Added: 6 years ago
From: thesilvershining
Views: 260,027
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (544)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • What's "queer" (in response to one of the many ignorant comments made), is that you have too much time on your hands and not enough sense God gave you, if that's how you respond after listening to one of the greatest songs ever written. Homophobic? Passing judgment onto others when you probably need to look in the mirror at yourself and not spend time spewing your hatred comments....figure out what your problem is! Seriously, small minded people are pathetic....

  • My first time seeing this and it's 2011 and I think it's a perfect memorial for Heath Ledger<3!!!!!!! I still cant get over his death ans just want to see him in more movies and with his beautiful daughter Matilda! Love Michelle Williams too!!!! I want Heath back... Who ever made this did it before he passed but its still oppropriate or now!! Thank You!!

  • why the fuck are everyones comments about homophobes and gays?? just enjoy the song and video...

  • @cena619cmpunkHHH AMEN!! They need to get on the small minded, ignorant, so sad for you bus and cruise on the road!  Bye-BYYEE!

  • I wonder if Jake Gynenhall goes in Heath Ledger's closet and snuggles his shirts now that he's dead..

  • people fixate on the guys so much the loose focus on the women...

  • jack, i swear.....

  • Jack Twist? Jack Nasty! :)

  • this one would have been a good soundtrack fro the movie...

  • i bet stevie Nicks liked this version over dixie chicks lol

  • HAHAHAHAHA! I didn't know what video was playing (the playlist was going in the background on my headphones) then I flipped to it around 2:17 and was like what the fuck movie is this? THEN at 2:22 i saw jake jilinhall with his filthy moustach and laughed out loud in the middle of the bus.

  • @cbtony1 your reaction made me laugh.

    The song is still good.

  • @cbtony1 LOL... wow... And I hate the smashing pumpkins anyway so you can have it.

  • That was a lot of mindless starring.

  • what ignorance it is to use this video...to fight fight fight. the movie is a masterpiece...the acting was sublime...and the storyline so true.....heath ledger never to be forgotten...did a genial performance here.....and he wasnt gay....so please people.....leave your dam hate behind.

  • just love how someone can post a video of a beautiful song to go along with clips to a beautiful movie and it turns into a fucking political fight.

    GROW THE FUCK UP, GUYS.

    LOVE IS LOVE. every single gay person i know has the biggest heart and they are so caring and loving towards EVERYONE. they're not going away for a long time, and i couldn't be happier about that. so deal with it.

    k i'm done :)

  • @blisterr29 . i guess you didn't actually read our conversation, politics were never discussed. it's also sweet that you say every gay person you know is caring and loving, but that also had nothing to do with it. since you didn't read the discussion, here's a quick recap. i asked everyone what could be appealing about anal sex. bopbopanna (a chick) assumed i was a homophobe, and tried to call me out. it became clear she was a man hater with an axe to grind. the end.

  • @SparksDrinker ok sorry.

  • @SparksDrinker I've just seen this. Ahahahaaaaa. A man hater? No. I just hate homophobic imbeciles like you that tries to cover your bigotry by asking questions in order to bait people. Go look at your porn stash and kid yourself it's about research and not about the fact no-one wants to date you.

  • @bopbopanna . wow bopbopanna you are stubborn. u have decided to stereotype me and your view will not change no matter what i say. for the last time, i have nothing against gay people, i just don't understand the appeal of anal sex (man or woman). release your hatred, u will feel better.

  • @SparksDrinker You keep saying that and yet your posts declare otherwise. I won't change my view on you because you are homosexist and homophobic. BTW: I don't hate you. I feel sorry for you. You are a fantasist and clearly, have a strange perception of yourself that is rather evident to all those reading your posts.

  • @bopbopanna i have a feeling u have been treated very poorly by men in the past. good luck.

  • @SparksDrinker Hahahaaaaa. I have a feeling that your "feeling" is about as delusional as your denial re: homophobia. LOL, LOL, LOL.

  • @bopbopanna repeating hahahaha's and lol's are a sign of desperation. it means u have nothing else to say. face it, because you're a chick u are over your head in a discussion about male on male sex. u are a cat trying to explain why dogs sniff eachothers butts. u think u know, but u have no idea.

