Added: 2 years ago
From: CBSNewsOnline
Views: 25,571
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (131)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Why does determining if someone has a Y chromosome involve psychiatric evaluation?

  • She needs to shave her pits.

  • if that happened to me i'd really beat the shit out of whoever said that

  • ya heard her speaking before the race saw everything about her, y wasnt her sex questioned right there and then? as athletes you have have a right to question your fellow competitors but those who claim to have ate her dust didnt think she was a he till they lost to her! with most of female athlete they look more male either way. this time the competition was tough and the best way was to torture the poor woman by questionin her gender. Get it "SHE IS A SHE"! and as Noodles86 said wud smack em!

  • U C HOW SHE WALK'D ALL DEY AZ..... DIN HIT EM WIT DA JOHN CENA U CAN'T C ME HAND!!!!! LOL..... SHE GOT AHH GOLD..... DO YA THANG GAL

  • @tgreeneA1 absolutely no fucking idea what you just said

  • Im a dude and if someone asked me if I was a girl or a boy I would of whipped my dick out and been like what you think!?!

  • ads r gay

  • She is intersexed/hermaphrodite. It doesn't have to do with anything psychological, its all biological. What would have happened if she didnt win the race? Would they have tested her then? I don't think people test losers. Let her classify herself as woman and I'm glad they let her race.

  • When you start winning major championships and all the financial rewards that come with it THEN YOUR BODY COMPOSITION SURELY DOES MATTER.

    If she is now a woman after having a male sex change operation then athletically speaking she is still a man in a SO CALLED WOMANS BODY

    Her voice and physical appearence indicates she used to be a man but i am suprised the International athletics association have allowed her to compete when her true sexuality is in question.

  • thats a fucking man fo sho. did you hear him talk nothin like a chick

  • @tukamapuda, Sorry to shatter your beliefs. Believe that in real life and not your little bubble of a fantasy world, people (females can have deep voices), although it is not common. Fo Sho life is very complex, perhaps you overlooked that in primary, secondary,  or did you even attend school. Don't worry it is not your fault, people like you are a testament that the U.S. education system has failed.

  • @paconot wow someone got offended. Im sorry if your a chick with a beard and talk with a man. im sorry i didnt know.

  • @tukamapuda *like a man

  • she's a real women as well , who cares about her feelings? people like to make a debatable comment in order to make a statement, and news readers and journalist like to think they got a story, thats what sells, well its been proven she's a women, a strong women or a manly women like most people would say but she's a women.

  • @izzymohh

    No woman not even Maria Matola has won a world final with such a huge distance advantage.

    Womens athletics is far closer time wise than in mens races.

    I believe Semenya is a man who has undergone a sex change resulting in huge dsparity in HER OR HIS ability over a womens only field

  • @llandudnoboy Well, thank God we do have to hinge our reasoning with your "belief." Get your facts straight if you intend on being credible or you can just temper your comments as "uneducated" opinion with no reference to resources that are based on FACTS!

  • Comment removed

  • Thats a man no doubt!

  • i wouldnt really give a damn unless i was one of the women eating "her" dust on the track....... it is kinda messed up for the real women who trained so hard for the race....

  • @dcarterfrom07 physically shes a woman, but she has so much testosterone that its debatable whether or not she can be considered a woman.

  • @dcarterfrom07

    Well said.

    Any athlete whose gender is called into question should not be competing at world level.

    There are two kinds of races Mens and Womens

    Usain Bolt cannot decide to have a sex change op to go after all the womens world records aswell.

  • @dcarterfrom07 men train as well, what's so different besides gender

  • @dcarterfrom07 Real women? What exactly is a "real woman"? Caster is only 18 years old, she was raised to be female, she lives female. SHE IS A WOMAN. It is her gender, or what she identifies with. She is a real woman and she has worked extremely hard to be where she is today, she's just a little different.

  • Yup she didnt even look the reporter in the face...read the body language. for 18 years you have not questioned urself....go run with the guys....run with the lighting Bolt or TY Gay..

