Sam Riley did a spectacular job as Ian. Do you guys know he'll soon be playing On the Road's Sal Paradise for it's 2011 movie release? I knew from the start he was a born star.
It's almost like the real event, when they played in the TV... but there is one mistake - by the historic way, they played Shadowplay, when Tony Willson introducted them.
Yup. One of the main reasons why the movie was successful. You should watch it if you're at all interested in Joy Division. The acting was pretty great too.
Note that the movie actors are imposed over the the actual original footage of this performance. Most noticeable from the guitarist's right side angle.
Aunque transmission tiene buena letra, una parte de lo que canta quedaría traducido de esta manera:
"Podríamos pasarlo bien,viviendo en la noche,
abandonados a la destrucción ciega, esperando nuestra visión."
"Y podríamos seguir adelante como si todo fuera bien, escondernos de esos días en los que estábamos solos. Quedarnos en el mismo sitio, fuera del tiempo, TOCANDO DESDE LA DISTÁNCIA, más allá del tiempo".
Y claro, podríamos decir que está canción es la clave, ya que todos sabemos que está dedicada a Deborah Curtis (su mujer), véase la frase TOCANDO DESDE LA DISTÁNCIA, que sirvió a Deborah como título de su libro sobre la biografía de Ian (TOUCHING FROM A DISTANCE)"
¿No es increíble?!! xDD
Ya no escribo más, que se agotan los carácteres xDD
I never knew about this group before I saw this movie. The movie seemed dark and compelling. I am one of the idiots that thought he was dancing... until I realized he was struggling with his fits onstage from giving so much. Don't care for his affairs, but deeply felt his pain... and LOVE this song now.
you're a fool, he's not dancing like that because he's epileptic, its just his style. do you think he could just have a seizure conveniently between each chorus? n00000b
Ian Curtis' daughter, Natalie, was in the crowd as an extra for the Derby Hall gig, Sam Riley had played Mark E. Smith, lead singer of The Fall, in the film 24 Hour Party People
Joy division!!!!! control fucking great movie!!!! fucking great group!!! one of my favorites... i make a tribut of atmosphere if anyone wants to see it there it is jejejeje
If I've got this right.. This part of control is trying to potray jd's first TV appearance right? So shouldn't they actually perform Shadowplay here? (as the clip of the real TV performance shows?) Confused!?
lol...deborah´s influence on the movie lol right...but funny is...or curious that while the movie continues and ian is getting closer to death...the light at his face star to disapear and they mark more the shadows...just like making the people feel that ian is reaching the shadows...
...there is the mundane/ordinary and there is the extrordinary, then, there is this clip, which is......extra-extrordinary! This has greatness stamped all over it...
I love you Ian!!! se que cuando muera nos volveremos a encontrar!
radiosterea 9 months ago
Ian Curtis great job
ixion58 1 year ago
The introduction was from when they perfromed Shadowplay. strange error or deliberate change.
Stube437 1 year ago
Hooky is from Jane St, Ordsall - SALFORD!
MrRedcap999 1 year ago
is this sam riley's voice or ..?
TheWritingWriter 1 year ago
@TheWritingWriter yeh its sam riley he is in a band he sings in a lower tone just like ian curtis did
squeekpile 1 year ago
How they found a drummer who looks just like Stephen Morris and could play just like him, I have no idea!
hightimesbruce 1 year ago
@hightimesbruce He only look's like him because of his floppy hair! definitely not a dead ringer though. Specsavers i think! good drummer though.
jameyinegypt 1 year ago
This film was so amazing I can't stop watching it
xXVolcomIdiotXx 1 year ago
Sam Riley did a spectacular job as Ian. Do you guys know he'll soon be playing On the Road's Sal Paradise for it's 2011 movie release? I knew from the start he was a born star.
jaymesandtunic 1 year ago
wow they just tried to copy their live video exactly
elurseeknay 1 year ago
The real song they first play on TV was shadowplay rigth??
Galansboard 1 year ago
@Galansboard thats what i was thinking!
