I am very happy for Melanie. She hasthe talent, the voice, the passion, the strength and the emotion of a true star. The artist in her emerges and will grow.She appears to be also a good hearted, unpretentious, and brave girl.
@Latoshia1971 indeed...people may be cursing her which is something natural for us human beings due to opinion variations BUT Melanie has already won it..you may be saying this and that, it wont change anything!! Good on you Melanie and good luck!
Totally adore Melanie, her voice is angelic and she's such a sweet, godly person.
Josh's response is pretty much teh definition of gracious. I've never really cared much for him but he's definitely an honorable person and inspiring.
@vivyenk I know, I'm just a big Rachel Crow fan, She is always happy,positive,funny,and most of all adorible. Plus even though she lost I learned she is going to be apart of the Walt Disney Company, it says she's getting her own show and will also make guest appearances on other disney shows.
All Melanie is a very over weight Pia Toscano with Pia being more talented..xfactor talent was a real joke any one on idol last year would have won this show easy!!
Simon has the best poker face in the world for acting like these votes actually counted! African-American women NEVER do well after winning American Idol so hopefully she can break that mold!
@1998dolphinlover Nah its not a random person. its trace the lead singer from the stereo hogzz, a group that was in the competition that finished in 11th place. Apparently him and Melanie are dating
@jamesdavidcalvin Your prolly pretty ignorant....She got the votes for one reason....This is a popularity contest not a talent contest.....And if you think otherwise....Your an idiot
@orangeoctober33 you disgusting pig. go wash your mouth out with soap b4 someone DO it for u! WHAT A STUPID THING TO SAY ABOUT SOMEONE. u must be a miserable and hateful person . . .
DO NOT SPAM PLEASE D: please like and comment on my friends video! i'm in a bet and i wanna win 50 bucks! please LIKE AND COMMENT and do not spam. i'm just trying to win a bet :( please ;) and i'll subscribe if you comment! PLUS IT HAS CATS! WHO DOESN'T LIKE CATS :D
I want her album already XD I'm going to keep my eyes glued on her progress. I also picked Melanie and Josh as the final two right from the start. Bring on the new Mariah Carey!
@bebb6 I thought that was the best look from a winner - she was truly stunned. So happy for her and laugh at the people who think that the show was fixed just because their favorite didn't win.
but on the real though i cant believe your chris fans really thought they was gonna let him win lol thats funny he had like the worst vocals out pf the whole bottom 10 and all his performances wasnt that good, they just kept him on for ratings knowing stupid fucks would fall for his story lol.
to be honest marcus was the best performer and i figured one of simon girls would of won, im just glad chris didnt he did not have the vocals or the ability.
@ICONiac4eva08 The only reason they're on this show in the first place is because they can sing. Just because it's performance based, doesn't mean the best performer will win. You need the voice and she was always on key. They were all amazing singers and performers in their own way; But Melanie just had a killer voice and it kept you entertained. They all deserved to be there and I think their finalist were the best, just so happens America loves Melanie more.~
i didn't watch it at all as i work every night its on but i was looking back and i thought both are winners no matter what i know josh will go very far even though he didn't win congrats to both
CHRISTMAS HOPE SANTA BRINGS SOME OF YOU HATERS RACIST A BIG BOX OF COAL BECAUSE THATS WHAT SOME OF YOU DESERVE FOR POSTING SUCH GARBAGE NO NEED FOR GARBAGE.. EVER HEARD THE SAYING IT GOES LIKE THIS TREAT OTHERS THE WAY YOU WANNA BE TREATED DO U WANT SOMEONE TO CALL YOU NAMES N TREAT YOU LIKE CRAP? I DIDNT THINK SO, ALSO IF YOU DONT HAVE ANYTHING ELSE NICE TO SAY TO ME THEN DO0NT SAY NOTHING AT ALL.. SOME OF YOUR BIG MOUTHS SERIOUSLY NEEDS TO BE WASHED WITH CLOROX BECAUSE I CANT NEGATIVITY !!
