Dear Rosemary - This Video Sucks Contest: Directed by Karl Richter

[LoyalKnightofOrion]

That girl is super cute :D

[EverlastClown]

You know, this video has an awesome production... it looks very 'pro'. But im pretty sure almost all of the winners from 'this video sucks contest' are just very well producted videos, and not the best ideas. Anyways, Rosemary looks hot :)

[AodhanMailey575]

bit serious, the foo's are about vaccum cleaners in aeroplanes with tenacious d!

[yankeesrule6497]

@AodhanMailey575 exactly.

[magnog777]

the only point of a foo fighters is seeing the foo fighters. truthfully the only one of these videos i enjoy was the white limo one with the guy in the banana costume

[tvrose2008]

that video may not be to my liking, but the song is...From this Rosemary, hearing Dave and Bob Mould sing 'Dear Rosemary' is like chocolate to my ears...It sounds so good blaring in the car...

[Babybodo1]

It's very professionally done, but I find the clip confusing. The boy and the girl are singing the same song? I don't quite get it.

[stevorulzdaworld]

Well....that chick has a fucking deep-ass voice :/

[Ramonajunie3]

so she's crying because she got a paper cut and doesn't wanna take a bath?

I AM CONFUSE

[sexmagik45]

isso sim é uma banda! não essas modinhas de merda do Brasil o//!!

[leandrofaria88]

very good, my favorite music of new album. Foo fighters need visit São Paulo - Brazil i am Waiting

[CecisAndrade]

@leandrofaria88 Eles vão para São Paulo ano que vem, Lollapalooza! *-*

[Scottbot101]

i like it :)

[emiliokup]

Sucks

[dustydeb66]

Excellent

[MrHeitz17]

A. I'm confused by it

B. I understand the whole couple with problems thing and that she tries to commit suicide... but still... what?

C. Still confused...

[aloumvrios]

nice work

[OriginallyMyGroup]

Can some one explain what this This Video Sucks Contest was about? B, Thanks you. :DD

[IDareToSpeak]

Best video for this contest I think

[liepinshtein]

^5 on the video!

[MsLizzy728]

eh?

[Cletten]

Love her voice ahahaha

[hellHoUnd791]

...What? Why is she singing? This song is supposed to be about her and the guy should be singing you gotta away from me.

[darktony85]

Great video

[foorockpeppers]

Not bad, but a bit too serious for the Foos.

[PicklesParodyPalace]

@foorockpeppers What are you talking about, Hot Buns was the most serious thing they ever donw

[gorillawang]

she's in the google+ video from break too

[AssAssin00009]

so, someone explain me this video :)

[rawkgawdez]

Absolutely NO relation to the actual meaning behind these brilliant lyrics. too funny this is. really.

[toscanoww]

Awesome video, can be an official video?

[CmdrViper]

she has big cans

[N4ndo208]

daaaaaaaaaamn, FKING NICE

[TheFutherMuckers]

foo fucking fighters rule!

[Danid0732]

i think the video fits just great, and the girl its beautifull and still kinda dark :D of course if we cut some unnecesary parts and put the foo's playin, so the video suck's a lot better :P

[resigal04]

I'm making a video for the song Still... I know, it's an old one but whenever I hear the video I can always picture a video in it. I have a little problem though! I'm not 18 yet and I'm getting a tattoo next summer (when i will be) that says "In your honor" and I want that in there. But looking at these videos make me wanna do the video NAO XDD

[pl2131]

such a dramatic video

[shmykelsathesecond]

This video doesn't suck

[hahahadotcom]

This is a very well produced video... but WTF was going on 0__o

[tropicalconcierge]

Great Video!

[BenRessler]

Who else think it sounds like the guy from Killswitch Engage at 3:12, 3:20, 3:52, and especially 3:58?

[mubs42]

@BenRessler that is taylor singing

[BenRessler]

@mubs42 No, it's Bob Mould.

[bestshowontheweb]

@BenRessler It's Bob Mould AKA the lead from Husker Du

[stringyu]

I like this song... very much... Good video! :)

[alxfto]

I love the beggining but I just don't like her acting...

[RedDevilThing]

it's really good, but I don't think it fits with the song

[Accipigna]

this video is one of the best among the other THIS VIDEO SUCKS contest videos, with BACK & FORTH and WALK. I think the other videos are way too dark, way too far from FF style , considering the song they are rapresenting.

too much pain and suffering . FF are EPIC instead ! not DEPRESSED !

[nevers4yforever]

This is really good. It's a bit messy, some bits could've been left out and it would've been top.

[OMGAFLYINGSQUIRREL]

i think it's a bit dark for the style of music..