MrMUGS94 1 year ago
@Galansboard yes it was on Grandana reports. this is almost identical xcept jd played shadowplay not transmission.
colecharmed 1 year ago
It's almost like the real event, when they played in the TV... but there is one mistake - by the historic way, they played Shadowplay, when Tony Willson introducted them.
e6e2e3e1 1 year ago
the movie was absolutely brilliant. the actors were great, the continuity (among with the songs) was perfect, everyone should watch it :)
SuperrrDuperrrr 1 year ago 3
'Control' was an excellent film.
shepshepherd 1 year ago
oh shit whos the actor that plays Bernard? He really looks like him when he was young!
franco216 1 year ago
they found the an exact same looking actor with ian curtis
graceofacat 1 year ago 8
Yup. One of the main reasons why the movie was successful. You should watch it if you're at all interested in Joy Division. The acting was pretty great too.
kevinbelmont 1 year ago 6
@kevinbelmont ive watched it many times actually and we totally agree that the acting acting was great!!
graceofacat 1 year ago
@graceofacat maybe a little akin to "The Doors" - Val Kilmer..
elshano12 1 year ago
@elshano12 IAWTC Kilmer = awesome
colecharmed 1 year ago
@graceofacat the actor is prettier than Ian Curtis
ptitpraince 9 months ago
Can we say Big Dogs Cock?
TheLoyalSkeptic 2 years ago 3
good but hardly with the passion of ian
BornOutOfAGuitar 2 years ago
The guitar is the only thing lacking. Other than that, it's an excellent portrayal
TheGreaterGood80 2 years ago
Yeah you're right!
majerlet 2 years ago
People don't even know how great this movie is for even existing.
I mean, when they start with "Drive-In Saturday" followed by "2 HB," you know you're in for a good time.
SonofMrPeanut 2 years ago
@SonofMrPeanut I downloaded the soundtrack, best i tunes purchase ever!
Exhibitionismist 2 years ago
His voice holds the weight of his own perception.
TheBarefootServant 2 years ago
dance ,dance,dance to the radio
totaldavo 2 years ago
The Thing that really shocked me when i saw this movie was how similar are the actors to the real members of Joy Division!
sas147741 2 years ago 17
Exactly that was what i thought.
ColumRogers 2 years ago
Tudo bem que no filme retrataram que eles tocaram "Transmission", mas na primeira apresentação na TV eles tocaram "Shadowplay".
interceptory001 2 years ago
beautiful
hot4six 2 years ago
andddd WE COULDDDDDDDDDDD DANCEEEEEEEEEE
ADESIREEZ 2 years ago 4
Note that the movie actors are imposed over the the actual original footage of this performance. Most noticeable from the guitarist's right side angle.
DaltinWentsworth 2 years ago 4
the best
industrialnyleon 2 years ago 2
Thanks, I know =)....Great film.
kevinbelmont 2 years ago
ta piosenka, czy film? Jak dla mnie- muzyka;))
DonaBeata 2 years ago
zgadz się, Joy Division is the best
industrialnyleon 2 years ago
que fome la version
yesmoncuraca 2 years ago
This is my favourite Joy Division´s song. I cant understand qhat says, becasue I speak spanish, but anyway i like it!
And I hope this movie is in Internet in spanish
franRW 2 years ago 2
Aunque transmission tiene buena letra, una parte de lo que canta quedaría traducido de esta manera:
"Podríamos pasarlo bien,viviendo en la noche,
abandonados a la destrucción ciega, esperando nuestra visión."
"Y podríamos seguir adelante como si todo fuera bien, escondernos de esos días en los que estábamos solos. Quedarnos en el mismo sitio, fuera del tiempo, TOCANDO DESDE LA DISTÁNCIA, más allá del tiempo".
greywasarrest 2 years ago
Y claro, podríamos decir que está canción es la clave, ya que todos sabemos que está dedicada a Deborah Curtis (su mujer), véase la frase TOCANDO DESDE LA DISTÁNCIA, que sirvió a Deborah como título de su libro sobre la biografía de Ian (TOUCHING FROM A DISTANCE)"
¿No es increíble?!! xDD
Ya no escribo más, que se agotan los carácteres xDD
greywasarrest 2 years ago
Gracias Grey...!
franRW 2 years ago
Do you know the funny part of this song?