CONSTANTLY REPEATING YOURSELF BECAUSE IM SO SICK N TIRED OF HEARING IT GIVE THIS SHIT A REST FOR ONCE IN YOUR PATHETIC SAD LIVES AND FOR YOU PEOPLE WHO HAVE JUDGED ME GOD IS THE ONLY JUDGE NOT YOU OR ANYONE ELSE GROW THE CRAP UP... I HAVE A GOD GIVEN RIGHT TO SPEAK WHATS ON MY MIND AND IDC WHAT ANY NEGATIVE PERSON HAS TO SAY BECAUSE IM DONE WITH STUPID PEOPLE BACK OFF MY INBOX I DONT NEED ANYONE TO REMIND ME SHE WON NO SHIT SHERLOCK DUH LMAO....I THINK SOME OF YOU NEED A HEARING AID FOR CHRIST
TO ALL MY HATERS WHO HAVE POSTED NOTHING BUT NEGATIVITY, STUPIDITY AND IMMATURITY ON MY PAGE.. I HAVE ASKED YOU NEGATIVE HEARTLESS HATERS LOSERS RACISTS WHOEVER THE CRAP YALL ARE NOT TO POST GARBAGE IN MY INBOX ANYMORE.. IT SERIOUSLY NEEDS TO STOP AND ALL THIS IMMATURE NAME CALLING JUST BECAUSE I SPOKE THE TRUTH ABOUT MELANIE, BECAUSE I'VE HEARD SO MUCH BETTER SINGERS PERSONALLY THAN HER ANYWAYS GROW UP..AND STOP REPEATING THE SAME BULL CRAP ON MY PAGE N INBOX I KNOW SHE WON NO NEED TO KEEP
josh handled it like a man. he's so freakin talented and humble. it really was a coin toss to see who would win. heads or tails. it's a shame there is no runner-up prize.
@ARBO2k9 Because Chris and Josh both deserved to win more. Better performers. But I bet all of them will end up very successful in music so it really doesn't matter who wins.
@Tude1231 As of singing she was by far the best, then Josh, Chris was boring and took a long ride off of his audition, and played the sympathy card way too much, Melanie is a great vocalist and this is what it's about Vocals, and Melanie winning proved that to everyone, to all the Chris, Astro, and Marcus fans out there.
HAPPY - HAPPY - ECSTATIC for our new "A Star Is Born"... Love her! 1st time I cry out of joy for a singing contest - It REALLY moved me! Want to be present if & when she comes to perform @ our beautiful Brampton Rose Theatre in Ontario. Canada. I'll pay top dollar...
@Cute12Cherry Chris sucks, he can't sing nearly as good as others in the competition, Melanie and Josh in the Final two was the right choice from the "get go"
proof dat dreams do come tru. melanie is an inspiration. Beyonce is a superstar, but melanie made me fall in love with this song (Listen) even more. I think she made it even more of a hit than it was. I love her, and Im happy she won. she totally deserved it. she was a winner even from the start. GO MELANIE......xoxo
OK PEOPLE WE KNOW SHE WON OK SO WHY ,MAKE ALOT OF VIDEOS OF HER COME ON NO ONE CARES I SURE THE HELL DONT NO NEED TO HAVE ALL THESE VIDEOS UP GOD PEOPLE R SO STUPID N CONCEDED I MIGHT ADD AND ANNOYING AND DUMB SO PLEASE DONT RESPOND TO THIS COMMENT IM ASKING NICELY DONT BE A FOOL NO NEED FOR ALL THIS NONE SENSE REALLY COME ON GET REAL NO ONE CARES WHO WON JUST GLAD THIS MESS IS OVER N READY FOR THE NEXT SEASON WISH MY FRIENDS WHO SOUNDS MUCH BETTER THAN SHE DOES WOULD HAVE MADE IT TO THE FINAL
@karenaycock I can feel your deep sadness and 'suffering'. you need to open your heart to receive the joy that only the love of God can bring. God is who he is not because you accept it or not, and surely when it is time you will find out. My prayer for you is that your eyes open to see the truth of who God is and Jesus Christ, while you still have time to do something about it.
@karenaycock "NO ONE CARES I SURE THE HELL DONT" - You sure as hell are a troll. Why else would you be on this video if you 'didn't care'. Drama out of nothing.
shes a lil CUT THROAT BITCH SHE DIDN'T HUG CHRIS OR ANYTHING WHEN HE LEFT... fucking lil whore..Yes she can sing but THAT'S IT! She doesn't have the X factor she's boring, she's ugly and there's really nothing different about what she can do and it's really annoying that someone who's supposed to have the "X" factor is supposed to win but the show turned out like american idol.. Can't stand her!
@daniellevasta87 i fucking agree with you bro, she's so fucking annoying bitch, she says she coud do young hommie better then chris, she's facking fat, uses a lot of make up and isn't beautiful at all, has a fucking fat nose,etc... Nicole is hot but she uhmmm NOT.
