A giudicare dai commenti - il più cattivo cita Beethoven, ma in genere si ricorre a Dio - sono io che non capisco nulla. E sia pure.
Ma sinceramente non riesco proprio a vedere tutta la sublimità di questa musica. Temi particolarmente geniali non se ne sentono. Le formule sono più o meno sempre le stesse. Va ravanando sincope dopo sincope con un colore sempre uguale. E a quelli che parlano di sentimento, ascoltino, tanto per dirne una, l'Andante della sonata 21 di Schubert ...poi ne parliamo.
ho ascoltato schubert..bello! ascolto da chopin, mozart , rachmaninov, bethohoven fino a bach.. questa musica qua sopra è stata eseguita nello stesso momento in cui veniva creata/pensata.. con tutto il rispetto che si può avere per un compositore come schubert.. keith jarrett è un altro tipo di genio, è impressionante il senso della storia che c'è in questo pezzo improvisato da 45 minuti.. lui racconta una storia,e la racconta in un modo bellissimo.detesto i bigottismo..
I have this cd .. I heard many times this music .. there is a reference to the best of contemporary and classical music seen again by the infinite genius of this remarkable and extraordinary pianist .. an expression of great sadness, coupled with a sense of inner rebirth, as if Keith Jarrett wanted to describe the human life with its failures as well as its victories..this contrast is perfect
@MrMamowi amazing!!!!!!!!!!! he has an amazing brain, and you could swear that there are 10 more brains in his fingertips!!!!!! thank you for posting.
The phrase "I dont believe in god" is silly and pretentious - it translates to "I dont believe in one who isnt God." By capitalizing "Atheist" and lower-casing "god" (when referring to a singular supreme Being) you sound religious AND stupid, two things when put together = danger.
The 8.22 min duration that has been kindly uploaded really ought to be listened to in its entirety: LA Scala - part 1, 2, and even Over The Rainbow lends further balance to an album that should rank alongside The Koln Concert. La Scala takes a listener on an epic voyage to the depths of self. Emotions within never believed existing, will rise up and humble self. This isn't a musical sphere in as much as a surrealism one where each listener will perhaps experience a totally different journey.
you know what? i don't like it. sorry, youtube. these chords sound like they could be from any angsty pop artist. don't get me wrong, i'm a man who loves his music, but this is generic to me.
@hesathinkingman well all I can say is that I deeply respect your comment, while I don't agree with it, because you justify it and you express polite saying the most simple thing: I don't like it! For me music, and art in general, is something very personal when it comes to opinions and there is not right or wrong when you say I like something or the opposite. People like yzxklfg must understand that and stop being so assertive.
Spiritual seekers past, present and future have eventually discovered the oneness that exists before mental differentiation, that which gets personified and thus eternally misunderstood, as God. This place doesn't contain resistance and in it life expresses itself totally. It is not hyperbole to say this music touches the divine. There is little conceptual framework to his playing. It can't be defined emotionally because it is almost pure expression. It's what all art aims to be.
je ne sais trop mais lorsque l'ont écoute cela nous ne pouvons qu'être dans le transport de l'instrument son corps joue pour que nous l'écoutions dans la pleine campagne du jazz dans sa total force
The last 20 minutes of the Lausanne concert is another one of my favourite extracts of piano music ever. He could really close out his pieces so emotionally.
musically speaking, the 8 minutes from Keith Jarrett's Bregenz concert are significantly more interesting, more captivating and more complex. There, he achieved the impossible.
La Scala is beautiful, but it doesn't contain the freshness of the Bregenz recording.
And please, for those who like to make everything so BOLD, do not mix "beautiful playing" with "best" playing or anything like that. Actually, the concept of "best" does not exist.
I know people are going to thumb down me, but i hate it when he makes those weird noises. It is an avoidable stain in this otherwise untouchable pice of musical beauty.
la belleza, lo sutil, la inteligencia emotiva, la tecnica, el vuelo, la pasion, todo lo que existe detras de la musica, eso es esta fraccion de musica del concierto de Keith, todo esto en 8 minutos, zarpado en magia e incansable de volver a escucharlo una y otra vez
the chord at exactly 5:20 min is the best chord known to man with out a doubt. (5min 20 this version, 41min 11 the real version) this chord contains so much power, so much passion energy and love. it is truely wonderful.
