I hate shakeb for saying that madhubala is not beautiful and from which angle does she look ugly in this clip man....you should feel some shame before talking about such a great star in bad taste wat do you know of her, her life and struggle......think before you speak..........
I cannot believe that we are getting 40's footage, such a treasure. Adorably sung by Madhu or someone else. The kid really doesn't have any resemblance to the Madhu Bala that all of us know....those greek/sharp features, sparkling eyes. I could be simply wrong!
@surjit1234 I am actually delighted to be wrong! I absolutely identify with the golden era of Hindi cinema though I was born in disco dancer generation. I came across 'tere sadhke balam' from Amar and stood transfixed by Madhubala's pristine acting and much commented 'classic' beauty. I cannot think of any modern songs that can do this....I am sitting here 1000s miles from India and just keep coming back to this gems.
@Voltairec I am 8,818 miles from Mumbai, where the movie made. I fell in love with Madhubala in the 50s. I could not sleep for two days when a friend sent me a copy of Basant 1942!
although she was born in Peshawar, her features clearly indicate that her family had connection with valley of Swat. A detailed study of her family roots may prove that
Madhubala is like a full moon. You may find defects in moon when you look too closely but there is nothing more beautiful in skies than moon in reference beauty and symbol for love. Madhubala's beauty is unquestionable to most people including myself. Yes we must speak our honest openion even when others differ.
She as a child, must have been of the best singer of her times. I love her songs.
A very curious and funny message regarding height boosting surgery was misdirected to you tube by some unaccountable mistake of my younger brother who only cares about his height with a devotion bordering on obsession.
He is 5feet10inches but he wants to get6feet
2 inches so he wrote to betz institute using
my name and computer inorder to obtain informations regarding height enhancement surgery but unfortunately dueto some
No sir, your boasting won´t do!!! There´s no sense in deviating from the topic. If you could add some out-dated vocabulary to your message, doesn´t mean that you are convincing. You understood very well what I initially meant. Besides, we aren´t holding any English language classes here. Your problem seems to be of a complete different nature. You´re pitiable. (bedauernswert)!
Did you ever know the saying: beauty lies in the eyes of beholder!? God knows how and where do you get all the energy and motivation to waste your time on finding faults in humans who are long been gone, and if there´re people having pleasure in admiring Madhubala, how are you being bothered by that!? Strange???
Iam sure you stayed indoors ages painstakingly and ponderously practising and swotting up this threadbare,flyblown and
motheaten stinking wornout English proverb
not German that beauty is inthe eye of the beholder.I reckon you wont mind pal if I correct you on account of your dreadfully and hopelessly erroneous lousy crap pidgin
German english with a limited vocabulary which you boastfully and shamelessly speak
and write.Actually it is beauty is in the eye of the beholder
One can't imagine a girl of 9 possessing such a talent -- all the more interesting to know that she herself sang the song! A very, very natural performer in all respects she was! All the human emotions and feelings she could portray with so much ease -- and in a natural flow!
There is another clipping from the same film, I think, where she is also surrounded by three more actors -- Mehmood's father, et al!
Thanks for thegreat clip n the info. My eldest brother n his friends use to sing this song and I remember all the words even now. Ratan film's songs also became so popular1
chandrashekhargupta is 98/100 times accurate.. just found him wrong twice :) However hes an asset to youtube ..am saying this though i neva had a chance to talk to him :)
Thank you so much for posting these sweet little songs sung by the precocious and utterly poised-- and cute as a button-- Madhubala at age 9. A natural performer, I dare say. No wonder she grew up to do every role with seemingly effortless talent and carved out a special place for herself as the finest of the finest actress in the history Indian cinema and in the hearts of millions. These clips are gems.
ji Shukriya aur Meri taraf say warm welcome ...to the Living Legend :) with best wishes as its a jungle out there on youtube and u'll come across every sort of music lover here.. ranging from layman like me and music-scholars like Kianwar and wonderful Rare Indian Songs Video uploaders like Lady SRazdan :)
This has been flagged as spam show
luv u......ur always here ......didi
simranwriter 11 months ago
luv u......ur always here ......
simranwriter 11 months ago
happy birthday
simranwriter 11 months ago
she is explaining wealth of poor people.A real peace and treasure of poor.Very Nice.
shiva4k60 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
nice video .......
visit my profile and enjoy the lot of information
nomorechatu 1 year ago
Prof Jee:
You are absolutely delightful.