@HerzamanEfeci She was joking about singing young homie, and if you think she's fat I pity you. I pity you because you've been brainwashed to think anyone with a full figure is fat. You're probably the type of person who thinks skin and bones are attractive. She's only annoying in your eyes because you're a petty little jealous freak. Get over yourself. While you're on youtube bashing her, she's out living her dreams and achieving more than you ever will. You will go nowhere with your attitude.
@daniellevasta87 Woah!! The only bitch around here is you! You try being infront of a stage in front of millions just finding out you're a millionaire and that you won! The only person lil whore cut throat bitch is you! Now grow some fucking balls!
I think that Melanie is very talented and pretty but I really don't think she should've won.
Simon voted her off once,she should've stayed off the show.
I'm not hating,I've loved Melanie from the beginning but I think Josh would've been a "better" winner only because he went the WHOLE show without being voted off.
Again,I'm not being mean,they'll both have amazing careers in music,I just think Josh should've gotten the 5 million dollar contract.
I was sooooooo glad she sang Listen when she won! This is the song that brought her through! Great job Melanie! your amazing and im so glad you won! :)
@orangeoctober33 You shut up! shes not boring to watch! shes so unique! i bet you cant even sing! Who cares if shes fat? she is amazing! You people are just mad she won:P
@NO34ful lol unique? im not the dude that called here fat, but dude. she is kinda boing to watch and not unique. theres other female singers in the industry just like her. powerful voice but just a statue.
@orangeoctober33 I'm pretty sure you should shut the hell up, she won because she's talented, and besides you yourself is probably fatter than her, don't hate cock eater.
What do Clay Aiken, Adam Lambert and Josh Krajcik all have in common..? They are all have more talent and will ultimately outsell and be better known than what ever the name of the people that 'won' their competitions ever will.
@daisyyyxoxo sorry but melanie is not the american veson of adele she is the next big star we never should compare melanie and other singers she is incredible :)
@jesuusful if you love them so much why don't you shut down your computer and and slam your head on a hard brick wall!
TheSlmfan1 4 days ago
Melanie and Josh both deserved to be in that finale..either or would have been phenomenal ..Melanie did her thing
briny7777 1 week ago
josh and chris sang really well, but the fat winner just yelled some words
jesuusful 1 week ago
nick cannon should be the announcer for the x factor. he brings excitement at agt
The4hybrid 1 week ago
at least smile for one second it looks like you're in pain
JennaKurtz 2 weeks ago
....mavaffanculo va!....doveva vincere Josh....Melanie in confronto e' una merda!
MrMassi86 2 weeks ago
@jamesdavidcalvin MEALanie? hahha
locovanity 3 weeks ago
yay melinie
mslil2cute1 1 month ago
loveyou melanie..!!we loveyou.
kamichdeguzman 1 month ago
I am very happy for Melanie. She hasthe talent, the voice, the passion, the strength and the emotion of a true star. The artist in her emerges and will grow.She appears to be also a good hearted, unpretentious, and brave girl.
Bravo Melanie!
solanjoe 1 month ago
she didnt realize she won until a moment later. She totally deserved it! Love her!
marqy7 1 month ago
yes Melanie won i am super happy i have waited so long thumbs up if you agree
coriolanmike 1 month ago
-.-
T00NFR00B 1 month ago in playlist More videos from XFactor2011TV
CHRIS RENE !
kickbackbra 1 month ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
represent America?? the only thing she is representing is KFC!
ericech 1 month ago
@ericech EPIC FAIL
shreddintheaxe 1 month ago
I'm so glad she won. She had just a beautiful voice...:)
23Nellie1 1 month ago 3
i really didnt expect for her to win, but she seems like a person who wouldn't get a big head
shaunav23 1 month ago
i wanted Josh to win but nicely done Melanie!
MakereNZ 1 month ago
CHRIS SHOULD HAVE WON
rbrb1558 1 month ago
simon was more excited than her
jellytots2008 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
It has been announced that Josh, Chris, and Astro have been signed by Simon Cowell with Sony Music and Syco Records.
LittleDrummerBoy131 2 months ago
Hi Melanie I live in Brazil but I'm a fan girl .. success ..
naty12zinha 2 months ago
Since the day of her audition, was more than obvious that she was going to be the winner of this X factor... SHE deserve it.
ccmp18 2 months ago
God Bless you Melanie, you are a true gift from God!!!
