Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (41)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • BRAVO...!! i love sax music... and you have become someone so important, at home or work i keep listening.... i want to say "thank you".

  • @crazypianolady cut him some slack he's putting his heart and soul into this audition

  • Do you tune your sax cos it looks really far on to the neck, and can sound a bit  high. Good improv though.

  • What mouthpiece do you use?

  • That was really good I play tenor to but not that good!!!!

  • hey charlie who is software for your latop or song

  • I play tenor but u r the best I've ever heard!

  • ah yes the tenor saxaphone one of my favorites

  • Okay you're an amazing saxophone player but i don't think that's material that they are looking for. You are AMAZING but i mean some parts weren't in the right key and it sounded a bit too rough and jazzy. But still... you are extremely good at sax and keep up the good work.

  • Really cool

  • if u dont get in the judges have no sense...hope u get in!! :D

  • Dude. Ur mega boss at this. but lets face it. the saxophones were made in the early 1800s to fill out the sound of the cello in symphony orchestra. they are one of the youngest instruments in the world and can rarely be used in orchestral music. You're DEFINITELY first chair material, but I don't see you getting into orchestra unless they need you.... I know its a bummer. I wanted to be in orchestra, at my school, but they wouldnt let me cus i play alto... Its super gay.

  • i like your take on this. sounds awesome to have a nice jazzy feel in this song, gives it another tone. you go to college there (unc charlotte)?

  • sounded to "jazzy" and "hip hoppy" for a classical audition.....this coming from someone who does both...daily

  • @SaxKing52 "too" But thats what makes it good...the fusion of two unlikely genres!

  • It sounded to rough for the music...

  • Okay well the improv fit horribly with the track, usually I would praise your playing but you made your sound too "in your face" growly. But nonetheless a good solo, just didn't fit the music. :)

  • Most of your solo clashed horribly with the track. Either you're in the wrong key, or you're crazy out of tune. And there really wasn't a flow. Just gibberish.

  • @evergreach2346 It sounded good to me ...

  • Cool. I couldn't improvise to that, for sure. Good luck with the judges. I want you to win, too.

  • I think you should have based it more around the main theme of the music =/

  • awesome, good luck!

  • Not the perfect classical music tone.

  • Wow.... I hate you for being able to improvise.... I can't improvise on my flute for the life of me and I've been taking improv lessons for a while now.... =/

  • I got to say that it is Awesome.

  • it was good, but too growly. this isn't jazz or rock & roll, it's classical music. This pretty much summarizes why saxophones aren't in symphony orchestras :/

  • @macintosh315 Yes They Are Sopranos Altos Tenors & Barits Who Told They Weren't !!!!!

  • @macintosh315

    Well, not really. There are classical saxophonists who play with tones suitable for classical ensembles and there are jazz/rock/etc saxophonists who don't. This guy is the latter. Search "classical saxophone" for plenty of examples of the former.

  • A bit too dirty and gnarly for the music but you're still pretty kickass. I might suggest listening to Michael Brecker for inspiration; he had a really flexible tone and I've learned quite a few licks from his many solos. Hope you make it.

  • ..meh...didnt really seem like it fits

  • Comment removed

  • I don't know about this man. I personally feel you could have done a HELL of a lot better. Plus, I've seen you do better. Improvising is your thing as far as I've seen.

  • Comment removed

  • didnt flow very well

  • @karatekween33 its the fucking song. he played it perfect dumbass

  • if you dont make it then obviously there is something wrong with the YouTube Symphony Judges

  • hey man do u remember me we had that issue over the contest well i dont think i won but o well at lest u got to c me play so im happy... anyways i was just askin if u can send me the sheet music for halo-alto sax and my screen name is 51boythatlovesjanie and my email is tylerjanielove@aol.com ---thanx bro :)))))

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more