  • @SparksDrinker Not at all. it's showing contempt for your argument. I have heaps to say, but the problem is: you wouldn't understand it.  I think it is patently clear to everyone else that you have an unhealthy fixation with the same-sex sex act. Face it. You're obsessed. Come out of the closet. Grow a spine and get a boyfriend.

  • @bopbopanna yes, you are a cat showing contempt for an argument about dogs. by the way, if anyone is obsessed, its the one who restarts and argument 8 months later.

  • @SparksDrinker Stop transferring. As said earlier: I only just discovered your silly reply. I am, indeed, persistent.

  • @bopbopanna yes u discovered it 8 months later and chose to restart it, yet you haven't brought any fresh ideas. u say persistent, i say stubborn and boring. this is the best way i can explain my point : guys like to make fun of eachother. i think butt sex is gross, so it amuses me to ask gay dudes why they would do that. u chose to believe i hate gays. the truth is i could care less about anyones lifestyle. if u arent hurting others, do what u want. but u wont accept that.

  • @SparksDrinker My point remains: you're a homosexist and homophobe. None of your posts have dissuaded me from that view. Now you're arguing that your interest in gay-sex is banter. That is an impoverished line - usually argued by someone trying to mitigate their original point of view. You chose to write ridiculous anti-gay posts and then argue that you're not a homophobe - yet your own posts prove you to be disingenuous.

  • @bopbopanna you just typed "You chose to write ridiculous anti-gay posts." i don't believe i did. could you please give an example of an anti-gay post i made?

  • @SparksDrinker Read all your posts. They are excellent examples of your homosexist, homophobic and anti-gay stance with your little qualifiers of each to their own. Sorry, but I'm not interested in sifting through your muck and mire, and enabling your sexual fixations.

  • @bopbopanna seems like you are very interested since you brought all of this up again. i knew you couldn't give an example because there isn't one. you chose to turn my simple curiousity about the pleasure of butt sex into something negative.

  • good song but i hate gay porn!!!

  • Muy triste me hizo recordar a alguien que se me fue de esta tierra... linda cancion

  • Excelente versión cover de The Smashing Pumpkins

  • me encanta Billy Corgan's voice

  • @historyris27 oh id make you sick alright. When i fill your stomach with benzine. You are a stupid little boy and will die as you lived; ignorant.

  • Goes through the bones...! So great song..

  • Beautiful movie.

    Is a great love movie...

    and

    God bless Billy Corgan!!

  • @fedepite queer

  • If nothing else this is a beautiful montage of Heath Ledger. I love this song, and I love this version. Check out "PS22's" version of this song. Very pure. It'll make you cry, if you're like that. I am.

  • why can't he sing like this all the time?

  • no words - love is painful who ever you are

  • Cool mix with the music--I agree with the subscriber--it's also about realizing that whatever you are, whoever you are, you should not be afraid to love those who are near to you...& love in all those those ways that truly express this 'force of nature'. For Ennis...this realization came sadly too late. Don't you love the way this breathtaking scenery interacts and underscores the eternal quality of the message in the film? This is a classic of our time.

  • @BritScot12 GAY! lol joking I didn't read your comment hahaha

  • this such a great song!

  • best cover ever i think.. this and when joe cocker did 'with a little help from my friends'

  • what a stupid comment!

  • Beautiful cover, unforgettable movie. Love and the human condition - amazing.

  • chill dudes........

  • Great song and a great video.. great movie and great version by the pumpkins!!

  • ok fuck all you homophobic dumbass pigs if some one wants to be gay its their right so for the love of god shut the fuck up jesus leave people the fuck alone and thats not what the song is even about it just goes well with the romance yes its romance homo or not deal with god im sorry most of you were raised in some fucking stupid home were being gay is wrong and still dont reallize that your stupid parents were wrong its about friggen love not sex not race not fettishs L.O.V.E. so please stop:)

  • damn right!

  • No im hetero but im sorry your ignorance probably doesnt understand that it means STRAIGHT i just dont fucking hate people for their sexual fettishs or their attractions you like what u like get over it geez whats wrong with a dude liking a dude

  • God dam dude ur really immature The future of america folks! aint it great?