Latoshia1971 2 months ago
@Latoshia1971 indeed...people may be cursing her which is something natural for us human beings due to opinion variations BUT Melanie has already won it..you may be saying this and that, it wont change anything!! Good on you Melanie and good luck!
islesofhapiness 1 month ago
HQ? are you sure? :D
davidchen3009 2 months ago
simons reaction is like a lil child haha so cute
SlimShaney08 2 months ago
i was so pissed, she was not even close to better then josh. shes fucking garbage compared to most people on the show
Cocaineawareness 2 months ago
@Cocaineawareness she is amazing
SlimShaney08 2 months ago
@Cocaineawareness Stfu ur a straight up HATER !
roseniggas 2 months ago
@roseniggas she only one because of the black people, like you
Cocaineawareness 2 months ago
@Cocaineawareness what a retard, you cant even spell won, racist too, you are a real winner.
zyshalol 2 months ago
@Cocaineawareness disgusting comment...she is amazing...
sarazoarleyva 2 months ago
@Cocaineawareness Yea she is garbage!!! i guess thats why she won..because you know people who cant sing win on singing shows
cellur111 4 weeks ago
Totally adore Melanie, her voice is angelic and she's such a sweet, godly person.
Josh's response is pretty much teh definition of gracious. I've never really cared much for him but he's definitely an honorable person and inspiring.
notcon4md 2 months ago 2
i called her winning this the second i seen her first performance :)
LXRGASCHAMBER 2 months ago 2
America got it right on this show, can't say the same about Idol.
eagle19612002 2 months ago
I am glad Melanie won but I just have one complaint, Rachel Crow was suppose to win.
TheMagnificentTrio 2 months ago
@TheMagnificentTrio If she was supposed to win,she wouldnt have been voted off.So please stop complaining...
vivyenk 2 months ago
@vivyenk I know, I'm just a big Rachel Crow fan, She is always happy,positive,funny,and most of all adorible. Plus even though she lost I learned she is going to be apart of the Walt Disney Company, it says she's getting her own show and will also make guest appearances on other disney shows.
TheMagnificentTrio 2 months ago
All Melanie is a very over weight Pia Toscano with Pia being more talented..xfactor talent was a real joke any one on idol last year would have won this show easy!!
spiritssearcher 2 months ago
@spiritssearcher Why don't you get lost you shallow asshole
musiclova2471 2 months ago
melanie is pretty
toyseller95 2 months ago
she desereves the title
toyseller95 2 months ago
that's gay.
lilwalker69 2 months ago in playlist More videos from XFactor2011TV
she was like, "wait did he say my name because i won, or because i got second place?" but then she got it
SillyLilly000 2 months ago
i think simon was happier than melanie
SillyLilly000 2 months ago
melanie's voice ismazing she's the only one who deserved to one yay mealnie good job
lolgirl721 2 months ago
lmfao! she was like 'wait he said my name right?' lol. so happy she won! :D
cmb121710 2 months ago
Ugh I can't stand Melanie - not marketable at all. CHRIS CHRIS CHRIS
princessanna57 2 months ago
melanie so deserved it. josh deserved it too.
GuruBubble 2 months ago
fuck that bitch, she is ugly.
osusauckes 2 months ago
@osusauckes her voice sounds like any other RnB artist.. we need someone like Chris Rene not this overrated bitch..
dkL33T 2 months ago
@osusauckes u suck!!!!!!!!!!!
SillyLilly000 2 months ago
@osusauckes ugliness doesn't matter, and BTW, shes beautiful
SillyLilly000 2 months ago
CHRIS RENE! CHRIS RENE!
44crosscrease44 2 months ago
@44crosscrease44 nah actually MELANIE AMARO MELANIE AMARO
cjuddy1000 2 months ago 2
@44crosscrease44 no!
SillyLilly000 2 months ago
Simon has the best poker face in the world for acting like these votes actually counted! African-American women NEVER do well after winning American Idol so hopefully she can break that mold!
TheJman6360 2 months ago
@TheJman6360 you know I tried for nearly two hours to vote for Melanie, and out of over 700 calls I doubt I got through I tenth of the time
NeoAguni 2 months ago
that awkward moment when the guy in white just came and hugged them randomly 1:52
1998dolphinlover 2 months ago 21
@1998dolphinlover i think thats her family lol
jojocupp7 2 months ago
@1998dolphinlover Nah its not a random person. its trace the lead singer from the stereo hogzz, a group that was in the competition that finished in 11th place. Apparently him and Melanie are dating
Sambaboy9230 2 months ago
@1998dolphinlover i think he's a family member of Melanie.
