Billie Godfrey is good but I personally don't think she comes anywhere near Carol Kenyon. I remember this from the first time around... LOL at the posters who believe Dani Filth's incoherent comedy version is better than this!! Sorry kids.
haven't stopped listening to this song since they performed on children in need. Am so glad they did their bit for charity as well as giving me something to listen to non-stop!
On the other hand, Heaven 17's fans could respect the fact that someone actually sold the rights to CoF to record it, and that they must found that song good, so please don't behave like someone profaned your sanctity.
I just see no sense in comparing the original version and CoF cover...
This is a great sing and I like CoF - I think their cover is really cool and funny... the funniest bit is probably that lyrics suit so perfectly their genre. But I don't see any use in coming to Heaven 17 ' s videos on YouTube and writing how the cover is better - what for? Heaven 17's fans will always consider original perfect and CoF fans will find the cover nicer, so who you try to convince?
there isnt many songs that are almost 30 years old and dont actually sound 30 years old if you get what i mean, this sounds as fresh today as it did 27 years ago, and billie godfrey makes this song even better
I remember Heaven 17 the first time around and have seen them live several times. I went to the 80's Rewind Festival this weekend and I can tell you that Billie Godfrey gives Carol Kenyon a run for her money - simply awesome!
@johnnybiggs100 no disrespect you you buddy, BUT the CoF cover of this song is horrible, the female vocalist on that is terrible, and the lead singer is equally as bad, no talent at all, deep growl voice aka no talent as a singer, man i can do that in my sleep as most people can, they butchered this song trying to make it fit into a genre it has no place being in
Thanks for posting this - much appreciated. A superb performance by all.
Slightly off-topic :- Does anyone (else) remember Glenn Gregory travelling from the BBC tv studios Wood Lane to Paris in around 35 minutes during an episode of Noel Edmond's Late, Late breakfast show ? I think he set a speed record.
Wow I am very impressed by the live performance. I remember the song from when I was at uni in Sheffield! The girl is esp good. Is she part of the band or was she a session /backing singer?
WOW! It's rare for a group to sound better live than the recorded version, but damn, this has blown me away! Such a rich unique sound with the keyboard and male harmonies, and her voice is incredible!
I'm probably going to be hunted down by people with pitchforks and torches for saying this but i prefer Carol Kenyon's voice. The original and the best.
Listen to Cradle of Filths version..... COMPLETELY DIFFERENT but brilliant too.... Just for different reasons... And no... I'm not some kid. 39 and love both xx
Gods of pop!
Dosbat1 4 weeks ago
Brill, but Glenns teeth job is a bit over powering lol.
johnnyblunder 1 month ago
MILF OF MILFS .. U FKN ROCK
ma1com10tatgmaildotc 1 month ago
Super sweet
mickyday2008 1 month ago
Wow! that blondes got some lungs on her.
TheGodParticle 1 month ago
cocaine is fucking shit...and thats what they mean in the 80's
tagesmuecke 2 months ago
Saw Billie Godfrey singing this on Loose Women ITV the other week, wow, she is brilliant!
gavsky23 3 months ago
Carol Kenyon sang this song SO much better, she was the best, why isn't she performing with them when they do this song?
This lady ruins it! :/
Takes me back to the 80's when i was a kid growing up :) (I'm 31 now!) i actually have there "Best Of Album" @ home, play it from time to time. :)
Hotlips4000isback 3 months ago
@Hotlips4000isback I couldn't agree more, Carol had a lovely melodic voice, whereas Biliie is very shouty.
TheDivineMissJayvee 2 months ago
@TheDivineMissJayvee
Yeah, this woman ruins an excellent song.
Its like getting Carol Decker(T'Pau(sp?) !) to "sing" this track, when all she would do is SHOUT it! :p
Hotlips4000isback 2 months ago
Billie Godfrey is good but I personally don't think she comes anywhere near Carol Kenyon. I remember this from the first time around... LOL at the posters who believe Dani Filth's incoherent comedy version is better than this!! Sorry kids.
EdgyBT 3 months ago
Pish compared to the Cradle of Filth version, this has no soul whatsoever.
BreandaenFitheach 3 months ago
they ditch the black in this.wankers
bedfordious1 4 months ago
Saw them live at Sheffield Tramlines festival a few weeks ago. Brilliant!!!
ttblade 5 months ago
Used to sing different lyrics as a kid...
There's a pie in the friiiiiiiidge....TEMPTATION! There's a microwave neeearby......TEMPTATION!