  • 16 i dont think threats are neccesary youve just proven my point for me

    just because i talk mature doesnt mean im old you see my ignorant friend i dont follow the whole fuck education fad of most teenagers today people like you are the reason the world is first of all so retarded and violent so thank you cpt. Dumbass you've helped me win my arguement :D

  • Check my profile i have vids of myself and no most teenagers dont talk like that because most of them are uneducated or just have a stupid personality you my friend are a prime example of this stupidity once again you help me win me arguement.

  • -_- lets be mature about this state your reasons why is being gay wrong?

  • and what makes me a fag enlighten me

  • i totaly back you up, this guy has sense in his head what so ever.

  • OMG!! hahaha..this song is now ruined..hahahaha

  • One of the best versions of the this song I have heard. Especially by a male artist. Thanks for posting:)

  • What a suitable song for this movie! Both awesome works of art!

  • Thats life, life isn't beautiful. But it is real. Anyway, beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

  • Life is beauty, beauty is the life in you. If you can seek question, you can seek reason. And without purpose, without need- nothing worthy of noise ever is produced. Life is the medium of all noise

  • oh my whata great cover. very emotional cant believe heath dies a year ago :( i still think about him

  • Boring film, great song.

  • I don't like it neither, the same I don't like peanut butter, but I accept someone likes it.

  • i didnt say i dont accept it, i just admitted to not understanding it. and your peanut butter analogy is terrible. there are many foods i dont like, but i can understand why other people like them, what i cant wrap my mind around is the attraction to a shit packed waste tube.

  • just curious, do you feel the same about women who like anal sex? or just men? There are lots of nerve endings down there that can be stimulated.

  • for me it goes both ways,  i've never understood why a guy would want anal with a girl, when there is a much better option one door over.

  • @SparksDrinker You can't understand it because you have no concept of love lurking in your brain. The first thing you correlate with two people being together is sex. Why? There's more to life than just having sex! Fuck, just open your mind. I've seen so many people refute homosexuality with "why would you like an anus?" Do men fall in love with a woman's pussy or for her? Same goes for anybody else. LOVE is fucking LOVE dude. Not even all gay men have anal sex, so what do you say to that?

  • @jmtley i guess i say you sound like a very high maintenance person. i wonder, when you have one of your hissy fits, does it turn your boyfriend on? another question.... wouldnt it be gross to get his poop on your dick? i just dont get it. a guys butthole is so disgusting. whats the attraction?

  • @SparksDrinker I sound high maintenance how? That makes no sense. The attraction is to the person not their orifices. Your argument became asinine right after you assumed things about me that weren't true. I'm just trying to let you know that people fall in love, regardless of sexual orientation, with the person not their holes. Any intelligent person would know this. What are you in your prepubescent stage? If people do engage in anal sex it's as clean as possible but not everyone even does it.

  • @SparksDrinker Oh and one last thing, why do you specify it as a "guy's butthole?" You sound like a homosexist, where you vehemently rant on about gay things to prove to yourself that your dissuasion towards homosexuality is right but everything that's nasty (for lack of a better word) simply just is and it's fine. I don't find anything wrong with anybody of any gender loving anyone of either gender. That's just me. Overall, you are entitled to your opinions. It shouldn't concern you anyway tbh.

  • @jmtley i swear i am not a homosexist,  and i dont vehemnetly rant on gay things. I also have no problem with to men being together, married or otherwise. To each his own, do what you want as long as it doesnt hurt anyone else. I am not talking about love either, I am talking about the act of man on man sex. I find it fascinating and puzzling that a man would desire to bury his penis in another guys butthole, or vice versa.

  • Well, for being straight you spend way too much time thinking about homosexuality. You obviously seem to think it's pointless to be gay (male-wise) if it's not about anal sex. You just don't get it, and I don't think anyone can help you understand. It's not something that can be explained away in layman's terms. What about lesbianism? What about heterosexuals who engage in anal sex? What about gay men who don't participate in anal sex? Being gay isn't just about sex. What don't you get?!

  • @jmtley to answer a couple of your questions..... 1)heterosexuals engaging in anal sex - i find that perplexing as well, i have no desire to have anal sex with women, the butthole is gross either way, just more gross with men.