022henry 1 month ago
lol simon
xxpinoyxx9 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I cant believe this fat ass cunt won...Shes a good singer but so boring to watch...
orangeoctober33 2 months ago
@orangeoctober33 please watch ur mouth. if mealinie was boring, no one would have vote 4 her.
jamesdavidcalvin 2 months ago 23
@jamesdavidcalvin Your prolly pretty ignorant....She got the votes for one reason....This is a popularity contest not a talent contest.....And if you think otherwise....Your an idiot
OzzyGod66 3 weeks ago
@orangeoctober33 wats wrong with you
xxpinoyxx9 2 months ago
@orangeoctober33 you disgusting pig. go wash your mouth out with soap b4 someone DO it for u! WHAT A STUPID THING TO SAY ABOUT SOMEONE. u must be a miserable and hateful person . . .
bebb6 2 months ago
Pricless.
gilmoregirl3rd 2 months ago
The best Wins...!
Wawan923 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
DO NOT SPAM PLEASE D: please like and comment on my friends video! i'm in a bet and i wanna win 50 bucks! please LIKE AND COMMENT and do not spam. i'm just trying to win a bet :( please ;) and i'll subscribe if you comment! PLUS IT HAS CATS! WHO DOESN'T LIKE CATS :D
/watch?v=pHp49axm_KU
sophieaiden00 2 months ago
loooool simon's reaction hahahahah was priceless
Tiina509 2 months ago
I want her album already XD I'm going to keep my eyes glued on her progress. I also picked Melanie and Josh as the final two right from the start. Bring on the new Mariah Carey!
Triqaeon 2 months ago
I have a feeling that she was pre selected by Simon & this was just a drama.
chopkonful 2 months ago 3
@chopkonful NO STUPID~ any one could see she was in shock!! this was a BIG moment for a this lady.
bebb6 2 months ago
@bebb6 I thought that was the best look from a winner - she was truly stunned. So happy for her and laugh at the people who think that the show was fixed just because their favorite didn't win.
ba4774 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
but on the real though i cant believe your chris fans really thought they was gonna let him win lol thats funny he had like the worst vocals out pf the whole bottom 10 and all his performances wasnt that good, they just kept him on for ratings knowing stupid fucks would fall for his story lol.
NickSoTalented777 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
to be honest marcus was the best performer and i figured one of simon girls would of won, im just glad chris didnt he did not have the vocals or the ability.
NickSoTalented777 2 months ago
I love you Melanie, you deserve it.
Atta687 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
oohhhaaiii thuurr music lover? zeppelin floyd hendrix? combined into one?
what kind of idea does my music bring forth? JUST THAT...see for yourself!
AbsoluteZeroMusic 2 months ago
I think Chris is the only one that has the xfactor.. Melanie and Josh have good voices but this isnt a singing competition....
ICONiac4eva08 2 months ago
@ICONiac4eva08 The only reason they're on this show in the first place is because they can sing. Just because it's performance based, doesn't mean the best performer will win. You need the voice and she was always on key. They were all amazing singers and performers in their own way; But Melanie just had a killer voice and it kept you entertained. They all deserved to be there and I think their finalist were the best, just so happens America loves Melanie more.~
ExtrasensoryRadiance 2 months ago
@ExtrasensoryRadiance and due to the fact that Chris's voting was screwed up.. yeah
ICONiac4eva08 2 months ago
i still love ur both . <3 .
ainLOVEyoseob123 2 months ago
Yayy ! i Love U Melanie <3
ainLOVEyoseob123 2 months ago 2
THANK GOD MELANIE WON, SOME REAL TALENT IN THIS WORLD. JOSH WAS GOOD BUT DIDNT HAVE THE X FACTOR LIKE MELANIE!
mslexii001 2 months ago
i didn't watch it at all as i work every night its on but i was looking back and i thought both are winners no matter what i know josh will go very far even though he didn't win congrats to both
mzfatd 2 months ago
She has the better voice but the josh guy has the x factor.
B1ackNinja04 2 months ago
Im sorry but no wonder Simon Cowell is going back to the UK, the UK version is easily the best.