[CyberZak619]

My favourite song from Wasting Light after Miss the Misery and White Limo! :DD

[pingola16]

She's hot, but she acts like my ass 01:02

[bleep77]

These THIS VIDEO SUCKS videos are actually kick ass! I wonder if Foo Fighters will adopt some of them into their real promotional videos! This song rocks, by the way. One of my personal favorites on WASTING LIGHT

[owengsp]

One of the best tracks from Wasting Light!

[TerjectorMan]

very artistic, lots of great shots

[Heyyduduheads]

Best music video EVER MADE!

[MrSam2014]

I don't understand what the whole thing about the black stuff all over her is about...i understand the parts where it shows them fighting but that stuff stumps me...x.x

[xiimeniwis]

@MrSam2014 i agree



[CryStalez]

meh..too much teen drama like

[Chafor]

boring!

[einbischen]

this really sucks

[funnyG1]

I thought this video fit...SH

[zeropsycho]

when she close her eyes, I remember of Thirteen in HouseMD

[drunkonmilk87]

hmm, this is my favourite song on the album, and i was expecting somthing a bit less...metaphorical.

[TheMetallica0111]

this video suck :D

[NoWhereMan1313]

great song great video. dont care about thinking about what it means or supposed to mean, i just like it and thats all that matters to me.

[nothingleft2losefoo1]

I LOVE-HATE reading all the foo "fans" complaining about the videos....sounds a like a bunch of jealous whiny children....if you don't enjoy someone's art then you should just shut up and move along....there is no reason to attack something that is based on opinon.

[AnimeNsA46]

how was that horrible were u expecting a girly 17 year old boy singing around girls... this was actually really good.

[CrossfireZX5]

In my opinion, this is the best out of all the 'This Video Sucks' videos, as it actually fits the song, unlike the horrendus videos for Walk, Bridge Burning, Rope, Miss the Misery and A Matter of Time. Arlandria was alright, but it definitely didn't fit the song, same goes for Back and Forth. Anyone who dislikes this video quite simply, are not true Foo Fighters fans

[nothingleft2losefoo1]

@CrossfireZX5 You sound like you are a total and complete moronic loser who has nothing better to do in life than attack people's art. i have yet to see a video in this contest that is worthy of your insults. if you don't like it then shut up and go see something you do like but don't waste your life's limited hours by attacking people who did nothing to harm anyone.

[carmmercials]

This video is not TOO serious, its perfect for the song because the song IS serious. How could they have made a classic comedic foo fighters video about such a heavy subject matter. This is a dark song! just listen to it! anyway, the whole point of the contest was for the contestants to interpret the song and make a video. If the foo fighters didnt want new and real interpretations of their songs then they would have just made the video themselves! i know the foo fighters dig this video...

[Chromeo2015]

shes hot hahahahahah

[wonderealm]

I think this video interprets the song perfectly - it's dark and heavy like the song, and it's extremely well concepted and fantatically produced. Very similar in tone and style to "Walking After You" which is ALSO an OFFICIAL Foos Vid.

[isaacADD]

I bet Dave Ghrol and Bob Mold hate this shit

[wonderealm]

@isaacADD Yeah? Are you good friends with them? I bet Dave Grohl likes this one, since he picked it to represent his song!

[isaacADD]

This one fucking sucks 

[shinystuffff]

Least favorite video so far, but oh well. I still love the song.

[jesusbautistacid]

what you got to do, is have a bunch of people on drugs on a plane...

[robFOV]

its way to serious! Not foos material!

[Klahz]

The point was I think a contest that was titled "This Video Sucks". Well, it seems by the comments that the winner was picked right then! Cause so many people are making comments that say that. But...they are making the comments with the added info that it is not a FF kind of vid. Yeah, think the point was made...great directing though and it obviously made an impact...which is what a great vid should! Way to go Karl Richter, Director!

[yinchangOfficial]

Awesome video.. really great production. beautiful people starring in it too. Is that guy Micky Shiloah? Saw him as the lead in another music video and checked out his youtube videos of him singing ...he's killin it! He's so hot!!!

[chesternaire242]

this video is fucking shit! not foo fighters at all

[kennedy1251]

this video looks like its been made for some chart pop bullshit song not foo fighters

[ThunderInTheCity]

sad day... this is my favorite song on the album. I hoped for more.

[ShinePink16]

i hate this video

[maxyramone77]

i don't like it, is horrible! but the song rocks! \m/

[mogi99999]

omg.. this is to emo

[TheGiuanni]

????what ?????

[TheGiuanni]

this video sucks

[TeeJay26]

Thumbs up if this looks like the "Beast and the Harlot" video from Avenged Sevenfold with the ink crap.

[Cowenleetin]

wtf is this

[jamdcfc10eng]

I am annoyed that there is criticism. These are bloody good productions.