ChoPhilly13 5 months ago
If this is LIVE which I think most of it is,its fantastic,she can really hit those high notes,hope they go on tour soon
exiledalien 5 months ago
So. Damn. Good. Still.
number1authority 6 months ago
Oh my goodness, she is absolutely amazing
TimeForTimer 6 months ago
Oh my, she's fantastic!
SwineNahNah 6 months ago
trainspotting babeeeeee!!
maurocordoba90 7 months ago
this woman has a better voice
xxwendyx 8 months ago
Could be a biased opinion but I prefer the cradle of filth version
skitzojoey 8 months ago
@skitzojoey woo hoo \,,/
yumeoihito 6 months ago
Lady in Red WOW!
sunnyblack15 8 months ago
In my opinion the best record of the 80's. Possibly ever.
1stumann 9 months ago
Ummm Tuesday oh wait hold on, ok yeah I lied about the whinch
Carbon657 9 months ago
This song needs more cowbell! Why is it gone !?
MexxPowers 9 months ago
Hahaha, wow how good is this???
They've both got amazing voices and completely nailed this performance.
schpongled 10 months ago
Great song, great performance. Absolutely brillant!
clausjensencom 10 months ago
a heavenly performance ! (forget the high wire , this is LIVE WIRE !!)
67bones 10 months ago
that blonde lass is a cracking singer and bloody gorgeous
donnylad73 10 months ago
brilliant ... just brill brilliante
67bones 10 months ago
she comes from southport merseyside
paul1944 10 months ago
Now that's how you sing live, these guys could take todays acts back to school
clemo2879 11 months ago
omg its orgasmic wot a song singin it sat 26.2.11 my mates birthday bash
frankie4257 11 months ago
lovin lady in red fab voice
joolsdecember 11 months ago
quality
b0ssman99 11 months ago
anyone else got the urge to buy some good honest broadband from yorkshire
GolfBallHeads 11 months ago 7
what a voice,a trully magical gift
donsee1000 11 months ago
Best rendition, ever! - omg sounded like comic book man there....
vortx100 11 months ago
She is good, but Carol Kenyon was better with the ooooey bit! lol
hobbesyhobbit 1 year ago 3
One word
Trainspotting :) x
lilrockere 1 year ago 4
I have always loved the power of the vocals in this song, great work. No need for 'autotune' with talented artists who can sing for real.
lintissa 1 year ago
@lintissa totally, I wish I could thumb this one comment up 500 times
sibeliandrift 1 year ago
That was just Fuckin ace !
hollowedhead 1 year ago
I saw these live and she was absolutely AMAZING! Completely upstaged everyone, including Belinda Carlisle who was on before her!
Bittersuiteful 1 year ago
Anybody know where I can find Hands Up To Heaven by Heaven 17?
I can't find it anywhere. Is that even the proper title of the song?
ShinyComics 1 year ago
shes georgous
mattclb1 1 year ago
Anyone know who the girl is, she's fantastic, better than Carol Kenyon...
graybermann 1 year ago 4
@graybermann If you read my description you will see her name is Bille Godfrey
Prototypeuk 1 year ago 3
@Prototypeuk OK Thanks. Although "Billie" could have been any one of the other blokes if you don't know...
graybermann 1 year ago
@Prototypeuk no need to be rude you little bitch, just be gratfull people are watching your vidieos :S
kishawiboi 1 year ago
@kishawiboi i don't think she has been rude at all..
amaneciamosiameses 1 year ago
@graybermann she was my singing teacher at bimm love her
alicemarie1990 11 months ago
@graybermann Billy Godfrey is her name. A well known and bloody good session singer who also teaches singing.
scarlebloke 10 months ago
@scarlebloke Thanks, what a voice, and lovely aswell, some bloke is lucky :)
graybermann 10 months ago
@graybermann Uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh NO SHE'S FUCKING NOT.
anwfeliEpiviwsi 3 months ago
@anwfeliEpiviwsi Jesus nigger, I posted that six months ago, you have too much time with your right hand.
graybermann 3 months ago
@graybermann Who cares when you posted it? Carol Kenyon was better than Billie Godfrey 6 months ago and she still is now.
anwfeliEpiviwsi 3 months ago
@graybermann NO WAY is she better than the great Ms. Kenyon..that woman has more soul in her pinky finger..not that Ms. Godfrey is bad..
brushotti 1 month ago
haven't stopped listening to this song since they performed on children in need. Am so glad they did their bit for charity as well as giving me something to listen to non-stop!
RonnyScroggins 1 year ago 5
@RonnyScroggins I am just about to upload the Children in Need video.
