I THINK ITS PERFECTLY ALRIGHT TO CRITICIZE HIM ABOUT HIS WRONG NOTE. U KNOW WHY? ITS BECUZ HEIFETZ HAS ELEVATED HIMSELF TO SUCH PERFECT STANDARDS; HE WANTS PERFECTION, THEREFORE WE MUST JUDGE HIM VERY STRICTLY. I LOVE HEIFETZ, THATS WHY IM A BIT DISSAPPOINTED WITH THE WRONG NOTE.
@ConquistadorAlfred good. cause many people are like blah blah blah, he messed up here and there and everywhere but they have never even seen the music. And ya he did elevate himself, but that part is very easy to mess up on, and if u listen closely, as a violinist you should be able to pick out the fact that he made alot of intonation errors and other "small" mistakes in this recording so he might have had lacking focus towards the ending.
KK ppl just calm down. About him messing up, you guys have to realize that he would not take anything other than absolute perfection. So therefore, it is valid that someone points that out because heifitz never kept anything that wasn't perfect, he would say "we have to that again". But he recorded this piece 3 times and didn't get pure perfection on any of them, in fact the recorder asked him "don't we have to do that again?" to which he replied "that note is going to make alot of ppl happy."
Heifetz did make some mistakes in his recording. If you listen carefully you'll pick them up usually a few, but I still love his recording! It's 100 times better than edit 128 places in just Beethoven violin concerto first movement alone.
"The technique, the great precission, these can be explained. For the heart, what musicians call 'the line' there are no words; we can only listen" . . .
Perfection was never more perfect - technique, musical feeling - why are people comparing? Heifetz set the bar - many are and have reached similar bars - but there is only one Heifetz.
@Baruchyoseph8 Before WW2 Vasa Prihodah was generally regarded as the supreme technician. He was shunned after the war, partly because he refused to boycott Nazi occupied countries, partly due to the situation regarding Alma Rose; this is why Prihodah is little known today.There is an excellent, audio only, posting of Prihodah playing this. His ease of playing of Paganini's music is quite bewildering.
@Baruchyoseph8 Heifetz did not set the bar. There were many other greats playing just as great as him. The only thing different about Heifetz is his constant use of ruboto in his playing. All he had the biggest carrer also, traveling over 2 million miles. Many violinist such as Kreisler who had to join the army, Josef Hassid who passed before his late 20's, Vasa Prihoda who Shiveringflower mentioned, Huberman Bronislaw, Eugene Ysaye, Josef Szigeti, and many more.
Like perlman said ..'' he is like a tornado moving in one place'' this is the phraze that represents Heifetzs playing he is really like a tornado he is fabulus !furiozo and he has a strong spirit
@lordhenrywotton69 Ok, now here. How about you run along and enjoy your little lukas david's playing and leave us here to enjoy the real master's playing, k?
it's the EdwinFischer1886 upload, with Artur Balsam, that you should listen to regarding Menuhin. (NOT the later recording upload from adamwas with Baller on piano). The early Menuhin is a remarkable and instructive comparison to this.
@2ndviolinist All of the great musicians, past - present are "better" ... there's an interesting interview of Pinhas Zuckerman discussing violinists (on CBC radio (maybe also on tv)- his comments, especially about Heifetz, are especially insightful ... and he's no slouch as a violinist himself (Zuckerman)
@nokia1242000 interestingly enough, when kreisler came back from watching heifetz play, he told his colleagues, "well, the rest of us might as well break our violins in between our legs"
indeed, heifetz is BRILLIANT. I learnt this piece last year... I got it done... but its almost impossible to play it without stuffing up somewhere! he does a brilliant job.
@PlatypusofCalifornia heifetz is my favorite, but there's nothing wrong with saying he messed up at 3:03 cuz he did. ppl have the right to say a fact. but we judge the song OVERALL, and this version is one of the best.
Really, Heifetz has too many serious fans to make a joke like that. But I thought it was funny nonetheless! Did you know that Michelangelo also totally messed up the hands on his David statue?
Little here, little there... VEry BAD performance! LOL
rybakostis 1 week ago
I don't care if he made a mistake. I don't care if he made ten mistakes. His mistake sounded good!
ahpedrami 4 weeks ago
LIKE!!!!!!!!
rotemcarm 1 month ago
I THINK ITS PERFECTLY ALRIGHT TO CRITICIZE HIM ABOUT HIS WRONG NOTE. U KNOW WHY? ITS BECUZ HEIFETZ HAS ELEVATED HIMSELF TO SUCH PERFECT STANDARDS; HE WANTS PERFECTION, THEREFORE WE MUST JUDGE HIM VERY STRICTLY. I LOVE HEIFETZ, THATS WHY IM A BIT DISSAPPOINTED WITH THE WRONG NOTE.