  • @jmtley 2)lesbians - i think with lesbian couples its more of an emotional connection than a physical one. i was never talking about love or long term relationships, my questions were more based on men who jump from man to man for the purpose of sex and pleasure only. i understand that long term relationships go well past the physical experience. i just dont get how one man can look at another man and think to himself... wow, i would love to stick my dick up that guys ass.

  • @SparksDrinker humans are complex. not that the two are on the same level, but with your reasoning it's similar to having a fetish for say, sadomasochism (wow, i would love to be whipped until i scream), it's just what said person's psyche may desire. just like a straight man desiring breasts, or a pregnant woman desiring pickles on ice cream. humans cannot be explained the way you are trying to deduce them to be. the pursuit to do so is futile, and you'll never get a satisfying answer.

  • @jiiibatsam actually i just did get a satisfying answer, thank you jiibatsam, you staement makes total sense.

  • @SparksDrinker yes, you're playing charades in dangerous territory

  • @jmtley Billy Corgan is a faggot!! I hate his voice!!

  • @SparksDrinker You sound like a very immature person. What are you trying to prove to your prayer group - that you're not gay? Sounds like you've thought waaaaaay too much about homosexuality to be straight. Your post reads to me like someone who wants to be gay, has analysed every possible sex act gay people engage in, but who doesn't have the courage to be themselves. Good luck to you, sunshine. Hope you resolve your issues.

  • @bopbopanna dear bopbopana, thanks for chiming in. i dont belong to a prayer group, because organized religion is bullshit. its true, i do think about homosexuality, i like to think about things that i dont understand and try to figure them out. maybe you can help me..... its hard for me to think of many things more disgusting than a mans butthole,  whats the attraction?

  • @SparksDrinker No the butthole fixation is your own. I'm not about to indulge you in any more of your homoerotic fantasies and issues. Reducing people's relationships to simply sexual acts is ridiculous and immature. Why fixate on sexual acts? There are many and various conceptual and theoretical questions you could be thinking on, but no ... you choose to think of someone's butthole. Hmmmm. Says it all really.

  • @bopbopanna . is it really so wrong to be curious? i'm not trying to "reduce people's relationships to sexual acts". besides, some relationships are based solely on the physical act, and i was more curious about those than deeper love. one more question bopbopann..... does it feel weird when your pecker is in someone's butthole and they fart? i've always wondered about that.

  • @SparksDrinker Yes. You are trying to reduce people's relationships to sexual acts. As for the pecker comments ... wrong equipment. I thought the "anna" at the end of the bopbop might be a give way. Now I sense a general overall confusion where it's not just curiosity on your part, but the inability to read a frame of reference.

  • @bopbopanna . haha ohhhhhh i get it your a chick. then why are we having this conversation? you have no idea what you are talking about. this is about men and the desire we may or may not have to fuck another guy in the ass. as a woman nothing you have to say about this is relevant, just like nothing i have to say would be relevant about giving birth.

  • @SparksDrinker Sorry. I disagree with you. Homophobia is everyone's business. You are correct though. I cannot speak of a lived experience as a gay man, but I don't think you can either? Or is this your confessional? Which may, in some way, explain the curiosity beyond normal bounds of detail?

  • @bopbopanna . see, thats where you are confused. i am not a homophobe, you just choose to see me as one. i could care less if someone is gay or straight, to each his own. i was simply looking for an explanation on the feelings involving one mans desire to sexually engage another man. since you are a chick, you input was not needed.

  • @SparksDrinker Wrong. You are a homophobe and you've proved it over and over again, and that instance my input is valid. I think you do care whether someone is gay, straight or otherwise because you choose to single out the gay male experience. Your reference to trying to figure out desire and sexuality is thinly veiled homophobia characterised as curiosity.

  • @bopbopanna u disappoint me bopbanna, i see now that you are a close-minded and judgemental person. you have labeled me as a homophobe based on my questioning of the desire to stick a pecker in a butthole. u say that i single out the gay male experience by asking that question. from what did i single it out of? as a man why can't i ask that question? and as a woman why are u sticking your nose in the middle? i guess i'll head over to a tampon chat room and throw in my 2 cents.

  • @SparksDrinker Glad to disappoint you SparksDrinker. The last thing I want is a homophobe with butthole and tampon issues as a cheerleader.

