Added: 1 year ago
From: AbsolonMaycon
Views: 73,270
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (163)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • MYA SUCKS, GO LINDSAY!

  • Lindsay's version sounds forced and unnatural....Mya sings this waaaaaaay better.

  • they should've kept it as a duet with mya

  • She has a hard time finding songs that suit her voice. Mya's is better, but she has a better voice, not that her voice is great or that Lindsay's is bad. LL kind of sounds like a little girl. LL and Mya both seem to have underdeveloped voices when singing.

  • Mya's version is much better. Lindsay's voice doesn't fit... We danced to this song (Mya's version) and I know the song very well. Lindsay's version is horrible I think...

  • Her voice doesn't even fit the song! It just sounds weird!

  • i like this one more than mya's. however! i think mya is more talented than she is. no offence i really like them both.

  • She singing too slow to the beat. HORRIBLE

  • she is not singing low notes i think

  • lindsay sings this better. mya sounds horrible.

  • lol....she can't sing this AT ALL... Mya all the way!

  • lol i like the way she says JR.

  • Lindsay is good R&B singer :)

  • I love thiss(:::

  • LILO version better than mya's !

  • love lindsay! get it girl better than mya

  • WTF Lindsay sings just as good as lots of other girls out there. She should do more music, she's definately got the party like a rockstar attitude.

  • sry dude lindsays version is a hell of a lot better mya has a nasty voice

  • Wtf? Lindsay Lohan can sing? @@! Oops...

  • why are all the lohan fans commenting how they like this version better on Mya's video, and all the Mya fans are here commenting on how they like Mya's version better?

    I don't like this version, she lacks swag, but come on, go tell other fans how much you love that version, not go to the video you already know you don't like. (I only clicked because I wanted to see what her version sounds like, it's not my favourite of the two, but I don't hate it...)

  • I love Lindsay Lohan and Mya is my #1. Sorry Lindsay you can't touch Mya is singing or dancing. Lndsay has no swag it sounds flat.

  • Has she been really successful in her music career so far? Just wondering.

  • @MissieElliot09 yes, her first album sold like 270,000 the first week

  • Mya's BETTER

  • I cant out this song of my head!!! I love it!!

  • Wow Lindsay Lohan great vocals?? WTF I love Lindsay but as an actress she is a horriable singer and can't sing for shit! But I do like her song Stuck she did pretty good on that song but she can't sing!

  • I like this version better than the one bye Mya. I don't like the way Mya says "Rocking" for some reason but thats the only reason I prefer this one! Other than that they are both really amazing! Where did you find this? I want it so bad!

  • Lindsay uses less autotune than Mya on here lol

    Lindsay's was better IMO.

  • @plug145

    do you know what auto tune is?

  • its funny how they comment on myas that lindsays is better and comment on lindsays that myas is better.

  • DELICIOSO

  • It's good. It's a different sound for Lindsay but it fits well. Hell yeah, good dancing beat too. :)

  • "G's up"???? "Up in the hood"??? Noooooo Lindsey ur not gansta ur a dope fiend!!! Mya's version was waaaayyyy better!!!!

  • @twigz36 hahaha so true, says it all :D that song just doesn't fit to lindsay..

  • I think both versions are ok. The lyrical content fits Mya better because she co-wrote it and I'm sure it's Mya's song because it was on her album Liberation.

  • her version is better cuz she has that scratchy voice which is sexier yea Mya sings better but the song wasnt meant for her vocal wise -_-

  • @VomitOnMyKunt what?? ridiculous. it's the other way :) mya's version sounds so much sexier

  • Wow. For people who don't know who MYA is, then they are either 10 years old, or don't know what music is.

    Please. Kids. STFU. Mya is an ACTUAL artist who had many hit songs back in the day, and is one of the many hip-hop/RnB icons that don't get enough light like they deserve and used to.

  • @vollygirl59 so true!! she was/is amazing, i loved her back then. where is she gone? oh yah, silly question, the good artists were all gone when the good music also was gone -.-

  • @vollygirl59 - LMAO at you. Mya and "back in the day" (along with "an actual artist") don't really go hand in hand, you know? "Back in the day" is usually used to refer to 80's, 70's, 60's and beyond...not the 00's. She was just another product, like the rest of those $2 R&B starlets. Disposable R&B fluff, nothing else. "Kids", indeed.

