Added: 5 years ago
From: themagpieswarble
Views: 72,688
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (274)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Mad props man.

  • thanks, gteat show :)

  • Nice. I enjoyed your use of hi-hat instead of a crash; it gave the song a different feel.

  • different than the original, but very good:)

  • i though itwas good,its obvisly a reallyhard song so props

  • would sound great with proper mics.

    Cheers

  • what is a broken cymbal if you dont mind me asking because ive always played this song using the hi hat before i was privy to this conversation.

  • nope.. wrong, he does uses a cymbal, and you're playing a wrong pattern, javodisforia is doing it right, you should take a look at his video and compare it yours.. keep working on it ;)

  • The guy below me is all wrong. There is definitely hi-hat in the song he plays it through out the whole song. Unless he has some ridiculous cymbal.

  • he does use a ridiculous cymbal. you uses a stack of broken cymbals, the hi hat isnt right.

  • they dont have to be broken, it can be a china with something to sizzle/mute it on top

  • ya of course it doesnt have to be, but thats what theodore uses

  • Dude, Im sorry but you are nowhere near what he plays. Whats up with you playing the hi-hat. You gotta listen to the song more carefully

  • well the hi-hat will suffice in his case because he doesnt have what he has

  • the drum part is all concentrated on the bassdrum, max stax (i use a 16" broken crash under another 16" crash) and the snare with many ghost notes.... no hi-hat or ride cymbal....

  • Great job, while... You are missing some cymbals and a floor tom to actually make this technically correct... You pretty much did this as good as you can with just that drum kit. 5 stars.

  • actually he isn't using a china he has a couple broken cymbals stacked on top of eachother that produce a china sound but with out the sustain of a china.

  • Great Job But if you listen to the song what you play on the snare jon plays on a china and he only plays the hihat on the A of beat 1. Still cool. keep on drumming man!

  • looks like you have awesome technique

  • it's still a good learning experience to play along with a song.

  • especially by the mars volta :P

  • shut up you sound stupid. drive your car off a cliff.

  • hahah. thats all you have to say cause you know you got chumped up. hows it feel to have everyone on this forum shit on your chest

  • grow up stop being such a child.

  • are you an idiot?

    wait why am i asking that...you are...obviously this guy has musical talent if he can cover a mars volta song on drums when 99 percent of the time it isnt in a 4/4 time...so Mr. i know everything about music...show me if you can match up to this guy before you start talkin shit...alright? fagget.

  • were you talkin to me. cause i think... wait im sure that i said everything you just said.

  • well you said "obviously you arnt a musician" and "you must be horribe" so that kinda says that you DIDNT say everything that i just said.

  • actually when i said you obviously arent a musician, i was talking to twonite2nite because he said the man above had no talent, to which i responded to him how he does. so why dont you read EVERYTHING i wrote before you say something. me and TWONITE2NITE were talking. and i was chumping up him before you came and made both of us look like jackasses. the kid in the video is an EXCELLENT drummer. to say the least.

  • hehe cool

    woo!

  • sweet

  • Dude, nice!

  • it's hard to compliment your drumming when my jaw's on the floor =P

  • nice drumming!

    :B

  • Is there a tab for it? Could you write up the intro?

  • aside from all the critical comments, good job

  • Get another snare. Other than that great

  • You played it well because you played it the way it would have been if Cedric and Omar came up to you with it, there's no point in learning other peoples songs; Good job.

  • and you create your own music im guessing...

  • sick! let's jam

  • nice drumming

    mad props son

  • cool!! good job men!!!

  • HAHAH WOLFMOTHER!?  WHAT YEAR IS IT!?

  • Not the way it is played at all.

  • You're absolutely right, and I'll take all the bad ratings anyone wants to give me. He wasn't even close on the groove.

  • ... after listening to the song more than 300 times, I think I can tell you, it is quite similar to the original.

  • nice! great job man haha i just noticed someone else started their comment the same way lol

  • great job man! complete respect!

  • nice job dude, i love playin to that song. in order to more accurately portray the song you should make a stack from old cymbals, thats what i did and it sounds exactly like the recording. nice job though

  • you're the reason i started drumming.

  • wow. that's a huge compliment. thanks!

  • I think Jon Theodore has made himself a legend by being fired from The Mars Volta. The amount of fans he has made...hats off to ya JT

  • Wow man, that just blew me away. Nice playing, very smooth. Very good groove, too.

  • awesome m8.tmv's drummer would be more than proud

  • Nice! I dream of being half that good some day.