Prototypeuk 1 year ago
great on children in need last nite, the girl singer is so much better than the original singer from years ago
8beale 1 year ago
did you see them last night on bbc children in need..damn they were good.
slim4711 1 year ago
Best band that merged electronic with soul!
240ups 1 year ago
I met Glenn Gregory in a Tenerife bar in '84, what an obnoxious prick !
Good tune though.
YCSMusic 1 year ago
On the other hand, Heaven 17's fans could respect the fact that someone actually sold the rights to CoF to record it, and that they must found that song good, so please don't behave like someone profaned your sanctity.
Zuzannaq 1 year ago
I just see no sense in comparing the original version and CoF cover...
This is a great sing and I like CoF - I think their cover is really cool and funny... the funniest bit is probably that lyrics suit so perfectly their genre. But I don't see any use in coming to Heaven 17 ' s videos on YouTube and writing how the cover is better - what for? Heaven 17's fans will always consider original perfect and CoF fans will find the cover nicer, so who you try to convince?
Zuzannaq 1 year ago 2
awesome 80's at its best !!!!
valhalla49 1 year ago
Heaven 17 with Billie Godfrey on "Later" with jools Holland on Friday night22 October 2010
winterlandboy 1 year ago
@winterlandboy saw the show ,brilliant song and that girl can sing ,any going to post it in you tube?
bigfellethanks 1 year ago
Who'd have thought that anyone could sing Carol Kenyon's original part as good. Yep they found someone who can - Billie - excellent vocals!!!!
soul4444 1 year ago 2
Ah - Billie is so, so good!
scarlebloke 1 year ago 2
Billie Godfrey: 10/10 in vocals AND appearance
Lethanor 1 year ago 2
Teeth job, bald head under cap - shame!
mikris50 1 year ago
there isnt many songs that are almost 30 years old and dont actually sound 30 years old if you get what i mean, this sounds as fresh today as it did 27 years ago, and billie godfrey makes this song even better
Great Song and timeless
deviousdanoh 1 year ago
fantastic vocals from billie godfrey
wankerscunt 1 year ago
I remember Heaven 17 the first time around and have seen them live several times. I went to the 80's Rewind Festival this weekend and I can tell you that Billie Godfrey gives Carol Kenyon a run for her money - simply awesome!
mrstychup 1 year ago
Comment removed
chompandcrunchie 1 year ago
Is this live in bensham?
langley6 1 year ago
Does anyone know where I can watch this entire programme? Why am I only hearing about this now?! Really guys, come on... keep me informed won't you.
TheSky16 1 year ago
this song is the business
ptech365 1 year ago
what happened to the girl who origanly sang this song?
jordan16195 1 year ago
Just came across this i've seen them live before and she is AMAZING
teenytobs12 1 year ago
Who covered who? I prefer CoF's version.
anonymice14 1 year ago
@anonymice14 CoF covered Heaven 17
MAHBOI35 1 year ago
come back ian craig marsh
marklee1783 1 year ago
OMG better they are better than in the 80s!!!!
maria461 1 year ago
OMFG !!! Excellent!!
neto4346 1 year ago
*goes to watch the cradle of filth version* O_e;; nooo thank you *returns to this* the original is sooo much better
roxas485 1 year ago 20
@roxas485 I respect the original but Cradle made it dark and better! It was like this song was made to be performed by Dani Filth!
johnnybiggs100 1 year ago
@johnnybiggs100 no disrespect you you buddy, BUT the CoF cover of this song is horrible, the female vocalist on that is terrible, and the lead singer is equally as bad, no talent at all, deep growl voice aka no talent as a singer, man i can do that in my sleep as most people can, they butchered this song trying to make it fit into a genre it has no place being in
deviousdanoh 1 year ago 2
@roxas485 just seen that version made my ears bleed
GolfBallHeads 11 months ago
@roxas485 naaaaaaaa CoF version is more good than heaven 17
seya567 3 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Cof''s version is MUCH BETTER
666Kleto666COG666 1 year ago
Holy crap.....AMAZING!!!!!
1980jlifts 1 year ago
cradle of filth vs heaven17 haha!
ShanLoveXiarmaine 1 year ago
Thanks for posting this - much appreciated. A superb performance by all.