I had forgotten just how beautiful this piece was. There are many memorable passages in Keith's solo performances and this is probably one of his very best. Thank you for posting it.
Hegel says that a work of art in perfection describes the same content as a true religious truth or a philosophical truth- the absolute - that which has actualised its potential. Keith is doing that here- giving voice to a structure of the universe which is part of himself but also universal, and part of all of us.
@314noceu sorry, there is nothing about theism or atheism in this music. This is a gifted improviser doing what he does best. The concept of God should play no part in any aesthetics.
@loren1283 I cannot comment on Keith Jarrett's beliefs. What I can comment on is the idea that something "beautiful" has the presence of a "god" inherent to it.
That's fantasy and comes with a lot of judgement, which is dangerous.
It's a fact that the idea of "god" has inspired many artists, but at the same time too many human beings have been massacred for not believing in deities.
Music is energy. And energy is pretty much everything. God is just an extrapolation of what we don't know.
wow. it's so great to see that someone feels the same way about this passage. i completely agree. tho i'm a bit torn between this and the last 10 mins or so of vienna part I.
Truely beautiful. Jarrett has a way of making it so much more than just music. he makes me feel something far beond anything words can describe, a genius, a true genius.
these last 8 minutes take all their sense because they're a complete release of the tension that invades the 38 first minutes of this track. The whole part I is an amazing musical trip, but he couldn't finish this better than this. Some of the most magic minutes of improvised music ever made on a piano
Una volta, quando ero molto giovane ed amavo già Keith, lessi che "Lalene" era -the most beautiful sound next to silence -... ora lo è questo pezzo... giuli 55
i used to tape this last part and listened to it over and over again... wishing to ignore and forget all the sadness and all those intense chaos that led before...only to cherish that very last indescribable delight...
complimenti a chi ha scelto questa parte del live alla scala..ritengo che sia il momento in cui Lui ritrova la "luce" dopo la misteriosa e poi tormentata sezione che lo precede..certo per apprezzare questi 8.22 minuti bisogna prima ascoltare il materiale precedente..per poi essere presi da quella che secondo me è una vera e propria Catarsi..vabè basta..con le parole nn si puo' descrivere l'indescrivibile..e il live alla Scala..per chi puo' comprendere..parla da solo..!!
Certo. Sono assolutamente d'accordo con te. Chiedo questa parte - la nascita dell 'anima. Ma per vederi la nascita si devi prima cosa ha desiderari (volere multissimo) 'per 36 minuti. Ti vedo capire. Grazie per commentare. Mi auguro che il mio italiano e comprensibile. Cari saluti!
@flamenco81 : ciao, io essendo un po' nuova in questo tipo di musica, sarei curiosa di sapere dove posso sentire questa prima parte che e' un po' misteriosa e tormentata?
I hope when you are watching footage from the 2nd World War, or just the evening news, you are thinking that they are also proofs of god's existence, because humans alone cannot be so cruel and stupid.
I don't believe in god, but this music is miraculous.
Goosebumps.
losabuelos1 2 months ago
@robdoubleyoo / Give John Coltrane a try / Another absolute Master
usmc2020627 3 months ago in playlist INTERSTELLAR SPACE
How much poorer the world would have been if this man had never been born. No one can touch his musical genius. Xxx.
robdoubleyoo 4 months ago
A giudicare dai commenti - il più cattivo cita Beethoven, ma in genere si ricorre a Dio - sono io che non capisco nulla. E sia pure.
Ma sinceramente non riesco proprio a vedere tutta la sublimità di questa musica. Temi particolarmente geniali non se ne sentono. Le formule sono più o meno sempre le stesse. Va ravanando sincope dopo sincope con un colore sempre uguale. E a quelli che parlano di sentimento, ascoltino, tanto per dirne una, l'Andante della sonata 21 di Schubert ...poi ne parliamo.
bellinianodoc 6 months ago
ho ascoltato schubert..bello! ascolto da chopin, mozart , rachmaninov, bethohoven fino a bach.. questa musica qua sopra è stata eseguita nello stesso momento in cui veniva creata/pensata.. con tutto il rispetto che si può avere per un compositore come schubert.. keith jarrett è un altro tipo di genio, è impressionante il senso della storia che c'è in questo pezzo improvisato da 45 minuti.. lui racconta una storia,e la racconta in un modo bellissimo.detesto i bigottismo..
goldfish1934 5 hours ago
Piano, never ceases to amaze.