  • wtf shes a gurl .. shes in shape she dnt dress like a gurl but that doesin mean anything .. i wish ppl will get a life and stay out hers

  • Man, fuck the media. She says she a chic, back the fuck off

  • dint they come to the conclusion that she wasnt a woman?

  • Who gives a fuck off? she obviously says she ain't a woman for some reason...just cos she a celeb don't mean she can't have a private life....all she wants is for those ppl all up in her business to back the fuck off

  • if she is not a women she is unfairly competing

  • I don't give a shit

  • she is also cheating... so she should be able to cheat?

  • He is a man who produces sperm (testesterone) thats why he looks like that.. he was probably raised as a girl because thats what his parents choosed but obviously he was raised in the wrong gender. that looks more manly than most gay men i ever known!! i mean he looks like a straight black man! and imsure he knew about his condition not developing breast, sounding like a man! not having periods!! looking so masculine his testicles are working hard! and doing a good job !

  • I don't need no stinkin tests to tell me he's a man, give him the boot up his cheating ass.

  • "She" has a genetic disorder. It's true that she was born this way. She has extra X and Y chromosomes or something like that so her body is a mash up of both sexes. Google Hermaphrodite if you want a better explanation.

  • i feel bad for her..this whole situation is bullshit. She was raised as a girl and has breast and vagina. Just because she doesn't have ovaries or her period doesnt mean she is any less of a woman. There are plenty of older flat chest woman or ones who cant dont have ovaries. God made her the way she is for a reason and to humiliate her on national tv for it is disgusting! She can get stoned to death in S.A. for some shit like that. They should be ashamed for the drama they have put her through

  • So if i was raised as a frog and I have webbed toes that makes me a frog? Your logic is rubbish.

  • Let us just think about this for a second. Caster has no uterus nor ovaries. Obviously resulting in the fact Caster could never have menstruated.

    If any woman ever made it to adulthood without menstruating they would have gone to the doctor to find out why.

    I very much doubt that she had no idea that anything was up. I fail to understand how anyone can think this was a total surprise to her.

    Just another example of how the media cares more about PCism than rationally looking at an issue.

  • She doesn't have uterus and ovaries. she didn't have periods, I believe she knew already that something was wrong with her

  • This is essentially about discrimination, and it's disgusting. If she looked more girly, whatever the fuck that means, they wouldn't have questioned it at all. What this story exposes, is that people are persecuted for being unconventional. Our fascist, nazi world remains the same. It's sexist too, because it implies that the way a woman looks, determines her strength. This criminal testing makes me wanna puke!

  • But we were right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!What the hell is with people thinking I'm racist because I think thats a man! Black girls are sooooooooooo sexy. Ok fine thats a girl.......I wonder if her boyfriend is a homosexual.

  • I AGREE @ FoziaAbdi.........some of these fools act like she had a gender test before, when she knows she's a woman. Or it is a new trend going on??? people just wakeup and get gender tests....she probably didn't know she had this condition or whatever, so how's this unfair?

  • I think semenya she is more pretty then english girl who had get the bronz medal :)

  • She looked so offended. I think if I were in her situation I would've smacked whomever dared question my sex.

  • EXACTLY! My question is why didn't they do the tests PRIOR to the games since her time improved so drastically. I believe that they were willing to allow it to slide until she beat all of the others so badly. She dusted them off!

  • Maybe she should have slapped them with that long dong swinging between her legs....

  • @n0odles86

    So would i be when i had trained incredibly hard for the last five years and then a man who claims he is a woman enters the most important race in your career and wins by such a huge margin.

    The reason there are separate gender only races at World level is that men are physically more powerfull and therefore faster than women.

  • What the hell was that? I'm not going to say anything because I don't know what to believe. And what's up with all these damn commercials anyway?

  • in the immortal words of Autin Powers, "She's a man, baby!"

  • Comment removed

  • Me tooo, Iam tired of these fucking western ideologies and their fucked up fucking minds!!!