kettlesarenice 2 months ago
YAY!!!! she won :) heck yessss she deserved to win... good thing simon went back for her ik the beginning
honeygirl2312 2 months ago 2
Josh krajcik should have won! melanie is same ole same, dull blah blah
PauletteB33 2 months ago
Good for you, Melanie! & Josh, I still love you. You're both winners to me! <333
missythesapungslayer 2 months ago
SIMON LIKES THEM HOOCHY MAMAS YOUNG LMAO I FIND IT FUNNY
karenaycock 2 months ago
CHRISTMAS HOPE SANTA BRINGS SOME OF YOU HATERS RACIST A BIG BOX OF COAL BECAUSE THATS WHAT SOME OF YOU DESERVE FOR POSTING SUCH GARBAGE NO NEED FOR GARBAGE.. EVER HEARD THE SAYING IT GOES LIKE THIS TREAT OTHERS THE WAY YOU WANNA BE TREATED DO U WANT SOMEONE TO CALL YOU NAMES N TREAT YOU LIKE CRAP? I DIDNT THINK SO, ALSO IF YOU DONT HAVE ANYTHING ELSE NICE TO SAY TO ME THEN DO0NT SAY NOTHING AT ALL.. SOME OF YOUR BIG MOUTHS SERIOUSLY NEEDS TO BE WASHED WITH CLOROX BECAUSE I CANT NEGATIVITY !!
karenaycock 2 months ago
CONSTANTLY REPEATING YOURSELF BECAUSE IM SO SICK N TIRED OF HEARING IT GIVE THIS SHIT A REST FOR ONCE IN YOUR PATHETIC SAD LIVES AND FOR YOU PEOPLE WHO HAVE JUDGED ME GOD IS THE ONLY JUDGE NOT YOU OR ANYONE ELSE GROW THE CRAP UP... I HAVE A GOD GIVEN RIGHT TO SPEAK WHATS ON MY MIND AND IDC WHAT ANY NEGATIVE PERSON HAS TO SAY BECAUSE IM DONE WITH STUPID PEOPLE BACK OFF MY INBOX I DONT NEED ANYONE TO REMIND ME SHE WON NO SHIT SHERLOCK DUH LMAO....I THINK SOME OF YOU NEED A HEARING AID FOR CHRIST
karenaycock 2 months ago
TO ALL MY HATERS WHO HAVE POSTED NOTHING BUT NEGATIVITY, STUPIDITY AND IMMATURITY ON MY PAGE.. I HAVE ASKED YOU NEGATIVE HEARTLESS HATERS LOSERS RACISTS WHOEVER THE CRAP YALL ARE NOT TO POST GARBAGE IN MY INBOX ANYMORE.. IT SERIOUSLY NEEDS TO STOP AND ALL THIS IMMATURE NAME CALLING JUST BECAUSE I SPOKE THE TRUTH ABOUT MELANIE, BECAUSE I'VE HEARD SO MUCH BETTER SINGERS PERSONALLY THAN HER ANYWAYS GROW UP..AND STOP REPEATING THE SAME BULL CRAP ON MY PAGE N INBOX I KNOW SHE WON NO NEED TO KEEP
karenaycock 2 months ago
This was a crappy first season, to be honest. And who didn't know she would win from the start? I have a feeling this show is just gonna tank.
cooolness3 2 months ago
She's good, but she's not Josh Krajcik good.
drunknnmunkyy 2 months ago
@drunknnmunkyy or chris rene good
MrLeakee 1 month ago
By the way, HQ my ass. lol
ProvocativeWoman 2 months ago
Aw she is so cute. I loved her reaction!
ProvocativeWoman 2 months ago
josh handled it like a man. he's so freakin talented and humble. it really was a coin toss to see who would win. heads or tails. it's a shame there is no runner-up prize.
brymaster18 2 months ago
@brymaster18 I think this was the one show that I couldn't decide who will win. I would of been happy if Josh wont too :P
ExtrasensoryRadiance 2 months ago
The loser here was Steve Jones..seriously..back off and let Melanie have her moment!
mariahfan444 2 months ago
she shouldn't have won.
Tude1231 2 months ago
@Tude1231 why?
ARBO2k9 2 months ago
@ARBO2k9 Because Chris and Josh both deserved to win more. Better performers. But I bet all of them will end up very successful in music so it really doesn't matter who wins.
Tude1231 2 months ago 2
@Tude1231 As of singing she was by far the best, then Josh, Chris was boring and took a long ride off of his audition, and played the sympathy card way too much, Melanie is a great vocalist and this is what it's about Vocals, and Melanie winning proved that to everyone, to all the Chris, Astro, and Marcus fans out there.
ARBO2k9 2 months ago
HAPPY - HAPPY - ECSTATIC for our new "A Star Is Born"... Love her! 1st time I cry out of joy for a singing contest - It REALLY moved me! Want to be present if & when she comes to perform @ our beautiful Brampton Rose Theatre in Ontario. Canada. I'll pay top dollar...