Everyone should learn it
JamesLoweProd 6 months ago
you don't need lyric, if you play like a god
thedarkplayer 7 months ago
For those with the "God" thing . . .
he just entered your ears . . .
horvathivan 7 months ago
Dear 314noceu , All things come from God who has created all things . You don't have to believe in Him , He believes in you .
ssn0651 8 months ago
@ssn0651 lets not make this video about religion huh!
PianomanMNL 8 months ago
I have this cd .. I heard many times this music .. there is a reference to the best of contemporary and classical music seen again by the infinite genius of this remarkable and extraordinary pianist .. an expression of great sadness, coupled with a sense of inner rebirth, as if Keith Jarrett wanted to describe the human life with its failures as well as its victories..this contrast is perfect
AlessandroFortarel 9 months ago 2
Expanding mind in an inspiration. My best friend... Thanks G-d .----
MrMamowi 9 months ago
Expanding mind in an inspiration. My best frien... Thanks G-d .----
MrMamowi 9 months ago
@MrMamowi amazing!!!!!!!!!!! he has an amazing brain, and you could swear that there are 10 more brains in his fingertips!!!!!! thank you for posting.
sld55555 3 months ago
The best example of expanding one theme and improvising!
mona2ir 9 months ago
The best example of expanding one theme and improvising!
mona2ir 9 months ago
this is possibly the most beautiful thing I've ever heard
allyoop2251 10 months ago 3
@allyoop2251 +1.
eduardobaplenz 8 months ago
wow
allyoop2251 10 months ago
The phrase "I dont believe in god" is silly and pretentious - it translates to "I dont believe in one who isnt God." By capitalizing "Atheist" and lower-casing "god" (when referring to a singular supreme Being) you sound religious AND stupid, two things when put together = danger.
1Eu4ic 11 months ago
The 8.22 min duration that has been kindly uploaded really ought to be listened to in its entirety: LA Scala - part 1, 2, and even Over The Rainbow lends further balance to an album that should rank alongside The Koln Concert. La Scala takes a listener on an epic voyage to the depths of self. Emotions within never believed existing, will rise up and humble self. This isn't a musical sphere in as much as a surrealism one where each listener will perhaps experience a totally different journey.
muzo56281721 1 year ago
you know what? i don't like it. sorry, youtube. these chords sound like they could be from any angsty pop artist. don't get me wrong, i'm a man who loves his music, but this is generic to me.
hesathinkingman 1 year ago
@hesathinkingman Listen to something else. And youtube didn't write the music. You're generic.
yzxklfg 1 year ago
@hesathinkingman well all I can say is that I deeply respect your comment, while I don't agree with it, because you justify it and you express polite saying the most simple thing: I don't like it! For me music, and art in general, is something very personal when it comes to opinions and there is not right or wrong when you say I like something or the opposite. People like yzxklfg must understand that and stop being so assertive.
lytrosis1 11 months ago
Keith, I have listened to you for 37 years. When I die I want to listen to you for all eternity.
pjd57 1 year ago 3
per certe cose non esistono parole per il commento
thedarkplayer 1 year ago
Io suono chitarra classica, ma i brividi che kate jarret riesce a procurare, nascono da una "nuova base", "una nuova concezione"... usa l'anima...
mastellonefrancesco 1 year ago
Spiritual seekers past, present and future have eventually discovered the oneness that exists before mental differentiation, that which gets personified and thus eternally misunderstood, as God. This place doesn't contain resistance and in it life expresses itself totally. It is not hyperbole to say this music touches the divine. There is little conceptual framework to his playing. It can't be defined emotionally because it is almost pure expression. It's what all art aims to be.