[Hjulvisp]

@jamdcfc10eng I believe people are critisising these videos because they are bad in terms of content, not production. People with depressed looks on their faces in slow motion, come on.

[jamdcfc10eng]

@Hjulvisp i see that, i just think there should be appreciation for time and effort into the videos

[doobsthegr8]

@jamdcfc10eng the criticism is caused by jealousy.

[bestshowontheweb]

@jamdcfc10eng You know that the criticism is praise in this case, right? It's called the "This video sucks" contest.

[jamdcfc10eng]

@bestshowontheweb only from the band... the comments are hardly sarcastic are they?

[DOPRDELEFON]

Same with bridge burning, too much frickin emo, is the band turning into a bloody tokio hotel or something? I know it's a fan video, but sometimes I think they really voted the suckiest video of all...

[UrbanGamer1]

I agree with the other comments so far. Really not a Foo's style of vid but I wanna give major Kudos to the makers/directors anyway as it looks extremely professional! :)

[purrfactmiss]

A beautifully crafted pop video, following all rules of music video making, even with a dear David letter. Not Foo, but nice.

[Hjulvisp]

This video sucks indeed.

[ianpasicolan]

It's so not Foo Fighters... true. But the video fits well with "Dear Rosemary". And frankly speaking, I can't even imagine the song having a funny Foo video treatment.

[ianpasicolan]

I can't even imagine Dear Rosemary being played on a funny Foo video, directed by Dave Grohl or even a fan. This is pretty good.

[RobanBrauer]

I dont like the video, but Rosemary looks very Beautyfull.

[TheMsSmallvillian]

the good thing about this video was the song.

[logiestewart]

The guy looks like Ashton Kutcher lol

[SuperVintendo64]

Just because they directed the video the way they did, doesn't mean they're not "hardcore Foo Fighters fans." Everyone has a different vission when they hear a song, and that's basically what this contest was made to show. Also, you can't really make a Learn to Fly video out of songs like this one.

[bendaniel81]

Wow, definately does not suck. Very well produced.

[xaveir14]

looks more like a MCR video

[doorrraaaa]

3:47 Dirty Dancing feelings

[rieyll]

I thought this video was pretty good, and it WAS chosen as a winning entry. So say what you want about it not having a foo fighters vibe, the foos clearly thought it is a good video. Also, not every foo fighters video is fun and laughs. Walking After You, Best of You, The Pretender and maybe even My Hero were all 'serious' videos.

[Foges6694]

It maybe doesn't seem very Foo Fightery, but fits the lyrics...

[darthiowa]

shut up

[00RV00]

Can everyone PLEASE stop complaining about the video and start talking about the hotness of that girl?

[TheHawkdaddy]

you're right, This Video Sucks

[ryandouglasrumsey]

I'm going to replace the music with a Breaking Benjamin song and re upload it.

[0371998]

Spread ...c'Est en apparence...le plateau de tournage de se film...Utilisé pour le video de Foo Fighters!...L'arcteur du video clip ressemble aussi beaucoup à Ashton Kutcher ! hmmm! regarder le

[0371998]

@0371998 Where this video have been shoot?

HE looks like the movie *SpreaD* performed by Ashton Kutcher

[officepen]

Rope video was great this one and the bridges burning one...SUCK they are like for some depressing emo band not the Foo Fighters..

[domination102]

I don't like it. Way to serious and ghey!

[robotknox]

dear venom...

[Mooser1512]

like the title says, this video sucks



[oiergasdn]

way, waaay too serious

[Vide0sPlz]

Damn, I only watched the first 56 seconds and it already sucks. For a song by any other band it's ok, but even the Foos themselves did say that the videos are supposed to be FUN! The ONE time I saw a video that was slightly sad by the Foos was maybe the Walking After You video!

Guys, please make your own videos again! I wanna see new videos that trump classics like Learn to Fly, Everlong and all of your other videos that are just plain fun to watch.

[TheBeatlefloyd]

SHIT! i thought i missed my chance when they made the rope video! i couldve tried to make something :/

[fimbulvter]

I can agree that this is not an ideal video for the song but that is what was picked by the foos or the record company.

[TJRy12921]

Wow you guys are being way too harsh. First off, I would love to see your video for the song if you can do so much better. And second, it's their interpretation of the song; it fit pretty well with the lyrics and was well done. No, FF would have never made this video themselves, but I think that was kind of the point of the contest, to see how fans interpret their music.

[fightingfoos]

Foo Fighters are not an emo band, why would you make this video.

[TheMightyQuinn3000]

Well...it says contest guys so obviously it means this is someone else's video they just added FF music to it. At least that's what it seems by the title and all.