Look at the background.
They are using Marshall Speaker Cabinets (model 1960A and 1960B).
The speaker cabinets were not introduced until several years after Ian's death. LOL
ashassk 2 years ago
Anorakinell . Geeeeeeeek
fred2892 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
In my opinion 24 hours party people is beter than Control
escons 2 years ago
tht is not leonardo di caprio ffs
joshisnotposh008 2 years ago 2
i love dis!
hosehoundlova 2 years ago
Leonardo di Caprio is Ian curtis hahahahahahahahahahahahaahahahahahahahahaha.
escons 2 years ago
Leonardo di Caprio? Are you serious? That's Sam Riley.
robbiedelon 2 years ago
it was only a joke, but the semblance with Leonardo di Caprio it's obvious.
escons 2 years ago
IAN CURTIS RIP
TayNStu 2 years ago
dead on, just like ian
hayley554 2 years ago
exelente personificación, un gran tributo a la banda.
ParkeAbandono 2 years ago
One of the best performances I have ever seen..EVER! And I've seen and rated over 3000 movies. What an amazing actor.
CatStevensDieHardFan 2 years ago
I'm more impressed that they were able to find a drummer who looked like Stephen Morris who could play the drums to this.
hightimesbruce 2 years ago 2
Le salio igualito!
confusion84 2 years ago
Raw and Brilliant!!!
weenmatt 2 years ago
Fantastic!
franzicodelica 2 years ago
uooh the performance of Sam is so incredible!
Beatlesalwayss 2 years ago
The sound quality of this video is far better than the other Joy Division videos.
hippychick105 2 years ago 3
that is because its from the movie which is a year or so old
chrisr56 2 years ago
because their not the real joy division. This is from the movie control
flipmatsk8 2 years ago
hahah dickhead..
jiminycricket1 2 years ago
this is a moviee not a music video
hippiepank 2 years ago
man he is hot, I couldn't take my eyes off him for the whole film...amen thanks for this performance Sam Riley
coquitaloca 2 years ago 2
For all those people who think that his dancing style could be an epilectic fit.. fuck off! When you are on a fit you cannot dance!!
amarilloour 2 years ago
"..except for the guitarist who comes from sulford, an important distinction"
hilarious! lol
rorschach1 3 years ago
they actually played shadowplay in real life
zigzagGreen 3 years ago 3
Oh, be fair! It is a very decent reconstruction of the song. It is nothing on the original, but it is a good version.
gombrich4444 3 years ago
oh snap, that was cool
poobustank 3 years ago
Genius, Ian was a unique talent. He moves like Iggy, with great stage presence.
If you have no sense of the history of post punk please don't bother to comment on this performance. You have no idea....
greshamjohn 3 years ago 3
i love him dancing :)
allyscarna123 3 years ago 3
WHAt???
violentinthedark23 3 years ago
Как будто в нем эта музыка, а тело это просто проигрыватель...
Как же его колбасит
( %
egaspud 3 years ago
this sounds like an elevator music version compared to the real joy division.
aubreylear 3 years ago
correct
Jadabh2 3 years ago
amazing!
rlima0511 2 years ago
This is like, way different than the original? How'd they do that?
bradleymuffins 3 years ago
well actually the first song they played on tv was shadowplay
Brennan54 3 years ago 7
the thing with jd's songs is that they are actually noy really hard toplay, but all together instruments with ian curti's voice made each song unique
takkisongs 3 years ago 2
I never knew about this group before I saw this movie. The movie seemed dark and compelling. I am one of the idiots that thought he was dancing... until I realized he was struggling with his fits onstage from giving so much. Don't care for his affairs, but deeply felt his pain... and LOVE this song now.
lauryndoll 3 years ago
actually half the time his dancing was actually dancing and the audience could never tell if it was a fit or not, he called it his "dead fly dance."
