier to learn the spanish. And by easier to learn I mean by its way easier to learn english enough for people to understand you.
toughbama 10 months ago
@toughbama That it is true, but it might also be confusing for the people in Spanish to learn english because for them it is backwards.
jjbulls4523 9 months ago
@toughbama Sorry you can't handle it XD
akireshaun 6 months ago
@akireshaun I ment it as a joke :p But you know what, for us, English is backwards as well... Languages depend on people many times. Some people have it easier than other to pronounce in certain languages. I am taking mandarin right now and it is very interesting , however, I took Japanese in the past and their pronunciation was easier for me because there where actually not many new sounds. Practice and involvement with the culture is the best way to keep up with languages
akireshaun 6 months ago
@toughbama I say the same for english many soundless letters for a two silable word.Really stupid...
PabloSanGi 2 months ago
@toughbama Lolololol Esto verdad y yo lo hablo tambian.
TheManiNicole 2 months ago
Chiease is much easier then Spanish ...
kingjameswww 1 year ago 32
@kingjameswww
I believe Spanish is easier than French.
biogovi 1 year ago
@kingjameswww Seems like it with pin yin huh? Even though I'm a native English speaker with one class in French and the majority of my co-workers are Mexican, and I've been trying to study Spanish with a bit of help from them.
You misspelled Chinese :-(
CatGameDaiyE 1 year ago
@kingjameswww and, apparently, so is english.
bitesh 1 year ago
@kingjameswww i speak spanish and english and this is bullshit It's hard haha
ad19935 1 year ago
@kingjameswww I love how u say it is easier to learn but u dont know how to spell chinese.
jjbulls4523 9 months ago
@kingjameswww unbelievable!, but we share the same alphabet!, not the case obviously with chinese.
JsonOslo 4 months ago
@tannguyen1981 yes i have heard that about vietnamese as well as some other SE asian languages, however, i am not very familiar with those. im having a hard enough time just learning mandarin at this point :)
ANOMALOUS4EVER 1 year ago
learning to speak it is not that difficult so far, but listening to other mandarin speakers, and understanding them and the tone.... is proving quite challenging :)
ANOMALOUS4EVER 1 year ago
Well I have to say that short words are rather a disadvantage. They might be a little easier to memorize (even though I dont believe they really are), but its way much harder to understand them in spoken language. If you miss one syllable youre often totally lost. Even if you understand the whole word its sometimes difficult because there are so many words that sound similar to the inexperienced ear.
I'm always glad of long words when someone talks to me in a foreign language.
sacrator 1 year ago
Thank you! ^-^ This was entertaining and informative.
TheBermuda 1 year ago
:/ better with video, not audio
Silentil 1 year ago
this is very helpful. Thank YOU
XxshandiexX 1 year ago
xie xie yang yang - we appreciate you!
FikiNom 1 year ago
GREAT STUFF! :D
itbeonlikedonkeykong 1 year ago
Chinese is an amazing language. I think once you get use to the tones it's really easy!! :3 Thanks for your cool uploads!! :D
lolchanele 1 year ago
most of what you said about chinese apply to Vietnamese as well. We too have only 1 or 2 syllables in most of our words. Our grammar is that easy as well - no conjugations.
tannguyen1981 1 year ago