You have been so generous to us thousands for years.
There is NO WAY we can thank you enough
vsv1949 1 year ago
shame on you shakeb shame...........
simranwriter 1 year ago
I hate shakeb for saying that madhubala is not beautiful and from which angle does she look ugly in this clip man....you should feel some shame before talking about such a great star in bad taste wat do you know of her, her life and struggle......think before you speak..........
simranwriter 1 year ago
I cannot believe that we are getting 40's footage, such a treasure. Adorably sung by Madhu or someone else. The kid really doesn't have any resemblance to the Madhu Bala that all of us know....those greek/sharp features, sparkling eyes. I could be simply wrong!
Voltairec 1 year ago
@Voltairec Thanks for giving your opinion. I am happy to report that you are absolutely wrong. Do some research, read some old 40s magazines.
surjit1234 1 year ago
@surjit1234 I am actually delighted to be wrong! I absolutely identify with the golden era of Hindi cinema though I was born in disco dancer generation. I came across 'tere sadhke balam' from Amar and stood transfixed by Madhubala's pristine acting and much commented 'classic' beauty. I cannot think of any modern songs that can do this....I am sitting here 1000s miles from India and just keep coming back to this gems.
Voltairec 1 year ago
@Voltairec I am 8,818 miles from Mumbai, where the movie made. I fell in love with Madhubala in the 50s. I could not sleep for two days when a friend sent me a copy of Basant 1942!
surjit1234 1 year ago
@surjit1234 sir can u share with me the copy of Basant..i am doing a research on Madhubala...my email address is skyrider_salman@yahoo.com
rowlerz 1 year ago
can any one told me from where madhu family belongs in peshawar
humayun06 1 year ago
Dad worked for Imperial Tobacco
Company in Peshawar, came to
Bombay in 1940.
surjit1234 1 year ago
although she was born in Peshawar, her features clearly indicate that her family had connection with valley of Swat. A detailed study of her family roots may prove that
orientlover1 1 year ago
a lovely girl, a future star!!!! RIP Mumtaz!!
TheMoncheri86 2 years ago 2
Singer: Shanti Sudha Ghosh,
(daughter of Parul and Pannalal Ghosh. )
derubala 2 years ago
Please tell me the basis of your comment.
surjit1234 2 years ago
Please tell me why you think so.
surjit1234 1 year ago
please google her name.
thee is a blog of Atul bollywood, he has details.
also my late uncle had the 78 rpm record of this movie.
so I knew from the record.
derubala 1 year ago
Madhubala is like a full moon. You may find defects in moon when you look too closely but there is nothing more beautiful in skies than moon in reference beauty and symbol for love. Madhubala's beauty is unquestionable to most people including myself. Yes we must speak our honest openion even when others differ.
She as a child, must have been of the best singer of her times. I love her songs.
I wish she was still alive.
uu0009 2 years ago 5
I figure I expressed adverse,disapproving
aswellas unfavourable but fair comments and
judgements of Madhubalas apperance only not of her acting talent My dear alternative thinker which were probably spurned widely
by her fanatics and arse lickers onthe you tube.
shakeb112 3 years ago
Lol!!!!
kqs92 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
(2)reached you tube instead of Germany so I
apologize to youtube for any inconvenience
caused and mistake committed by my brother.