  • tests to determine whether she has what's been called 'a medical condition'

    yea, a dick

  • Its a man did u see the hair under the arm pit watch at 0:49

  • you have some learning to do

    ask yourself what defines being a "man"?

    and what defines being a "woman"?

    and ask yourself what type of person can be intersexed?

    you see there are more than two sexes but its going to take a while for "men" more than "women" to take that into the brain and accept it!

    gender is a social construct

  • Comment removed

  • Even yo galfrend has hair under her fucked up armpits ...

  • SHIT that voice just does it... She's a man, man!

  • wrong...or maybe right but no "man" ...many "women" have husky voices!

  • You r so stupid, some men have weak voices to such extent that they could sound like women, does that turn them in2 women? Fuck u and ur fucked up mind.

  • good answer: i don't give a damn about it

    ;)

  • excellent answer

    and most people should accept people for being individuals and it shouldnt matter what is between the legs and we actually need to stop focusing on gender

    i am xxy chromosomes by the way

    intersexed

    and i believe most humans are a mix of two or 3 genders

  • Is that Usain Bolt on the tv

    Jamaica to the world

  • Ok, why is this such a big problem NOW! Why is it that before she ran the race... nothing was said... and she won! What's the problem now, when no one said anything before! I'm sure she's a women... And yesterday they said she has the testosterone the levels of man which was like 3!

  • Just ask shim's boyfriend if his butt hurts.....

  • LMAO!

  • I love YOU CASTER!<3

  • Its a Hermafrodite.

  • I seen lots of Maury shows, it's a man... Look at the reaction, BURRRRNED!

  • She *IS* the father of my baby!

  • LOL!!!!

  • she doesnt shave under her arms thats a small sign she proli is half an half

  • You people are so dumb... Alot of women in Africa don't shave their armpits, legs and arms. You aren't african, so how would you know that? She's a fam; she's a lesbian. full blown lesbian. She doesn't care about manicures and lipsticks like western women do and she doesn't fit to the western female stereotype. She was tested twice already in 2006 and passed. Now she won, they wanna whine and find an excuses.

  • I'm sure they'll find she's a woman, but with the testosterone level of a man. Not that uncommon. That means she'll be disqualified and unable to compete with woman. She didn't do anything wrong, just a fluke. I feel bad for her.

  • yeah, shes a woman alright... IN YOUR BRA!!!

  • W...T...F

  • Comment removed

  • I think everyone should be tested to be fair. The must be able to do a simple chromosone test before an event.

    In any case I do think Caster has a chromosomal disorder which means she is biologically male but has female genitalia. The people in her village probably just saw a vagina when she was born and assumed she was a girl and brought her up that way.

  • She has an adam's apple.

  • It's not fair to the women in the race. This person is obviously a man.

  • Well folks, if you want to see what black lesbian look like, there you go.

  • Men are atheltically superior...

    Never has a woman changed sex to "manhood" and been a significant force... So why are watering down our Military Forces... will the Fasco-FemNazi eventually get their "GI JANE"... (only if she is a "he")

  • Where has this person been that it is just now a big concern? If it is found that she is a she they should help her look more like a female if she desires such help!

  • this whole thing is so hurtful for a young girl. If I was nearby I would spit in the interviewer's face for asking her that question.

  • Ok seriously, i know that she may look like a man but why would she go thru all of the surgery pain just to be humiliated of looking like a male???

  • Just let Perez Hilton be the judge - HAHA.

  • deep voice, hairy armpits, man face, muscles as big as a man, just look at the competition around him, i mean her, none of them are that big, his upper body is bigger than Bolt's, if he she isn't a man, then he she has been taking steroids or testosterone

  • i feel so sorry for her, it's not her fault she's not conventional looking.

  • 0:46 - Hairy female armpits = disgusting... seriously. I bet thats a man though

  • Is it possible Semenya was Caster-ated?

  • groannnnnn

  • wow.

    he...she....look-a-like-a-man.­

  • DO we have camel toe?

  • I guess she isn't going to be prom Queen.

