Added: 4 years ago
From: pawnsdream
Views: 231,573
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (349)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Oh my gosh, I freaking love this song! He's amazing! I'm not even Scotish whatsoever, but I'm totally with all of you for your independence! If I could, I would vote yes! :D <3

  • Thumbs up if you are voting YES to Scottish Independence !

  • If I was a Scott's I would be so proud of this....

  • great modern version of a classic scottish song about brothers all over the world and humanity in general sharing the same problems and thinking can we solve them together? unfortunately the answers nearly always naw. i cant beleive the old firm zombies are argueing over this,and thats how it will not change cos they just soak up the sectarianism and hatred handed down to them,as if punk or anything involving moving forward and thinking for yourself never happened.a mans a man for a that! x

  • classic!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • An excellent interpretation of Burn's finest. I notice the flag wavers have been out on force: I think they missed the point! Internationalism, equality and respect for all is my understanding of the song.

  • Freeeee Dome......See You at that Gig !! not long now...

    Oh and Thankssss- Paolo For Keeping our Culture ALIVE !!

    Magic. My Man- and Oh That.!!

  • @Mr.Rasberry

    You Shure Sound Like A GooseBerry!!! on this thread and a Sour!! one at that. and Oh THAT!!!- shame you only got Fakespear!! Down your neck Oh the woods.

  • I would love to see Scottish independence and I believe in my life time I will however I don't see how "A mans a man" has anything to with independence for Scotland.

    That Man to Man, the world o'er,

    Shall brothers be for a' that.

  • @delboystir1

    I think that's exactly the point! That Burns wrote an anthem about the Universality of Humanity & our common, shared experience, it MUST be embraced as the Anthem of the Nation that gave us Rab Burns! It would be the perfect tribute to him!

    And it's so far beyond petty Jingoism, that it would "dae yis a' proud!", and you'd have the rest of the World singing it too, because it's so catchy & universal!

    Sounds like the Perfect National Anthem to me??

  • Didn't mind this at all, an alright rendition.

    As for the comments in independence, you may believe in it. It ends there, Scotland would be in the red and deeper financial problems than Ireland if it broke from the union. - A union that took Scotland out of bankruptcy. Arguments for North sea oil are also invalid.

  • @MrRaspberryBeret How is it invalid? And thats one source of income??? we have fantastic opportunities to grow tourism and our skilled workforce for banking, economics and some of the finest engineers in the world....... not to mention all the opportunities for exporting our products... Open up to the idea of Scotland being like our similar sized neighbours like norway, sweden, holland and belgium etc.... We deserve the right to sustain our culture and choose OUR OWN destiny!

  • @Yeratubeful That simple, huh? ......the only thing the splitting of the union leads to - is misery, higher taxes , absorption into the Euro and the handing of powers over to Brussels. You'll see how quickly Scotland is on her knees and asking for handouts from the EU. Scotlands power and standing is maintained while in the union - and is all the better for it.

    /signed > a Scotsman who doesn't watch Braveheart with breakfast, lunch and dinner.

    Vote devo max or no in the referendum, thanks!

  • Get grip you f...... eejits , This is Scottish Guy singing a Scottish song f... your sectarian shit . SCOTTISH AND PROUD

  • great version Paolo

  • My Brother played there a couple of times! Well sung Paulo, hats off to u!!!

  • I want to see Paolo Nutinit do a whole album of Burns covers.

  • Great performance. It's hard to believe that he was barely 20 yo.

  • Minted tune and anyone who's trying to turn it into some sorta sectarian crap can go fuuuuuucccccckkkkkkk themselves wether they be prodesant or catholic!

  • go listen to more Paolo Nutini and I'll bet you never criticize him again. Listen to Autumn Leaves

  • It's a pity that they crack a bunch of dumb jokes at the start, because they're basically right- Burns was well punk.

  • I really love this song but this guys singing is kinda warbly

  • I saw this when it went out first. Thought he was weak, poor, no attempt to do it well. Decided I didn't like Paolo. A year later, we were in Venice, and heard a song playing which was great. Asked who it was - they said 'He's Scots! He's Italian too!' - it was Paulo's album. Since then have bought two albums. Love what he does. But this was crap and still is... neither does Paolo justice, nor the song...