66littlebutterfly 2 months ago
CHRIS RENE should have won :D xx
Cute12Cherry 2 months ago
@Cute12Cherry Chris sucks, he can't sing nearly as good as others in the competition, Melanie and Josh in the Final two was the right choice from the "get go"
ARBO2k9 2 months ago
simon jumped when he heard melanies name he was happier than her lol :D
MrTitan311 2 months ago 31
@MrTitan311 he probably gets half of her $5m
abc40968 2 months ago
Nicole can i take you home atleast for tonight/.?
Patricklous23 2 months ago
aw what a shame
suberkin 2 months ago
I'm kind of glad Melanie didn't talk to the host, let her have her moment! She was overwhelmed! He was being too pushy...
trilingual28 2 months ago
both winners, I like you both :)
MrDinoslav88 2 months ago
she's okay......
anon00093 2 months ago
So glad she won... She is amazing and will be a great role model for all.......
calamityfairydust123 2 months ago
lov her!!!!!
littlemisssoccer14 2 months ago
If she wasnt good, do u really think America wouldve kept her around
AwesomeLifeTV 2 months ago
This reminds me of Kelly Clarkson and Jason Guarini
AwesomeLifeTV 2 months ago
proof dat dreams do come tru. melanie is an inspiration. Beyonce is a superstar, but melanie made me fall in love with this song (Listen) even more. I think she made it even more of a hit than it was. I love her, and Im happy she won. she totally deserved it. she was a winner even from the start. GO MELANIE......xoxo
kalowtie1 2 months ago
OK PEOPLE WE KNOW SHE WON OK SO WHY ,MAKE ALOT OF VIDEOS OF HER COME ON NO ONE CARES I SURE THE HELL DONT NO NEED TO HAVE ALL THESE VIDEOS UP GOD PEOPLE R SO STUPID N CONCEDED I MIGHT ADD AND ANNOYING AND DUMB SO PLEASE DONT RESPOND TO THIS COMMENT IM ASKING NICELY DONT BE A FOOL NO NEED FOR ALL THIS NONE SENSE REALLY COME ON GET REAL NO ONE CARES WHO WON JUST GLAD THIS MESS IS OVER N READY FOR THE NEXT SEASON WISH MY FRIENDS WHO SOUNDS MUCH BETTER THAN SHE DOES WOULD HAVE MADE IT TO THE FINAL
karenaycock 2 months ago
@karenaycock I can feel your deep sadness and 'suffering'. you need to open your heart to receive the joy that only the love of God can bring. God is who he is not because you accept it or not, and surely when it is time you will find out. My prayer for you is that your eyes open to see the truth of who God is and Jesus Christ, while you still have time to do something about it.
Nollywoodboxofficetv 2 months ago
@karenaycock "NO ONE CARES I SURE THE HELL DONT" - You sure as hell are a troll. Why else would you be on this video if you 'didn't care'. Drama out of nothing.
emy0ox 2 months ago
Best part about her winning? Is knowing Josh didn't throw a fit and even said that Melanie deserved it :)
jayden2595 2 months ago
The host SUCKS...Worst host on t.v. No wonder the ratings can't top Idol... Definitely looking forward to American idol.
youTubeboy 2 months ago
shes a lil CUT THROAT BITCH SHE DIDN'T HUG CHRIS OR ANYTHING WHEN HE LEFT... fucking lil whore..Yes she can sing but THAT'S IT! She doesn't have the X factor she's boring, she's ugly and there's really nothing different about what she can do and it's really annoying that someone who's supposed to have the "X" factor is supposed to win but the show turned out like american idol.. Can't stand her!
daniellevasta87 2 months ago
@daniellevasta87 change the channel next time
shreddintheaxe 2 months ago
@daniellevasta87 i fucking agree with you bro, she's so fucking annoying bitch, she says she coud do young hommie better then chris, she's facking fat, uses a lot of make up and isn't beautiful at all, has a fucking fat nose,etc... Nicole is hot but she uhmmm NOT.
I'm glad that ther is someone thinking like me :d
HerzamanEfeci 2 months ago
@HerzamanEfeci She was joking about singing young homie, and if you think she's fat I pity you. I pity you because you've been brainwashed to think anyone with a full figure is fat. You're probably the type of person who thinks skin and bones are attractive. She's only annoying in your eyes because you're a petty little jealous freak. Get over yourself. While you're on youtube bashing her, she's out living her dreams and achieving more than you ever will. You will go nowhere with your attitude.
thespeshulkid 2 months ago
@daniellevasta87 Woah!! The only bitch around here is you! You try being infront of a stage in front of millions just finding out you're a millionaire and that you won! The only person lil whore cut throat bitch is you! Now grow some fucking balls!