    No offense. ;)

  • @samsamba08 WOW. You actually took the time to clarify this? LMFAOOO. Okay....sooo, NOT back in the day, right?

    Back in the 2000s, Mya was AN ACTUAL SINGER. Not some red-headed retard who drove her entire life down the shitter, and put out an album with no singing abilities.

    ..i mean c'mon, Lindsay's song ''Rumors'', really? You take that seriously than MYA?

    I'd rather listen to $2 disposable R&B fluff, whether it's Mya, BlackStreet, or Boys 2 Men, than this stupid shit.

  • @vollygirl59 - My comment was about Mya, not trying to "defend" Lohan in any way. I despise Lindsay Lohan. This is the first and only "song" I've heard of hers, morbid curiosity I guess. I just thought it was funny, that a 00's artist like Mya is already considered nostalgic and retro among you kids. What I said about her (Mya) being a product along with the rest of those artists and all that I still hold true...she was hardly groundbreaking, you know. A dime in a dozen.

  • @vollygirl59 Heres an idea dumbshit if you dont like it dont listen to it that ever accured to you honestly i've met smarter pidgens

  • @gretanovo "Dumbshit"? Me? I'm sorry, but I'm not the one who misspelled words like:

    OCCURRED or PIGEONS

    I've met kindergartners smarter than you.

  • @vollygirl59 by that comment it was obvious that the only song from her first album you heard is Rumors. try giving it a listen before judging. she has better vocal abilities than most chicks out there now

    she has a great vocal range, her voice doesn't break when she sings loud either.

  • @plug145 it's obvious that you're judging that I didn't listen to her whole album. Quite the contrary; in fact, I have.

    The album is on youtube, and none of the songs are remotely catchy as her Freaky Friday song "Ultimate" (which, I am guilty of actually liking.)

    If Lindsay ever took on singing; rock is really her field; not pop or hip-hop. This song is definitely not fit for her.

  • @vollygirl59 you just proved you didn't listen to it by that comment.

    the whole speak album is r&b/rock. the only songs that aren't rocky are Rumors and Speak

    I have to agree that her voice is better for rock, but in my opinion she still does amazing on pop tracks, she proves that on Stuck

  • @plug145 It's whatever you wanna believe buddy, but i have heard it. The whole album is very pop-ish and trashy hip-hop. Sticking in some guitar and drums don't automatically make a song "rock", but then again, it's a matter of perception. So if you think i'm wrong, then whatever.

    And going off on ur previous comment; lindsay's vocal abilities don't outdo 'most chicks out there'. Unless you're talking about Miley Cyrus, then that's a different story.

  • @vollygirl59 they do outdo any singer I've heard coming out from disney.

  • @plug145 won't argue with that..

  • i love this song

  • Ummm . . . Mya's version is so much better, her voice is like honey. Lindsay should stick to pop or rock, dont think r&b/hiphop is her thing. I guess cause Lohan's more well known cause of her "issues" people just like this cause her name's on it?

  • that's a nice couple!! a smoked rapper and a toxic barbie o_o

  • sounds like a Britney song to me.

  • Convenhamos que Ficou MUITO² melhor com os Vocais da Lindsay Lohan.

  • 5*

  • Reminds me of Britney's Circus.

  • Mya just got pwned...

  • woww ... was that mya's voice in the back? this is so dubbed ... lol

  • um no ... not feelin this version, like mya's.

  • nice nice <3

  • I don't know why but Lindsay's version is way better...

    She make the song more sexier..

    Seriously...

  • I love you with all my heart Lindsay. She is the best! I love his music ... Please Linds; Launching soon his third album "Spirit in the Dark" You are the best forever! I LOVE YOU.

  • This song was officially released under Lindsay's name.

    Go look at J.R. Rotem's Wikipedia page. He's the producer of this song and in his discopgraphy it says "Walka Not A Talka" - Lindsay Lohan feat. Snoop Dogg, so obvi. it was released under her name, not Mya's, or it would say Mya.