Shazbut01 1 year ago 4
Comment removed
Shazbut01 1 year ago
Al minuto 5.07 mi commuovo sempre, è inutile.
danfit83 1 year ago
wonderful!!!!
lidiascardoso 1 year ago
Keith Jarrett must be a god. no human could do such a thing
tekknoplast 1 year ago 7
great song. thanx a lot!
MissGunbar 1 year ago
This was my first time listening to Keith and la scala. This is too beautiful for words.
gcgx 1 year ago
je ne sais trop mais lorsque l'ont écoute cela nous ne pouvons qu'être dans le transport de l'instrument son corps joue pour que nous l'écoutions dans la pleine campagne du jazz dans sa total force
tyranisation 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ma sì, facciamoci del male, piangiamo come vitelli, senza motivo, solo perché è bello, solo perché la musica la musica la musica
Alessandro1985 1 year ago
perfection
paijaaguppai 1 year ago
beautiful,amazing,speechless,incredible,on that way this music did affect on my heart...
tarahumare 1 year ago
anybody knows who painted the picture displayed at 6:43 ? and at 8:00 as well
I find them great :)
funkybarber1 1 year ago
Absolutely gorgeous! The emotion is like nothing else.
TheBakedPotato420 1 year ago
Rick Wakeman blows this guy away.
GaryNull 1 year ago
@GaryNull
you don't know music
mdol256 1 year ago
@GaryNull oh ffs don't be so silly
cosmicjazzer 1 year ago
The last 20 minutes of the Lausanne concert is another one of my favourite extracts of piano music ever. He could really close out his pieces so emotionally.
UppruniTegundanna 1 year ago
so nice ! ですね.
maidoodesu 1 year ago
musically speaking, the 8 minutes from Keith Jarrett's Bregenz concert are significantly more interesting, more captivating and more complex. There, he achieved the impossible.
La Scala is beautiful, but it doesn't contain the freshness of the Bregenz recording.
And please, for those who like to make everything so BOLD, do not mix "beautiful playing" with "best" playing or anything like that. Actually, the concept of "best" does not exist.
otavioandradas 1 year ago
wow....
westofdashannon 1 year ago
This end is much more enjoyable and beautiful with all the tension built by the piece before...
Romichouu 1 year ago
I know people are going to thumb down me, but i hate it when he makes those weird noises. It is an avoidable stain in this otherwise untouchable pice of musical beauty.
Zebarbas 2 years ago
@Zebarbas
Yet this untouchable piece of music wouldn't exist without those weird noises. Think about that.
HigashiSeiun 1 year ago
@Zebarbas
To me this is a heartbreaking reaction and it absolutely exresses me.
panagogt 1 year ago
ill...
Strategicxx 2 years ago
fucking perfect
thedarkplayer 2 years ago 5
Piano GOD!
his music is awesome!
pwgavlas 2 years ago 2
Beautiful!!
ursuletu74 2 years ago 3
..this, and the last part of Vienna part I, I've always tought they are the best music minutes ever recorded.
There is nothing comparable to music talking itself, just flowing trought Jarrett. And in those piece endings, music had something big to tell us
dvallesi 2 years ago 18
@dvallesi
Totally agree. For me it is The Koln Concert.
pompo2000 1 year ago
wow
sergioprs 2 years ago
This is alchemy.
cosmicjazzer 2 years ago 5
Che poesia!
annacaragnano 2 years ago
Bellissimo! Grazie per averlo pubblicato.
giampi46 2 years ago
This album is simply fantastic. Along with Radiance it's my favorite Jarrett work by far.
papa1980 2 years ago
gut soweit
quogir1 2 years ago
la belleza, lo sutil, la inteligencia emotiva, la tecnica, el vuelo, la pasion, todo lo que existe detras de la musica, eso es esta fraccion de musica del concierto de Keith, todo esto en 8 minutos, zarpado en magia e incansable de volver a escucharlo una y otra vez
medeskito1 2 years ago
How truely moving. The Koln concert, Moth and the Flame. This man is a genius with a soul.
brodo1204 2 years ago
@314noceau Sometimes some thing are too beautifull to be true.
Also atheist, but I had the same feeling with this but before also with some Prince songs.