  • Played this last week as my father was laid to rest in the crematorium, he loved Burns, and he would have loved Paolos' rendition.

  • an amazing song 2 keep up scotch pride and morale along wi a dram or two lol. great song paolo.

  • Fantastic rendition -the sentiments of Socialism and pride are ageless and belong to no particular generation. That a 21 year old can sing this song with such enthusiasm today would have brought a smile to Burns's face. Well done that man!

  • Comment removed

  • Talented dude. Met him one time outside the abc, was sound as fuck.

  • wonderful,

    will be a nation again,

    up the St'Andrews flag!!

  • Paolo does this no justice. Unfortunatly he sounds like a ned sining this wonderful song. No offence to the man, but this aint the song for him. Ronnie Browne owned this song

  • @TaiDieVest hahahahaha wank comment of the week!

  • @TaiDieVest I have to disagree, this is not a song for the Hoi Polloi to sit in their drawing rooms and discuss the working classes patronizingly, Paolo captures the tone of the song perfectly, the rawer the sound of this song, the more fitting. (And by this comment I am in NO way suggesting Ronnie Browne is one of the Hoi Polloi.)

  • mister paolo, you rock baby ! this is just fantastic .... 

  • Cmon Paolo Nutini and Rabbie Cmon SCOTLAND :!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Scottish AND PROUD

  • Cmon Paolo Nutini and Rabbie Cmon SCOTLAND :!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • OMG, he truly IS a real Scot! What I wadnae gie tae hear'm sing "Flower of Scotland" at the op'nin o' a national rugby match! NZ in the fa' mebbe? We can on'y hope!

    Is it my imagination, or does he actually bear a resemblance tae Auld Rab?

  • OMG He truly IS a real Scot! What I wadnae gie tae hear'm sing "Flower of Scotland" at the op'nin o' a national rugby match! NZ in the fa' mebbe? We can on'y hope!

  • Im speechless, Im listening to this already an hour or so. It rocks :)

  • I am scottish, therefore I am a legend:)

  • C'MON SCOTLAND!

  • I was there the night this was recorded, he was un-fucking-believeable, one of the best performances ive ever seen and what a tune to sing:))

  • when he sung this he was 20-21 fucking unreal!

  • Who knows how Rab would react? But it's fun to guess, isn't it? I think he would be polite to the undoubtedly handsome Paolo but might have privately thought that the boy didn't quite let go, didn't quite storm the song.

  • AYE!

  • typical wanks turning this into a sectarian debate, Scotlands shame

    great version of a great song

  • @tazz121 Correct,it's bloody pathetic isn't it?

  • @tazz121 Scotland's shame is to be in the union with a race as foul as the english.

  • @JakobVirgil WHOSE LANGUAGE IS THAT YOU R'E SPEAKING then.....

  • @speedcrane now your just rubbing salt in the wound. :)

  • @JakobVirgil I'm Scottish and believe in an independent Scotland and if we do have any "shame" then it's having people like YOU living here. That's if you DO! Your comment is both nasty and childish.

  • He is sooo young! 

  • How can a cracking song by rab burns being sung by another Scotsman be ruined? A Hun thinks he sees a tricolour in the background and thinks Fenian? What an eejit. Great song, well sung

  • Its great! Such a young man sings this song! Love it!

    Love "Auld lang syne" too, hes got the voice and the feeling!

  • Its great! Such a young man sings this song! Love it!

    Love "Auld lang syne" too, hes got the voice and the feeling!

  • I wish I was the same age as Paulo....In Scotland (which means the whole fuckin' world...) his music, words and general feel are real! If I should be so privileged as to work with Paolo Nutini I would consider myself blessed....the MAN'S THE GOWD for aw that

  • I wish I was the same age as Paulo....In Scotland (which means the whole fuckin' world...) his music, words and general feel are real! If I should be so privileged as to work with Paolo Nutini I would consider myself blessed....

  • paulos drunk

  • lol..is he steemin?