Slightly off-topic :- Does anyone (else) remember Glenn Gregory travelling from the BBC tv studios Wood Lane to Paris in around 35 minutes during an episode of Noel Edmond's Late, Late breakfast show ? I think he set a speed record.
drpoxy 2 years ago
Wow I am very impressed by the live performance. I remember the song from when I was at uni in Sheffield! The girl is esp good. Is she part of the band or was she a session /backing singer?
ravrik 2 years ago
awesome singing Billie!
pyraplastic 2 years ago
Martyn looks fab-o. This chic is awesome too.
nuwavegurl 2 years ago
WOW! It's rare for a group to sound better live than the recorded version, but damn, this has blown me away! Such a rich unique sound with the keyboard and male harmonies, and her voice is incredible!
christhesnaildriver 2 years ago
This was an awesome performance. I'm not sure what genre it's classified as, but it's almost like a new-wave disco sound.
PremaritalSex1 2 years ago
Briliant song 5 stars
zeboh 2 years ago
omg, i was about to bash them for trying to substitute Carol Kenyon but this chick is AWESOME! very good!
jonasmjr 2 years ago
LOVEEEEEEEEEE THEM!
interplanetkitty 2 years ago
Comment removed
sirmuttley 2 years ago
Comment removed
sirmuttley 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
is he gay?
jlspma 2 years ago
Excuse the language guys but Billie Godfrey is FUCKING AWESOME!!!
foggy4xchamp 2 years ago 2
Top track
RogueBrit 2 years ago
Billie Godfrey came to my school the other day! she was helping train people for a school production 'stars in their eyes' and I met her!
aliwb 2 years ago
Can't believe how great they sound!!!
godisatan 2 years ago
sounds great!
monimania 2 years ago
Saw them last night with so many other 80s bands it was amazing!!!!!
nikkimooo3 2 years ago 2
Trainspotting forever
javierpl311 2 years ago 3
what the fuck... its been 20 odd years, he dont look a day older
mgsherry 2 years ago
I'm probably going to be hunted down by people with pitchforks and torches for saying this but i prefer Carol Kenyon's voice. The original and the best.
schneiderlover 2 years ago 6
Carol Kenyon- oh how I fantasised about her. She's the reason.
noc99 2 years ago
I saw this live on TV not so long back, I'm sure it was not more than a few months ago, if not, definately 2008.
montyspond 2 years ago
what year was this screened?
mullio 2 years ago
November 2008
Prototypeuk 2 years ago
Listen to Cradle of Filths version..... COMPLETELY DIFFERENT but brilliant too.... Just for different reasons... And no... I'm not some kid. 39 and love both xx
foggy4xchamp 2 years ago
When Billie came in it blew my bloody balls off!!!! AWESOME
foggy4xchamp 2 years ago 17
She is great. I'd love to meet her
Prototypeuk 2 years ago 4
I met her! she came to my school!
aliwb 2 years ago
@Prototypeuk i have :P
aliwb 1 year ago
AWESOME! 5 STARS!!!
randomglen 2 years ago 4
Thats Billie Godfrey shes amazing and cute too
PaulAllsop68 2 years ago 4
Nothing like the 80´s, everyone has to assume it, the decade with more originality in music
BlackSkyThunder 2 years ago 11
she has the best voice everrr (y)
JakeeJR 2 years ago 4
omw ..
im 13
and i seriously usually dislike my dads music haha
But i love this trackk omw yesss :D
JakeeJR 2 years ago 4
me too, billie godfrey came to my school and I met her!
aliwb 2 years ago
heaven 17 are amazing live!
Laurz1233 2 years ago 6
Grandissimi!
lagomax 3 years ago 3
The woman in this video has a really amazing voice. Brilliant!
HanDuran 3 years ago 4
Get out and see them live,,,,nuff said, Awesome!
666JK 3 years ago 5
Great job, superb live performance of one of the best 80's song!
joel60112 3 years ago 2
OMG the lead singer's voice is still superb! Its like they never left at all!
You guys are so fortunate to have this show on TV! But thanks to YouTube, 80s fans in Asia like me can stilll wctch them : )
I have seen Heaven 17, Howard Jones and Kajagoogoo, Ali Campbell on this show on 1983, any other acts I missed out?
ykmsp 3 years ago 4
Spandau Ballet was on there too. ;)
HanDuran 3 years ago 3
This is fab !
yhoo cnt beat a bit of heaven 17
duet n tht x
ursibabes 3 years ago 2
Were was Carol Kenyon ?
torosaurusmcr 3 years ago 3
Heaven 17 were the best live act that night. They sounded fantastic vocally and music wise.
bondbug73 3 years ago 2
that woman is really brilliant at singing0.0
zaqwsxcderfv555 3 years ago 2
What is Quentin Willson doing playing the keyboard at 0:44, 2:14, 2:41 and 2:49
Prototypeuk 3 years ago 3
i was there!!! im in the audience!!! it was brill!!! they did every song twice
romeo6669 3 years ago