I shall be especially grateful to youtube if that particular message of my brother posted
on Friday July 25 is obliteratd if it is
possible other wise all the people who are braincase,blockhead,numskull,malevolent
venomous and vindictive picking a quarrel who
need psychiatric treatment inorder to get
their disorderly brain fixed will laugh at me.
shakeb112 3 years ago
A very curious and funny message regarding height boosting surgery was misdirected to you tube by some unaccountable mistake of my younger brother who only cares about his height with a devotion bordering on obsession.
He is 5feet10inches but he wants to get6feet
2 inches so he wrote to betz institute using
my name and computer inorder to obtain informations regarding height enhancement surgery but unfortunately dueto some
inexplicable reason and his reckless mistake
his message
shakeb112 3 years ago
I suggest that a brain surgery would be more appropriate in your case to in order to elevate your intellectual height, rather.
kqs92 3 years ago 3
I am a cambridge guy born and bred
and educated in cambridge university and you
are doomed to lose the battle each time you
clash with
...and you say, you´re a Cambridge guy...!
kqs92 3 years ago
No sir, your boasting won´t do!!! There´s no sense in deviating from the topic. If you could add some out-dated vocabulary to your message, doesn´t mean that you are convincing. You understood very well what I initially meant. Besides, we aren´t holding any English language classes here. Your problem seems to be of a complete different nature. You´re pitiable. (bedauernswert)!
kqs92 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
May I introduce myself.I am Mr.Shakeb a British
national living in England and Iam interestd in height increasing surgery in order to get at least 4
inches more taller provided it is absolutely innocuous.I shall be especially grateful if you kindly let me know the total cost of the height
increasing operation and how many more inches
can be added to a persons existing height aswellas
the operation is hundred percent safe and not
very painful.
shakeb111 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i dont like indian film and songs
XxalmasSxX 3 years ago
Mr. Shakeeb111
Did you ever know the saying: beauty lies in the eyes of beholder!? God knows how and where do you get all the energy and motivation to waste your time on finding faults in humans who are long been gone, and if there´re people having pleasure in admiring Madhubala, how are you being bothered by that!? Strange???
kqs92 3 years ago
Mrkqs92
Iam sure you stayed indoors ages painstakingly and ponderously practising and swotting up this threadbare,flyblown and
motheaten stinking wornout English proverb
not German that beauty is inthe eye of the beholder.I reckon you wont mind pal if I correct you on account of your dreadfully and hopelessly erroneous lousy crap pidgin
German english with a limited vocabulary which you boastfully and shamelessly speak
and write.Actually it is beauty is in the eye of the beholder
shakeb111 3 years ago
2 it is not beauty lies in the eyes of beholder.I have been conversant with this english proverb ever since my childhood.
probably you are not aware of this proverb.
so I shall suggest you pal never try to teach your grand father(mother) to suck eggs
because I am a cambridge guy born and bred
and educated in cambridge university and you
are doomed to lose the battle each time you
clash with me because youre as thick as two
shortplanks and reacted like a bear with a
sorehead to me
shakeb111 3 years ago
3) for my recent comments to your sweetheart
Madhubala inorder to stickup for just a whore
and vehemently antagonize a gentle man like me
who never did you wrong.Shame on you.
shakeb111 3 years ago
I suggest allthe indians who regard madhubala as the most beautiful woman inthe
whole wide world must critically watch this clip taken from the movie Basant of
cross eyed and crooked toothed,unsightly child star madhubala who they think has
miraculously blossomed into a most beautiful
woman against all expectations,just in order
to change their firmly ingrained ideas
of her beauty instilled by madhu in their
head.
shakeb111 3 years ago 2
Madhubala isn't the only person who was not exactly pretty as a child and grew up to be a
beauty - I'm sure we all know people like that. And others who were adorable as kids and grew up to be unattrative - what's your point?
shamimb 3 years ago 3
Dear shamim
Thank you very much seeking my views regarding madhubalas metamorphosis from an
unattractive little girl to a most beautiful
woman inthe whole wide world but in actual fact she wasnot as beautiful and glamorous as
she was cracked up to be by most of indian
and pakistani movie lovers.