  • @andybmfc yepp haha

  • Proud.To.Be.Scottish.

    No offense to anyone but Edinburgh is the place to be.

  • @Aldoo97 bang on

  • @Aldoo97 You're alright. I'd be proud, too.

  • Well if Paolo is singing like a sheep, I have to say I´ve never seen a better singing sheep! He must be the most gorgeous sheep on this planet! ;)

    Paolo is the best!

  • How to sing like a sheep !

  • Lionel McClellend of Moffat performs his own version of the famous Robert Burns ode to humanity.

  • he was a good guy

  • check out this verion from lionel. lionel died about a month ago he has a good guy

    Lionel McClellend sings a man's a man for a' that- Robert Burns' ode to humanity

  • Pure , Raw and brilliant !

  • Paolo catches the whole philosophy of being Scottish - which is the same philosophy from Timbuktu to Cape Horn - The Scots Nation were never beaten and can always relate to their brothers - Maori, Navajo, Nigerian, Apache, Aborigine, Lakota, Ghanaian - the Scots stood up to the English government and spread their love across the whole world!

  • Great song Paolo,stirs the hackles when a watch it

  • What can I say...............

  • iam just so proud of you paolo, well done you truley brought Robbie back to life ! well done ma son xx love ya <3

  • @MrTeedy287 Are you listening to yourself? Have you been brainwashed against Irish history? Are you seriously saying Scotland has more problems with the Catholic/Protestant thing than Ireland?

    Anyway, Paolo is one of our best singer/songwriters and this is an amazing version of this song.

  • my favourite song ever...and this young man owns it. best i've heard.

  • paolo can sing anything you give him...........hes fantastic wat a voice

  • OMG why does someone whos representing Scotland have to look like such a junky/ Drunk onstage all the time disappointing

  • @NatLvsRawknRoll

    What do you want??? Kilts, haggis and shortbread? He sings with pure emotion and pride. In my eyes he represents Scotland perfectly.

  • love this guy

  • is the drum a tricolour ? the fenian bastard

  • @aggyuvf naw ya blind orange bastard :L its a fuckin album cover ya prick so fuck off back tae yir wee cave n the uvfs fae irleand m8 this is fuckin scotland

  • @aggyuvf  naw ya blind orange bastard its a fucking album cover n the uvfs fae irleand this is scotland ya prick

  • @aggyuvf av tae go bak tae irleand wen ur the wan way uvf in yir name narro minded orange bastatd disgrace tae the world ya cunt

  • @11andyp2k9 Bolt ya papish cunt

  • @aggyuvf the scots are an irish tribe? edinburgh call weedgies soap dodgers? ye need yer ain patter and yer ain race ya wee manky knucklescraper!

  • @kilomeister hahahaha all this scottish talk is hilarious!!! hahahahaha

    "yer ain race ya wee manky knucklescraper!" hahahaha i dont even know what that means but its hilarious!!!

    anyway im not scottish but i am half irish and one of my best friends is scottish and i have a lot of respect for you scots

  • @aggyuvf it's orange yellow and white. wouldn't a tricolour be orange green and white?  seek an optician.

  • Superb Paolo if i ever leave Scotland i will be in tears to this

  • Just Magic bonnie Scotland

  • Aye! ;)

  • Paolo rocks, im not scottish- but litening to him i want to be!

  • shivers up yer spine

  • this should be the scottish national anthem.

  • jewish centre of scotland ???/What on earth are you talking about??Paisley is purely rangers supporters pal which means protestant so happens hes italian grandfather makes him catholic ., celtic supporter. Get your fucking american ass over here and we will sort your out

  • @toscarider

    Talk about missing the point! He's singing Burns, and aw' that the song wis aboot!

    Grow a brain please!

  • @toscarider Im a celtic fan from paisley and a catholic, its not purely protestant in the slightest.

  • awesome!

  • absolutely sensational! imagine this being our national anthem!

  • The sooner that this is the Nation anthem the better , at least its not looking backward to past achievements, but a song of equals and forgiveness.

    Efter a' he's ony a' man!!