I think u hear this music when we die and pass the white tunnel to "heaven".
LenovoFightsPoverty 2 years ago
Keith Jarret is great.... He has something that no one else has.
BreatheLust 2 years ago
when i first heard the Koln Concert i couldnt stop listening to it for about a month. i' t's gonna take little longer with this i think.
ZiemowitBucko 2 years ago 5
it's 8 months now that i'm listening to koln concert every day !!
modir23 2 years ago 2
@modir23 wow !! I said this 3 months ago and i'm still listening to this masterpiece :-))
modir23 2 years ago
a Classic definitely...Jarrett never fails an audience..i also like him edgie with Miles on the early 70's that was great.
19TOFY58 2 years ago
indescriptible emoción. alegría celular.
vasmujo 2 years ago
the chord at exactly 5:20 min is the best chord known to man with out a doubt. (5min 20 this version, 41min 11 the real version) this chord contains so much power, so much passion energy and love. it is truely wonderful.
joshmc4 2 years ago
The timber of chord at 1:39 it's quite wonderful as well
dvallesi 2 years ago 3
best song ever
thedarkplayer 2 years ago
Outside the chord inside the music !
astorlisapiazzolla 2 years ago
I had forgotten just how beautiful this piece was. There are many memorable passages in Keith's solo performances and this is probably one of his very best. Thank you for posting it.
dario1947 2 years ago
Came across this quite by accident. What a moving peice. Perfect way to start my day. This is music that draws your soul from its hiding place.
InifinityInc 2 years ago 3
and this is only the last 8 minutes of PART 1 of two parts
XxTwist67xX 2 years ago
Play this at FULL VOLUME at 4am.
Nyquistic 2 years ago 4
I am an Atheist. But in this music, I see god. This confusion makes me cry buckets of tears that nobody sees.
314noceu 2 years ago 48
Hegel says that a work of art in perfection describes the same content as a true religious truth or a philosophical truth- the absolute - that which has actualised its potential. Keith is doing that here- giving voice to a structure of the universe which is part of himself but also universal, and part of all of us.
raphaelhudson 2 years ago 2
@314noceu sorry, there is nothing about theism or atheism in this music. This is a gifted improviser doing what he does best. The concept of God should play no part in any aesthetics.
otavioandradas 1 year ago
@otavioandradas I dont know about that, most if not all good improvisers believe in somthing higher.
loren1283 1 year ago
@loren1283 I cannot comment on Keith Jarrett's beliefs. What I can comment on is the idea that something "beautiful" has the presence of a "god" inherent to it.
That's fantasy and comes with a lot of judgement, which is dangerous.
It's a fact that the idea of "god" has inspired many artists, but at the same time too many human beings have been massacred for not believing in deities.
Music is energy. And energy is pretty much everything. God is just an extrapolation of what we don't know.
otavioandradas 1 year ago 5
@314noceu you see something nice, something that has great energy. that has nothing to do with god. you don't need to get confused. just enjoy it.
what you see is a human being using great intelligence, emotions, talent and hard work to create something good.
otavioandradas 1 year ago
@314noceu get a job you hippy
krugertown 1 year ago
wow. it's so great to see that someone feels the same way about this passage. i completely agree. tho i'm a bit torn between this and the last 10 mins or so of vienna part I.
mcphate 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
valeristavrev 2 years ago
Beauty...
myreau 2 years ago 3
Almost as good as the last 6 minutes of The Koln Concert..
'Nuff said!
DuranXL 2 years ago 2
Truely beautiful. Jarrett has a way of making it so much more than just music. he makes me feel something far beond anything words can describe, a genius, a true genius.
joshmc4 2 years ago 3
music of existenz
Alessandro1985 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
But why does he moan and groan? A friend said it's orgasmic.
AtterseeSommer 2 years ago
He's thinking of all Youtube comments he's going to get.
utuber2 2 years ago 5
This music is beautiful. I may have to get La Scala. To all 4 who voted me thumbs down: Eat shit.
AtterseeSommer 2 years ago
this is awsome music,keith is the best! Thank You!
DeenZaa 2 years ago
...