  • @bopbopanna . i just got back from the tampon chatroom,  man there were alot of bitches in there. they didn't want to hear what i had to say and all of them were in a really bad mood. they kind of reminded me of you.......

  • @SparksDrinker Really? I just got back from a homophobes convention. Most of them were about 15, pimply, lived at home with their parents and the closest they'd come to actual sex was with a piece of soap in the shower. Apart from that they were great.

  • @bopbopanna i don't get it. a piece of soap in the shower? did they carve a hole in it and fuck it? again the fact you are a chick limits you in the discussion of male sex. you also are still labeling me as a "homophobe" which is hilarious because it couldn't be further from the truth. whats the word for having no respect for dumb bitches such as yourself? i'm 100% guilty of that.

  • @SparksDrinker And now you reveal your true character and pedigree. Tsk, tsk. It did not take long. I don't know the answer to your question, but I certainly know the term for your particular pathology.

  • @bopbopanna i've never tried to hide my character. as a chick you just see what you want to see. believe it or not a) i have no problem with gay dudes, if a friend of mine told me he was gay i'd have no problem with it. gays should be able to marry, join military, and i actually enjoy many things in the gay culture. b) i think 90% of women are over-sensitive, attention seeking drama queens. i also feel very sorry for any men in your life.

  • @SparksDrinker Stop projecting. The only person that is acting like a drama queen and wants attention is you. The rest of your post is dissembling or cognitive dissonance.

  • @bopbopanna  . haha that is a good one, you say i want attention when it was YOU who decided to butt in when one guy asked other guys about the desire to participate in butthole sex. you decided that i was a homophobe and that was that. ever since then this has been about me defending myself against an attention-seeking harpy.

  • @SparksDrinker No. You proved yourself a homophobe and continue or perpetuate your denials through cognitive dissonance. This is a public forum and a public thread. You seemed to be harassing people for explicit information on sex acts (that would constitute sexual harassment off-line and in the real world) under the guise of "curiosity". (Read voyeurism). Now when the heat is on you to justify your position and actions, you start swearing and trying to draw boundaries. You've been owned.

  • @bopbopanna . you're trying too hard bopbo, don't turn into a lawyer on me. besides, it's you that is doing the harassing, i was simply asking a butthole question at a video about gay cowboys. some free advice: stay out of conversations you don't belong in and get a sense of humor.

  • @jmtley thank God someone is patient enough to take on douches like that.

  • @jmtley Yeah,that's something a shrink of mine has told me,that people are too focused on who's going to bed with who when it comes to relationships nowadays.

  • @jmtley It's called IGNORANCE...but you know you that...love your response but some people just aren't worth your time....killer song...let's stick to that! :)

  • heres a thought for you. well the other option... thats where the piss generally comes out from. and that place where you put your cock, yeah, a woman tends to bleed out of there every once a month. you do know that the shit tends to stay in the intestines until it needs to come out. so yeah its where it comes out but... not when ur actually having the sex, unless your unlucky. oh and btw plp enjoy it cos there are a lot of nerve endings, oh and guys have prostate glands.

  • ^Thanks you! Also, it's not a "poopy hole". It's not like you put it in and you can feel the shit and then pull out and all around your dick it's poop. That's not how it works.

  • There's more to life than sex. But if ever love a woman or man you would know what that is like.

  • I like this, but I think the original version is better.

  • I've only ever watched BBM once because it kinda destroyed me. I'm glad that you didn't use Stevie's version as that would have blown out my kneecaps and decimated my eyeholes.

  • this version of the song really fits the clip so well. im all for sticking up for the originals but this cover is just beautiful, its so different but it works. reminds me of something jeff buckley would do. i love billy's voice so much so i suppose that helps.. :)

  • Brilliant movie....but I'm sorry this cover is not up to par....and to the person who compared this to Stevie...ur nuts. Dixie chicks made a better version than this one.

  • Are you kidding me? the original is great and all but I much prefer this one. But to even try and compare the smashing pumpkins to the effin dixie chicks?? That's a laugh. I guess everyone's entitled to their own opinion...

  • The original was actually by Fleetwood Mac yo. But I agree with this being the better cover.