halcooper 3 years ago
its not epilepsy, its just his style you noobs.
proulx1q 3 years ago 6
you're a fool, he's not dancing like that because he's epileptic, its just his style. do you think he could just have a seizure conveniently between each chorus? n00000b
proulx1q 3 years ago 10
Ian Curtis' daughter, Natalie, was in the crowd as an extra for the Derby Hall gig, Sam Riley had played Mark E. Smith, lead singer of The Fall, in the film 24 Hour Party People
MrFloydPink 3 years ago
no he didnt mark e smith made a cameo himself. sam riley wasnt in 24 hour party people ive seen movie 100s of times hes not in it
benforsh 3 years ago
rest of cast listed alphabetically: John Lydon ... Himself (archive footage) (as Johnny Rotten) Tim Paley ... Dr. Watson Sam Riley ... Mark E Smith
MrFloydPink 3 years ago
dude he was hence why they say the line about the fall in control
anthonylovesfmw 3 years ago
Lol,was he lying in that interview then?:P.
He was a pretty good Ian Curtis IMO by the way.
Chaossspirit 3 years ago
i love this movie ,this song,..... j.d i love you
titansito4 3 years ago
i fucking love this movie!
mexicanhitmen21 3 years ago 2
dance dance dance dance dance to the radio...!!!
very good performance :D
31415lar 3 years ago 2
it is really like an original performance of them....grat, very good movie...
magnusm7 3 years ago 5
Oh dude. It looks like they're actually playing! In a movie! =O
Tomewmew 3 years ago
they are, they all rehearsed the not too difficult songs :O)
TheGoodDoctor62 3 years ago
It boggles the mind that people actually get songs right in a movie though....:D
Tomewmew 3 years ago
joy division was important as the sex pistols were, nuff said, no need to elaborate
stillwaiting4godot 3 years ago 14
More important I would say, the Sex Pistols sold out...
loveunderlaw 3 years ago
is his fucking acting just genius or am i fucking crazy?
elsoda 3 years ago 5
Joy division!!!!! control fucking great movie!!!! fucking great group!!! one of my favorites... i make a tribut of atmosphere if anyone wants to see it there it is jejejeje
Spaulding84rbn 3 years ago 3
If I've got this right.. This part of control is trying to potray jd's first TV appearance right? So shouldn't they actually perform Shadowplay here? (as the clip of the real TV performance shows?) Confused!?
adsman82 3 years ago
The Best bit is Tony Wilson talking at the start
topclass123 3 years ago
Sam Riley really did a great job with this movie :Do
Chaseyboeyy 3 years ago
It may be me, but did anyone else notice in the movie how prominent Ian's wedding ring seemed to be??
kurtj98 3 years ago
lol...deborah´s influence on the movie lol right...but funny is...or curious that while the movie continues and ian is getting closer to death...the light at his face star to disapear and they mark more the shadows...just like making the people feel that ian is reaching the shadows...
tinosteiner 3 years ago
Tony Wilson , Rob Gretton and Joy Division a Marrige made in Heaven
topclass123 3 years ago
the real version is joy division performing shadowplay
hideroad 4 years ago
Corbijn's style and Joy Division's music seem to have been made for each other.
SaintRussell1914 4 years ago 5
...there is the mundane/ordinary and there is the extrordinary, then, there is this clip, which is......extra-extrordinary! This has greatness stamped all over it...
eboracumawake 4 years ago
Fabulous film and clip.
Squab1972 4 years ago
Do they have the real recorded version of this? Or is this specific performance created for the film?
I'd like to see the orig.
JohnnySwitchblade 4 years ago
I think this is the original:
watch?v=6ZwMs2fLoVE
two videos look similar and the band is wearing the same clothes.
Ronk15 4 years ago
this is the best film i've ever seen. the best band and one of their best songs.
HoldenCaultfield 4 years ago 2
fantastic clip, from a awesome movie
boomjch 4 years ago
thx for putting this here!
uea978 4 years ago