  • marry me

  • good work the other guy fucked it up

  • you need to build that cymbal jon is hitting every second in this song....its a bunch of cracked cymbals riveted together...other than that... that was sweet

  • That was really good man. You are a very competent drummer.

  • Yup, alot of the mars volta songs are hard. GOOD TRY MAN .

  • You're making it more difficult than necissary. It's just a series of rudiments. - -

    RLRRLRLL RLLRLRLL that's the basic beat between the snare and hihat.

  • dude, no he's not.

    he's the closest to accuracy I've seen yet.

    Don't deflate his performance.

    Awesome fucking job, man.

  • wow man good job......thats a fucking awesome song

  • Λpollo : but...the puerto rican food...different story

     eusebia : and that was supposedly English IdentityCrisisBH† : beep mr williams pays no atterntin in his cocksure KuroPanther : authentic mexican food is great

  • help, of corse i will hep. any fan that's whacko and loving is yours to be aloved ba eboday

  • Awsome job dude! The mars volta is my favourite band :)

  • God damn that kicked ass...wish I could play like that.

  • yeah, it's a hard song to play

    great job

  • Great job man!!! really hard song to play!!

  • yeah its a fast song. p.s. get a new crash, it sounds like garbage

  • i wish i could get a whole new set of cymbals.

  • Anyone who says he plays it wrong should freaking slap themselves in the face for sheer stupidity. It doesn't matter if he plays the song exacltly how The Mars Volta plays. It's all about the beat men!

  • kudos to you kid. i was jogging to this song to day and thought how ridiculously hard it would be to play this song on drums. and here you are.

  • Wow, well performed, and with the least bit of asshole thrown into this one piece of constructive criticism, just try and work on your improvization. Other then that, sounded great and to *Roscrab* TMV have needed a new drummer for the past year, wake up.

    I'm sure Jon himself would be impressed with this.

  • fool

  • imma do one of myself and weel just see witch is the best. ;)

  • "I'm sure Jon himself would be impressed with thistupid fuck

  • what's your problem?

  • yeah hes good but he plays totally wrong, he's not getting the fill ins right and the main beat isnt even on the hi hat... lol

  • lol omg. thx for the news. it hasn't been said 5 million times before.

  • no prob buddy :)

  • toll agree:D

  • ya its good, exceot you play it very wrong.

  • i'm really interested, what's he doin wrong? I don't know a lot about drumming.

  • man, at least try to play the real thing next time...

  • fucken awesome

  • WOW! That was really impressive! I really admire you for even attempting that, since Cygnus...is a hard song to keep up with.

    If TMV ever need a new drummer, send them this. :D

  • Muy buena tecnica y control

    y esa cancion... excentele igual (Y)

  • Great work. You even look like Jon. Hehe

  • Damn. Your an awesome player!

  • nice playing.

    not a nice colour ;P x

  • you did amazing.

  • I love it. Great job!!

  • very nice job dude, its just to finally see som good vids on here. im transcribing "miranda i dont think that ghost..." the second installment of it and its going pretty good maybe ill record some

  • dammmmmm how long have you been playing dude??

    that was perfect :']

  • Awesome :D Great timing, alot of passion. Thats all what good drummer should have imo. I wish that drummer in my band could play that. I must show him this video. Mb he'll start practicing more.

  • great job man

  • Nice job, you definitely have a good sense of timing, something I find lacking with many videos. Good smooth style.

  • great job

  • dude thats awesome

  • i like it, great song, great performance

  • I forgot my childhood dream about becoming a drummer. You reminded me

  • Nice work. Jon Theodore is easily one of the best drummers on the planet and that was pretty impressive.

  • right on, good job man

  • That was fukcin awesome!

  • Definetly wasn't perfect but you kept up thats for sure. It's good to see someone doing justice to a song on this site.

  • keep up.

  • not perfect, but a nice attempt. you're able to do something a LOT of people cannot, and that's even ATTEMPT to imitate jon theodore. keep it up

  • that´s cool man, really greart

  • really nice keep praticing

  • eh.

  • wachin lo aser super!!!

  • yeahhh thats all dude... u play so cool cygmus yeahhh...

  • nice!

  • I've been trying to figure out that one too. I think the majority of the rhythm is played straight 16ths on the snare, using your left hand for the hi-hat choke and finishing the phrase with a single paradiddle with your right hand accenting with that trash hat thing Jon Theodore uses. On the paradiddle, where you would double-stroke with the right, use a single but still double with the bass drum underneath. Thats the way I think I saw it in concert.