  • This doesn't sound like Lindsay Lohan at all. :(

  • lol "Me and mya in the back of" yeah, this is definitely originally lindsay's song. Morons. Go listen to the original and the better version.

  • Mya's version is better. Lohan sound...off singing this record.

  • dam this song is straight trash. she can't even hit the high notes in the interlude. respect to mya

  • Lindsay we love uuuuuu!!!! #LiLoTeam

  • lindsay lohan version is totaly better than maya this song is so cool i love it ...this song sound so sexy

  • This versions alright.. but .. girls like Lindsay.. should never try to be gangsta lol

  • this version is so BORIIIIING!!!! she sucks.

  • The best song with Lindsay ever.

  • you can tell lindsay didn't spend alot of time on this.cause it would be epic.but her voice is so fucking sexy.i can't help but be tempted.

  • JUST MAKE ANOTHER FUCKING ALBUM LINDSAY!!!!!! You get all made because your songs are getting leaked.They're getting leaked because everyone wants you to just do it!

  • Hell naw. I don't like this version. This is what you call a beat biter.

  • Ready to hear facts?

    Mya wrote and recorded this song and J. R. Rotem produced it in 2007 for her Liberation album that wasn't released anywhere except for japan, due to the album being bumped from the U. S. schedule. This song was slated to be the first single, but when Motown (the label she was releasing Liberation on) decided on Lock U Down as the first single, Walka Not a Talka was supposed to be the second single, but Motown then decided on Ridin'. The album was bumped, she ended up leavi

  • Sounds like a KIDZ BOP version of the original. Horrible.

  • This is way better than the original by Mya. It's so much more inetersting than the original. Go Lindsay!!!!!

  • thiis some bullshit delete this bullshit mya's better

  • @TheNaenae0

    no...

  • yet they keep Mya's vocals at the end of the song?

  • Awesome my Girl...

  • i love this song so much mya;s version is so boring & not fun this one is like holla

  • the only reason they put her on this song is cuz she gets papped & media interest...!

  • I like Mya's more, and if you dunno who Mya is look up case of the ex o.o Her best song imo. I had to hear both to see what the comments were referencing, and lol yeah Mya's for sure.

  • LOVE THIS love her voice. lindsay is infinitely times more interesting than mya and that goes farther than singing abilities. besides i like lindsay as a singer

  • This is just...fucking terrible.

  • Garbage!

  • the version from mya is better

  • ii love it!!

  • Awesome video.

  • Mya's Version >>>>>>>>> this version *just stating #facts

  • OMG!!!!!!!!!! HOW COME I'VE NEVER HEARD THIS B4? I LOVE THE BEGINNING!

  • @PenniwiseXX same!! i love when she says :-and lindsay-. sooo amazing!

  • DAMN!! way better than Mya's version, if they add a little europop/ techno/ house, have a rockin' video with Lindsay doing a sexy dance routine...then this song could go straight to the Top 40 :)

  • @Electricpeacesurge right!!i dont even know who this mya chick is,but lindsay did an amazing job with this song!!i think thats coz her voice is unique,none has a deep voice like hers in celebs.she rocks! lindsay we love yaaaa <3

  • Dammn... i love this girl

  • love this version! you go lindsay!

  • okay lindsay suck on here she taking too long to finish the words before the beat and she doesnt has the voice for this beat thumbs down

  • wow..ok...so lindsay did this song like a pro! Shes on fire in this song! I just listened to mya's, and lindsay did WAY better, plus lindsay is 234567897644X better to look at ;)

  • This one is better, ¡Lindsay is the best, baby! (L)

  • GEE Lindsay's version of the song is BETTER... :) Sexier and HOTTER :D LOVE IT! Luv u LiLo...

  • @frost100db YH!! i love it!!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • why would J R Rotem waste his talent on shit like this? haha

  • I Like both versions!!! Mya and Lindsay did well and snoop D. O. Double G brought fire..so both versions are hot! And linsay has a good voice too.

  • Further clarification, Snoop Dogg Lindsay refers to as Mya, however, no influence at all and leaves Lindsay free to make a cover and mount with the parts sung by Snoop.