  • I thought Stevie did the original?

  • Stevie Nicks was in Fleetwood Mac when she sang this.

  • thats awesome, i never knew that before now n-n

  • search youtube for the video of Dixie Chicks with Stevie. It's much better than this one. I love Smashing Pumpkins but think this is the worse thing I've heard them do. Dixie Chicks already sound a little like Fleetwood Mac anyway so it was a natural for them to cover it.

  • agreed. I'm a huge pumpkins fan but I don't really think Billy has the best voice or style for this.

  • No No No No. Dixie Chicks version is horrible. You are entitled to your own opinion, but come on. Have some common sense.

  • will she ever forgive me

  • This was great, thanks for posting. ^_^

  • Good bye Mom. Thanks for the lessons on the seasons of my life. I am ready to change. Bye. I will love and miss you forever.

  • what a touching post...hope all is well with you.

  • I'm sure your mother is very proud. Blessings to you. :)

  • I saw this movie and I thought it was depressing as hell. I had scene like a bit where they were drinking whisky so, so I did that or not pure but southern comfort 100 proof and was taking shots and by end this movie had depressed the hell out of me. I wanted to see those two gay fools get together. They were just soul mates. I'm not gay, but I mean who cares, I mean that's why it's such a tragedy that Jack dies and then Ennis realizes what he lost. Fucking depressing movie Man.

  • love the hole pieces album, and this track sets the tone for it. childhood memories, dead actor, gay cowboys and a great tune.

  • I love this film...!!! and the video is beatifoul ^^

  • Better than the Fleetwood Mac's.Could've been on a less gay movie,though

  • Naw.I mean Stevie did great too.I just prefer Billy's voice better for this.The guitar sounds better too.YES I CAN tell the difference.listen to about 1:34 in.

  • This song was written by Stevie because

    of something that was going on in her life

    it sounded good to Billy

    and he can sing it with his gay voice

    all he wants but

    you can't better perfection.

  • This just shows how sad the movie really was...and its just such a beautiful song i really do like Billy's vocals better than Fleetwood Mac's. Still the orginal itself is amazing...but mainly this just draws out the movie and the way it was perfectly insync with the parts of the movie is just beautiful.

  • shit vid but an amazin tune

  • oh em gee. i died.

  • this is my favorite song of all time,and i dont think it could have been used better. This is probably the most intelligent video ever made and if you haven't seen the movie it means nothing

  • I think you're wrong. I haven't seen it, but this video almost the the story. I really liked it. And the song is beautiful.

  • touche

  • gay. and this version isnt nearly as good as the Fleetwood Mac version simply for the fact that Stevie Nicks isnt singing it

  • Oh aren't you clever, mentioning gay in a comment on a Brokeback Mountain video...

  • well it is gay. would it be more proper to have said homosexual? maybe you think its just to cliche to speak of homosexuality in the midst of the gayest movie ever made, maybe you're right. I should have simply said I dont care for this version of the song so I wouldnt leave myself open to ridicule from the gay rights activists

  • Yea that's all I was saying. I guess I misinterpreted your intentions in the use of the word gay, but I mean I'm not judging lol.

  • Maldito imbécil!

  • tu gusta joven muchachos

  • smashing turned this normal song into a masterpiece

  • I dont know what you mean by normal but the only difference from this and the original is Billy's voice which is annoying here. I dont mind his voice when its drowned out by lots og guitars but it doesnt sound good here. Stevie has a MUCH better voice

  • YOUR FUCKED IN THE HEAD

  • why do you say that? I believe I maintain a healthy equilibrium, I might eben consider myself worldly

  • shutupp. yea fleetwood mac did it origianlly, but if anyone deserves to cover it at all its the smashing pumpkins

  • que bonita cancion y pelicula. adoro smashing pumpkins

  • its not a dixie chicks song. its by fleetwood mac. and its a beautiful song.

    mirror in the sky what is love...

  • There seems to be an overkill of profanity and disagreements on youtube's comments nowadays. There seems to be so much anger out there. The worst part is - when someone is insulted they insult back - and the whole wall of comments is like an online world war. Is it too much to ask to ignore someone?

    Anyway thats me - over and out.

  • coerect my friend shows a lack of intelect