ConquistadorAlfred 1 month ago
@ConquistadorAlfred can u even play this?
THEMOVIEMAKER202 1 month ago
@THEMOVIEMAKER202 yes
ConquistadorAlfred 1 month ago
@ConquistadorAlfred good. cause many people are like blah blah blah, he messed up here and there and everywhere but they have never even seen the music. And ya he did elevate himself, but that part is very easy to mess up on, and if u listen closely, as a violinist you should be able to pick out the fact that he made alot of intonation errors and other "small" mistakes in this recording so he might have had lacking focus towards the ending.
THEMOVIEMAKER202 1 month ago
@THEMOVIEMAKER202 i commented on that part since everyone was talkin abt it :p
ConquistadorAlfred 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
KK ppl just calm down. About him messing up, you guys have to realize that he would not take anything other than absolute perfection. So therefore, it is valid that someone points that out because heifitz never kept anything that wasn't perfect, he would say "we have to that again". But he recorded this piece 3 times and didn't get pure perfection on any of them, in fact the recorder asked him "don't we have to do that again?" to which he replied "that note is going to make alot of ppl happy."
THEMOVIEMAKER202 2 months ago
Comment removed
THEMOVIEMAKER202 2 months ago
Comment removed
THEMOVIEMAKER202 2 months ago
Thank you very much !
whenmyguitar 3 months ago
never been a better violinist before and after
Haifetzblue 4 months ago
Heifetz is the greatest violinist the world will ever know.
TheViolindan 4 months ago
О.....еть!!!
zefir00 5 months ago
Splendid!
irisfiamma 5 months ago
Heifetz did make some mistakes in his recording. If you listen carefully you'll pick them up usually a few, but I still love his recording! It's 100 times better than edit 128 places in just Beethoven violin concerto first movement alone.
snowmen10 6 months ago
@snowmen10 Still! : )
irisfiamma 5 months ago
классно
fidelkopanev 6 months ago
классно
fidelkopanev 6 months ago
OMG HE MESSED UP LOL
salamijoe 7 months ago
2EZ4 Jascha Heifetz.
MrSquirrel13 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
w w w youtube com/balladforisrael
ed
w w w eddy nu
eddyjacobsensongs 10 months ago
w w w yutube com/balladforisrael
ed
w w w eddy nu
eddyjacobsensongs 10 months ago
who is the pianist?
FlyingBanana1024102 11 months ago
"The technique, the great precission, these can be explained. For the heart, what musicians call 'the line' there are no words; we can only listen" . . .
iwannamakeanaccount 11 months ago
Perfection was never more perfect - technique, musical feeling - why are people comparing? Heifetz set the bar - many are and have reached similar bars - but there is only one Heifetz.
Baruchyoseph8 1 year ago
@Baruchyoseph8 Before WW2 Vasa Prihodah was generally regarded as the supreme technician. He was shunned after the war, partly because he refused to boycott Nazi occupied countries, partly due to the situation regarding Alma Rose; this is why Prihodah is little known today.There is an excellent, audio only, posting of Prihodah playing this. His ease of playing of Paganini's music is quite bewildering.
shiveringflower 1 year ago
@Baruchyoseph8 Heifetz did not set the bar. There were many other greats playing just as great as him. The only thing different about Heifetz is his constant use of ruboto in his playing. All he had the biggest carrer also, traveling over 2 million miles. Many violinist such as Kreisler who had to join the army, Josef Hassid who passed before his late 20's, Vasa Prihoda who Shiveringflower mentioned, Huberman Bronislaw, Eugene Ysaye, Josef Szigeti, and many more.
lowso231 7 months ago
Like perlman said ..'' he is like a tornado moving in one place'' this is the phraze that represents Heifetzs playing he is really like a tornado he is fabulus !furiozo and he has a strong spirit
violonistchris 1 year ago
lukas david live scherzo tarantella better
lordhenrywotton69 1 year ago
@lordhenrywotton69 Ok, now here. How about you run along and enjoy your little lukas david's playing and leave us here to enjoy the real master's playing, k?
rapter9800 1 year ago 2
sounds like vengerov, or vengerov sounds like him!! exactly same tempo!
Violincrazy 2 years ago
Thank you for posting! This is no doubt the definitive performance of the Scherzo Tarantelle.
cwldoc 2 years ago
By the way,
it's the EdwinFischer1886 upload, with Artur Balsam, that you should listen to regarding Menuhin. (NOT the later recording upload from adamwas with Baller on piano). The early Menuhin is a remarkable and instructive comparison to this.
Which is better? Does it matter??
ipmoic 2 years ago
3:03 is the only thing you can REALLY notice.. the others only if you have a really good ear...