    Follow me on twitter: @ xMaicon_Ab

  • To clarify to everyone: Nothing I can do to change the situation of the song belongs to Mya, was just sort of cover, but the music is published by the official as Lindsay. I love Lindsay and also respect the opinion of those who do not like, just do not want to offend, because there is no way to defend it. Those who liked the song, know that you feel the same.

  • Hi Guy's

    I like this song alot im always listening to it and Lindsay rocks i cant wait to get her new cd hurry up and get it released over here please Lindsay Lohan rocks the whole world im addictted to this song l0l im always listening to it i cant stop listening to it l0l.

  • this song is very very hot!!!!

    

  • HORRIBLE

  • thats totally bad

    Mya feat . snoop dogg - walka not a talka

    is the one and only

    shut up lindsey.......thumbs up for mya

  • Its a shame that people dont take her seriously because of her personal life, she is a really talented actress and singer.

  • Great song! Hope she drops a new album soon!

  • Ok Lets Get For All Yall TRYING to Dog Lindsay About This Song..She Prolly Did it For The Hell of It Not As Anything serious..and if lindsay is such a terriable singer and all this and that WHY ARE YOU ON HER PAGE LOOK UP AT HER MUSIC..Look Up Sombody or Somthing else if all you wanna do is talk shit cause to be HONEST lindsay has MORE TO WORRY ABOUT THAN YALL HATERS..SORRY to Be Statin HONEST FACTS

  • Perhaps because we were recommended to this song and it just turned out to be a pile of shit. So get a life kiddo cuz if what you are truly worried about is hoping we don't hurt Lohans feelings then you need a reality check.

  • Mya's version is much better than Lindsay's version.. Really it sounds like crap..

  • Glad to see lindsay back :) and Glad shes doin' well! Keep goin Girl!

  • WOW OMG the computer does a great job!!!!

    seriously what the heck is this :P

    blechhhhh!

  • This sucks ass! She's a terrible singer, no wait that's a compliment, she's the worst wannabe singer! >.<

  • @hateme2death You don't know what terrible is until you've heard Norah Jones.

  • Lindsay is a real boss bitch.

  • @jacksongriffey have you met nicki minaj?

  • this is horrible...

  • Crap.com, this talentless crack whore needs to crawl back to her hole.

  • Not better than Mya, but it's alright.

  • wow i actually like this!!! great job lindsay! she does alot more better then mya....... iv liked lindsay since her first songs came out........ i new tht she would come back to music! - roy

  • G's up, G's up! Yeah!

  • @sigridvanosch can u tell me what means G's up?? :/ plzz!

  • @sigridvanosch Can u tell me what means G's up?? plzz!!

  • Wow, This is good!

    Well done lindsay! (lll)

  • @cyborobin Thumbs up if you don't know who Mya is, you don't care and know that Lindsay is the hottest woman alive!!

  • @egocentric69 She keep drinking that syzzurp, she won't be alive much longer.

  • @egocentric69 come on now...mya is MUCH hotter than lyndsey...lol not even a contest...

  • @egocentric69 how the hell do you not know who mya is you idiot? she's had mutiple hits, certainly a better SINGER than lindsay freakin lohan, and more respected as a singer than lindsay ever will be.

  • @egocentric69 lol perfect

  • @egocentric69 How do you NOT know who Mya is? Unless you weren't born in the 90s that is...

  • Cheaaper!  u.u

  • HHAHAHAHA is this song a joke? If you're a walka not a walka throw it up? Get the fuck out of here and go back to rehab Lindsay

  • This kinda reminds me of that song at the end of The House Bunny. It reminds me of Emily Stone's part in that song...

  • i think this was a mya track b4 ...

  • this song make my hump hit the floor...

  • snoopy snoop

  • let's listen to original version by Mýa's Liberation (2007, Motown Records). Lohan fu**ed this song, Mýa's original song is the best!

  • I adore this. (:

  • Love it.

    WELL DONE LINDSAY

  • sexy song !!!

  • sexy song,

  • OMG

  • ahh that's better, Linds! ;)

  • wow

    wtf

    LOL

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more