GarageSPA 2 years ago
Amo la musica e il pianoforte, ma questa musica mi ha veramente sorpreso...
Alberto
spiritusvocis 3 years ago
these last 8 minutes take all their sense because they're a complete release of the tension that invades the 38 first minutes of this track. The whole part I is an amazing musical trip, but he couldn't finish this better than this. Some of the most magic minutes of improvised music ever made on a piano
mama2tbug 3 years ago
Man, I couldn't agree more. I just revisted this after about ten years from last listening. Simply amazing. No one can touch Keith.
sgtb1961 3 years ago
This is almost unbearably beautiful...
cosmicjazzer 3 years ago 2
Non è un genio?!?!
farooldi 3 years ago
Una volta, quando ero molto giovane ed amavo già Keith, lessi che "Lalene" era -the most beautiful sound next to silence -... ora lo è questo pezzo... giuli 55
manrfo 3 years ago
in this here present gem -- Keith got it goin
co2md 3 years ago
i used to tape this last part and listened to it over and over again... wishing to ignore and forget all the sadness and all those intense chaos that led before...only to cherish that very last indescribable delight...
joyumn 3 years ago 2
Doesn't make much sense when plucked out of the middle of a longer piece. Evey note affects the next so you really must start at the very beginning.
JoanPatitucci 3 years ago
complimenti a chi ha scelto questa parte del live alla scala..ritengo che sia il momento in cui Lui ritrova la "luce" dopo la misteriosa e poi tormentata sezione che lo precede..certo per apprezzare questi 8.22 minuti bisogna prima ascoltare il materiale precedente..per poi essere presi da quella che secondo me è una vera e propria Catarsi..vabè basta..con le parole nn si puo' descrivere l'indescrivibile..e il live alla Scala..per chi puo' comprendere..parla da solo..!!
flamenco81 3 years ago
Certo. Sono assolutamente d'accordo con te. Chiedo questa parte - la nascita dell 'anima. Ma per vederi la nascita si devi prima cosa ha desiderari (volere multissimo) 'per 36 minuti. Ti vedo capire. Grazie per commentare. Mi auguro che il mio italiano e comprensibile. Cari saluti!
verte22 3 years ago
@flamenco81 : ciao, io essendo un po' nuova in questo tipo di musica, sarei curiosa di sapere dove posso sentire questa prima parte che e' un po' misteriosa e tormentata?
Elephinat 1 year ago
@Elephinat ciao..allora questa è la parte finale del primo tempo del " live " alla Scala..
insomma se lo vuoi sentire tutto devi trovare il cd di Keith Jarrett " La Scala" ..
ciao
Antonio
flamenco81 1 year ago
this is so strong and beautiful it makes me cry:))
IgorJanis 3 years ago 3
if you don´t believe in god just listen to this music
this is so beautiful, i´ve listened to it maybe 300 times (köln,paris,vienna,osaka as well) and it gets better and better
godawica 3 years ago
I hope when you are watching footage from the 2nd World War, or just the evening news, you are thinking that they are also proofs of god's existence, because humans alone cannot be so cruel and stupid.
I don't believe in god, but this music is miraculous.
robagetep 3 years ago
Truly. It really is nothing short of a miracle when music of this beauty manifests...
cosmicjazzer 2 years ago
The best, this track is one of the best in the absolute sense. I do not know how to define it, perhaps music of the sky.
Keith Jarret is eternal as Mozart.
isprone 3 years ago
This music saved me from great despair.
I remember vividly. I drove to N. Ca. by myself back in '97. 'La Scala' was my soundtrack.
Sublime.
mishima1974 3 years ago 4
Jarrett is a genius!
thejazzmusic11 3 years ago 3
I spent DAYS listening to these EXACT 8 minutes. Even for Jarrett, it's *incredible*!
familiareal 3 years ago 2
Yes, Jarrett is more than our world.
pianonoten 3 years ago 6
maybe the best 8 minutes of piano solo history
quattrocentocolpi 3 years ago 22
let me quote you on that on info page.
verte22 3 years ago
Thanks, I know this 'music from heaven' very well. La Scala is (??) Jarretts last Solo Concert with long symphonies.
pianonoten 3 years ago