Merry Fucking Christmas :)
HabboWNI 2 months ago
Hahaha, that's being speechless! LOLz!
nessaholichu 2 months ago
HAHAHA SIMON COWELL 0:22
FUNKTHEPUNKS 2 months ago
Comment removed
FUNKTHEPUNKS 2 months ago
Woohoo melanie!!!!! Your awesome!!
ashlover18 2 months ago
thought this show is for new singers. really strange to see that already famous one from pussycat dolls
artyqs 2 months ago
well she is better than the recent Idol winners..take that teenage girls with cellphones who watches idol!
1Nanalo 2 months ago
Man I wanted Chris Rene to win
ranDUMBcomment 2 months ago
@jonathangarcia09 .... shes not hot.... but shes talented
anonymouspersone 2 months ago
im just glad josh did not win... im sorry he is talented but his voise is annoying to me.... thats only my openeon
anonymouspersone 2 months ago
melanie-your a star
MrStargates 2 months ago
chris wasn't that good he couldn't hjit those up and down notes his voice was all the same
Royelsworth 2 months ago
you people are stupid, shes fuckinh amazing and if she werent good, then why the fuck did she juss win $5,000,000
ryrymooojica 2 months ago 23
@ryrymooojica true, but a true artist composes his/her own music....she hasn';t shown that she can do that.
ihofaerefa 2 months ago
i want chris rene!
freezymoney 2 months ago
i thought josh should of won!
calhoo5 2 months ago
I always knew it would come down to these two!
LittleE6 2 months ago
I think that Melanie is very talented and pretty but I really don't think she should've won.
Simon voted her off once,she should've stayed off the show.
I'm not hating,I've loved Melanie from the beginning but I think Josh would've been a "better" winner only because he went the WHOLE show without being voted off.
Again,I'm not being mean,they'll both have amazing careers in music,I just think Josh should've gotten the 5 million dollar contract.
MissHomeSkillet 2 months ago
I think they both will do well....
wondery34 2 months ago
I was sooooooo glad she sang Listen when she won! This is the song that brought her through! Great job Melanie! your amazing and im so glad you won! :)
NO34ful 2 months ago
she looks so confused at first its funny lol
queennena96 2 months ago
I cant believe this fat bitch won..She is so boring to watch.
orangeoctober33 2 months ago
@orangeoctober33 You shut up! shes not boring to watch! shes so unique! i bet you cant even sing! Who cares if shes fat? she is amazing! You people are just mad she won:P
NO34ful 2 months ago
@NO34ful lol unique? im not the dude that called here fat, but dude. she is kinda boing to watch and not unique. theres other female singers in the industry just like her. powerful voice but just a statue.
TheTenners 2 months ago
@TheTenners Shes the best and she won!
NO34ful 2 months ago
@orangeoctober33 you're a idiot whos's care about fat ??? she's so talented and you a jealous
santituz 2 months ago
@orangeoctober33 I'm pretty sure you should shut the hell up, she won because she's talented, and besides you yourself is probably fatter than her, don't hate cock eater.
NastyV3548 2 months ago
I really wanted chris to win but also josh and also melanie for the first time they all deserved it!
MARISAandIZZY 2 months ago
she deserves that SO much. glad to see that she won :) she was my favorite from the start!!
MacHorak2012 2 months ago
SHE WENT TO MY SCHOOL! :D
TheJeffWeekly 2 months ago
and the winner is...Melanie Amaro!
melanie: oh
melanie: (dissapointed)
melanie: (see's name) Oh My Gosh!!!!!!
Mreggstream 2 months ago
@Mreggstream LOL I said the same thing. I was like um does she knows she won, someone (being the whole entire audience) needs to let her know she won
19EHF 2 months ago
What do Clay Aiken, Adam Lambert and Josh Krajcik all have in common..? They are all have more talent and will ultimately outsell and be better known than what ever the name of the people that 'won' their competitions ever will.
Vitotesta 2 months ago
normal Black person voice.i dont like how shes singing..shes just shouting...
BubzHugz 2 months ago
@BubzHugz what a fail of a comment.
Powerlight958 2 months ago
Melanie Amaro = American Version of ADELE♥ She is amazing and has a breathtaking voice.
daisyyyxoxo 2 months ago
@daisyyyxoxo sorry but melanie is not the american veson of adele she is the next big star we never should compare melanie and other singers she is incredible :)
martvonfilip 2 months ago