Drowned in left pedal, phrasing is unclear, notes are missing here and there, and when the faster notes start in the right around 2:35, she totally loses track of the melody in the left hand. Incredibly overrated pianist. Why listen to this when you can listen to Gilels?
@bloodgrss This performance does not have a single note of musicality in it - there are many 10-12 year-olds on YT who play with much more musicality :-))
unglaublich schönes stück, und unglaublich schön gespielt. wie kann man das nicht mögen?? hier ist ein kostenloser replay-button: 0:00 für alle die diese interpretation auch so oft anhören, wie ich :-)
People talking about versions from Ashkenazy and Kocsis, neither of which is good. Gilels is BOSS on this, the transcription of Rachmaninov's Vocalise (which he did not write for piano)
how immensely beautiful. i remember running into this video a few years ago and being reluctant to recognize what my ears were hearing -- just another asian chick who can play the heck out of the piano. it was easy, almost comforting to assume that pose. but now that the years have passed and this blessed creature has maintained and expanded the magic that pervades everything she takes on, it is apparent that she is UNDENIABLY one of the greats. Yuja Wang.
My daughter was in band. One year, the band director died in a car crash. I found my daughter sitting in her room crying & listening to this piece. She told me "This is the saddest song in the world." I think she is right, and Yuja plays it with such sensitivity.
Accepting that the recording quality is not the greatest, her performance nonetheless is the best of the Zoltan Kocsis-version transcriptions on Youtube. It's marvelous how she brings out the many different voices in the closing section (with the running filigree of notes), which you don't hear on any of the other performances -- this is phenomenally difficult to achieve (I know because I have the score and have been trying to emulate her!)
@Kris9kris: Thanks for pointing out the Ashkenazy and Kocsis performances. I agree with you -- the Ashkenazy rendition "plods" along, with little lyricism. Listening to him and Yuja, I realize they both added some notes to the closing section (with the running filigree of notes) to create voices that Rachmaninoff had in his original but which Kocsis omitted in his transcription.
This isn't very good. The balance of her two hands here is not good at times. Saw her twice at concerts. She has very fast hands, but when it comes to slow movements, she is not musical - lacks depth in her playing. Maybe she will be better when she gets older. Wish her the best.
@bachpiano1 So, you are pianist, i think. Please post your interpretation of this piece to know what do you mean, because im not understand why you said that... Regards.
i saw ms. wang at the chicago symphony center last night and it was magical especially her set of scriabin preludes and etudes. she is one to treasure. she didn't play this but she did play the gluck...amazing, beautiful...yuja.
Not really the best of Yuja; rather woolly in conception & execution. The transcription is neither richly sophisticote, (à la Wild),nor pure & faithful, just somewhere between. She should rework the idea, or adopt one of the more distinguished versions.
I disagree to other comments, here. This is one of the worst things I have heard from Yuja. Generally she is quite strong technically, but poetically she usually lack a lot. let us see how she develops at this area in the future.
Drowned in left pedal, phrasing is unclear, notes are missing here and there, and when the faster notes start in the right around 2:35, she totally loses track of the melody in the left hand. Incredibly overrated pianist. Why listen to this when you can listen to Gilels?
Tursunzore 1 week ago
@Tursunzore Exactly!!! :-))
Bret6464 20 hours ago
you can find the sheet music on scribd.com
MrSzatyo 1 week ago
Zoltan Kocsis transcription but she played the short version (without repeats)
MrSzatyo 1 week ago
@bloodgrss This performance does not have a single note of musicality in it - there are many 10-12 year-olds on YT who play with much more musicality :-))
Bret6464 2 weeks ago
DAAAAMN who transcribed this!!!?!?!?!
It's not Richardson!
iPlayPiiano 1 month ago
please someone can send me the Sheet music to piano of this ?? :((((( !!!
reidabuate 1 month ago
brilliance and beauty, I bow before you in admiration, but I stand up straight in inspiration :)
MaximusDowns 2 months ago
Yuja Wang... One MusicWoMan!
TheABCDVWXYZ 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
unglaublich schönes stück, und unglaublich schön gespielt. wie kann man das nicht mögen?? hier ist ein kostenloser replay-button: 0:00 für alle die diese interpretation auch so oft anhören, wie ich :-)
zockerflo 2 months ago
where is the 1st Ballade ? )))))):
fevercovers 2 months ago
the first time i heard this, i could stop hearing it for hours
iori142 3 months ago
which college did she study piano?
principessadolce22 3 months ago
@principessadolce22 curtis
apdoshi70 3 months ago
People talking about versions from Ashkenazy and Kocsis, neither of which is good. Gilels is BOSS on this, the transcription of Rachmaninov's Vocalise (which he did not write for piano)
sammarco02 3 months ago
@sammarco02 Ashkenazy plays Kocsis' version you nut.
doovud 2 months ago
how immensely beautiful. i remember running into this video a few years ago and being reluctant to recognize what my ears were hearing -- just another asian chick who can play the heck out of the piano. it was easy, almost comforting to assume that pose. but now that the years have passed and this blessed creature has maintained and expanded the magic that pervades everything she takes on, it is apparent that she is UNDENIABLY one of the greats. Yuja Wang.
utubuser10 3 months ago
omg..its so beautifull!!:))
multiyuukicross 3 months ago
Valentina is Brava..!Not Yuja...
jrgliebermann216 3 months ago
Very beautiful. I feel so touched. I hear a sensitive heart crying silently inside.
cheval63sg 4 months ago
very good
JESUS1John 5 months ago
Beauty...as always, dear Yuja!