  • your an idiot

  • Damn! You make it look so easy. Great job.

  • it's too bad your not playing the actual part

  • you're

  • not too shabby babby

  • nice..

  • wow, I didn't know how cool the drums were in this first song

  • cool man! it's neat to see another drummer's interpretation of this song. i play it a bit different, but who's to say who's correct? cygnus is pretty damn quick. nice stuff. :)

  • Very, VERY nice.

  • Greeeeat video dude.

  • you're very very good dude! my greets!

  • very nice and smooth :)

  • Dude, that was awesome, keep up the good work

  • very impressive man! The Mars Volta kick arse

  • what are the name of song???:D

  • Cygnus...Vismund...Cygnus!!!! Nino Preparate..Sangre Sonando, De Rabia Naci

    Pete

  • very nice playing man, my favorite song off frances the mute

  • good job man...definately not the easiest song...great job

  • Holy hell, man. That was freakin' amazing.

  • nice!

  • sick ill nasty, you're fantastic.

  • Umm...The mars volta kinda suck...like there guitarist is fucking amazing but the music is just retarted. They kinda tryed to go with the whole copying Rush with the Cygnus and made a 30 minute song but it just didnt work out and it was WAY too long and boring. And oviously they have band problems cause theyve gone through like 10 drummers, but be

  • daaaaang. why cant i be you?

    <3

  • Awesome, almost makes me wish I was a drummer instead of a pianist. I mean, I won't have any problems keeping up with mars volta! hahaha

  • you like too deeply concentrated

    have a little fun with tmv songs :)

  • this is probably one of the best drum covers i've seen on youtube.

    it's hard to get a feel sense of natural skill when a person is trying to play a song beat for beat.

    for just doing your own thing, this rocks. great quality too, i really like the song playing underneath.

    i'd love to see some more volta interpretations!

  • thanks a bunch man. looking back at this video there is a lot of sloppiness and mistakes and i feel like i've even improved since then.

    but i always enjoy just messing around over a song (hence the mozambique latin beat in the middle of this one.)

  • this is really good but wrong

  • agreed. go see my "cygnus improved?" video.

  • Oh god forbid he might mix it up a little.

  • thats the way you do it!

  • damn right. you keep up good, and you've got taste too! mars volta!

  • Jon Theodore is one of the best drummers on the planet. I can't believe he quit The Mars Volta! But pretty nice playing anyway. The only negative I can say is that it seemed like you were concentrating on not playing too loud? It just seemed to me that if you were playing with a band, you would have played it better because you wouldn't be holding back. Feel me? Not a diss at all man, I'm a drummer myself, and you played that shit nice. Respect

  • damn man you're fuckin groovin.

  • thats pretty good dude, nice feel, u've pretty much got the groove, i think the 'a' of 1 isn't snare but on bass tho, and yeah lol jon's using his stack alot here. fills are pretty accurate. nice one!

  • great drumming!

    I tought it was harder to reproduce Jon drumming but as you're showing it's humanly possible.

    could you please do the same thing for Roulette Dares?

  • Way to go man...Jon Theodore is one sick bastard and you kept up damn well.

  • washington state

  • where do you live?

  • yeah, that's not the way theodore does it...

    i wish you could see it. browse it. and you'll want to quit.

  • Pretty good timing man. If you want to pay it right you need some kind of stack instead of the hi-hat in this part. I think Jon used to use some old busted up cymabals as a homemade stack.

  • Yeah, man. I'd kinda like to make one of those. I'll have to look into that.

  • KICK ASS DUDE

  • I just saw Mars Volta in concert.... for some reason they sounded like shit, but song played here actually sounds good. anyway, good drumming!!

  • Just goes to show how amazing they are. Most other bands consist of nothing but common time with a snare on two and four. It's hard to even tell what the time signature is looking only at the drums.

  • waaav, niice

  • damn.. i wish i can do that

  • noice. atleast u go along with it. not like other frigtards on this site lmao

  • niice !

  • wow..men really cool.

  • Nice drumming, far better than the javo one :)

  • congratulations, mars volta drums...is hard.

  • are hard..are hard..

  • Nice set, and Volta////is soo hard to play along with.

  • i wish i could play like that

  • that was really kool

  • ha pretty cool

  • ah, some mistakes but u play very good

    i liked! congratulations!

  • so you wanted to start with an easy one, eh? Nicely done!

  • this is good but the other guy on youtube does it way better