  • Cheerful little ditty, is he speaking English? I'm Scottish but never visited the "old country", Americans are like that, we get off the boat and don't look back and cry in diaspora. This guy looks xewish.

  • Comment removed

  • @GilleanFreire The Jewish center of Scotland? Thanks for the info, I didn't realize that is where Paisley's orginated from, Hellmans mayo, weaving, and Scottish Whiskey.

  • Comment removed

  • @GilleanFreire He looks xewish. He is from a xew part of Scotland, his people were merchants, His names are all xewish names, he looks gay as well. My people were from the old country but have been here since the 1600's and so I have not got a feel for the language. Some of his songs I like though but he looks xewish.

    He might have an ounce of Scottish in him by his drinking habit and light stomach.

  • f all to do with celtic or rangers am a reangers fan n av got a man crush on this guy here hes 1 of the best singer/songwriter in my generation so dont care what team or what coulour just loving the music paolo !!

  • Ohhhh Wow, love itt. Gorgeous. Dottee you just love his accent :)

  • great stuff. have look at ..na rionnagan.. at the barrowlands you ll love them. ploz leave them a note cheers

  • funny thing is, ye generally find that the majority of these individuals for example the guy below aggyuvf couldnae tell ye the first thing about the supposed religions/history they preach.

    i could count four or five guys i work with that shout the loudest about there catholic/protestant beliefs and are generally regarded as being of low inteligence and regularly get the piss ripped out of them.

  • Bigoted tally bastard

  • Great song Paolo ha ha ya fenian tally bastard the Gers are gony win the league, still great song though :)

  • Gon yersel Paolo!  Fantastic - Rabbie would be proud of you!

  • Scottland!

  • Mon Paolo!

    Hail Hail Celtic FC!

  • tim card???what becoz of an album cover???

    dont make me laugh.....

    i'm a big gers fan and still fink this guy is a legend, just a pity the narrow minded,very bitter few of both sides have to try and spoil it....but then again whats new??

  • proud tae be a scot !!! go on yer sel

  • You Scottish people are so sad,thank god I got out when I did. I was born and raised in Scotland to Irish parents,but left as soon as I could.What's the deal with this protestant /catholic thing,over here we just accept people for what they are...Rangers.. Celtic..who cares but yet people think we're the ones who have issues with religion?Far from it here in Donegal,we're proud of our live and let liven reputation.

  • im from donegal and i think paolo nutuini is a legend and he makes this song great. C mon Donegal

  • @MrTeedy287 Ok we r all sad m8.

  • tim card? when the hell did it become a card?

    seriously get a grip people

    enjoy the music instead of trying to cause arguments

    celtic, rangers, who the hell cares.. its a game.. nothing else

  • So you think he dosnt play the tim card ,what about the cover on sunny side up your having a laugh.

  • @archiel2005

    Plays the Tim Card?

    What because he has green and yellow on his album cover !??

    you people really need to take a good look at yourselves! Get a grip !!!!

    We are NOT British, NOT Irish

    WE ARE SCOTTISH ! ;) and so is paulo !!!

    I hate Scots who fight amongst themselves (rangers n celtic fans)

  • I am so proud to be Scottish!!!

  • @iluvjawnx an' so ye should be Oidhche mhath....

  • Great singer shame he plays the tim card in your face

  • @archiel2005  agreed !!!!

  • never plays the tim card ,amazing singer

  • what's a tim?

  • Paolo Nutini's version is as valid as any of the great folk artists who've covered this. Man's an awesome talent

  • Freekin' right on, bro!

  • Rabbie would be 100% behind this version of A Man's A Man - Paulo gets it!!!

    Fuck the Tory, Middle Class, Safe, Let's vote for the Party who will protect our savings/mortgage/lifestyle/bol­locks!

  • YES! S.N.P. Rabbie was a patriot.

  • @billyconnearly right on brother

  • Go on yersel!!

    Alba go Bragh!

  • fantastic

  • Happy Birthday to the man himself!

    *****

  • Scotland for independence! BURNS NIGHT TOMORROW! Lets all eat our Haggis and enjoy one of scotlands best Heroes!