BaRToLoMaSi 2 years ago
Comment removed
ipmoic 2 years ago
Menuhin is better but neither are in the league of the greats you can hear in early recordings.
2ndviolinist 1 year ago
@2ndviolinist All of the great musicians, past - present are "better" ... there's an interesting interview of Pinhas Zuckerman discussing violinists (on CBC radio (maybe also on tv)- his comments, especially about Heifetz, are especially insightful ... and he's no slouch as a violinist himself (Zuckerman)
Baruchyoseph8 1 year ago
*His biggest mistake is just after 0:07 on the scale going down
00Eregos00 2 years ago
I think it's actually at 3:01 and 3:03
ChessmsterX 2 years ago
no, wieniawski didnt write it the way heifetz wanted to play it so HE was wrong :P
CornDoctor 2 years ago
Comment removed
00Eregos00 2 years ago
It's really stupid to make any discussion about Heifetz. HI IS THE GREATEST VIOLINIST in any centuries!
I like Maxim Vengerov very much, but NOBODY and NEVER will tuch the level of Mr. Jasha Heifetz! He is the LORD of all VIOLINISTS!
frago1 2 years ago 5
don't forget about Paganini and Ysaye!
VMCCommunity 2 years ago
the truth is, they haven't been recorded, people who heard paganini say he hada gorgeous sound but ive serious doubts that it was better than heifetz
signorpaganini 2 years ago 5
what do u think about Kreisler?
nokia1242000 2 years ago
Ooooo! I love Kreisler! BUT: he is from the "OTHER age".... He had a totally other way and mind to play.
frago1 2 years ago
To me, kreisler is like a king of violinists :)
nokia1242000 2 years ago
@nokia1242000 interestingly enough, when kreisler came back from watching heifetz play, he told his colleagues, "well, the rest of us might as well break our violins in between our legs"
uzu50m 1 year ago
anyway will maxim play again ??? i love heifetz and i think he is one of the greatest violinist ever just said that i liked more vengerov....
ffswww 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
vengerov plays this much better
ffswww 2 years ago
yasha heifetz better and cleaner lol
for me he is the best violonist.
not maxim. and now maxim doesn't play. he stopped like 2 years ago.
he is my oncle so i know that.
douchie336 2 years ago
heifetz ftw! his precision is remarkable, vengerov doesnt have anything on him!
ViolinSpaz 2 years ago 15
@ViolinSpaz I like Vengerov version much better - more musical and passionate
violinoamore 1 year ago
@ViolinSpaz dumbass
anlinwang2 4 months ago
Simplesmente perfeito Jascha Heifetz na cabeça
jeffersonfsoares 2 years ago
He did not mess it up at 3:03. You just don't understand this type of music....
Sibelius2000 2 years ago 3
I do prefer another performance though...
PlatypusofCalifornia 3 years ago 2
Its pretty depressing to see that as the only comment on a video of jascha heifetz playing something like this, "hey he messed up at 3:03".
Heifetz plays this better than anyone I've heard man...don't you have anything else to say?
PlatypusofCalifornia 3 years ago 53
indeed, heifetz is BRILLIANT. I learnt this piece last year... I got it done... but its almost impossible to play it without stuffing up somewhere! he does a brilliant job.
ViolinSpaz 2 years ago 2
@PlatypusofCalifornia who gives a shit? so he points out a mistake. big deal. its not like hes acting like hes better than heifetz or anything
anlinwang2 4 months ago
@PlatypusofCalifornia heifetz is my favorite, but there's nothing wrong with saying he messed up at 3:03 cuz he did. ppl have the right to say a fact. but we judge the song OVERALL, and this version is one of the best.
ConquistadorAlfred 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
He messed up a little at 3:03
MadAznViolinist 3 years ago
You are right... Thx for comment.
R1ca88 3 years ago
try to mess like heifetz does you will be so happy to mess like him:]
douchie336 2 years ago
@MadAznViolinist HAHAHA u make me lol
kiop9000 1 year ago
@MadAznViolinist He didnt mess up.
kiop9000 1 year ago
@kiop9000 ya he did
THEMOVIEMAKER202 2 months ago
@MadAznViolinist do you know ANYthing about violin?
iwannamakeanaccount 11 months ago
@iwannamakeanaccount yes
MadAznViolinist 10 months ago
@MadAznViolinist
Really, Heifetz has too many serious fans to make a joke like that. But I thought it was funny nonetheless! Did you know that Michelangelo also totally messed up the hands on his David statue?
kingofcobwebs 7 months ago
@MadAznViolinist
hes human. and nobody cares about missed notes. except u.
Justincraft66 2 months ago
@MadAznViolinist You messed up " a lot" at 3:03
horozcorc 1 month ago