[MCMANUSJS99]

if i made this vid @ 3:20 the chick would have applied the lipstick like the blackhole sun lady, hahaha...... im pretty sure the bathtub water was supplied from the gulf of mexico near louisianna

[tommig1995]

they got the parts the wrong way round, shouldn't it be the guy who sings it?..

[MatthewLimburgTV]

I'm a hardcore Foo Fighters fan and everything, and Dear Rosemary was one of my favorites from Wasting Light, and it had potential to be a future single, but then this video came along and dashed all those hopes. This isn't a FF video for sure. Dave Grohl usually finds a way to put himself in a scene. Not only that, this video makes no sense at all. This is probably the worst video I've seen since Rebecca Black's Friday. This song deserves better than this.

[meshugeah]

this video would fit with "I should have known" much better, but i like it anyway^^

[DanYul55]

yeah I can see why not many ppl are liking this video. I agree with @mwpros1.

[maaaarius123]

To everyone complaining: Was this supposed to be music videos in the style of the regular Foo videos? Everyone has the right to interpret a song into whatever feelings they get from it, that's kind of the point of music in my opinion. I think all the music videos was pretty good and it looked professional considering (wild guess) the lack of time and money they had making it. Good job everyone.

[thatguy2308]

It would have been a decent video had it been any other band.

[SamaSyaoran]

I see they wasn't lying when they said "This Video Sucks".

[ballinastack93]

that guy just wishes he cud sing like dave!!

[kallemalle1234567890]

Well, I guess it only was a matter of time, until one Foo Fighters video looked like a effin Greed video, not to diss them...

[muldyer]

The video is very dark, doesn't look like foo fighters vidz.

I must admit i am hopping to see a funny video like they usually do for the next video !

Like they said in back and forth, lets have some fun with those videos !

[ToothyMTG]

Well made but doesn't really fit to the Foos, imo.

[evenszender]

This Video Sucks

[PureAsGold]

I was waiting for Spiderman to come in and defeat Venom, wait....

[gringo117]

@PureAsGold I was hoping she was going to eat Tobey McGuire...mmmmm brrraaiinnsss

[moon7xx]

i got shhhivers ! excellent...

[mwpros1]

Whoever made this video and the Bridge Burning video is clearly not a hardcore Foo Fighters fan. They did it just to enter this contest. The Rope one is actually pretty cool because of the fun twist at th end, but this video and the Bridge Burning video are so not Foo Fighters videos, at all. mxpcmmwider said, "it doesn't have the right vibe at al."

[foorocker91]

@mwpros1 i agree. they are both well edited and are well done. but the Rope one was definitely the best and had a foo fighters feel to it.

[rise0rdiex2]

@mwpros1 Gee I wonder why it's clearly not a foo fighters video. I think it's fantastic, on the contrary the Rope one kinda lacked any meaning, as fun as it was. The arlandria one was pretty cool too.

[JDogge96]

@mwpros1 ya man i totally agree with you they are a little to serious for at foo fighters video

[wonderealm]

@mwpros1 Actually, I'm pretty sure you're not going to spend all that time and resources to make a video this involved "just to enter the contest" Do you know how much work and expense goes into this? A ton. You wouldn't do all that UNLESS you were a fan. I'm certain that everyone who entered the contest are fans.

Bottom line, the foos were looking for something different on this album. It's not a "FUN" song, why would it get a "FUN" video?

[Joebeast23]

@mwpros1 Seriously though what the fuck does a little girl who's sad on her birthday have to do with foo fighters. Especially in walk WTF does the muppets have to do with the Foo Fighters, They don't even compare!!

[TheTickleable]

@Joebeast23 I think walk is so awesome! but it reminds me of everlong, but I think it's so foo fighters with the muppets XD

[drunkonmilk87]

@mwpros1 the 'walk' one and 'back and forth' are both very good. funny too.

[c21burke]

Hauntingly excellent. Such a dark heavy song, it needed a similar video and this person has achieved it perfectly.

[mxpcmnwlder]

this video is not foo fighters - it doesnt have theright vibe at all

[ohgeorgieee]

Best one. Kudos Karl Richter, whoever you may be.

[TheMagichippo]

really cool

[drunkonmilk87]

really well done.

[ksatvlinderke]

my fav. one!!! foo 4 life man XD

[jasonmckenna]

10/10 video, very good

[norfolkboyo]

Cool video

[froggy1112]

way better than the bridge burning fan clip

[Healy1313]

"You got away, got away, got away from me. Now get away, get away, get away from me."

[diedelpozo]

yes, my fav... love the images, cameras, lights... 10 points.

[jenlovesfoofighters]

love this!!!!!!!!

[MrMartinoo1]

this video is gonna get huge i think! and we will remember how we watched it at 220views :D

[noversrain]

the video doesn't go well with this song. at all...maybe with I shoul've known

[Remixsification]

damn... real fans... nice work