  • I want this song but cannot find it anywhere that lets me download it. Does anyone know where it can be bought or downloaded?

    Krissy

  • steal it from u tube , google u tube downloader 2 mp3 , thank me later ure welcome

  • Thank you so much

  • The Scottish Nation has been under the English heel since 1707! Forget the religious side - England has been under a German Monarchy for these 300 years - Scotland must take back Her Birthright - an enlightened vision of the future which embraces ALL Nations as Brothers and Sisters One World - One Love!

  • wel never b independant u bampot. were in europe now fanny baws

  • and did we vote for that?????? NO!!!! another burden put on us by our southern niebourghs...fuck europe

  • Scotland is so close now to achieving its Independence and freedom, and the sooner we get our country back the better!!!

    Don't let the unionists stop Scotland's march to freedom, VOTE YES FOR INDEPENDENCE!!!

  • You can come back to us if you want.

  • proud to be scottish, the two best scots ever!

  • Comment removed

  • Alba gu Brath?

  • @pastapesto11 you truly have the best music. i am american and am in love with paolo!

  • @pastapesto11 what did you say that was removed?

  • @TheAmazingamerica I honestly cannot remember, but it won't have been anythinh bad, coz I love this man! He kicks a s s! xx

  • @pastapesto11 okay, just being curious.

  • Come on scotland. Paulo is such a wonderful representitive

  • COME ON SCOTLAND!!!

  • Scottish Enlightenment. on ye go Paolo Dain it fir us Scots.

    Can ye imagine Burns reciting it , now that would be amazing...och eiy

  • Yis dae know that Rabbie Burns wrote it......Paoli is jist singin it (albeit very well)

  • such a brilliant song from brilliant writer and sung by a man who sings from the soul

  • Comment removed

  • I am not Scottish but all of you who are should be so proud I think Paolo Nutini has one of those voice you rarely find...he is just brillian!!

  • Well done lad.

  • Wow! Paolo is one of the best musicians of our time and he makes me proud to be Scottish!

  • What a man! What a country! So much pride...I love this! 

    Makes me wish I was Scottish!!!

  • The joy he takes in his signing is infectious! I love to listen to him!

  • I have seen his name and read his interviews for quite some time,but it is a real shock to see and hear him.

    I will guess, not counting on misfortune,that he has a very long and prosperous career ahead of him!.

  • he's the absolute best...

  • breathtaking ,

  • When i first seen this video title Paolo Nutini sings Burns i cringed....but to be fair Paola gives this everthing and his dictation is spot on ...and thank god he adopted his own accent rather than that fake American soul one he normally portrays...not a bad version at all.

  • robbie burns would lovve him..he is so special

  • what a phenomenal version of phenomenal piece of writing i think a near perfect performance. the thing stopping its perfection being the skipped verse.

  • Paolo is the best Scottish talent of a generation. He sings in his natural tongue, and this video just sums the guy up. Legend in the making.

  • I think he's awesome, and , yes, a very cool version of Robbie Burns lol

  • Some of the best words ever written; makes me proud to be a Scot and hopeful that people listen to these words and put them into practice in their lives.

  • I WAS THERE :D:D:D

    Love yu paolo <3

  • Paolo is  just amazing! No wonder the young people of Scotland have made his records million sellers, and I admire their choice and taste in music, they are spot on !!!! Albainn gu Brath,

  • Is he dishy or what!! I would die to join fruitfully with him.

  • not even close to the Old Blind Dogs version.

  • i love paolo!

    he missed out a verse though

    'a prince can mak a belted knight

    a marquis, duke an' a' that

    but an honest man's aboon his might-

    guid faith, he mauna fa' that

    for a' that, an' a' that

    their dignities an' a' that

    the pith o' sense an' pride o' worth

    are higher rank than a' that'

  • good catch

    i'm sure he had a time limit

    but hopefully paolo, who is the absolute best...."the coward slave we pass him by, we dare be poor for a that"

    has captiivate me, 41, my great aunt 92, my little cousin 15, my older cousin 53

    scotland rules, and paolo is a great example