  • this is a disgrace. fuck you faggots

  • definite man!!! no doubt!!!!

  • hahaha she must feel ugly.

  • Nice "You can't see me" @ 0:40 . Damn, this ain't gonna help her gettin' a man. Da fuck's a gender test?... Pulling your pants down?

  • It looks and sounds like some kind of Man-Beast. Half man Half beast. Has any one checked to see of it has balls ?

  • Check out the voice...my vote is male.

  • She acts like a man and even talks like one

    I do think it`s a chick though cos i know some african chicks who grew up working hard and they end up not lady like

  • SHE LOOKS LIKE THE RAPPER MEEK MILLZ.

  • wtf? lmao!

  • that's a man lol

  • People like you aren't even worth the time of day. LOL. Because you haven't done shit with your life, you want to down somebody else? and with racial slurs? Your obviously a lame and jealous of her.

    Dont get mad, get a life.

  • damn, her voice is alittle deep, but hell, I talk for a living and I heard broads with deeper voices than that.

    And what the hell do they mean, "runlike a man?" So because she's fast, she runs like a man? I fucking hate the media b/c they have no ethics at all.

  • yes it´s a little hyped up by the media, but not made up by it, gender tests are actualy something quite normal in sports

    There have even been some cases where someone was in the wrong gender, in the old times sometimes as cheating by just putting a man in womans clothes e.g. in shotput, but later also accidently because of weird circumstances

    Here this girl is new in worldwide sports, and she has a muscular structure which doesn´t look feminine, which is really rare, so tests are just normal

  • All I am saying is, they are disrespecting her & they dont know the outcome yet. Media is so negative & it makes me sick. If it's a man, then take the championship & keep it moving, if not, then keep it moving anyway, but why be negative towards her when it's possible she's a woman? Hell Ann coulter has an adams apple and... welll they do call her a man, but the point is, all the disrespect for this woman w/ no proof is absurd. Looks can be decieving. why dont they do these test b4 the race?

  • Man if you dont think she looks/sounds/performs like a man then you need to get your eyes checked

  • looks can be decieving.

  • its not just the looks its the voice too im not saying that i think 100% its a man i just dont think she or her family should be shocked that this happend all im going to say though im not picking up any girl from south africa

  • They should do these test BEFORE the race. I bet they test them for everything else.

    This isnt the first time a question like this has come up. They really need to smarten up.

  • if you bob marley think there are only two sexes...maybe its time to look inside a medical book......and recognise intersexed people and transsexual people and look at some "women" who are generally obese which can have moustaches and husky voices......a people check is what you need

    i call "normal" people abnormal because people who are aware of more than two sexes/genders have their eyes open

  • Well i dont think there are only two sexes i know there are people with both. But this is not the case here, this person has one of two things A. Has a penis or B. Has a vagina. I need a people check what the hell does that mean should i be able to accept this person as a women when she cleary looks like a man is that what your crazy ass is trying to say. I think you are both thats why your sticking up for this he-she.

  • you want to do a god damn gender test? just get a drop of blood and do a karotype. How fucking hard is that CBS? You could mention you can get the results in hours, and it's pretty damn obvious if shes XX or XY

  • my vote is female.

    Most runtly average joes would call almost all female trackstars manly. Her musculature looks feminine - according to world class female athlete standards. Her hips are quite narrow though, which would help her run better and may just be a quirk like her broad shoulders... and um.. deep voice.

  • hahahaha

  • Sorry, but I think that's a man right there. Deep voice and built like a lightweight boxer...There's no other explanation.

  • so disrespectful.

  • Maybe, but what if it is a man? They should just let this person cheat their way through? I mean if it really is a girl they should have no problems with the testing, he/she shouldnt be mouthing off. This is serious stuff, not some kiddy games. Of course they will want to verify it. It is a little disrespectful but if it does turn out to be a guy I'm sure people wont say that. This should not be as big a deal as people make it out to be.

  • agreed. seriously now if she is a woman everyone is still gonna call her a man. its sad really she is screwed regardless of if she's a man or not.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more