I dont reckon the miracle of turning a boy
and a girl from ugly to most stunningly handsome, beautiful man and woman ever performed by Almighty God inthe world apart
fromin fairy tales.
shakeb112 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Dear shamim
Thank you very much seeking my views regarding madhubalas metamorphosis from an
unattractive little girl to a most beautiful
woman inthe whole wide world but in actual fact she wasnot as beautiful and glamorous as
she was cracked up to be by most of indian
and pakistani movie lovers.
I dont reckon the miracle of turning a boy
and a girl from ugly to most stunningly handsome, beautiful man and woman ever performed by Almighty God inthe world apart
fromin fairy tales.
shakeb112 3 years ago
(2)No doubt people can change upto some extent but it is highly improbable that they
can be transformed completely upto this extravagant extent from ugly to stunner.
so for my money madhu was not as charming as she is
erroneously and unjustifiably believed and
lauded by her fanatics.
shakeb112 3 years ago
Dear shamimb(1)
Thank you very much seeking my views regarding Madhubalas metamorphosis from an
unattractive little girl to a most beautiful
woman in the whole wide world but in actual fact she was not as beautiful and glamorous as she was cracked up to be by most of indian
and pakistani movie lovers.
I dont reckon the miracle of turning a boy and a girl from ugly to a most stunnigly
handsome and beautiful man and woman ever performed by Almighty God in this world
shakeb112 3 years ago
One can't imagine a girl of 9 possessing such a talent -- all the more interesting to know that she herself sang the song! A very, very natural performer in all respects she was! All the human emotions and feelings she could portray with so much ease -- and in a natural flow!
There is another clipping from the same film, I think, where she is also surrounded by three more actors -- Mehmood's father, et al!
Enjoyed both.
devmadhu 3 years ago 4
Thanks for thegreat clip n the info. My eldest brother n his friends use to sing this song and I remember all the words even now. Ratan film's songs also became so popular1
biyer08 3 years ago
Wow! she is singing so maturely, she could have been a singer too.
Who would have thought such a simple chubby cute and innocent young girl like her would turn into legendry beautiful heroine of India.MADHUBALA!!!
chanto7 3 years ago 2
Thank you for shairng this wonderfjul and precious clip. It should be archived for posterity. Even at age 9, she was a naural actress.
ZAINUKHAN 3 years ago
Parul Ghosh on Baby Mumtaz (who later became famous as Madhubala) in Basant (1942). Pannalal Ghosh's music on Pyarelal Santoshi's lyrics.
chandrashekhargupta 3 years ago
You are wrong! According to Anil Biswas he composed the tunes (Panna Babu did only the orchestration) and here Baby Mumtaz sang it herself.
surjit4321 3 years ago
chandrashekhargupta is 98/100 times accurate.. just found him wrong twice :) However hes an asset to youtube ..am saying this though i neva had a chance to talk to him :)
lovehumanity 3 years ago
Thank you so much for posting these sweet little songs sung by the precocious and utterly poised-- and cute as a button-- Madhubala at age 9. A natural performer, I dare say. No wonder she grew up to do every role with seemingly effortless talent and carved out a special place for herself as the finest of the finest actress in the history Indian cinema and in the hearts of millions. These clips are gems.
moviestuff22 4 years ago
Thanks for the video. Great clip.
wentyAUS 4 years ago
she's sooo cute- it sounds and looks like she's actually singing the song
sandhaeliya 4 years ago
She is! This is her own voice!!!
surjit1234 4 years ago
Wonderful, nostalgic clip. Thank you for posting.
srazdan 4 years ago
Prof. Saheb thanks for this GREAT clip,
kianwar 4 years ago
ji Shukriya aur Meri taraf say warm welcome ...to the Living Legend :) with best wishes as its a jungle out there on youtube and u'll come across every sort of music lover here.. ranging from layman like me and music-scholars like Kianwar and wonderful Rare Indian Songs Video uploaders like Lady SRazdan :)
Regards
Dr.Bukhari
lovehumanity 3 years ago