Sophiestelle 5 months ago
My daughter was in band. One year, the band director died in a car crash. I found my daughter sitting in her room crying & listening to this piece. She told me "This is the saddest song in the world." I think she is right, and Yuja plays it with such sensitivity.
spongebobnik 5 months ago in playlist Dog Music
Doesn't any body have the sheets to exactly this piece?!
Stefan95EP 5 months ago
Accepting that the recording quality is not the greatest, her performance nonetheless is the best of the Zoltan Kocsis-version transcriptions on Youtube. It's marvelous how she brings out the many different voices in the closing section (with the running filigree of notes), which you don't hear on any of the other performances -- this is phenomenally difficult to achieve (I know because I have the score and have been trying to emulate her!)
HTinWeho 6 months ago 3
@HTinWeho
What about he transcriber? It's also on YouTube. I find Ashkenazy a little bit boring. Yuja hasn't big hands but very skillfully uses them.
Kris9kris 5 months ago
@Kris9kris: Thanks for pointing out the Ashkenazy and Kocsis performances. I agree with you -- the Ashkenazy rendition "plods" along, with little lyricism. Listening to him and Yuja, I realize they both added some notes to the closing section (with the running filigree of notes) to create voices that Rachmaninoff had in his original but which Kocsis omitted in his transcription.
HTinWeho 5 months ago
@Kris9kris Yeah I bet she skillfully uses them.
ImmortalSpecies 3 months ago
Bad. Wrong tempo, voice doesn't emerge at all.
hymnofashes 6 months ago
@hymnofashes Okay, response the right one.
TheSilentdarkmuse 6 months ago
Richardson's transcription
lt6jam 7 months ago
Pretty piece of music.
robertslistening 7 months ago
Does anyone know, who transcribed this piece to a piano-only version?
Reduts83 7 months ago
...brava Yuja ....excellent....
NuovoCurioso 8 months ago
Bravo
hadge3jo 8 months ago
Para todos los que amamos la Música.
pmrsanse 9 months ago
Para todos los que amamos la Música
pmrsanse 9 months ago
is it just me or everyone that she seemed 2 shine ?_?
0xXxXfactorXxXx0 10 months ago
looks like Curtis Institute of music
sergeyyak 11 months ago
@sergeyyak Yes, it is!
yundiful 10 months ago
This isn't very good. The balance of her two hands here is not good at times. Saw her twice at concerts. She has very fast hands, but when it comes to slow movements, she is not musical - lacks depth in her playing. Maybe she will be better when she gets older. Wish her the best.
bachpiano1 11 months ago
@bachpiano1 So, you are pianist, i think. Please post your interpretation of this piece to know what do you mean, because im not understand why you said that... Regards.
ctnpinternet 8 months ago
i saw ms. wang at the chicago symphony center last night and it was magical especially her set of scriabin preludes and etudes. she is one to treasure. she didn't play this but she did play the gluck...amazing, beautiful...yuja.
utubuser10 11 months ago
BRAVA!
Vesivian 1 year ago 5
Not really the best of Yuja; rather woolly in conception & execution. The transcription is neither richly sophisticote, (à la Wild),nor pure & faithful, just somewhere between. She should rework the idea, or adopt one of the more distinguished versions.
NOSEhow2LIV 1 year ago 2
@NOSEhow2LIV agreed.
elieltanr 1 year ago
@NOSEhow2LIV i dont think its her own version, it is the Zoltan Kocsis version. but i agree, there are more beautiful versions of this piece..
hotbebimauz 10 months ago
@hotbebimauz Gilels performance is worth listening to :-))
Bret6464 8 months ago
Agree with the last comment, this is just plain muddled mush, what technique? clarity?
hanamano37 1 year ago
I disagree to other comments, here. This is one of the worst things I have heard from Yuja. Generally she is quite strong technically, but poetically she usually lack a lot. let us see how she develops at this area in the future.
pvn2474 1 year ago
so poetic!
chutdigadut 1 year ago
Perfect!!!! I love it!!! beautiful!! can't explain it!
098musica 1 year ago 2
sehr schön
TheRekisum 1 year ago
extremely beautyfully played, yuja has not only an outstanding technique but also true musicality...
hotbebimauz 1 year ago 21
Meravigliosa musica...suonata dalla meravigliosa Yuja Wang...pianista "excellent"
NuovoCurioso 1 year ago 2